Capital Punishment Essay: Match Death With Death

863 words - 3 pages

We Must Match Death with Death


For anyone living in Texas, it is common to hear about convicted criminals being sentenced to death. Is justice being served? When someone has committed a heinous murder, justice must prevail. But that ideal becomes harder to achieve as we scale the moral high ground and look all around, from behind the jail cell bars to the crushed life of the murdered victim.

The following essay will focus on the proportionality of the death sentence as a form of punishment.



First of all, if there were no persons in the world, only things, there would be no values. There are values in the world only because there are persons: people who have not only desires , but also rationality and freedom. Something is valuable only relative to a human goal. Then, as the source of values, humans have dignity, which Immanuel Kant defines in his Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals as something so valuable that nothing could transcend it in worth. It follows that to be human, to have dignity, one must value above all else those things which give you dignity. This means one must value absolutely the rationality, freedom, and autonomy of oneself, but also of other individuals. However; there are some crimes, some murders, committed with such violence and complete disregard for life, that we stop valuing the rationality, the freedom, and the autonomy of the murder so highly. The question is how much do we devalue the criminal?


Kant had some ideas about how to find out the proper level of punishment. First, guilt is a necessary condition for judicial punishment. That means that only the guilty may be punished. Second, guilt is a sufficient condition for punishment. All the guilty must be punished. Lastly, the correct amount of punishment is that which is equal or proportional to the moral seriousness of the offense. Next, we must determine whether or not the death sentence is proportional to murder. To ease the flow of analysis, lets assume that it is a particularly violent and awful murder so that we can center our argumentation on the value we place on the life or the criminal and not on desert. Lets say that punishment is the only course we are going to take and the choice is between a life sentence and a death sentence. Do we value life, in the general sense, so highly that we will not kill the murderer? Those in support of a life sentence argue that life is the most...

Find Another Essay On Capital Punishment Essay: Match Death with Death

Death Penalty Essay: The Barbaric Practice of Capital Punishment

3558 words - 14 pages capital punishment or its reinstatement (Hook 46). Other studies determined numbers even worse for those who would favor retaining the death penalty.               The FBI concluded that states without the death penalty have lower murder rates than those who have the death penalty (Campaign). Similar studies worldwide found that countries with the death penalty also have higher murder rates than those without (National). In fact, "the

Capital Punishment Essay: Hypocrisy of the Death Penalty

653 words - 3 pages capital punishment but the most premeditated of murders, to which no criminal's deed, however calculated it may be, can be compared? For there to be equivalence, the death penalty would have to punish a criminal who had warned his victim of the date at which he would inflict a horrible death on him and who, from that moment onward, had confined him at his mercy for months. Such a monster is not encountered in private life.  

Capital Punishment Essay - Should the Death Penalty be Abolished?

746 words - 3 pages women commit about 15% of all criminal homicides"(Death Penalty). Discrimination of social classes is also an issue. "A defendant's poverty, lack of firm social roots in the community, inadequate legal representation at trial or on appeal"(Death Penalty) affects the ruling immensely. Killing someone with malicious intent is the same for all people no matter what their sex or race. No one person should go without severe punishment because of

Capital Punishment: Arguments for Life and Death

623 words - 2 pages punishment applied to adults. The usual alternative to the death penalty is life imprisonment and only applied to the greatest criminals For the past decades, capital punishment has been one of the most contested political issues in America. Capital punishment is not merely or even primarily a legal question. It is a practical and moral question. I don't have any problems with the death penalty, but only if all avenues have been

Death Penalty: Capital Punishment and Violent Crime

1590 words - 6 pages Capital Punishment and Violent Crime Hypothesis Most Americans are pro-death penalty, even though they don't really believe that it is an effective deterrent to violent crime. Those who are pro-death penalty will remain so, even if faced with the best arguments of anti-death penalty activists and told to assume the arguments were absolutely true. Violent crime Violent crime is a major problem in the United States. According to

Death penalty. Paper supporting capital punishment

1914 words - 8 pages of their claim, they cite the difference in homicide rates of Michigan and its' neighbor Indiana ( one state without and one with the capital punishment, respectively). (Miller 69)'Between 1972 and 1990, the homicide rate in Michigan was generally as low as or lower than the neighboring state of Indiana, which restored the death penalty in 1973 and since then has sentenced 70 persons to death and carried out 2 executions.' (Bedau 4) In another

Capital Punishment Must Be Put To Death

1800 words - 7 pages Capital punishment, better known as the death penalty, has been around for centuries. Like all elements of modern society, the death penalty has evolved over the course of many years. Initially, the death penalty was administered by a royal court or monarchy through brutal stoning. Since then, the guillotine, noose, electric chair, and [currently] lethal injection have all been tools created to administer the death penalty here in the United

Critical Analysis of Edward Koch's Essay, "Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life"

962 words - 4 pages In Edward I. Koch's essay, "Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life", readers view the opinions Koch has toward the death penalty in today's world. Koch reviews a variety of excuses to abolish the death penalty. He argues the importance of the death penalty, as well as, argues excuses of the death penalty opponents. He argues the ethics and politics towards the importance and support of the death penalty. In the following essay

Capital Punishment Essay - True Justice Through Application of the Death Penalty

1104 words - 4 pages Court of the United States declared in its 1976 Gregg vs. Georgia decision that "the punishment of death does not invariably violate the Constitution" ("The Death Penalty...").  This supports the fact that capital punishment is not cruel and unusual.   Monetarily, the death penalty is the most efficient manner of dealing with perpetrators of heinous crimes. The long-term financial advantages of the death penalty are difficult to pinpoint

The Death Penalty (essay gives reasons for and against capital punishment).

728 words - 3 pages killed white victims; in the same amount of time, only 12 executions were to white defendants who killed black victims. This shows that there is racial biasing when it comes to sentencing people to death row. Before deciding which side to take on this very important issue, one must first become familiar with reasons for either viewpoint.To argue against capital punishment is to want to send prisoners into the streets. Justice should be based on

This is a presuasive essay on Capital Punishment. This essay has a pro-capital punishment stance. Argues against common statements used to challenge the death penalty.

857 words - 3 pages Capital Punishment - Fair and BalancedCapital punishment is a difficult issue to address and has been the subject of highly controversial debates over the decades. The United States Supreme Court decided in Furman v. Georgia that the death penalty was a form of cruel and unusual punishment. However, just three years later in 1975, the Supreme Court reversed their decision, and executions resumed under state regulation. The death penalty is

Similar Essays

Capital Punishment Essay: Death Penalty Maintains Justice

1213 words - 5 pages seems an obvious point, but it is worth remembering, as it warns us that state-sanctioned executions must never be taken lightly. Just as firm is the fact that in most cases, the death penalty is a matter of justice and equality. With most crimes, the purposes of the punishment are to rehabilitate the convict and to send a warning to others who would commit similar crimes. In contrast, the death penalty intends neither to rehabilitate nor

Capital Punishment Death Penalty Essay

1506 words - 6 pages killed. It would cost much less money if the criminal was killed the same way they killed the victim, and as soon as it happened. If a person killed someone by shooting them, the state has to pay for all the expenses to lock him up. They also would then have to pay for the punishment, whether it is life in jail or the death penalty, it will turn out to cost thousands and thousands of dollars. Compare that to the price it would cost if the method of

Capital Punishment The Death Penalty

565 words - 2 pages court. The accused may also appeal the decision or request a stay of execution as he sees fit. Although the risk of an accidental death is there, the legal proceedings are in place to prevent an unwarranted death.An argument put forth by many is that the economics involved with capital punishment is irrelevant. This is true to the individuals and groups who are financially well off - but not to the remainder of the population. To sentence a

Capital Punishment Essay: Death Penalty Is Good For The Economy

1320 words - 5 pages murderers should be given the death penalty and have it carried out at once. The death penalty is a controversial sentence. Not everyone feels the same way, but I believe that, in America, the death penalty for murderers is beneficial to the economy and it's a punishment that fits the crime. Anti-death penalty supporters argue the death penalty is unconstitutional -- "Capital punishment is a barbaric remnant of an uncivilized society. It is