Talking Back To Civilization Essay

1649 words - 7 pages

Talking Back to Civilization

Talking Back to Civilization , edited by Frederick E. Hoxie, is a compilation of excerpts from speeches, articles, and texts written by various American Indian authors and scholars from the 1890s to the 1920s. As a whole, the pieces provide a rough testimony of the American Indian during a period when conflict over land and resources, cultural stereotypes, and national policies caused tensions between Native American Indians and Euro-American reformers. This paper will attempt to sum up the plight of the American Indian during this period in American history.

American Indians shaped their critique of modern America through their exposure to and experience with “civilized,” non-Indian American people. Because these Euro-Americans considered traditional Indian lifestyle savage, they sought to assimilate the Indians into their civilized culture. With the increase in industrialization, transportation systems, and the desire for valuable resources (such as coal, gold, etc.) on Indian-occupied land, modern Americans had an excuse for “the advancement of the human race” (9). Euro-Americans moved Indians onto reservations, controlled their education and practice of religion, depleted their land, and erased many of their freedoms. The national result of this “conquest of Indian communities” was a steady decrease of Indian populations and drastic increase in non-Indian populations during the nineteenth century (9). It is natural that many American Indians felt fearful that their culture and people were slowly vanishing. Modern America to American Indians meant the destruction of their cultural pride and demise of their way of life.

American Indians associated many things with the injustice of modern America: their poor education, containment onto reservations, restricted freedoms (of religion and traditions), and limited rights as so-called American citizens. An advocate for Indian education, Henry Roe Cloud wrote, “Is the Indian a ward of the government or a citizen? What are his rights and duties? . . . [He] must be trained to grapple with these economic, educational, political, religious and social problems” (59, 60). Cloud challenged the American educational system by rhetorically questioning the meaning of Indian citizenship and campaigning for more Indian societal responsibilities. In the Society of American Indians' (SAI) Quarterly Journal , progressivist Carlos Montezuma wrote, “Reservations are prisons where our people are kept to live and die, where equal possibilities, equal education and equal responsibilities are unknown” (93). In Indian schools, children were not even allowed to speak their native language for fear that they might return to their savage ways. Essentially, American Indians only wanted equal rights and equal citizenship; they wanted Euro-Americans to stop treating them like lower-level beings. But Euro-Americans continued their quest to mother the...

Find Another Essay On Talking Back to Civilization

Why did the Mayan Civilization collapse?

3926 words - 16 pages , the Southern Maya highlands, second, the Southern, also known as Central, Maya lowlands, and third is the Northern Maya lowlands. The Mayan civilization was populated (densely), and its culture was dynamic, which had one of the most dynamic societies ever existed in the world. The Mayan culture had many different areas such as the Mayan art, literature, and mathematics. The Mayan civilization is similar to other Mesoamerican civilization, back

Lord of the Flies-evil in human's heart - NCC - Essay

1010 words - 5 pages heart. The conch is a symbolic figure of civilization and order. As the novel progresses, the conch turns from pink and creamy to bleached in order to symbolize the loss of power, which is emphasized when it eventually breaks. The significance of breaking the conch shows that civilization ends and the boys become complete savages. When there are no rules and civilization to hold them back, the boys show their true nature which is evil at its core

Pleasure and Aggreshion. Related to Freud

1340 words - 5 pages . From that sense civilization steps inwith a beneficial propose, as it tame the human nature. But, civilizationcreates human source of worry and distress, and also oppresses our basichuman instinct. As we looked for substitute for our sexual desire, we alsosacrifice our aggressive nature for the benefit of civilization.Finally, it is clear that civilization has its discontents, but how can wesolve such a problem. It is impossible to look back and say

Modernity and The Age of Enlightenment

1554 words - 6 pages When talking about the concept of modernity, most people will probably think such concept is related to the contemporary era they live in where many advanced technology present in everyday life. In this so-called modern era, people from different regions and cultural backgrounds share many similar characteristics, such as their daily technology or civilization, general knowledge and science, and even the way they dressed. In fact, many

The Rise of Islam

1072 words - 5 pages any problems or illnesses that lived within them and simply take them out. Then after removing the illness, they sewed them back up and gave them the chance to live another day. The Islamic Civilization also focused on math and sciences. They created algebra and also invented the university. Having a university allowed students to learn so that they can help and find more discoveries in the world. Algebra was presented by Al-Khwarizmi and

From Civilization to Savagery

1326 words - 6 pages Mokokoma Mokhonoana once said, “Morals are nothing but a civilized society’s attempt to tame some beast called man.” Many works of fiction discuss how these morals are challenged when faced with isolation from civilization. One of the most famous of these works is William Golding’s fiction novel, Lord of the Flies, which explores the theme of civilization versus savagery through the story of a group of English boys who are stranded on a deserted

Western Civilization

681 words - 3 pages managed to figure out so much with so little help back then? Even today still,we are trying hard to figure out how they managed to even build the pyramids. So, it is easy to say that the Egyptians not only demonstrated a form of civilization, but more so they carried a more advanced form of civilization that we have ever encountered.I asked myself how exactly they had demonstrated that form of civilization. In my mind, the Nile River was the root of

Western Civilization

681 words - 3 pages managed to figure out so much with so little help back then? Even today still,we are trying hard to figure out how they managed to even build the pyramids. So, it is easy to say that the Egyptians not only demonstrated a form of civilization, but more so they carried a more advanced form of civilization that we have ever encountered.I asked myself how exactly they had demonstrated that form of civilization. In my mind, the Nile River was the root of

Ancient civilization - History - Essay

453 words - 2 pages about the civilizations that follow the Mesopotamians and Egyptians which are the Assyrians, the Neo-Babylonians, the Medes, and the Persians. It mentions architecture, society, art, etc… Chapter 2 is about the Aegean Civilizations, which includes the Minoans, the Mycenaeans, and the Greeks of the Archaic Age. The chapter starts off talking about the Minoan civilization, which lasted from 3000 BCE through 1100 BCE. This civilization thrived on the

The Commandments of Society

950 words - 4 pages talking and you ignore them it lowers their self-esteem and gets them off track to what they were talking about. Society needs to grasp the idea of listening to others because you can never know if the topic they are discussing may be directed towards them. This commandment can be related back towards the golden rule because no one likes it when someone interrupts their presentation. The fourth commandment does not relate to any of the previous

Frankenstein Vs I, Frankenstein - University of Manitoba/ Engl 1400 - Essay

513 words - 3 pages  results to the destruction of the Monster himself, his creator and everyone his creator loves.   Just like the Monster in Shelley's book, the Monster in I, Frankenstein also attempts to connect back to civilization after the death of his creator. For example, the monster moves back to the city. Shortly after the monster enters civilization, he meets the Gargoyle queen who names him, Adam. This action illustrates some form of acceptance which also gives

Similar Essays

With Regards To The History Of The American Civilization In A Retrospective View From A Future Native Historian An Essay Written From The Future Perspective Looking Back On America

1568 words - 6 pages It would seem that you wish to learn of an ancient civilization that has long since disappeared and vanished like dust into the wind. This civilization bore the name "The United States of America". But were they really United? Were they really a superpower? Or was this just all in their head? Let us take a walk.........1492. A man takes a gamble; risking it all a man crossed a vast ocean in search of a new world. The man was labeled as insane

Civilization Or Barbarism: Which Is More Acceptable?

937 words - 4 pages . Another civilization that contained barbarism was the Greeks. In Ancient Greece, the Gods were able to get slaves from the symposium to become their personal slaves and sex slaves. The Greeks thought that foreigners sounded they were saying “bar, bar, bar” when they were talking so they started calling them barbarians. In certain Greek city-states, politicians would pass laws that were unfair or just for their benefit, and the people would not be

The Myth Of The Matador And Theseus And The Iliad By Homer

2547 words - 10 pages the center of the Minoan Civilization and the political system of civilization; as it was taken over. The Minotaur also represents the people of the Minoan civilization. They probably fought back ruthlessly however; weaken just like the Minotaur in the end fell. This suggests their utter defeat toward the Mycenaean civilization. Sir Author Evens started to excavate for Knossos in the island of Crete. Sir Author Evens was able to find

Lord Of The Flies Essay

841 words - 4 pages into a shelter and stayed there for two days straight, talking” (61), the island is a savage place, so it foreshadows a decline in Percival’s civilization. Talking in shelters symbolizes Percival trying to stay civilized by reciting his telephone number and address, hoping he would return home, and back to civilization. However, his incantation fails. “Percival Wemys Madison, The Vicarage, Harcourt St. Anthony, Hants, telephone, telephone, tele