This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Censorship In Schools Is Not Justifiable

1124 words - 4 pages

Censorship in School is Not Justifiable
Walt Whitman once said, “The dirtiest book of all is the expurgated book.” Between the years 2000 and 2009 a total of 3200 books were challenged in school libraries in an attempt to expurgate, or censor, the content in books provided to students. Today the trend of censorship continues as popular novels such as The Hunger Games, The Fault in Our Stars, and Captain Underpants are censored from schools across the nation (Challenges by Reason).Censorship in regards to literature refers to the examination and suppressing of a book because of objectionable material. The process of censorship in school libraries often begins with an outspoken parent, teacher, student, or administrator and ends in the banning or abridgement of a novel deemed inadmissible. Censorship is protecting many students from controversial, immoral, and potentially unsuitable content; however, this is not always the case. Students, parents, teachers, and administrators with different backgrounds, beliefs, and morals are not creating a library pleasing to everyone because of the variety of opinion. Censorship in school is not justifiable, because it restricts discussion and knowledge of new, controversial, and necessary ideas, allows a handful of people to make decisions for a larger group based on opinion, and undermines democratic ideals.
The discussion and knowledge of new, controversial, and necessary subjects is restricted among students due to censorship. Student access to books on topics such as self-harm, sexual orientation, depression, religion, etc. are limited because of censorship. These topics may not be appropriate for all individuals, but these books have the power to save lives, change lives, and awaken students to the realities of the world. Librarian Jen Chesney argues that, “As a Librarian, you have to provide material for every person and issue whether you believe in it or not.” Anti-censorship activists argue that the provision of knowledge should not be restricted on the basis of opinion. Heinrich Heine states, “Wherever they burn books they will also, in the end, burn human beings.” Restricting the discussion of new and controversial ideas rather than tolerating and acknowledging the presence of new and controversial ideas is causing more pain than it is worth in the school setting. The idea of censoring reality from school libraries is unreasoned, yet that is exactly what pro-censorship individuals advocate. The discussion and knowledge of new, controversial, and necessary ideas among students is restricted due to censorship.
Censorship in school libraries allows teachers, administrators, peers and their parents to decide what a student may or may not read based on their opinion. Opinion is variable between different groups of people within the school; therefore, a single person or a small group of people cannot be trusted to make decisions on the behalf of a larger group. Kekla Magoon argues, “That no one person...

Find Another Essay On Censorship in Schools is not Justifiable

Censorship is NOT Good Essay

999 words - 4 pages the Liberal Left censors and undermines education, how hypocritical is that? Who is to say whose moral beliefs are correct, with censorship you are saying with absolute certainty that your are, and not being tolerant of others. Throughout my speech I have proved censorship in libraries and schools is unjustified because it is ridiculous, unfair and selfish, and censors are hypocritical, arrogant, and intolerant. I hope you learn censorship is not a good thing, speak out against it.

Censorship of Books in Schools Essay

1902 words - 8 pages Censorship in schools is a major crisis. Books across the US are being pulled from shelves because of school boards wanting to censor them. People who want to censor books in the school systems would be taking away important practice in vital writing skills, as well as depriving students of the First Amendment rights to free thought and expression. The most important question that people ask is concerning censorship is not whether it should be

Censorship in Libraries and Schools

1071 words - 4 pages Censorship in Libraries and Schools What would you do if you went to your child's school and saw that they were looking at inappropriate material on the internet? Would you react the same way if they were in a public library? Who decides what is okay for your children to view? Who decides where they can view it? What can you do about them being able to view these things? Are there any laws that can prevent this from happening? What are

Censorship In Public Schools and Libraries

2759 words - 11 pages these censorship attempts are being waged, often successfully. Indeed, more than 97% of challenges take place in public libraries, school libraries, and classrooms (“ALA Challenges by Initiator”).When these challenges succeed, they also succeed in taking important, compelling, worthwhile literature from the hands and minds of students. Book banning in public schools and libraries is unethical, counterproductive, and futile; not only is it impossible

Is the ban on Muslim headscarves in French schools justified? If so, why? If not, why?

1585 words - 7 pages I will advance the thesis that the banning on Muslim headscarves in French schools is not justified. By saying that the French ban on Muslim headscarves in public schools is not justified, I mean that, even though this ban was implemented as a means to neutralize public space, in hope of developing autonomy, as well as to protect females’ rights in traditional Muslim communities, the ban actually infringes on a more pressing rights of a person

Censorship is Not an Effective Way to Protect Children

1913 words - 8 pages prevails in America today, and not only censorship of pornography or violence on television, but it seeps into our textbooks and classrooms too, all in the name of protecting the children. Many reasons exist for people to favor censorship, both by the government and in schools. These people may feel that internet filters and rating systems insufficiently block obscene material. Some people believe that children exposed to inappropriate material

Is censorship strong enough in today's media?

893 words - 4 pages and "reveals that even a brief exposure to violent video games can temporarily increase aggressive behaviour in all types of participants"( hardest form of media to apply censorship to is the Internet. This technology is becoming more popular in homes and schools. The children of today cannot avoid the Internet, as it is part of their education, social life and a pleasurable pastime. You only have to turn on the news to see

Censorship is in Contradiction to Children’s Rights

972 words - 4 pages . It should be instilled into them the opportunity and freedom we have been given to speak about those beliefs and share with others that have differing views. The opportunity to study differing theories about the creation of our world should be explored, as education is truly exploration. Student groups in public schools should not be banned from practicing if they are religious or alternative lifestyle based. Censorship does not protect

Censorship is necessary in modern society

442 words - 2 pages language and taboo subjects in their performances. Critics of censorship argue that the only people who will watch or listen to such material are adults who have made a conscious decision to do so. Thus, it is claimed, it is unjust to censor material like this since it is not forced upon people who may subsequently be offended by it.All things considered, it can be concluded that a certain degree of censorship is always necessary. The best course of action would be to attempt to achieve a balance between the requirements of the country and the public on the one hand, and individuals' rights on the other.

Jimmy is a Justifiable Jerk: The Question of Love in Atwood’s Oryx and Crake

2459 words - 10 pages this idea is for Jimmy to consider when the reader considers Jimmy’s use of love. Jimmy is in a relationship with Oryx but love is not what is motivating him to be there: a desire for power, to be able to use and influence someone is his motivation. Jimmy uses Oryx to satisfy these underlying needs which originate from his childhood. Jimmy’s interaction with his depressed mother funnelled his desire to use power to create a reaction in his mother

Huck Finn: To be or not to be? Is the book racist and should it be thought in schools?

872 words - 3 pages South, and it is most certainly not a racist book.The word "nigger" is used so often in the book , that it doesn't just appear in every chapter but also on almost every page. Does that mean that this book is racist? Without reading the rest of the text, the answer would be yes, but at the end of the book the doctor makes a speech about Jim in front of an enraged mob who caught him and after complimenting him ends the speech with "He ain't no bad

Similar Essays

Is Censorship Justifiable? Essay

928 words - 4 pages serious destruction.However, for all that can be said for censorship, is it really effective?Internet censorship is pretty important in Singapore, banning 100 pornographic sites. However, pornography is on the rise, and there are thousands, even millions more of such sites that are not banned. Even more ironic, a website, entitled "Defeating Singapore Internet Censorship - How to", is not censored. How can censorship be justifiable in this case

The War In Iraq Is Not Justifiable

4198 words - 17 pages The War in Iraq is Not Justifiable Thousands of young men and women are sent overseas to be killed or injured only to return crippled for life or in a coffin. I commend all in the military for their service and I would never disrespect any soldier. In fact, my best friend?s brother entered the United States Navy out of high school and has served three years so far; he is in active duty serving on an aircraft carrier. I have the same

Censorship In Schools Essay

3737 words - 15 pages age group (1999). In other words, selection is about choice, while censorship is about exclusion. Censorship can take different shapes depending on the public school system: Schools can give teachers a list of acceptable books to teach, just provide guidelines, or leave it up to the teachers to judge which books are appropriate (Agee, 1999). Teachers are often very nervous about including texts that are not traditional or specifically

Censorship In Schools Essay

1607 words - 7 pages is censored varies. Anyone can censor, including parents, teachers, school officials, and board members (Taylor 8-10) Many things are censored in schools and places where children are present because parents do not want their kids to be exposed to inappropriate content (Taylor 10). Students are entitled to their First Amendment rights just as much as adults are, but schools still censor things like newspapers, books, and clothing. Censorship