Capitalistic Punishment Essay

963 words - 4 pages

Capitalistic Punishment "An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth" says the Old Testament of the Judeo-Christian Bible. Throughout history, different societies have incorporated this principle into their legal and cultural lives. In today's context in the United States, this traditional form of retributional theory has taken the form of state-sponsored capital punishment. The infamous "death penalty," legalized nationally in 1976 by Supreme Court decision, has resulted in the execution of over five hundred convicted (rightly and wrongly) murderers in the past quarter century. In the minds of advocates, the ultimate penalty has swiftly and justly incapacitated killers as well as effectively deterred future murderers. On the contrary, both common sense and empirical evidence reveal capital punishment to be inefficient, ineffective, and unjust; therefore, the death penalty should be abolished in the United States.Most of those who espouse capital punishment laud it for its supposed deterrence effect; that is, its alleged ability to intimidate would-be criminals into abstaining from murder for fear of the fatal penalty. According to statistics, however, no such effect is apparent. "Since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976, the number of executions and the size of death row have substantially increased. Yet during this same period of time, the FBI Uniform Crime Reports show virtually no change in the national murder rate" (). Moreover, some sociologists like Hugo Adam Bedau in his book The Death Penalty in America suggest that these very executions intended to deter crime, may, in fact, incite crime through a "brutalization" effect, whereby a cycle of violence and murder is only intensified by government-approved homicide. Common sense backs up this empirical evidence. First, one can classify homicides into two categories for practical purposes: pre-meditated and non-premeditated. Obviously, those who plan to murder either plan to get away with the crime or simply are not concerned with the consequences of their actions. Similarly, those who kill in a spontaneous fit of emotion or while under the influence of drugs or alcohol have not rationally considered the ramifications of their actions. In both instances, no matter how serious or intimidating the threat of punishment may be, the concept of deterrence is questionable at best.Another questionable characteristic associated with the death penalty is the fallacy that it is the most efficient method of retribution. Surely, executing a convicted murderer would be the most cost-effective manner to incapacitate him or her. This might be true if the American justice system were structured differently, but according to studies "the death penalty is not now, nor has it ever been, a more economical alternative to life imprisonment" (Spangenberg 47). And furthermore, in The Death Penalty in America, Bedau cites research that shows states like Florida, New York, Kansas, Maryland, and North Carolina...

Find Another Essay On Capitalistic punishment

19th Century Theories in Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment

2539 words - 10 pages 19th Century Theories in Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment   "I teach you the Superman. Man is something that has to be surpassed. What have you done to surpass him?" These words said by Friedrich Nietzsche encompass the theories present in Dostoevsky's nineteenth century novel, Crime and Punishment. Fyodor Dostoevsky, living a life of suffering himself, created the character of Raskolnikov with the preconceptions of his

Cast Away Essay

870 words - 3 pages In the movie Cast Away, Chuck Noland says that to turn ones back on time is to commit a sin. In this movie, Chuck’s life revolves around time, and his ability to make more money is directly affected by time. This fact, however, is exactly what is related as a bad thing. Throughout the movie, capitalistic ventures, which require an extreme investment of time, are characterized as evil. The message sent in Cast Away is that we live in a

Time Machine

882 words - 4 pages threat to wealthy elite. During the first meeting in Time Traveller’s house, the narrator says “To discover a society … erected on a strictly communistic basis” (Chapter 1). He answers the Very Young Man who comes up with an idea of investing money in present and getting back the compounded investment in the future, a strictly capitalistic way of thinking. Also, Time Traveller says “At first, proceeding from the problems of our own age, it seemed

Immigartion, Incarceration and Deportation

1707 words - 7 pages Introduction I choose to research about immigration and incarceration and deportation because I believe there is a lot of racism with minorities specifically with Hispanics in the United States. This topic got my attention because immigration is an endless and controversial topic in the democracy system of this country. The capitalistic system in politics is very racism with minorities. This is a very touchy subject that millions of people is

Politics and Criminal Law

1540 words - 6 pages crimes rise, the public demands increased action from political leaders. Politicians then respond by expanding criminal codes, but fail to focus on policing and punishment. They often exaggerate crime problems in the United States. The overstated crime problem, backed by a capitalistic media and misinterpreted statistics has created an enormous punitive crime policy, which is further supported by individualistic theories of crime. By constantly

Consumption, Fear, and Truth: the Dangerous Realities Predicted in a Post WWII Society

1114 words - 5 pages forced into a corrupted system by fear and punishment. In Orwell’s dystopian society of 1984, the main character conforms to the system unwillingly though he understands the corruption and dreams of revolt. In Brave New World the citizens are controlled by consumption and pleasure so they are content and find no reason to rebel. This illustrates the extent and success of the brainwashing as a human being with free will would not willingly

rear window text

1279 words - 6 pages apartment window we see how people live in their natural state and give the film a sense of realism. Each window shows what life was like, living in America in 1950. Each character represents different social classes. As Jefferies lens focuses on apartment complexes across the alley, it displays a capitalistic view of the tenants. On the top floor lives a hard working pianist in what appears to be apartment house suite with the great view and accompanied

The War on Terrorism

1278 words - 5 pages representations of the true Islam. In order for a true Islam to occur the Taliban set forth new laws that had dire consequences. They developed an aspiration to become a national Islamic government. With this new government they attempted to eradicate crime with the introduction of Islamic law that allowed harsh punishment for crimes, for example public executions and amputations. Members of the Taliban said their aim was to set up the world's most

One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest Analytical Essay

1262 words - 6 pages control. Another branch of the theme of oppressors and salvation that relates to Nurse Ratched, as well as Randle McMurphy, is the idea that they are both representatives of figures based in Catholicism. Sexual repression and freedom is seen with the ultimate punishment in the ward, a lobotomy, being stated as equivalent to castration. Both of the operations are seen as emasculating, removing the men’s personal freedom, individuality, and sexual

Elite Philosophers: John Locke, Niccolo Machiavelli, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels

1576 words - 7 pages simply by communicating whereas Machiavelli argued how the weaknesses of a human (fear) can be used to achieve what the monarch needs in the state. The ultimatum of having freedom or being enslaved sets a boundary on what people thought about at the time. Locke also talked about discipline just as Machiavelli had, that was the fact that if someone does not follow the laws set by society themselves then they should be subject to punishment (Locke 31

Globalization's Expiatory Sheep: Victimization of workers

2146 words - 9 pages exploitation is just not sustainable. (Henderson 1) So, taking this into account, one can see the flaws in the oppositions argument that demand for low prices controls worker wages. Not only is there a problem in the oppositions excuses, but there are also problems with worker wages that need to be faced and dealt with.As everyone knows, we live in a capitalistic society in which everyone tries to get ahead and make the most profit they can

Similar Essays

Bartleby The Scrivener Essay

1176 words - 5 pages , the forlorn and eccentric scrivener Bartleby. Anyone who comes across him may consider him to be an intrepid hero who openly deviates from the exploitative capitalism, or a wicked villain who brazenly disturbs the established capitalistic social order. But I would prefer to regard him as a tragic figure of the capitalistic society, who is doomed to the miserable fate because of the intolerance of the capitalistic society to the aberrant, his

The Merits And Pitfalls Of Capital Punishment Today

1843 words - 8 pages . Capital punishment itself is a separate entity from the associated proceedings and should be considered as such, however it will not be for the sake of monetary comparisons. That said, capital punishment and its associated proceedings can have significant cost cuts if it is more widely embraced by the general public due to the simple fact that, in our capitalistic economy, every bit saved makes a difference and improvements will be made in order to

Failures Of Capital Punishment Essay

793 words - 3 pages to carry out executions.” In a capitalistic standpoint, there is the notion that it simply costs too much. There is another and more simple standpoint and that is that the death penalty is not working. This is where I personally stand on the issue. The death penalty is a just punishment for a convicted individual, but the system in the United States is not functioning properly for it to be a means of punishment. As far as deterrence goes

The Reflection Of Self Realization In The Major Dramatic Works Of Arthur Miller In The Light Of Aristotelian Definition Of Anagnorisis

2694 words - 11 pages reads Larry’s letter, Chris leaves the decision of any punishment up to his father: “Now you tell me what you must do… tell me where you belong.” (All My Sons) The firing of a gun from inside the house serves as final punctuation to Chris’s speech. Having become aware that there is something bigger than his family, Joe has carried out his threat to shoot himself. Close to tears, Chris returns from his father’s body inside the house and goes