Challenging Comparative Advantage Essay

1497 words - 6 pages

Comparative advantage is a principle developed by David Ricardo in the early 19th century to explain the benefits of mutual trade (Carbaugh, 2008). Many underlying assumptions of comparative advantage depend on states of economic equilibrium and an absence of economy of scale. In reality, economies are dynamic and subject to innovation and interference; which has led to revised assumptions of return and competition (Krugman, 1987). These factors have created questions of free trade and governmental participation in an economy by the development of strategic trade policies. These new concepts do not replace the theory of comparative advantage; however, they further explain how trade can benefit a country's economy (Krugman, 1987).
Comparative Advantage Theory
The principle of comparative advantage holds that trade can exist internationally even when one country holds a distinct advantage over another country in the production of a good. Ricardo made several assumptions for his theory to hold true including: the existence of a two nation model with labor as the only input, fluid labor transfer across industries, fixed technology with zero transportation costs, the absence of governmental barriers allowing for balanced free trade and ignorance of price and production models (Carbaugh, 2008). Under the Heckscher-Ohlin theory, the basis for trade is resource abundance, however trade equilibrium is assumed via equal technology and demand between nations (Nobel Media, 2006). Both theories require constant returns and assume the existence of perfect competition (Schweinberger, May, 1996).
Constant return means input and output costs remain the same over time regardless of production levels (AmosWEB LLC, 2000-2012). The concept of perfect competition assumes goods are homogenous, individual buyers and sellers have no influence on pricing, are attempting to maximize profits and are free to leave or enter the market. Manufacturing adjusts to meet a constant return on the product (Hunt & Morgan, 1995). Effectively, these theories rely on national monopolistic models to explain comparative advantage (Ossa, n.d.). While the standard of comparative advantage explains why trade can exist between countries, the assumptions do not account for conditions of increasing returns and imperfect competition.
A Dynamic Economy
The principle of comparative advantage provides a simplified theory explaining why free trade is possible, even when one country has an economic disadvantage. Both the Ricardian and Heckscher-Ohlin theories rely on fixed economic assumptions of constant return and perfect competition. However, intuitively the basic principle of business is to increase returns through innovation, improving processes and technology or increasing economies of scale. Organizations understand they control pricing and are price setters, rather than price takers as suggested by perfect competition (Krugman & Obstfeld, 2003). The idea...

Find Another Essay On Challenging Comparative Advantage

Gender Inequality at a Workplace Essay

1231 words - 5 pages children while she produces additional children than while she engages in most other activities” (Becker 38). Typifying the roles of men and women in the labor force due to family concerns and women’s biological purpose has provided men a source of comparative advantage in work. It is, therefore, natural for most companies to think that women cannot be as capable as men in terms of assuming strenuous or challenging positions because women, by

The Internationalization of Human Resource Management - Printed

9045 words - 36 pages 1990). However, almost none of the work comprehensively and systematically has examined HR practices in relation to each other and to business strategy to determine how these practices contribute to competitive advantage. This is the essence of comparative HRM thus human resource management in this international context requires focus on the functions, policies and practices of human resource management in different countries.Different countries

THE CHALLENGES OF DOING BUSINESS OVERSEAS MBA 501

1450 words - 6 pages get the business to a successful start overseas. Looking at what comparative advantages the Czech Republic has will identify any opportunities for Steve to take advantage of in his business. An evaluation of Hofstede's four primary dimensions will assist Steve in assessing the business environment for cultural differences in business, and possibly opposing customs and protocols. In addition Steve will have to research any trade barriers, and

Leadership in the International Marketplace

1519 words - 6 pages had absolute advantage, they also had comparative advantage. This was achieved through several strategic initiatives. The result was a company with a well respected reputation and a disposition that could command a higher price for services rendered. As a result, in 2006, Infosys had gross revenues of over two billion U.S. dollars” (Derersky, 2008). As part of its overall strategy, “Infosys used its GDM as a strategic outsourcing tool; using

Trade Secrets

1304 words - 5 pages with the operation, he decides to download and transmit the company's trade secret and gives these secrets to Samsung and China. Now that I placed the image in your minds, this is an example of "Economic Espionage." Industrial espionage happens when individual decides to share sensitive information to outside companies or foreign countries for profit. The action causes companies financial loss or loss of comparative advantage of the owner

Trade Secret

1304 words - 5 pages with the operation, he decides to download and transmit the company's trade secret and gives these secrets to Samsung and China. Now that I placed the image in your minds, this is an example of "Economic Espionage." Industrial espionage happens when individual decides to share sensitive information to outside companies or foreign countries for profit. The action causes companies financial loss or loss of comparative advantage of the owner

Strategic Human Resource Management

2154 words - 9 pages Human Resource ManagementBeardwell, Claydon and Holden (2007) identify five comparative models of personnel management and HRM, which are the planning perspective, people management perspective, employment relations perspective, structure/systems perspective, role perspective. In personnel management, the planning perspective is marginal to corporate plans; in people management perspective, the people are viewed as a variable cost, subject to

South Africa

1402 words - 6 pages about their future. The diversity of the “Rainbow Nation” is a big advantage. It provides many challenging business opportunities, if exploited carefully and wisely. South Africa should embrace change for better future and welcome its investors with opened arms. South Africa should be aware that forming a trade association or union similar to NAFTA or EU is of most importance, as it could open many global doors. The fear-atmosphere that spread

Comparing HRM and IHR Practitioners

1509 words - 6 pages for organization through its configuration of resources within a challenging environment (Johnson and Scholes, 2006). Moreover, Hoque and Noon suggest the involvement in strategic planning processes is one of the features of HRM. Besides, a research demonstrates the organizations with a written HR strategy generated 35% greater revenues than those without (Higginbottom 2002). Further views for IHRM, O’Keeffe contended, in the tendency of global

An Inside Look at Federalism

1061 words - 5 pages completely powerful and subnational governments merely carry out decisions made at the national level. There is a great advantage associated with this type of federalism – the legislative process carries out comparatively smoother (in reference to federal units). The reason here being there are simply less obstacles to overcome. When the central government makes a decision, it is passed down to the subnational level and while they do hold some

Malaysia's Hybrid Approach to Governement Policy and Institutions

1185 words - 5 pages technologies in the process and assembly industries. There is less confirmation that the vast streams of FDI have yet been made as local design, development or research proficiency. Malaysia tries to move far from industries which endeavour its comparative advantages of natural resources and low labour costs, towards new higher-worth added sectors in view of national technological advantage. The recent focus has been less on the amount of profit

Similar Essays

Goldberg Review

1204 words - 5 pages into account by all students studying international business. Mistakenly understanding the European Union to be similar in nature to other free trade zones such as the NAFTA has the potential to take away from a businessperson’s possibilities at successfully conducting trade with a country that is part of the Union. The topic of comparative advantage has been heavily discussed in lectures, as well as in the main text, Building an Import/Export

Rbs Computer Failure 'caused By Inexperienced Operative In India' By Hannah Furness

1154 words - 5 pages gained by companies through IS/IT outsourcing. Provide suitable example to support your answer. Comparative advantage is an economic law that demonstrates the ways in which protectionism is not necessary in free trade. In the competitive advantages there many types of competitive advantages that are include in the firms cost structure, distribution network, product offerings and customer support. For the IT/IS, it is the customer support and

Human Resource Management And The Global Marketplace

1598 words - 6 pages published has been focused primarily on the collective bargaining functions of HRMs. In recent years, though, good comparative research on national HRMS has begun to emerge. However, almost none of the work comprehensively and systematically has examined HR practices in relation to each other and to business strategy to determine how these practices contribute to competitive advantage. This is the essence of comparative HRM as a result; human resource

Durex’ Loveville Campaign Essay

2660 words - 11 pages , if share is decreasing we will need to change the whole mix drastically 5) What is my comparative advantage? Int Qual and Quant. Exp. I will determine what not to change in product I will focus more on my comparative advantage in next campaign 6) What is the awareness for my product/service? Ext Quant. Des. I will decide the message of my marketing campaign. I may or may not change the distribution. 7) Do we have high brand loyalty