Case Study Culture Clash In Corning And Vitro Joint Venture

1679 words - 7 pages

1. Identify and discuss Corning's strategic predisposition toward a joint venture with Vitro.Because of long histories of successful joint ventures and had been an innovative leader in foreign alliances for over 73 years, Corning's strategy of establishing the joint venture relationship with Vitro seems to be a ideal combination and will lead to success. However, the joint venture became subject to a series of cultural and other conflicts that began to undermine this vision. According to company officials and external analysts, cultural differences were a principal cause of the alliance's failure. Therefore, lack of fully understanding Mexico culture is the key predisposition of Corning's strategy.What is culture? One of the well-accepted definitions is given by Goodenough (1971), who has defined culture as a set of beliefs or standards, shared by a group of people, which help the individual decide what is, what can be, how to feel, what to do and how to go about doing it. The main cultural clashes between two companies are discussed as follow:● Different decision-making style between Mexican and American:Vitro and other Mexican businesses are much more hierarchical, with loyalty to fathers and patrons somehow carried over to the modern corporation. As a matter of loyalty or tradition, decisions are often left either to a member of the controlling family or to top executives, while middle level managers are often not asked their opinions.As a result, Corning managers who work in the joint venture were sometimes left waiting for important decisions about marketing and sales. Refers to a Corning executive: "If we were looking at a distribution decision, or a customer decision, we typically would have a group of people in a room, they would do an assessment, figure alternatives and make a decision, and I as chief executive would never know about it. My experience on the Mexican side is that someone in the organization would have a solution in mind, but then the decision had to be kicked up a few levels.'● Different working efficiency:The Mexicans sometimes saw the Americans as too direct, while Vitro managers, in their dogged pursuit of politeness, sometimes seemed to the Americans unwilling to acknowledge problems and faults. The Mexicans sometimes thought Corning moved too fast; the Americans felt Vitro was too slow.● Other difference in culture:America is a advanced country in modern society with only 227 years history, traditional culture has far less important position than fashion in most Americans' mind, contrarily, traditional culture plays a significant role in Mexico, most Mexican are conservative even in large companies. For instance, Corning's offices in upstate New York are in a modern glass enclosed building, while Vitro's headquarters in Monterrey, often thought of as Mexico's Pittsburgh, are in a replica of a 16th century convent, with artwork, arched ceilings and antique reproductions.To sum up, attitudes,...

Find Another Essay On Case study--culture clash in corning and vitro joint venture

Enter foreign market through licensing and joint venture

1079 words - 5 pages much area. This will affect the relationship between licensor and licensee. In the worst case, the relationship can end in a lawsuit. Pros and Cons of Joint Venture By entering a joint venture, it provides an access to greater resources. Since all the partners are contributing resources to the business rather than just one party contribute capital, there is availability of greater resources such as capital resources, experienced employees

Enter foreign market through licensing and joint venture

991 words - 4 pages may carry out the joint venture method. The firm can seek for local partner in order to achieve recognition and reputation in the market and this will facilitate to raise the market power of the firm. When the firm observes that foreign market is low competitive intensity, in this case, the firm can select the licensing entry mode. In addition, the external factors also participate in culture distance and market barriers but both factors allow the

Eli Lilly in India: Rethinking the Joint Venture Strategy

910 words - 4 pages Question1: Did Eli Lilly pursue the right strategy to enter the Indian market?In 1993 Eli Lilly, one of the leading pharmaceutical firms in the USA, started a joint venture in India with the leading Indian company Ranbaxy. The decision was dictated by the conditions of the US market and opportunities of the Indian market.Costlier manufacturing practices due to strict governmental control, soaring prices in 1990s, invasion of cheap generics to

Culture Clash: Advantages and Disadvantages

667 words - 3 pages equality in a community and peacefully get along and even agree to disagree enlightens the belief that contrasting cultures don’t have to clash but can coexist. Opposing consequences can occur and culture diversity can be an unfavorable rocky road, usually from language barriers and social nonacceptance of people from a different culture. While language barriers are easier to amend, social acceptance takes time or no time at all if barriers are

The Clash Between Amish Culture and Modern American Culture in the Film Witness

3390 words - 14 pages The Clash Between Amish Culture and Modern American Culture in the Film Witness Witness is a mix of genres; it has romance, action, is part murder/detective story, and is a thriller. The aim of the director, Peter Weir, is to show the clash of cultures between the Amish and the Modern American culture. Peter Weir the director likes to place characters into an unusual situation like in this film he has a Pennsylvanian

Infertitily and In Vitro Fertilization

2527 words - 11 pages an imperfect world? Now, this is a risk many are not willing to take. Again, though, In Vitro Fertilization does help people, and has become safer to do in recent years. People can go through this process with less of a mean of error. People do not have to worry about whether or not it will work as in earlier years. In fact, according to the latest study in 2012 “more babies were born via IVF in 2012 than ever before, accounting for 1.5 percent

In Vitro Fertilization and Infertitlity

1488 words - 6 pages Rheanna C. Robinson Dr. Moody Honors Biology/ Period 7 16 May, 2014 In Vitro Fertilization and Infertility “In Vitro Fertilization or artificial fertilization is the fertilization of an ovum by sperm outside the body when normal conception is not achievement because of a woman’s low fertility” (http://www.medterhttp://history1900s.about.com/od/medicaladvancesissues/a/testtubebaby.htmms.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=7298). In virto is a

A randomized study on the outcomes of gonadotropin priming and nonpriming in in vitro maturation

2042 words - 9 pages patients. This study is conducted aiming to compare the oocyte maturation rate and pregnancy rate after in vitro maturation of oocytes between the group receiving 3-day FSH priming on day 6 and the non-priming group (control). Material and methods Approved by the Siriraj Institutional Review Board, the research was conducted in the infertile clinic of Siriraj Hospital. The study included the infertile women aged 18-35 years, who were primary

A First Time Expatriates Experience In A Joint Venture In China

1747 words - 7 pages the fact that they might threaten the success of the joint venture. This case shall try and analyze what factors may have caused this pull out to occur, what may be its consequences, and what we feel should be done, in order to reinstate trust and confidence – to make the joint venture a success. Adaptation, Acceptance and Experiences. James had been a keen admirer of international culture and has been fascinated by the Far East. His wife

Technopoly and In Vitro Fertilization Charlotte Robinson

2465 words - 10 pages ). If used properly and ethically, in vitro fertilization can be a wonderful tool in helping infertile couples become parents. The following is a case where in vitro fertilization went wrong and the legal issues that ensue.Not too long ago, there was a case in Great Britain where an infertile "white" couple under went in vitro fertilization to have a child. To their dismay and surprise, the mother gave birth to twins. The problem is the twins were

Managing in Today's Health Care Organizations Change and Culture Case Study I

2214 words - 9 pages /external customers, patient satisfaction, reportable disease matrix, and systems thinking versus linear thinking. The second step in the training process will involve the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO). In February 1997, JCAHO instituted a measurement system designed to review data trends and patterns in an effort to improve patient care. This tool will be adopted by our organization to ensure our compliance with

Similar Essays

Corning Vitro Joint Case Study

2796 words - 11 pages aliens, or earthquakeshttp://globaledge.msu.eduConclusionJust single line is needed for this case study conclusion.Cultural clash could be the main reason for joint venture collapse. Understanding of cultural difference is vital important for the success of joint venture. International business scenario in modern era explains the importance of the cross cultural study. Corning and Vitro could avoid the failure of the joint venture alliance if

Siemens Business Case: Joint Venture Essay

1025 words - 5 pages Siemens Business Case: Joint Venture Introduction Siemens is a global corporation who specializes in electronics and electronic engineering throughout the energy, healthcare, and infrastructure and city sector industries (Zhao, 2004). This corporation focuses on energy efficiency and healthcare innovation. They invest over $6 billion a year for research and development (Siemens, 2014). Because of the large amount of money spent on research and

Case Study: Dow Corning And The Silicone Breast Implant Controversy

2938 words - 12 pages Brief HistoryAn equal joint venture between Dow Chemical and Corning Glass Works in 1943 created a company to produce silicones for commercial applications. This company was called Dow Corning. In 1930 while Corning researchers were working on possible applications of silicone in glass makings they had developed several resins, fluids, and rubber compounds that could withstand the extremes of hot and cold temperatures. It was 1940 when Corning

Nora Sakari: A Proposed Joint Venture In Malaysia

5087 words - 20 pages with. Both the problems concerning differences in national cultural values and organisational culture can be sorted out.From our point of view the problems identified are in minor when compared to the advantages Nora can explore by a joint venture with Sakari. Our advice is that Zainal should contact Kuusisto in order work out an agreement of a joint venture between Nora and Sakari.Our advice is based on the facts presented in the case. We cannot