Censorship Essay Don't Censor Child Pornography

1318 words - 5 pages

Don't Censor Child Pornography

      In November of 1997 a Williamson County, Tenn. grand jury indicted Barnes & Noble booksellers for violating state obscenity laws prohibiting the display of "material harmful to minors". The materials in question were two books that featured photographs of nude children: Jock Sturges' Radiant Identities and David Hamilton's The Age of Innocence. Since then, Radical Right activist Randall Terry has launched a crusade aimed at forcing bookstores to remove the "criminal garbage" of Sturges, Hamilton and (recently added to his list of demons) Sally Mann from their bookshelves (bookweb). To implement his program Terry issued a call to Right sympathizers, urging them to march into bookstores and tear offensive pages from the targeted books. Several bookstores around the country fell prey to Terry's vandals. In response to these incidents and the threat of future public vandalism, Barnes & Noble recently issued a memo to each of its 1000+ stores directing them to place the contested materials under lock and key, and to allow customers to view them only in the presence of a store manager (apocalypse 9709).


This response is upsetting. It is upsetting because it means that, in several significant ways, Terry has won. True, no one (as of yet) has put Sturges or the others in jail (as Terry has called for), but the public's right to view the supposed "pornographic" content of their work has been significantly diminished by Barnes & Noble's action. By acknowledging the threat of Terry and his small group of supporters, B&N has reified their claim that the work of the named photographers needs to be segregated from the "decent" public's reach. It installs a technology of surveillance that insures that all but the most unabashed of teens (and many adults) will not choose to view these images for fear of stigmatization. By placing these books under lock and key, B&N reinforces the discourse on child sexuality promoted by Terry: that it is a deviant behavior that must be repressed, and anyone who thinks otherwise must be a pervert or a pedophile.


But what of this? What is it about child sexuality that causes this reaction against images of nude children? None of the pictures in Mann's, Sturges' or Hamilton's books show children engaged in any sort of sex act. And none of them were taken without the model's and her or his parents' permission. So why are they labeled "pornography" by Terry, and (more disconcerting) by many people with less extreme political views? What is the discourse of child sexuality in the United States such that these pictures are even at issue?


Terry, who is also the founder of the anti-abortion group Operation Life, was confronted with these issues at a recent press conference. According to the Village Voice, Terry was asked if he considered the images in question arousing. He responded that he did not. "So what's the problem?" the questioner followed. "If they're not...

Find Another Essay On Censorship Essay - Don't Censor Child Pornography

Censorship: Justified or Not? Essay

1185 words - 5 pages kinds of media which gives allows us to freely express and exhibit our perspectives and ideas. On the other hand, this revolution in the media industry saw the production of certain media that are unsuitable for certain audiences. Thus, government bodies such as Malaysia’s Multimedia and Communication Commission are set up to selectively evaluate and censor contents to ensure that media would not be harmful to the public. Therefore, this essay

Censorship: A Tool for Revoking our Rights and Happiness

2760 words - 11 pages body disapproves of the values behind the material and limits access to it. An example would be pornography. Military censorship is the process of keeping military intelligence and tactics confidential. Military censorship is used to counter espionage. Political censorship is when government conceals secrets from citizens. Government can use political censorship to prevent the free expression needed to revolt. Political censorship is also used to

Children and the Censorship of Internet Pornography

4232 words - 17 pages side of town can now be viewed at any time in the privacy of one"s home" (Anderson 2). In order to understand how to aid in the critical decision of whether or not to censor child pornography, an individual has to first clearly understand a few terms. These terms will aid in a clear understanding throughout the case study. a.)Definition of "Censorship." The American Library Association defines Censorship as "the change in access status of

The Evil Side of The Internet

3023 words - 12 pages . Specially with new web pages being created by the second every day, in all parts of the world. I started thinking about the positive and negative aspects of the internet and how much it has changed our life. Then due to a show on Sally, I decided to gear my essay towards the different types of social corruption that is being motivated and cultivated on the internet. Different topics came to mind such as, hate crimes, cyber sex, child pornography

What is Pornography?

2261 words - 9 pages depicts sex as solely an act of procreation. In today?s complicated times however pornography is viewed by some as having extremely harmful social consequences, while others claim that it is a harmless diversion that helps relieve sexual tensions. Before I start stating facts I would like to say that this paper is about regular pornography and not child pornography. In-order to analyze pornography thoroughly we must look at three important issues

The Negative Impact of Pornography on Society

1168 words - 5 pages for or against pornography. The word pornography generally means sexually explicit words and images whose sole purpose is sexual arousal. Feminists are trying to ban pornography because they feel it will lead to discrimination and violence against women, while others believe that the censorship of this type of pornography is a direct violation on the first amendment. Though not all pornography should be censored, pornography that contains sexual

Violence in the Media

1342 words - 5 pages Catcher in the Rye. The novel is believed to have become Chapman's script for murder (Berger 45). Pornography, which usually depicts sexual violence, is a significant source for crimes. Porn magazines are models for child molesters to tape and put on child pornography websites. The presence of sex shops increases crimes in the surrounding area. In most movies, there is at least one act of violence that is viewed by the audience. For example, in the

Censorship of the Internet

987 words - 4 pages computers to protect their business and schools can censor what is accessed as well, so why would it not be acceptable for the government to censor what is accessed in order to protect the citizens of the United States of America. Some believe this is an infringement of free speech, while others find censorship of the internet a necessary evil in today’s cyber world. When you take an indepth look at what is readily available on the internet it should

persuasive essay on Cenrorship of the Internet and the Tyrrany of Our Government

1244 words - 5 pages (Censorship and the Internet 1). There exists today no way of effectively tracking and determining from where a bulletin was posted, especially with the automatic dialing and encryption technology available. Thus even trying to censor the Internet as a whole would be only an exercise in futility.Although pornography and potentially destructive material exist on the Internet, not all potentially offensive material shows violent sex acts with children or

Why is Pornography Bad and Erotica Good?

2226 words - 9 pages censored. There are many potential responses to the argument against the censorship of pornography and the acceptance of erotica. The United States common law distinguishes between offensive, indecent, and obscene speech. Offensive and indecent speeches have first amendment protection, but can be limited with a compelling government interest, as in the case of minors. However, obscene speech has no first amendment protections (Akdeniz 237). Pornography

Save the Internet! Speaks of cencorship

1550 words - 6 pages .' (Only) This is an ideal approach to censorship and should be exercised in every country. Parents at home can also be more responsible over what information is retrieved by their young ones by installing programs like SurfWatch that will block pornography from access (Quitter 45). In addition to this problem, child pornography also prevails over the Internet.Another distressing issue about the Internet is the presence of child pornography

Similar Essays

Censorship Essay No Need To Censor Pornography

1370 words - 5 pages No Need to Censor Pornography       Pornography is often considered an ugly word and possibly an ugly act. The pictures and words of pornography can be vulgar and degrading to many of us, but is it the evil of all things? Is it, and it alone, responsible for sexism, rape, racism, battery, and child abuse? No! The media is loaded with many sexist, racist, violent material, and most of it is not considered pornography. The issue of violence

Untitled Essay

1232 words - 5 pages drinking. Part of the problem is that censorship laws are not enforced. Some newsagents will sell a twelve year old, pornography, (legal age of 18) but will not sell them a packet of cigarettes (legal age of 16 until June 1994). The obvious derivative from this statement, is that fines and punishments for selling pornography to underage persons, are not high enough. So why don't we raise them? The answer to this question can be found on the

Pornograhpy On Internet Essay

1109 words - 4 pages age of 16 until June 1994). The obvious derivative from this statement, is that fines and punishments for selling pornography to underage persons, are not high enough. So why don't we raise them? The answer to this question can be found on the screen of every computer in the world. The Internet, or as one person put it,'The closest thing to true anarchy that has ever existed.'How is one to censor the Internet when it is literally impossible? What

America Needs Internet Censorship Essay

1303 words - 5 pages ...pornography, real victims are forced to undergo humiliation and pain to gratify sick minds.” Therefore, pornography is related to brain impairment. As a matter of fact, those individuals with damaging thoughts are the ones that watch and produce pornography. Additionally, “exposure to obscene material correlates with increased rapes, prostitution, child molestation, violent crime, the abuse of women, and sex addiction in men” (Hacker 5). Many