This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

‘Capital Punishment Is The Only Real Way To Deter Potential Criminals’ Discuss And Evaluate How Introducing Capital Punishment Fulfills The Aims Of Criminal Sanctions

1311 words - 6 pages

Liam O'Shea'Capital punishment is the only real way to deter potential criminals' Discuss and evaluate how introducing capital punishment fulfils the aims of criminal sanctions.We read stories of ancient times where grand armies march and conquer vast lands, killing thousands of inhabitants and executing their leaders in front of the masses. These events to us seem medieval and brutal; however we only need to go a certain distance to find these events in real life, a reality to many. Capital punishment is the legal practice of lawfully taking someone's life, a practice that is performed by 58 countries. However, one must look at recidivism rates and understand the difference between a ...view middle of the document...

This difference in the way criminal sanctions are performed give society the ability to see what works, and what doesn't. Recidivism rates are a good guide at determining this. Recidivist is a person who continually commits crimes despite being punished on other occasions. In Australia, a country without capital punishment, recidivism rates across the country come to 38.2% whilst in the US, 67.5% of prisoners were reinstated in prison. The question then comes into force, does capital punishment help curb recidivism rates and fulfil criminal sanctions? Or are we murdering murderers for no benefit at all? According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, the United States' gaol population equates for 0.94% of the US resident population, which is 743 inmates per 100,000 law abiding citizens, 5.65 times more than Australia. These numbers truly show that the prison population in the US is much larger than Australia's. The answer behind all of this may be the way men and women are rehabilitated in prison. According to the Australian Institute of Criminology, rehabilitation of prisoners does work and those who undertake these courses are more likely to stay out of that group of 38.2% reoffenders. However all this information cannot be upheld without the mentioning of the fact that these criminals, as violent as they are, are humans and they, just like you and me, have rights.It seems quite contradictive and hypocritical that justice systems around the world are able to take someone's life away from them if they have done the same to another. It seems even worse when it is possible for them to take the lives away from people who have only done harm to themselves through the instances of drug trafficking or homosexual acts. People have rights, and these rights should not be limited to only law-abiding citizens. In Australia, we as citizens or as visitors within the Australian borders are given 5 expressed Constitutional rights, statutory protection and treaties and conventions that the Australian Government has signed. It is these treaties and conventions that secure the right of prisoners that are in detention and one of these treaties that Australia and many other UN member nations have signed is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights which states in Article 3 that "Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of person", then later followed by Article 5 "No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment." These two key articles are one of many other articles of...

Find Another Essay On ‘Capital Punishment Is The Only Real Way To Deter Potential Criminals’ Discuss And Evaluate How Introducing Capital Punishment Fulfills The Aims Of Criminal Sanctions

Capital Punishment and the Bible Essay

1268 words - 5 pages installed in order to deter potential criminals and to spare the lives of potential victims.7           Even as far back as when Numbers was written, when a man was proved to be a murderer, he was to be executed with no opportunity for appeal.8  Capital punishment becomes the means of retribution for individual crimes.  The most overlooked issues in the capital punishment debate is that persons condemned to death are compelled to

The Unconstitutionality of Capital Punishment Essay

2383 words - 10 pages sides, it is very clear that the death penalty is unreasonable and should be illegal. Capital punishment is not a deterrence to crime. Although it does eliminate the chance of a criminal to commit another crime, it could also end the life of an innocent person. Statistics gathered from comparisons between the states with and without capital punishment reveal that the death penalty does not deter criminals from committing crimes. Arguments

The Death of Capital Punishment

1328 words - 6 pages penalty is simply an illusion of humane professional murder (Zivot). While capital punishment may or may not deter the world of crime, one person at a time, it does so in a manner that not only abolishes a life but also the humanity of those whose believe in it through its violations, financial costs, and faults; therefore capital punishment should be put to death. Supporters of this form of this sanction believe that capital punishment does more to

The Bible and Capital Punishment

1420 words - 6 pages ) The victim’s blood defiles the land. The only way that you can change that is to kill the murder (25:3334) (‘Biblical Penalty for Murder’).      Murder is not the only thing that the Bible allows death as a punishment for. According to an outline called ‘The Bible and Capital Punishment,” the old Testament gives twenty-one ‘crimes’ in which the death penalty is an okay form of punishment. There are only three out of the twenty-one listed offenses

Capital Punishment And The Innocent

1238 words - 5 pages Capital Punishment And The Innocent A man saddened by the reality of his life takes his first step in years on to free land. As he is walking in freedom, a single tear slowly rolls down his face. His eyes seem to give off a blank stare while he begins his journey back to where he was almost a decade ago. So much has changed. Being locked up helped him realize the meaning of life and how wonderful of a gift that it is. Ironically, being

The History of Capital Punishment

1587 words - 6 pages regarded as a better punishment. It gives a criminal time to think about his actions and reform himself, which should be the goal of a punishment. It is clear that capital punishment is wrong in many ways. Not only is its use indicative of a morally deprived society, but it is also simply impractical and useless. Capital punishment—while it may aim to do otherwise—does not deter crime; it serves only to increase the violence in a society that is

The Ethics of Capital Punishment

1518 words - 6 pages another’s right to live do not have that right for themselves. The real argument at stake here is not moral though but whether or not capital punishment is the best deterrent for crime. The theory of deterrence can be defined as the idea that the threat of punishment has to be severe enough to contradict the pleasure that the criminal would obtain from the crime. There are two types of deterrents specific and general. A general deterrent could

The Abolishment of Capital Punishment

2581 words - 10 pages painless and ethical. Today’s methods are less painful than in the past. All methods result in pain for the criminal; some would say that it is wrong to put them through that kind of pain. Others say criminals who committed acts like rape or murder deserve to suffer like their victims suffered (“Issue”). Those who are in favor of capital punishment believe that all states should use the penalty and sentence criminals to death if they are

The morality of Capital Punishment

2110 words - 8 pages the scope of this paper, I offer a summary of the article "Capital Punishment" by Hugo Adam Bedau. Bedau's article argues against capital punishment and talks about the two main principles of retributive justice that relate to the controversy of capital punishment. I will refute Bedau's claims and offer my arguments for the morality of capital punishment, including how capital punishment is a crime deterrent and how it keeps

The History of Capital Punishment

2147 words - 9 pages the desirability, worth or importance of ones life to consider legally ending someone’s life. Considering the value of life leads straight into the argument of capital punishment, especially in regards to murder. The concepts of ethical formalism, utilitarianism, and religion applies to capital punishment (Pollock, 2012). Ethical formalism applies to capital punishment because it is the concept that holds that the only thing truly good is a good

The Benefits of Capital Punishment

1089 words - 4 pages than the death penalty would be an insult to the victim and society” (Mike Royko, Chicago Journalist). Given the benefits of capital punishment it is hard to imagine why anyone would be against it. Capital punishment is very capable of deterring crime. It not only keeps the criminal behind bars for life, but it also prevents parole boards and criminal rights activists from giving hardcore criminals the chance to repeat their crime. If laws

Similar Essays

Is Capital Punishment A Human Way To Deal With Criminals?

1355 words - 5 pages Capital Punishment has been around for as long as there has been written language. It has been used all over the world, in different cultures, and has been executed in different styles. In the past, the death penalty was taken for granted for almost any crime you can think of (Garland). However in today’s society, the question has been asked if Capital Punishment is a humane way to deal with criminals. For most of recorded human history

Capital Punishment: A Negative Way To Deter Crime

2404 words - 10 pages , a lot of the costs go to the people who help complete the execution. In North Carolina the cost of each death penalty case exceeds the cost of life in prison by $2.16 million (Death Penalty). It would cost Florida approximately $24 million to execute a person (Death Penalty). Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is a negative way to deter crime. Not only is it a negative process but a costly and risky one too. States and tax payers are

“Capital Punishment Is The Right Way To Deal With Murderers.”

942 words - 4 pages not do might get executed, but it wasn’t their fault. On the one hand, capital punishments deter potential murderers and criminals from breaking the law or offending, because it shows that there'll be consequences for committing a crime. However, there's no proof that capital punishment is a better deterrent than life imprisonment, they both keep the criminal away from the general public. Using capital punishment suggests that an executed murderer

The Practice Of Capital Punishment Essay

1217 words - 5 pages fear in the mind of a criminal. In fact, ever thing is finished in a few seconds when the criminal is given lethal injection or hanged. That suffering can never act as a deterrent. Usually, die-hard criminals are highly courageous in their endeavors, and procedures such as capital punishment cannot deter them at all. On the contrary, capital punishment fosters racial disparity in the society and any effort to correct it goes in vain, if the