Captain Robert Semrau: A Question Of Ethics

2412 words - 10 pages

On October 19, 2008, Captain Robert Semrau of the 3rd Battalion of the Royal Canadian Regiment shot and killed an unarmed, gravely wounded Taliban insurgent in Helmand province, Afghanistan. At the time of the shooting Capt. Semrau was employed as commander of Operational Mentor Liaison Team call sign 72A composed of four soldiers divided into two firing teams. The team had been conducting a clearing operation in conjunction with the Afgan National Army whom the team had been mentoring when the forward faction of the company came upon an enemy position. An intense fire fight ensued resulting in Capt. Semrau calling in an air strike with an Apache helicopter. After the air strike was completed the two divisions advanced coming across a Taliban guerrilla who had been gravely wounded when he was shot out of a tree by the Apache strike. The on-scene Afghan National Army officer, Captain Shaffigullah determined that “the man was too wounded to save, telling the others: If Allah wants him, he will die. If not, he will live.” Unsatisfied by this, Capt. Semrau made what he perceived to be a moral decision and subsequently fired two rounds into the insurgent’s chest to put him “out of his misery.” The ‘mercy killing’ was kept secret amongst the witnesses of the Operational Mentor Liason Team and Afghan National Army for two months. The incident remained a secret amongst the close circle of witnesses for two months before a member of the Afghan National Army broke the silence in December of 2008. The break in the silence gave Corporal Steven Fournier the courage to discuss the incident of Oct. 19th with Chief Warrant Officer David Fisher and the National Investigation Service. Capt. Semrau was then subsequently arrested and taken into military custody December 30, 2008. The charge sheet of Capt. Semrau dated December 18, 2009 stated
Charge 1 (alternate to charge 2): S. 130 NDA, Second Degree Murder (s. 235(1) CCC), Charge 2 (alternate to charge 1): S. 130 NDA, attempt to commit murder using a firearm (s. 239(1)(a.1) CCC), Charge 3: S. 93 NDA, behaved in a disgraceful manner, Charge 4: S. 124 NDA, negligently performed a military duty imposed on him.

Capt. Semrau was tried before a military tribunal and found guilty of charge 3, behaving in a disgraceful manner. His sentence was a reduction in rank to second lieutenant and dismissal from Her Majesty’s service.
The morally and ethically questionable actions of Capt. Semrau have been heavily scrutinized as details of the ‘execution’ have emerged throughout the investigation and trial. Notwithstanding the opinions of the public and Canadian military, the actions of Capt. Semrau were illegal and immoral. Through discussion of applicable Canadian criminal law, ethical principles, obligations, types of dilemmas and how Trevino’s 1986 interactionist model of ethical decision making one can evaluate the legality and morality of Capt. Semrau’s ‘mercy killing.’
The Criminal Code of Canada is an...

Find Another Essay On Captain Robert Semrau: A Question of Ethics

Veteran Service Organizations- A Question of Legitimacy

3492 words - 14 pages Afghanistan veteran community. However, it wasn’t until researching the advocacy tenet of their mission statement that questions of legitimacy arose. Legitimacy In order for an organization to claim representational authority for a specific group, one must question its legitimacy. Many measures can be used to determine an organization’s legitimacy. For the purpose of this investigation the following measures will be used: 1) The number of valid

Robert Frost: The Life of a Poet

1181 words - 5 pages Robert Frost's words touch everyone who reads them and have become a standard for schools and libraries everywhere. The poet of freedom knew tragic joy for eighty-eight years. His days were not free of tears, though some have thought he was unduly optimistic. Despite problems at home and his rough start, he rose to become one of the greatest poets in American history. Using the New England countryside as a base for his poetry, Robert Frost

Robert Borden - A Leader of Men?

785 words - 3 pages rights to women and the introduction of conscription, serve as some examples to establish Sir Robert Laird Borden as one of the greatest leaders in Canadian history.Financing a war costs a great deal and can be quite a strain on the government and economy. During 1918, the cost of war for Canada surpassed $1 million a day. However, the Canadian economy was quite successful during the war. Canadian farms were very prosperous since the war isolated

Robert Frost - A Comparisson Of 3 Poems

1235 words - 5 pages Comparing Frost’s "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening", "Birches", and "The Road Not taken" Robert Frost was an American poet that first became known after publishing a book in England. He soon came to be one of the best-known and loved American poets ever. He often wrote of the outdoors and the three poems that I will compare are of that "outdoorsy" type. There are

The Virtues of the Vices of Virtue Ethics by Robert Louden

2086 words - 8 pages we do not seem to be able to know with any degree of certainty who really is virtuous and who is vicious. For how is one to go about establishing an agent’s true moral character?” Hursthouse states that “Virtue ethics has been characterized in a number of ways… as… ‘agent-centred’ rather than ‘act-centred’; … with Being rather than Doing; … [rising] the question, ‘What sort of person should I be?’ rather than… ‘What sorts of actions should I do

Question of Ethics

913 words - 4 pages Positive law can be defined as a written law that has been passed by a branch of government, regardless of whether it offends anyone's sense of right and wrong. Positivism separates law and morality (Mayer, Warner, Siedel, and Lieberman). Positivists believe that any ethical theories of morality, religion, and justice should play no role in the analysis of the law. Positivism has two values. First, by requiring that all law be written, it

A Company's Code of Ethics

1945 words - 8 pages A company's code of ethics is very important to establishing the expectations and quality of its brand. The code of ethics are concrete expectations for employee behavior, accountability and communicates the ethical policy of a company to its partners and clients. A good business practice is to have sound ethics. Having good ethical practice is knowing the difference between right and wrong and choosing what the right thing is

A Short History of Ethics

1276 words - 5 pages In chapters three and four of A Short History of Ethics, Alastair MacIntyre makes a clear distinction between two philosophical doctrines at loggerheads: the Sophists and Socrates. The Sophistic amalgam of personal success, lust and power is constantly interrogated by an interlocutor in an endless plight to reveal Sophistic ignorance, fruitless desires and the right to universal justice. MacIntyre identifies the codes of both parties, and

A QUESTION OF AUTHORITY         The most read book of all

2037 words - 8 pages A QUESTION OF AUTHORITY The most read book of all time: the Bible. The most read teachers from within the Bible: Jesus Christ and the Apostle Paul. The subject and reason behind all of the Apostle Paul's writings: Jesus Christ. The most influential teacher whose life most closely preceded Jesus' life: Aristotle. Both Jesus and Aristotle spent their efforts trying to teach one how to think, and consequently how one ought to live. Aristotle, Jesus

Imperialism in the Tempest - a Question of Ethics and Morality

1469 words - 6 pages When one interacts with strangers, feelings of superiority and inferiority are bound to occur. In Shakespeare's time period, most of the Europeans' perspectives were disrespectful, arrogant, and full of ignorance. Like the Native Americans, for most of the European colonists who landed in the "New World," it was their first exposure to the people of a different race. And yet, their first intuition of the Native Americans was described as

Tower of Babel. A look at Robert Louis Stevenson's work

916 words - 4 pages kindly, meaning he was sober--or violent, meaning he was drunk. The latter mood was the cause of death of the cabin-boy, Ransome. So wholly different were Mr. Shuan's two moods that he was completely unaware of his actions. Captain Hoseason, another example of this contradiction, is shown to be a slavedriver and a murderer. However, Stevenson tells us also that he is genuinely religious and kind to his mother. This duality of Captain Hoseason's

Similar Essays

Patents The Question Of Ethics

5122 words - 20 pages desperately needed cheap medicine. Merck had already reduced the prices on its two major Aids drugs by almost 90%. The question was whether to oppose a law that would permit the importation of even cheaper generic versions produced in violation of internationally recognized patents.How AIDS is different in Africa...AIDS in sub- Saharan is different from other medical situations in three important respects. First, the few effective drugs are all

Comparing Jane Goodall's A Question Of Ethics And Heloisa Sabin's Essay "Animal Research Saves Human Lives"

1189 words - 5 pages choices human beings make. This view can be unrealistic in many situations. Jane Goodall’s A Question of Ethics was a very emotional and Rogerian style essay, but I found it lacked the supporting facts and credibility that can be found in Heloisa Sabin’s aggressive “classic” styled essay Animal research Saves Human Lives. Heloisa Sabin helped establish the Sabin Vaccine Institute in 1993 whose mission is to promote the role of vaccines which will

This Essay Discusses The Question Of Ethics When It Pertains To Taking Part In A War

1120 words - 4 pages Can an ethical individual take part in a war?Turning this question around in my mind, trying to think of it in a critical manner, and researching others' thoughts on the matter, I have concluded that there cannot be a true and valid answer to this question.To take part in a war in which you will be in battle leads to killing, violence, the end of life. To take life, I believe that you must make the subject subhuman. In saying this, I mean that

Captain Tory A Short Story About How Captain Tory Learned To Take Heed Of Others, No Matter How Unreliable They May Seem

604 words - 2 pages Tory.“I told you, boss. He had the kid hostage and he wanted something. Something of ours. He killed the kid!” replied Baxter with questionable confidence.“That’s ridiculous.” Tory tried to shrug Wiley Baxter off as delusional, but the more he watched the disturbance, the more worried he became. Suddenly, he had an idea. Captain Tory ran to Wiley Baxter’s room and turned on the radio.“…Ten minutes ago, a