Capital Punishment Removes Rehabilitation From Incarceration

1510 words - 6 pages

Capital Punishment Removes Rehabilitation from Incarceration
Capital Punishment refers to the sentence or decision to
a capital crime such as murder, rape, or assault. Many times,
the sentence is life in prison or execution. Currently, the
United States is the only western democracy that still has
execution on the books. An alternative to execution is life
imprisonment, which is common throughout the world. There are
many features, however of life imprisonment that are debated.
Treatment of offenders of capital crimes is questionable in
certain prisons. Also, the safety of society is a question at
hand when discussing life imprisonment assuming the prisoner
could be up for parole or escape. Lastly, the rehabilitation
process of offenders of capital punishment is a big question
mark. Many wonder what success it brings, just how effective it
really is, and what its purpose is for criminals who've
committed such horrible crimes as homicide, or other capital
crimes.
The Article "The Wrong Man" by Alan Berlow points out
some of the wrongs about the death penalty. There are numerous
stories of men who spent their life on death row, only to be
released days or hours before their death because of being
proved innocent. In his article Alan talks about "the growing
number of innocent prisoner being discovered on death row" and
how the government needs to "wake up"(Berlow 7). This means
that more and more cases are being rushed to execution without
all of the facts. Remember, in order to give a sentence, the
client must be guilty beyond reasonable doubt, and it seems
that this is sometimes ignored as unclear cases are being
pushed by officers and lawyers to executions. Another point
brought up by Berlow is how good of a lawyer defendants have in
these capital cases. "Most public defendants are so poorly paid
that talented lawyers tend to stay away from this sort of
practice (Berlow 9)." This means that defendants that are poor,
which most are, cannot afford to get a lawyer that will look
into the case as much as he can, and try to help the defendant
as much as possible. Because of the economic status of most
people tried for murder, a lot of cases end up being like this,
where the public lawyer is paid poorly and doesn't give much
effort towards the case at all.
Berlow also talks about how the death penalty may be
taken away. He says "if it could be proved that an innocent
person has been executed (Berlow 14)", the public support would
drastically decline. Now, Berlow says "70-76% support the death
penalty depending on the poll (Berlow 13)." This is a major
increase from the earlier part of the century, and as
executions become more and more common, public opinion and
media attention go down. Berlow says how maybe if someone that
was innocent beyond doubt was executed like in England, the
same result of England would be likely to happen: a banning of
the death penalty. To...

Find Another Essay On Capital Punishment Removes Rehabilitation from Incarceration

Capital Punishment Essay

3867 words - 15 pages sole end for punishment - proper goals include measurable deterrent effects, isolation of persons dangerous to society, and rehabilitation. Since all three of the “proper” goals could be accomplished sufficiently through a less severe. less permanent punishment, such as extended incarceration, capital punishment was excessive. The arguments contained in the Furman decision were readdressed by the Supreme Court four years later in Gregg v. Georgia

Final Essay

945 words - 4 pages sophisticated prisons and prisoners, the question still stands… which is best; rehabilitation or punishment? Without taking an either or approach, one can see that it is more a question of what balance do we need? ”Incarceration when an offender is sentenced to prison it could affect offenders psychologically. Offenders can become depressed due to separation from family, and society. Incarceration of an offender can hurt the family structure

What is The Problem with the US Correctional Systems

2033 words - 8 pages , electrocution, hanging or shooting by the military under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. But in California, incarceration is preferred method to punish offenders, according to randomhistory.com. Corporal Punishment is consequent from a Latin word meaning body. Which meant physical punishment and in the past it was very common. In California, corporal punishment has been implemented instead of capital punishment. Prisoners and civil rights

The Purpose of Punishment in a Modern Society

2454 words - 10 pages Punishment has been in existence since the early colonial period and has continued throughout history as a method used to deter criminals from committing criminal acts. Philosophers believe that punishment is a necessity in today’s modern society as it is a worldwide response to crime and violence. Friedrich Nietzche’s book “Punishment and Rehabilitation” reiterates that “punishment makes us into who we are; it creates in us a sense of

Are Prisons Effective?

1544 words - 6 pages other party will be less willing to break the law and end up in prison as well. Furthermore, punishment itself would satisfy most of society when the criminal is imprisoned. Prison offers law-breakers a chance to receive drug treatment, educational benefits, and as stated before, a chance at rehabilitation. Also, incarceration costs less than leaving criminals out of prisons because the cost of housing inmates is less than the cost of their

Alternative Incarceration:ARE BOOT CAMPS AN EFFECTIVE FORM OF INCARCERATION? Introduction & Overview of the Problem.

4890 words - 20 pages (i.e., repeat offending, return to prison) and to reduce costs versus longer-term traditional incarceration (Simon, 1995, p. 27). Other common goals include providing general deterrence for young offenders, providing enhanced discipline, instilling a strong "work ethic," and rehabilitation (Ransom & Mastrorilli, 1993; Souryal and MacKenzie, 1994). For example, the official goals in Florida are "to divert offenders from long terms of

Theories of Punishment

809 words - 4 pages form of punishment commonly occurred during the pilgrim years when stockades were prominent. A decent example of deterrence would be the use of capital punishment to deter people from acting out certain crimes such as murder. In the use of deterrence, the individual criminal is not the focus of the punishment. Research has shown that increasing the certainty of the punishment, not the incensement of the severity, has a deterrence effect. A lot of

Cost of Incarceration

1553 words - 6 pages What is incarceration? Incarceration is the act of placing someone in prison. Incarceration serves as a punishment for criminals due to their actions against the law. It is a solution for keeping the public safe. Prisoners follow a strict rules and schedules while following the culture within the walls among other prisoners. As a result of their crimes, convicts lose their freedom and are place among others who suffer the same fate. Crime is the

Rehabilitation or Retribution?

967 words - 4 pages re-entering into prisons.Yet, rehabilitation and punishment are mutually exclusive goals, but they become more and more integrated in modern society, since the late 18th century prisons have combined elements of punishment with elements of rehabilitation. As the French philosopher Michel Foucault put it, punishment shifted over time from the disciplining of the body to the disciplining of the "soul" (Politics.co.uk, 2007). Therefore, incarceration

The Mission of the Correctional System

1291 words - 5 pages taxpayers. Prisons are the first and the most effective punishment. It removes the liberty of offenders, forcing them to comply with a structured, disciplined and tough regime where everyday choices usually taken for granted are removed. But along with this punishment we must also give offenders the chance to reform and change their behavior. Offenders must take responsibility for their behavior and take the opportunities for reform offered to

Capital Punishment Throughout History

1668 words - 7 pages , capital punishment should be continued in the United States. From the moment a man enacts violence against an innocent person, he has denounced the principle of individual rights. He chooses to no longer act as a rational being, but rather a predator among men, to harm and destroy those around him. Rationality is the human reasoning and the source of human rights. Those who contradict rationality are detrimental to society and have no rights

Similar Essays

Rehabilitation, Not Capital Punishment Essay

700 words - 3 pages Rehabilitation, Not Capital Punishment           The death penalty is the punishment used in 38 states, and many other countries, as a way of disposing the people in society who are mentally or emotionally disturbed, love their families very much, have a bad temper, or just plain made a mistake.  These reasons account for many homicides that take place each year.  Capitol Punishment is

The Christian Perspective On Capital Punishment And Rehabilitation

2873 words - 11 pages Capital punishment is the taking of an offender’s life for a crime which he has committed and found guilty of by a court or tribunal under law. For Etuk, capital punishment is the death penalty when it is executed after a due process of law carried out by a society’s duly constituted apparatus (2000, 6). It is distinguished from other forms of extra-legal killings such as shooting on sight of suspected criminals, assassinations, disappearance of

The Pros And Cons Of Capital Punishment From All Angles.

2374 words - 9 pages a life has been taken, no full restitution can be made, of course, but some kind of service to the community might be required as a way of partially making amends. EVALUATION Such, in brief, is the argument for and against capital punishment, one founded on justice and the nature of moral community, the other resting on love and the nature of an ideal spiritual community. If we stand back from this description and make an attempt at evaluation

Criminal Rehabilitation In The United States Justice System

2028 words - 9 pages stingy spending on the prisons, which can be seen from the billions of dollars that are thrown at prisons to keep U.S. citizens locked up. This dangerous and inefficient system must be reformed for the benefit of U.S. citizens that are involved in them whether through paying taxes or being in these prisons. Although the fear of punishment deters crime, United States criminal justice systems should focus on rehabilitation. In its past, the United