Case Analysis "Uninsured On Life Support" Ethical Issues In Healthcare Case Study

1165 words - 5 pages

Elizabeth Castro-Wilson
PHI204
Case Study #2
I. Statement of the problems:
The patient, Malala, is a 20 year old uninsured female who has suffered severe head trauma as a result of an ATV accident. She is currently hospitalized and on life-support. Several neurologists have evaluated her case and all agree that her recovery is highly unlikely or impossible. Her family members have begged for the hospital to continue her life-support because they believe that Malala has been responsive on a few occasions, but those “responses” were unverifiable.
Malala has been on life-support for 76 days, which costs approximately $14,000 daily. The cost of her emergency treatment prior to being on life-support totaled around $227,000. Although the hospital does receive funding from federal and private sources for charity, those funds have been reserved or already used for expenses and programs. Malala’s family is also unable to cover these expenses.
The accident, for which Malala was determined to be “at-fault”, happened not long after the Affordable Care Act was initiated. No one has been able to find out if Malala had applied for insurance. According to a family member, it is unlikely that she ever applied for insurance because she had expressed that she did not feel she could afford it anyway. Malala was working two jobs but neither of them offered any insurance benefits.
II. Resolutions to the problems:
The physicians, hospital administration and Malala’s family members all face some extremely difficult decisions in this case. I don’t believe there are any possible “win-win” scenarios here. So, I will be analyzing this case using a utilitarian approach by first identifying the available courses of action, considering what persons and/or organizations will be affected by those actions, and then recommending the action that will produce the greatest advantage and least amount of harm for all.
There is an important lesson to be learned here—if a person does not have or can’t obtain health insurance, for whatever reason, then they should not be engaging in extreme sports. Furthermore, people should not engage in extreme sports at all without understanding the risks and potential consequences involved and how to prevent them (for example, wear a helmet to prevent brain trauma). I understand most 20 year olds aren’t thinking ahead like that, but this is the general “moral of the story” that comes to mind while analyzing this case. Malala’s injuries and the current moral dilemma are all consequences of carelessness and poor judgment.
A question that came up in my mind when analyzing this case was the possibility of Malala’s state offering emergency Medicaid benefits. Here in Arizona, I believe that the hospital will submit an application for any uninsured patients in the emergency room. Sometimes Medicaid will approve assistance for just the one emergency encounter, and other times they will approve and continue coverage forward for the patient. It was mentioned...

Find Another Essay On Case Analysis--"Uninsured on Life-Support" - Ethical Issues in Healthcare - Case Study

An Ethical Analysis of Enron - BUS323 - Case Study

888 words - 4 pages had invested. Analysis Based on Ethical Theories Enron’s scandal fortifies the need for a company to be transparent as well as maintaining a thorough auditing program. It is socially understood that the executive management has the duty to be transparent and operate the company in a transparent and ethical manner, but they did not see it this way. Deontology states that a person should fulfil their duties and obligations, but this was not the

Ethical Principles On The Case Study Concerning Joelle

691 words - 3 pages Unit 1 Individual Project 1Running head: Unit 1 Individual ProjectUnit 1 Individual Project: Ethical Principles On The case Study Concerning JoelleJohn F ShalkowsiCourse: BUS207-0805A-75 Business EthicsInstructor: Eric FreemanDate: November 14, 2008American Intercontinental UniversityEthical Principles On The Case Study Concerning JoelleThe first principle Joelle could apply would be the Egoism Principle. If she chooses this principle it says

Life Course Case Study

3267 words - 13 pages , collecting information on the four interrelated dimensions of the life story: structural, socio-cultural, interpersonal and personal story. According to Janet Z. Giele and Glen H. Elder, Jr., "Any point in the life span must be viewed dynamically as the consequence of past experience and future expectation," I have tried to keep this in mind while conducting my study and analysis of Mr. Gambina's life span.TheoryThe sociological theory that I shall be

School Counseling: A Case Study in Ethical Decision Making

3174 words - 13 pages unprofessionally and on my own cognisance. I would be violating the ACA, Au, (2008), ACA, US, (2005) and EQ’s, (2008) Student Protection Policy. Option 5 This is the most ethical option to select it follows ACA (2008) Standard 2.1.7.1, ACA (2005), Standard c.2.a, c.2.e, c.2.f, and EQ. (1994) Code of conduct and (2008) Student protection policy. In researching and reading relevant documentation on the case, conferring with my supervisor and other

Legal Issues in Nursing for BSN. Case study

1152 words - 5 pages Running head Case 1Legal Issues Case StudyCase 2Nursing Situation:Cindy Black (fictitious name), a four-year-old child with wheezing, was brought into the emergency room by her mother for treatment at XYZ (fictitious name) hospital at 9:12 p.m. on Friday, May 13.Initial triage assessment revealed that Cindy was suffering from a sore throat,wheezing bilaterally throughout all lung fields, seal-like cough, shortness of breath (SOB), bilateral ear

Tassal case study: Issues in Tassal's sustainable development

3156 words - 13 pages by the CEO to conduct a study and to provide him with a business report on Tassal's sustainable development issues. 1. Introduction The purpose of the report is to research and describe the problems faced by Tassal's sustainable development and to provide viable solutions. The report is divided into five parts, the first part is the introduction of the basic concept of sustainability. The second part discusses the sustainability of the

Case Study Analysis

1156 words - 5 pages Case Study Analysis: The patient,MMMM, needs a blood transfusion and possibly surgery to save her life as well as the life of her unborn child related to an injury she sustained from a motor vehicle accident. The patient does not want to receive blood products or surgery. The patient's reluctance is related to her faith, which is based upon biblical scripture pertaining to blood. The primary ethical issue in this case is the patient's right to

McKinsey Case Study Analysis

2766 words - 12 pages elite firms focusing on issues important to top management for 70 years. The long history of the company is described with the addition of tables and charts to depict 20 year growth rates, mission and principles, areas of practice, and functional groups. Succession, employee growth and development; expansion, and shrinkage are explained in detail within the case study. The company expanded from the original small organization to one of global

Case Study Analysis

2396 words - 10 pages For this paper I will be talking about the analysis of personal and organizational ethics and values between the For-Profit and Not-for-Profit Organizations. The two organizations that I’ve chosen are Acer and Habitat for Humanity. I chose the two organizations off a whim, sometime ago I’ve either read something about them or overheard about them in a conversation. Throughout this class I found myself enjoying doing research on these

Xerox Case Study Analysis

1023 words - 4 pages Xerox Case Study Analysis Xerox's "Book In Time" is a revolutionary product, presenting some new opportunities for the company. It is simply a matter of costs. The Book-in-Time equipment allows for a publishing company to produce a 300-page book for $6.90, something which could have been previously reached only for lots larger than 1,000 copies. A significant decrease in publishing costs, given the fact that these cover up to 20

IBM Case Study Analysis

2313 words - 9 pages becoming a leader in the business of microchip technology. In order to accomplish this, the team started the planning process by conducting a thorough analysis of the external environment, scanning for potential clients and competitors, as well as looking internally for highly motivated and skilled staff. King put great emphasis on finding out and understanding their clients' needs, which added to their early success. Therefore prior to the crisis

Similar Essays

Case Study Midwest Healthcare

809 words - 3 pages Assignment 6-2 Case Study: Midwest Healthcare SystemDavid SmithHCM300-E1WWProfessor Dorr09/27/2014IntroductionWhen accepting a position of leadership at any organization it is important to obtain all pertinent information in regards to the health of the organization. As the new Chief Financial Officer of the Midwest Healthcare System this information will be needed in order to take an in-depth look at the current issues plaguing the organization

Case Study Analysis: Issues Around Abortion

2331 words - 9 pages prove biased as they favor one resolution over the other, as they force some to bear babies they do not want by restricting their options. Ethical Issues Abortion may appear ethical or unethical depending on various viewpoints and circumstances. The fetus is considered a person and bringing it to term may be unethical as the act is considered as murder. In some situations, the mother may require to terminate a pregnancy for her bodily autonomy

Ethical, Legal, And Professional Issues In Counseling University Of San Francisco Case Study, Assignment

674 words - 3 pages Introduction The professional codes of ethics and standards of practice for licensed mental health professionals provides guidelines for therapists when faced with ethical issues that are difficult to resolve. Therapists are expected to engage in a careful review of ethical decision-making process and utilize available resources as needed. This paper provides summary of a journal article titled “When Good Enough isn’t” It identifies legal or

Us Healthcare Solutions Case Study

3502 words - 14 pages . Competitors have superior access to distributors.3. USHS does not have proven infrastructure for delivering the product information to health care organizations.4. Difficult to demonstrate savings to companies and MCO's on evidence base data.5. Regarding end of life care, families think it is a family matter not service provider matter.6. Staff not in place to provide services.7. There is no 24/7 operations for customer support. Gaps in