This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Cause For Abandonment: The Seduction Theory

2272 words - 10 pages

The Seduction Theory

In 1896, Freud published an article entitled, “The Aetiology of Hysteria,” (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999). Within the paper, he presented his scarcely known “seduction theory,” which stated that the repression of memories from childhood, and sometimes infant, sexual trauma produced hysterical symptoms in teenage and adult individuals (generally women) (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999). Moreover, Freud claimed that the only way to alleviate these symptoms was through “the retrieval and reliving of repressed memories,” (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999).
Interestingly, however, within just a year of publishing this controversial article, Freud appeared to be having doubts about his theory. In a letter to close friend, Wilhelm Fliess, Freud wrote that a “great secret has been slowly dawning on me in the last few months,” (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999). Reportedly, the great secret was that Freud no longer believed in his theory and was attempting to reorganize his theory on hysteria to better suit the evidence and research he had collected (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999). In his new theory, which would eventually spawn what the psychological community recognizes as the Oedipus Complex, Freud argued that hysteria was caused by repressed memories of sexual fantasies, not memories of actual sexual abuse or trauma as he once believed (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999).

Freud’s Doubts

In another letter to Fliess, dated September 1897, Freud expressed four general concerns and reasons for abandoning his theory (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999; Aron, 2012). First, he referred to the fact that he could not bring resolution to any of his analyses nor could he explain partial successes (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999; Aron, 2012). If his theory was correct, why could he not cure any of his patients? Next, Freud remarked that in every case “the father had to be accused of being perverse,” (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999; Aron, 2012). If this were true, then Freud’s own father would need to be accused of such perversions (Gleaves &Hernandez, 1999). Having just lost his father in 1896, however, it would seem as though Freud might have been trying to repress the notion that his own father could have sexually abused him or one of his siblings (Aron, 2012). Third, Freud indicated that the unconscious was unable to discern fact from phantase (i.e. fiction) (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999; Aron, 2012). Finally, he noted that if unconscious memories could in fact break through to the conscious level in even the most severe cases of mental illness (which he believed they could), than it would seem unlikely that therapy could help individuals whose unconscious is met with great resistance from the conscious to retrieve repressed memories (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999; Aron, 2012). After disclosing these reasons to Fliess, he officially published his reasons for abandoning the theory in 1905 (Gleaves & Hernandez, 1999; Aron, 2012).

Theories from Today’s Psychologists

Despite supplying the...

Find Another Essay On Cause for Abandonment: The Seduction Theory

Naval Rivalry as the Main Cause for World War One

1970 words - 8 pages Naval Rivalry as the Main Cause for World War One It has been argued that Naval rivalry was the main cause of World War One, this is because in 1898 Kaiser Wilhelm II wanted to have the most powerful and strongest navy in the world as he was extremely militaristic which worried Britain and consequently caused tension between the two countries. I believe that to a certain extent that Naval Rivalry did contribute to

The History, Cause and Effect, and Reasons for Piracy

818 words - 4 pages Piracy in Somalia What is the first thing that comes to your mind when you hear the word pirate? To this day, pirates are still roaming the oceans in search of some loot; not necessarily treasure, but food, money, or supplies necessary for survival. This research paper will examine the history of piracy, along with the causes and effects of pirate-related activity and why piracy still exists. What exactly is piracy? Well, it is the practice of

Barbara Christian: The race for literary theory

931 words - 4 pages Literary theory or "The Literary Theory" ?' The Race for Theory' , Barbara ChristianMany Western philosophers have played an important role in setting up the Literary Theory., who throughout history have been in the top of the literary hierarchy. They have considered the distinctions between written literatures and then they came up with the redefinition of literature, which lead them to the changes in literary critical language such as to ' re

The Goal Setting Theory for Employee Motivation

1524 words - 6 pages Goal setting theory can help motivate employees to do their job as managers can relate to Professor Edwin Locke goal theory. The underlying concept behind this theory is the belief that people’s goals play a vital part in deciding their behavior. People drive to satisfy these goals to help their emotions and desires. Goals guide people’s responses and actions. Goals command employee performance and actions and this can call for action or

Nursing Theory: The Basis for Professional Nursing

1078 words - 4 pages Virginia Henderson's principles are discernible in her interpretation of nurses' roles in humanity. She posits that nurses are uniquely positioned to render assistance to anyone regardless of the individual's health status in the fulfillment of activities that contribute to health or its recovery or at least, afford the individual comfort at his/her final hours. That is, the activities that the individual would have performed for self-had he

Thomas Aquinas Metaphysics: Catholic Theology and The Quest for the Cause for Being

1417 words - 6 pages corporeal, metaphysical minds began to wonder why things existed at all. After all, if things did not have existence, then there would nothing to consider. So, being and existence, which were before just two metaphysical concepts, became the highest powers presiding over the rest of reality, and the first philosopher to completely delineate these concepts would become equally important. This is how the quest for the cause for being began. Out of

It Takes a Hero to Die for a Cause: Responsibility for One’s Choices in The Stranger

1112 words - 5 pages concerned with the truth, motivated by his moral values. When Meursault dies for the truth, he is committing the ultimate act of heroism: sacrificing oneself for a cause. In The Stranger, people are born devoid of intrinsic moral values. Any moral values that they have are developed on an individual basis. In both the Arab’s murder and Meursault’s subsequent questioning and trial, Meursault holds the power of choice. It would have been easy for

The Colonists Did NOT Have Adequate Cause for the American Revolution

500 words - 2 pages Were the Colonists Justified in Their Rebellion against England? Yes Did the Colonists Have an Adequate Cause for Revolution? No Starting after the termination of the Seven-Year’s war, by the Peace of Paris, England repeatedly violated the American Colonists’ rights. A series of events, happening between 1763(ending of the Seven-Years’ war) and 1775 (starting of the revolution), could be taken as motives for the American’s revolution

Henry VIII’s Desire for a Divorce as the Sole Cause of the English Reformation

1355 words - 5 pages Henry VIII’s Desire for a Divorce as the Sole Cause of the English Reformation The English reformation is widely discussed amongst historians; it was a process that saw the removal of the longstanding Papal influence and the beginnings of a new English Church. Although Henry’s divorce with Catherine of Aragon played a significant part in provoking a reformation there were other factors that lead to the creation of the

Is the Lack of Motivation a Cause for the Nursing Shortage

1932 words - 8 pages satisfaction including financial benefits and relationships with coworkers. While pay is not necessarily the driving force for job satisfaction, failing to reward nurses financially for experience or above average performance may cause dissatisfaction and turnover. Positive relationships with coworkers and having a management that listens and values concerns and issues from staff contribute to nursing satisfaction. Systems that provide advancement

Cause and effects of Divorce in American couples and children for the last 25 years

1658 words - 7 pages In today’s society, divorce has become a normal thing in our lives. Married couples today are getting a divorce due to many different reasons. This essay will examine the cause and effect of divorce on children and couples for the last 25 years in America. Few of the causes might be getting married or the wrong reasons, lack of equality, abuse, spouses having an affair, loss of romantic feeling, conflicts, and other problems that will be

Similar Essays

The Model Minority Theory: The Cause Of An Overlooked Culture?

2401 words - 10 pages Asian Americans (Fong 62.) While the theory might appear to give Asians praise for their hard work and success, in reality it covers up and marginalizes the real experiences Asian Americans face. For example, one of the ways the Model Minority theory harms the Asian American community is that it hides the fact that there are many Asian Americans living below or at the poverty line (Fong 62.) When it comes to academics it covers up the fact that

The Cause Of Dawnfall For Nazi Germany

2107 words - 8 pages A. Plan of Investigation Despite its defeat in World War II, many historians continue to debate the cause of downfall for Nazi Germany and argue that the factor at hand was the key to stopping a surely unstoppable force. While many say that the defeat is due primarily to poor strategy, was the limited development of advanced military technology by Nazi Germany the flaw that led to its defeat in World War II? In this investigation, the overall

Giarda Lamblia: The Cause For Traveler's Diarrhea

1185 words - 5 pages ). G. lamblia is a diarrheal disease that is known worldwide. It is a food and water borne disease (Nazer, 2013). It is well known for being called the “travelers disease”. G. lamblia was recognized in the 1970s when it appeared in travelers coming from Endemic regions (Nazer, 2013). Causal Agents Giardia lamblia comes from the kingdom, Protista, with the subkingdom of Protozoa (Keas, 1999). G. lamblia has unique paired organelles; it has two

The Potential For Avian Influenza To Cause Another Worldwide Pandemic

1690 words - 7 pages The Potential for Avian Influenza to Cause Another Worldwide Pandemic Abstract There are three major factors involved in the start of a pandemic; the viral strain must be new, able to cause serious illness, and transmit efficiently between humans. This article explores the avian influenza virus?s potential to cause another global pandemic through its ease of transmission and ability to evade treatment. Avian type A influenza virus generally