This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Good And Evil On The Rail Case Study

1447 words - 6 pages

Good and Evil on the Rail Case Study
Sanchez’s love for trains since his early teenage days led him to his career as a Locomotive Engineer in Metrolink commuter rail system. He loved his job, had a few disciplinary issues here and there; absences and failure to follow rules set mostly in the use of his cell phone during operation hours. On September 12, 2008, a day like any other, he was up ready for his daily routine. On this day, Sanchez was chatting with a teenage rail fan that he planned on sneaking in later in the day. He started by disobeying protocol; he passed a yellow rail light past Chatsworth station failing to notify the dispatcher and call out. After passing this station, he made a critical mistake. As always, he doesn’t obey some of the rail light signals, seeing a red light ahead signaling him to STOP, he fails to signal dispatch on signal whilst not stopping. His train passed over a power switch turned meant for an oncoming freight train; the two trains collided, killing 25 people, leaving many injured.
An investigation had to be done by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTBS). Its aim was to investigate transport accidents and make safety recommendations. NTBS did a detailed analysis of the accident also focusing on the management of Metrolink. Sanchez was hired and being supervised by Connex who ran the trains owned by Metrolink but, overall responsibility for the operations was undertaken by Metrolink themselves. The efficiency tests on every railroad were done by Connex. Their role was to observe the trains, monitor the radio traffic, and the analysis of data collected recording devices in locomotives so as to check the employees’ compliance to set rules (Steiner & Steiner, 2011).
With all the tests ever done during Sanchez’s employment by Connex, only a few failures were recorded. In the few recorded incidents he was caught up with, he was only counseled on it and not to be checked back on, on their compliance. For example, in the period when the safety regulations came to effect, Sanchez compliance was tested, a manager arranged someone to call his cellular, and Sanchez lied to have forgotten his cellular in his pocket rather than stowing it away switched off. The manager only counseled him on spot about the policy. The manager never bothered to get arrange other calls to test if he complied. From the later confrontations and being sited to disobey the wayside signals and radioing the Metrolink operations, it is a habit he had. All Connex did was speaking to the accused about the policy, a few observations, and then trusting them to comply again. The Connex Company was supposed to foresee the implementation of the safety policy, but it had a hard time in implementing them; “we run the railroads as Metrolink want,” Top Connex manager (Steiner & Steiner, 2011).
From its findings NTSB might be true on stating the probable cause of the collision between the two trains to have been the inattention Sanchez gave to the...

Find Another Essay On Good and Evil on the Rail Case Study

The reality of good and evil

2401 words - 10 pages because there is a reason why they did that. So in other words, what they do is not based on good or evil or even right and wrong, they just based it on they 're on personal feelings. This by right would make people to doubt or even ask if good or evil exist.As I said that this two are the most major factor that actually make anyone doubt the reality of good and evil. I mean considerations or experience may change a person's view in life so why

The Coexistence of Good and Evil

837 words - 4 pages The book To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee is often associated with a various number of themes such as racism, social inequality, the importance of family values, and much more. But one of the more hidden messages of the book centers around the idea that there is a coexistence of good and evil. This theme is really brought to life the more the reader is able to understand the book. Through sub themes such as coming of age

The Good and Evil in People

957 words - 4 pages readers to believe that at one point Katagiri becomes Frog briefly as Narrator becomes Tyler Durden in Fight Club. The lack of dialogue adds a strong case, so what does Worm, the nemesis of Frog, represent? If readers think Frog is the "good" Katagiri, then the “un-Frog” part of Frog is Worm, Katagiri’s dark side. To stop the pending earthquake, Frog faces Worm. Worm, the sleeping underground monster, plans to wake up and terrorize the people

The Road Between Good And Evil

676 words - 3 pages The Road of Good And Evil During ones life he/she will meet many different people. As he/she travels down life's unpredictable road and enters the work force, he/she will meet both kind and cruel supervisors. Likewise in the Narrative of The Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, Frederick experiences good and evil masters. Although the people Douglass meets are in complete control of his life, he encounters both cruel and kind, only

Religious Beliefs on the Power of Good and the Power of Evil

3091 words - 12 pages really matter who is to blame. Just because there is suffering in the world, it does not mean that God doesn't love humans. Every good thing always eliminates every evil that it knows about and can eliminate. Whether it eradicates evil fully or not, we are still doing good and I feel people do not recognise this enough. People focus more on evil, such as the child killers in the case of toddler James Bulger. The media spent

This is an analytical essay on Beowulf and the role of evil versus good. It talks about how evil is needed to define the good guy

1269 words - 5 pages relationships were fully for his benefit. The enemies define him as a hero and give us thefull picture of him as the good. The evilness of the enemy is needed in recognition of the heroand understanding good and how it functions. Evil is used to understand good; in fact we needevil to fully grasp this good. Does, this mean evil is actually an act of good because good cannotfunction without it?

Good And Evil

1310 words - 5 pages through out the world and the entire human race are based on the aspects of good and evil and their endless struggle for dominance. However despite this endless struggle many have claimed that good always wins, but can that truly exist. What is good with out evil, many have become so used to a society where both are so internally intertwined that a society where only one exists has only been created with imagination. This aspect of a good society

Good, Evil, and Conscience

1737 words - 7 pages ). Determining your morals, and thus, your concept of good and evil, is solely based on life experiences, environment, and the interaction of these two forces.Traditional good and evil are often denoted by common belief systems, such as the good versus evil stories presented in the Bible along with other religious texts. These systems survive the ages usually through preaching, practice, and studious work, and are now seen today as what one may call the "base

Good And Evil

690 words - 3 pages Good, as well as evil is a strong, existing force inside us all. An Indian chief of the Pawnee tribe once said, "All things in the world are two.In our minds we are two, good and evil. With our eyes we see two things, things that are fair and things that are ugly.... We have the right hand that strikes and makes for evil, and we have the left hand full of kindness, near the heart. One foot may lead us to an evil way, the other foot may lead us

Evil And Good

980 words - 4 pages As children, we hear many stories about the confrontations between good and evil. “There are relatively few ways to do good, but countless ways to do evil, which can hence have a greater impact on our lives, and the lives of others beings capable of suffering,” written by Plato. His words could be used the same way on how we characterize the differences between good and evil, affecting how we view them. Fairy tales and other media have their

Good and Evil

815 words - 4 pages . As many would see the good in this particular novel to be Ralph, and the evil to be Jack, there is another perspective. Each and every boy on that island has moments of savagry, and then moments of regret. They understand what is morally right, but on occasion, listen to the demon in their head that tells them to disobey their concience. Jack is the prime representative that someone of the most evil intentions still knows whats right and wrong

Similar Essays

On The Battlefield With Good And Evil

737 words - 3 pages As a kid I always loved going to the movies and seeing Spiderman, Batman, or Superman kicking the bad guys’ butts’ on the big screen. It seems movies these days always have the same overarching theme though good vs. evil. Even those super girly princess movies have aspects of good and evil. Take The Little Mermaid, for example, there is the protagonist, Ariel, and the antagonist, Ursula, and just like in all of the other movies, the

Christians' Beliefs On Good And Evil

1816 words - 7 pages Christians' Beliefs on Good and Evil Christians may believe many different things about the power of good and the power of evil. The Roman Catholic Church teaches that God is all good and perfect. They teach that God perfectly loves; they also teach that God has the power to do anything (omnipotence). But there are all kinds of evil things in the world that cause people to suffer. These include moral evil, natural

St. Augustine: Thoughts On Good And Evil

1056 words - 4 pages the evils of life and it can also guide them into a righteous path” (Augustine 137, 139). Man decides if they do good or bad. In Book two chapter one, Augustine confesses to God and reflects on his inward being. Through his confessions he developed a different understanding on the views of sin and evil. By looking at himself Augustine realized he wanted to get closer to God. In his youth he was promiscuous and he was eager to please the eyes of

How Are Good And Evil Represented In "The Strange Case Of Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde"?

2060 words - 8 pages "The strange case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde" explores the idea that there is evil in all of us. Therefore there are many things which represent both good and evil in the story in this essay I am going to explain how Robert Louis Stevenson achieves this.Robert Louis Stevenson set this short novella in London in Victorian times. London in Victorian times was full of dramatic inventions, the slow destruction of the rigid class system and the