This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Charisma And Leadership Essay

724 words - 3 pages

Whether a person with average charisma could be considered a superior leader or not will depend on a number of factors. First, it is important to understand what factors constitute charisma, also known as "idealized influence" (Mumford & Strange, 2002) and by inference average charisma. Connelly, Gaddis and Helton-Fauth (2002) cited House (1977) to indicate that Charismatic leadership arises from the interaction of leader capacities (self confidence, dominance, moral conviction), leader behavior (successful role modeling one's beliefs and values, articulation of goals and visions, communicating high expectations, tapping into followers motives), followers characteristics (motive compatibility, identification with leader), and situational factors (crises, need for social change) (p. 257). In other words, charisma involves envisioning, energizing, and enabling and therefore a true commitment towards the overall well being of an organization and its employees.Second, as one examines the relationship between charismatic leadership in general (weak or strong) and effectiveness, it should be realized that this is inherently a weak one (Nadler and Tushman, winter, 1990) as it has many associated risks and is limited by (1) unrealistic expectations, (2) dependency and counter-dependency (3) reluctance to disagree with the leader… and (4) limitations of range of the individual leader (pp. 110-111). As such, the authors concluded that while charismatic leadership is a necessary ingredient for effective [or superior] organizational performance, it is not sufficient (p. 112).Still, these inherent limitations are even more compounded or reinforced as one begins to further analyze the relationship between charisma and the impact on leader effectiveness or performance, in the context of two basic types of charisma, "personalized and socialized", as described by House and Howell (1992) and cited by Connelly, Gaddis and Helton-Fauth (2002, p. 257). The authors suggested that charismatic leaders who epitomize the personalized behavior reflect a vision that is defined by their own personal values and beliefs, irrespective of what the followers think (p. 258). In this regard, it shows that this form can even be considered a dangerous attribute if the leader does not possess good intentions. In contrast, socialized charismatic leaders "develop shared goals with their followers…and seek to reduce psychological distance from those they lead"...

Find Another Essay On Charisma and leadership

What is Leadership? Essay

1745 words - 7 pages on the Personal Computer, and this thus authenticates him as Charismatic visionary leader. Supporting this further, is the definition of Charisma by Klauss in his paper that Charisma as an element in the communication/leadership process occurs when a leader’s extraordinary claim is present to remedy a distressful situation and when responsibility for resolving that stress situation is accepted by the communicator/leader. When people believe that

Destructive Leading in Cambodia Essay

1031 words - 5 pages of Kampuchea. This group was compiled of a majority of kids aged 12-20. The youth’s main task was to spy on adults to ensure the adults were following the strict regulations. Although the Khmer Rouge was loyal and efficient, the Youth League was by far Pot’s most trustworthy group. Pot’s charisma and focused leadership made him easily liked by young people. With all scholars obliterated, the Khmer Rouge started educating the youth of Pol Pot’s

Transformational & Transactional Leadership

925 words - 4 pages dimensions which are pointed out by Bass (1990, p. 28), ‘charisma, idealized influence, inspirational motivation, intellectual stimulation and individualized consideration’. Apart from these basic roles, charisma leadership has its own role of literature since it has similarity with transformational leadership and they are contribution to each other (Judge & Piccolo, 2004, p. 755). On the other hand, there are three dimensions of transactional

Weber and Religion: The Prophet Motive

1190 words - 5 pages are in no way 'bureaucratic' or 'organisational'. As we move clockwise we are introduced to the prophet. We also move to societies which are now organised around social institutions such as the state. These societies are also more hierarchically organised into classes and social groups. The prophet is in part similar to the magician. They like the magician will base their claims to leadership on their own personal properties of charisma. Thus

Leadership Models and Communication

1117 words - 4 pages these leaders can therefore be termed as ineffective leaders. Therefore, leadership is not limited to a role, rather leadership skills comes from within.Transformational leaders set challenging expectations and enable others to achieve higher levels of performance. Bass (1985) depicted transformational leadership as comprising of four distinct factors: charisma, inspiration, individual consideration and intellectual stimulation (p. 178).A basic

Leadership: Transactional versus Transformational

1026 words - 5 pages Weber (1920/1947, p. 358-359) described charisma, as a personality characteristic possessed by extraordinary, god-like exemplars. Robbins and Langton (2003, p. 395) asserted that the two most popular approaches to leadership are contingency models and the study of charisma. Burns (1978, p. 4) who built upon the work of Weber categorized two types of leaders, transactional and transformational. Kuhnert and Lewis (1987, p. 650) argued that

Charisma and Political Communication

1987 words - 8 pages If I said that Hitler, Obama and Jesus have one thing in common, would you believe me ? Indeed, all these people mentioned have this super ability to move masses wherever they have been thanks to their charisma. Actually there was no concrete agreed on by all definition of charisma. These term has a Greek origin...... Which means grace and special gifts. In ancient Greece, the "charits" where goddess who had charm, beauty, loveliness and could

A Theoretical Philosophy of Leadership

2487 words - 10 pages must develop trusting relationships and a climate of cooperation. TRUST & CHARISMA Trust and humility is vital to leadership. Eastern philosophy regards the lack of “self” as something of primary importance. Transformative leaders cultivate trust though clearly translating their vision and how it may be achieved to their organization (Northouse, 2006). Articulate the vision in a manner that does not focus on self-interest. Self-centeredness

Management and Organizational Behavior Leaders and Leadership Case Analysis: Robert L. Johnson

1555 words - 6 pages 1) Entrepreneurs are special types of leaders. How would you classify them in general terms of leadership style and characteristics?2) How does vision and charisma play a role in Robert Johnson's success? Are there other important leadership skills he possesses?Entrepreneurs are leaders that know in their gut that creativity and innovation are the lifeblood of their organization. New ideas can lead to programs that are superior to those that are

Charismatic Leadership Within an Engineering Technology Management

1648 words - 7 pages involves looking beyond the engineering needs and focusing on the business aspect (Gaynor, 2008). Charismatic Leadership. Weber defined the term charisma as a particular quality of an individual personality by virtue of their special abilities and attributes (Bryman, 1992). It indicates that charisma is a special quality that not all people possesses it. According to Riggio (2012), charismatic leaders are fundamentally very ingenious communicators

Charismatic Leadership

2047 words - 8 pages followers and encouraged them to follow his steps. The life and the visions of Martin Luther King, Winston Churchill, or Mother Theresa sent powerful message to the masses, which approvingly set on to pursue their vision.4. TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT OF CHARISMATIC LEADERSA potential controversy in the study of charismatic leadership in organizations is the fact whether or not charisma can be cultivated. Although there are some personal traits

Similar Essays

How Does Charisma Relate To Effective Leadership And What Cross Cultural Implications Might Derive From Charismatic Communication?

1899 words - 8 pages charisma relate to effective leadership and what cross-cultural implications might derive from charismatic communication?CharismaCharisma originates from Greek, and means "divine favor" (, such as performing miracles or foreseeing the future. Since the dawn of literature, starting in ancient Mesopotamia with the epic of Gilgamesh, through the ancient Greek literature, right up to the spread of Christianity, divine

Charismatic Leadership: A Controversial Style Essay

680 words - 3 pages persuasion and negotiation skills. Their followers want to identify with them and emulate them, they develop intense feelings about them, and above all they have unrelenting trust and confidence in them.Managers are being told they need charisma to be a successful leader in visionary companies; students are being taught the pathway to certain organizational success is through the use of charismatic leadership. Buried in the literature, however

Can A Person With Average Charisma Or Personality Be A Superior Leader?

633 words - 3 pages Can a person with average charisma or personality be a superior leader? Support your position and if applicable, provide an example.My answer is No. A personal trait alone is not a factor for superior leadership. Ralph Stogdill argued that, "traits of an effective leader can only be assessed in conjunction with other factors, such as the nature of followers and the characteristics of the situation" (Wren, J.T. 1995, p. 125). Furthermore

Transformational Leadership And Schools Essay

1783 words - 8 pages establishing values and ethics at the workplace to create an environment that is more satisfying for the followers. The element of charisma also is very important and effective in this process. Kouzes & Posner (2007) introduce transformational leadership as a leadership style that inspires people and according to Burns (2003) transformational leadership occurs when, in their interactions, people “raise one another to higher levels of motivation