Censorship In Books: Research Report (Who Should Decide What High School Students Read?)

1846 words - 7 pages

Aaron SchwartzEnglish 11 AP5 November 2004Fired UpPenny Culliton walks into her classroom carrying Maurice, by E.M. Forster. She sits at her desk and tells her class to take their copies out. She promptly starts talking about the acclaimed author and his writing style, along with the homosexual ideas in the novel. Students are interested in both aspects of the book, the writing and the ideas, and join in on the discussion. In the middle of class she receives a note saying that she is to see the principal of the school. When she finally meets with him, she is notified that she is being fired for assigning her students a novel with gay and lesbian characters. She, along with her students, was outraged at such news. Nobody could believe that she would get in trouble for teaching what she wanted, not to mention what she was teaching was nothing more than an acclaimed novel (http://users.rcn.com).Many teachers like this one, avoid controversial books altogether because of the chance of losing their jobs. Books are being challenged all the time for reasons as unimportant such as Ann Frank's Diary of a Young Girl, "being too much of a downer"(http://www.abc.nl). Most of the reasons against these books are not justified, but are still powerful. It is the select few parents who are the cause of the restrictions put on teachers. One of these groups is the religious parents who say that any obscenity at all is against their religion, and that we should not be corrupting kids, and the other group is the parents who have no justification of why these books that their kids read may be more harmful than helpful. Teachers create a safe learning environment in which greater literature, although containing more profanity, may be taught so that morals can be learned along with what makes these writers so great. It is not fair that teacher's jobs are at risk for wanting a change. Teachers should raise the level of obscenity in books that are taught in order to subject kids to great literature, while transitioning them into adult literature in a safe environment. Instead of the school board deciding what books are allowed to be taught, teachers should be able to choose their own literature.Many people will not listen to reasoning. Some people against having certain books in schools feel, "in some cases, no matter what convoluted explanations are given, that agenda [of schools] seems like corrupting the morals of our child"(http://pabbis.com). They will not even consider the teachers point of view. Religious parents believe, "Schools try to teach children to have respect for the diversity of cultures and religions but don't seem to understand that this reading material undermines individual and religious values"(http://pabbis.com). There is not consideration of the benefits society will gain from this diversity and exposure to various religions. These parents believe that their kids will do what they read in books, and that there is only bad influences in these...

Find Another Essay On Censorship in Books: Research Report (Who should decide what High School students read?)

Should Students be Required to Pass Proficiency Tests in Order to Graduate from High School?

1002 words - 4 pages What if an adolescent took a test that solely determined whether or not they make it to their high school graduation? For most high school students this is a reality. High schools across the U.S. require all of their students to pass proficiency tests in order to graduate. These state-wide tests include having a standard knowledge in reading, writing, and mathematics, as well as science in some states now. These tests show the level of

Should High School Students Take The Exit Exam

1218 words - 5 pages graduation. Requiring students to take an exit exam is as unfair as James Baldwin not receiving service and then told "We don't serve Negroes here"(140) because of his race. Due to its multiple reasons of unfairness, exit exams should not be a requirement for graduation from high school and school board officials around the nation should do away with the test.According to the Education Commission of the States, more than half of the states in the

Male and Female High School Students Should be Educated in Separate Schools

1286 words - 5 pages range of obtaining high marks. However, should boys and girls be educated separately at high school in order to have higher marks? People claim that when both sexes study in the same class rooms their confidence level will increase and the relation between both sexes will deepen and strengthen its roots which will be beneficial for all students in their future life as well as their school life. However, educating both genders in the same class

Question:Should school start later, for high school students? Pursuasive essay. Thesis:School should start later for high school students.

900 words - 4 pages school. I fell asleep in my first two classes, and I could blame this on the sleep I got last night; or should I say the lack of sleep- only 6 hours." Students would perform better if school started at a later time."With teenagers' busy schedules today, the first activity to give way is usually sleep" (Kaufman). The sleep deficit of teenagers obstructs their high school achievement. To accommodate for teen's sleep necessity,, high schools should

should students have cell phones in school?

697 words - 3 pages The question of whether cell phones should be allowed in schools has been hotly debated over the years. The reality is, bans on cell phones are hard for schools to enforce. No matter how many rules a school will place, students will still go around them and do what they want. A 2010 Pew Internet & American Life Project study found that “65 percent of cell-owning teens at schools that completely ban phones bring their phones to school every day

High School Students Drop Outs

1979 words - 8 pages In spite of high school student dropout prevention programs already in place in the public school system, even more are needed to help students realize the dire consequences of dropping out of school. A study done by NYC Department of Education states, “Over 20,000 students drop out of high school each year”. It also states, “Most of them are Black and Hispanic. Another study was conducted in 2006 and concluded that about 19 percent of Hispanic

"Students Should Not Be Forced to Do Community Service" This essay explains the negative effects of forcing students to fulfill a community service requirement in high school.

623 words - 2 pages , and add more pressure to the already hectic life of a high school teenager. Students should not be commanded to do 75 hours of community service!To begin, requiring 75 hours of community service could be a disservice to students because it could hold many back from graduating. A lot of students have a very busy schedule and might not be able to do the required amount of time of community service. It may be mandatory to go somewhere or to do

Students Should Wear School Uniform

751 words - 3 pages what are they going to wear the next day to school. Instead they should be worrying about other things for example to study for a test or homework. That is why students should wear school uniforms.In conclusion, I believe that the school board of education in Perry has made the best decision that all students must wear school uniform. It is the best decision because it reduces violence, social outcomes, and it also saves parents money and time. I

Second Year High School Students Should Be Allowed to Choose Their Teachers

1961 words - 8 pages Have you ever been tired of getting the same kind of teacher? The one who doesn’t understand you? The one who you don’t understand? Teachers are some of the most important people in our lives, so why not have the right to choose them? Students who are in their second year of high school should be able to choose their teachers. They are capable of doing so, but why aren’t they allowed? Students should have this choice because of many reasons

Parental Pressure Within High School Students

1375 words - 6 pages “I'm going to be grounded for 10 years” many times so when the opportunity to do research on this came up, I chose this as my subject. II. How does parental pressure influence students in high school? If there is an influence, is it positive or negative? I would like to do research on this because it raised my curiosity. For me personally, I do better in school if I am calm and have little pressure, but there might be students out there at

Parental Pressure within High School Students

1489 words - 6 pages to do research on this came up, I chose this as my subject.II. How does parental pressure influence students in high school? If there is an influence, is it positive or negative? I would like to do research on this because it raised my curiosity. For me personally, I do better in school if I am calm and have little pressure, but there might be students out there at Ramapo High School that think differently. These are some of the things that I will

Similar Essays

High School Internet Censorship Essay

1032 words - 4 pages High School Internet Censorship     The common image that comes to mind on the topic of censorship is that of book burning. Dating back to ancient times, the easiest way to deal with unwanted writings has been to get rid of them, usually by heaping them into a blazing pyre. In his most famous science fiction novel, Fahrenheit 451, Ray Bradbury warns of a futuristic society where all literature is destroyed under a kerosene flame and the

The Dangers Of Censorship In High School

2589 words - 10 pages her court fight will "give other teachers the courage to battle censorship--and rein in school officials who fear the power of words" (p.29). Ultimately teachers must decide what they are going to present to their students. They must be guided by a sense of what the students need, want, and are prepared to handle. Questions must be raised to help students critically discuss and understand the issues that are raised in class and how they affect

Censorship For Middle School Students Essay

1110 words - 4 pages . If the party’s intention is to deny students access to ideas with which the party disagrees, it is a violation of the First Amendment” [First Amendment Center]. Though the First Amendment bars government authorities from prohibiting the free exercise, abridging the freedom of speech or practicing religious censorship in the United States, individuals have successfully pushed to remove books from public and school libraries. This basic concept

Functional Literacy In High School Students

1395 words - 6 pages Functional Literacy in High School Students   What is Functional Literacy? Prior to 1985, functional literacy was defined as the ability to read or write in English or another language. Standards for measuring one’s functional literacy have changed numerous times over the decades. In the 1930’s functional literacy meant having three or more years of school. During the WWII era, it meant completing a fourth grade education. The