This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Changing The Electoral System In Canada

2040 words - 9 pages

Kyu Bin Lee
Professor Paul Kopas
Political Science 101
March 13, 2014
Changing the Electoral System
Canada’s friendly neighbor to the South, the US, has an electoral system that is composed of 3 separate elections, one of them deciding the head of state. The president elected by the people and he or she is the determining person of the country’s political system. In the US runs like a majority system” In Canada, however, elections are held slightly differently. Citizens vote for a Member of Parliament in a 308-seat house and candidates win not by a majority, unlike in the US, but by a plurality. This means that a candidate can actually win by simply having more votes than the other candidates. This method of representative democracy, in general, does not cause too much controversy in a global scope but has caused controversy in a Canadian scope. With many critics of the Canadian election system calling it archaic and non-modern, the idea of reforming the election system has been in discussion numerous times. In 2004 by the Citizens’ Assembly on Electoral Reform, created by the government of British Columbia, brought into question the current first past the post system. In an alternative state at which the Canadian election system is changed, a different set of questions is brought to the table. How can changes to the electoral system affect how the House of Commons is run and its respective procedures? In this essay, I will be discussing the possible effects of changing the Canadian electoral system on the House of Commons.
When looking at the possible implications of changing the electoral system in Canada, there are 2 possible systems that can be examined. First-past-the-post is an electoral system at which the candidate with the most votes wins the position and the candidate with fewer votes has no representation at all. First-past-the-post is a simple system, which is utilized with a two party competition (Milner). The US electoral system uses first-past-the-post to select it candidates. Proportional representation is another voting system at which the number of seats in the legislature is determined by the number of votes received (Gallagher 34). FPTP is the current system used in Canada but in the past years, critics of the system are suggesting the use of a PR system due to the advantages it can bring and it is also more democratic and modern. If changes were to occur, PR would most likely be implemented.
First-past-the-post (FPTP) voting system in general allows candidates to win who may not have a majority of the vote. It privileges big parties and majorities at the cost of smaller parties and coalitions. It also favours parties with strong regional concentrations over parties whose electoral base is more spread out. This is Canada’s current election system and for the past couple of years. In the years that Harper has been in power, he has won majority of the seats with less than 50 percent of the votes. In fact, in 2011, “Stephen...

Find Another Essay On Changing the Electoral System in Canada

The Potential of a Majoritarian Electoral System Instead of a Proportional Electoral System in South Africa

1345 words - 5 pages The journey to democracy has been strongly driven by electoral systems. These systems provide routes for governments to represent the wills of their people. It provides the platform of legitimacy to the government and in most cases ensures freedom and order within a country. This essay will discuss the major differences between a majoritarian electoral system and proportional electoral system. In addition, it will demonstrate that the use of a

The Marginalization of Minority Groups in The Electoral System

1387 words - 6 pages The marginalization of minority groups in the electoral system impedes a comprehensive representation by further entrenching and aggravating ethnic division. The lack of minority representation in political-decision making has limited the ability of a true representative democracy to come into fruition. The inconsistency of elected assemblies mirroring the population has decreased the representation of ethnic minorities and deepened the racial

Reforming the Canadian Electoral System

1479 words - 6 pages Although Canadian electoral system has always undergone periodic reforms, new challenges always accompany electoral changes and therefore the system should be consistently reformed to meet new circumstances.The current electoral system in Canada is a product of a series of electoral changes that have always taken place since the foundation of the Canadian confederation in the mid 1880s. During the early years, the rights of individuals to vote

The Flawed Electoral College System

1041 words - 4 pages There are quite a few criticisms that surround the Electoral College system. In the next few paragraphs we are going to explore some of these criticisms and some of the advantages and disadvantages of various reform proposals. One major criticism that we faced and still face today is why not vote by popular vote instead of rely on the Electoral votes. Well one of the reasons being is that states like Wyoming or Idaho benefit from it and

The Changing Face of the Police in Canada

648 words - 3 pages Canada's police. Inasmuch as Parliament requires democratic legitimacy, Canada's police forces require that citizens accept their authority in their respective communities.Accordingly, the police in Canada have made a number of structural changes to more accurately reflect the makeup and social values of contemporary Canadian society.Women in the Police Force:As social values have changed and the role of the police has adapted accordingly, women


2765 words - 11 pages , electoral systems have frequently been the focus of intense scholarly debate. Electoral reform in Canada has been a main focus of these debates and "proportional representation (PR) is currently proposed as a solution to a large number of the country's ills" (Fitzgerald, 2001, 49). There clearly are many advantages for a country to adopt a PR system, however, in Canada, the adoption of such a system could have potential negative consequences thus

Review of “Electoral Reform Proposal Failures in Canada”

960 words - 4 pages Review of “Electoral Reform Proposal Failures in Canada” The author Lawrence Leduc is a political science researcher at the University of Toronto. Aside from this article, he has written many other scholarly critiques about the political system in Canada. From the very beginning, it is evident that Leduc’s academic credentials confirm his strong background in politics. In other words, readers would appreciate his expertise on the topic

We Should Abolish the Electoral System

2510 words - 10 pages to face, is we don't directly vote for our president. In 2000, the majority of us voted for a President who in the end was not determined the winner. There are many other corruptions in our current electoral system, including the underlying racist and sexist roots, voter inequality and other flaws that go against every true democratic principle. The only solution and the only way this country could be truly democratic is to abolish the Electoral

Ways to improve the Electoral System

899 words - 4 pages There are numerous ways to improve the Malaysian electoral system both in fairness and efficiency. Currently, there is a lack in confidence in the validity or neutrality of the Electoral Commissions (EC). Members of the EC are elected by the Yang di- Pertuan Agong (YDPA) after discussing with the Conference of Rulers (Legal Research Board, 2013). However, according to Article 40 the YDPA can only act after receiving advice from the Cabinet or a

Analysis of the Malaysian Electoral System

1249 words - 5 pages According to the Election Commission (EC) of Malaysia (“Process of election”, n.d.), there are six steps for the Electoral process in Malaysia. It consists of the issuance of the writ, nomination of candidates, election campaign, polling, counting of votes and announcement of results. Firstly, a writ to the Returning Officers (RO) will be issued by the Election Committee under the Elections Act 1958 (“The election process - 13th Malaysian

Plurality Voting System in Canada

2551 words - 10 pages The current plurality voting system in Canada is regularly attacked for unfairly representing the popular vote and giving some parties a disproportionate amount of legislative power while leaving others with none. Opponents contend that other electoral systems would be far superior and provide a better democracy. Proportional representation (PR) is usually cited as the best alternative; the debate of proportional representation versus plurality

Similar Essays

Draft: Are Current Political Conditions Ripe In Canada To Mobilize For A Change From Single Member Plurality (Smp) Electoral System?

916 words - 4 pages POLI 2304 Paper Intro The research question I chose for my term paper was number 13, which asks “Are the current political conditions ripe in Canada to mobilize for a change from our single member plurality (SMP) electoral system? If so, what should be the nature of the change? If not, why not?” To address these questions, I created the thesis statement “Canada’s current electoral system unduly favours the pluralist approach to the detriment of

Electoral Reform In Canada Essay

1870 words - 7 pages Electoral Reform in Canada The issue of electoral reform has become more important than ever in Canada in recent years as the general public has come to realize that our current first-past-the-post, winner-take-all system, formally known as single-member plurality (SMP) has produced majority governments of questionable legitimacy. Of the major democracies in the world, Canada, the United States, and the United Kingdom are the only countries

The Electoral College System Essay

1413 words - 6 pages Most democracies in the world today have multiparty system. There are 3 or more political parties that gain the power and control the government. However, throughout the history United States have had a two-party system. Currently, these two parties are Democrats and Republicans. This two party system is a result of nation’s choosing its officials through popular vote. In America, Electoral College elects the President and the Vice President

The British Electoral System Essay

1776 words - 7 pages The British Electoral System In democratic states, electoral systems are of great importance. Elections give people the right to choose their government; ensure that governments represent the majority (or largest minority) of the people; ensure peaceful changes of government (stability); allow people with fresh ideas an opportunity to enter the political arena; confer legitimacy of government and allow the government