Chemically Assisted Interrogations And Reid Interrogation

1683 words - 7 pages

The Reid Technique is not the only interrogation technique that has been utilized when attempting to retrieve the truth from an uncooperative and/or unwilling suspect. Among the many other options that have been utilized are: polygraph, hypnosis, voice/physical/mental stress, torture and chemicals. In particular let’s focus on the use of “Chemicals” in the assistance of obtaining a confession about a crime in comparison to the use of the Reid Technique.
First, let’s examine the background for the use of chemicals. Because of its use for obtaining confessions from suspects and the general idea that suspects (or anyone else) are not capable of lying while under its’ influence it has been referred to as “truth serum.” Over time the chemical(s) has changed. The first truth serum to be identified and classified as such was a pharmacological agent used as an anesthetic named scopolamine. Robert House, an obstetrician in Texas, was using this chemical for his pregnant patients in 1916. He noticed that some of his patients who received the anesthetic scopolamine during delivery fell into a half-sleep in which they could sometimes answer questions without remembering having done so afterward (REFERENCE EL-HAI).
Scopolamine works by depressing the central nervous system and diminishing inhibitions, thus, allowing for them to be less guarded and use less discretion and caution allowing them to “spill the beans.” Albeit, Dr. House had the idea that this chemical could be used to help with verifying a suspect’s claim of innocence, contrary to today’s idea of getting a confession. He so strongly believed in this theory that he traveled to various jails and demonstrated the process of using chemicals to validate claimed innocence. In 1922 he used the technique on two prisoners in a Dallas Jail and the prisoners both ended up being exonerated of their charges. (REFERENCE) Thus began the age of truth serum for investigations as well as, the term narcoanalysis was born.
After House’s death in 1929, the use of scopolamine and later truth serums — sodium amytal and sodium pentothal — changed course, truth serums began to be used for interrogation purposes on suspects who were being treated as though they were guilty, versus being used on those who were thought to have possibly been falsely accused and wrongfully convicted. In 1942, there were scientists working for the Office of Strategic Services (OSS), the CIA’s wartime predecessor, who were asked to develop a chemical substance that could break down the psychological defenses. After testing several compounds, the OSS scientists selected a potent extract of marijuana as the best available "truth serum." The cannabis concoction was given the code name TD, meaning Truth Drug (REFERENCE LEE truth serums). The search for a true “truth serum” was still in hot pursuit. In 1947 the U.S. Navy launched Project Chatter which utilized a hallucinogenic drug derived from the peyote cactus, which is similar in...

Find Another Essay On Chemically Assisted Interrogations and Reid Interrogation

Anatomy of a False Confession Essay

1613 words - 6 pages are a large component in the elicitation of false confessions. Inbau, Reid, and Buckley’s (1986) Criminal Interrogations and Confessions encourages and describes the step-by-step process that officers should use to elicit a confession, including deceit and psychological manipulation. The Supreme Court has approved the performance of deceit and deception with the explanation that “that alone cannot make an innocent person confess.” (Irsay, 2002

Interrogation Techniques Essay

620 words - 2 pages Interrogation is a conversation, between a law enforcement officer and a person who is suspected of committing a crime or assisting others to commit a crime (AIU Online, 2007). Interrogations are used in many occasions. They are done to get someone to confess to something, weather it is a crime or giving out information of a crime or someone. When conducting an interrogation the interrogator has to have confidence and creativity. If you do not

Psychology of Confessions

2068 words - 9 pages found that innocent suspects had told more plausible denials. However, those denials had cause the interviewers to use harsher guilt-presumptive interrogations. This study had also shown that the presumption of guilt started a process of behavioral confirmation which led to shaping the interrogation, the suspect’s behaviors, and the judgments of the observers. 8. Describe the three types of false confessions as introduced by Kassin and Wrightsman

The Use of Deceptive Interrogation

2770 words - 11 pages fingerprints, to confirm his or her guilt, telling a suspect that he or she has been identified by an eye witness, holding a line up where a supposed witness identifies the suspect, [or even] getting a suspect to agree to a lie-detector test and telling him or her that it has proved their guilt.” These tactics are all part of what is known as the Reid technique of deceptive interrogation. Other forms of deceit also contained within the Reid

Analysis of Interrogation Methods as a Means to Gathering Information

1756 words - 8 pages Interrogation is a method commonly used by the Army to acquire information from a suspected individual or groups. The aim of this process is to make the individual to confess or give up information that can lead to recovery of personnel or protect against future dangers. Interrogations can be used in numerous ways to gather information. The U.S. Army has been involved in various Intelligence collection around the world especially since the

Futility of Coercive Interrogation Techniques

1625 words - 7 pages Futility of Coercive Interrogation Techniques The US military base in Guantanamo Bay, which was used as detention facility and interrogation activities of suspected terrorists apprehended by US sequel to 9/11 attack in 2001, during the period, terrorist suspects witnessed a wide range of coercive interrogations and inhuman acts ratified by US government and termed “Enhanced Interrogation Techniques”. The joint armed forces and both intelligence

False Confessions and the Norfolk Four Case

3106 words - 12 pages proceedings of the Norfolk Four case reveals how the interrogation process, both in its nature and application, coerces suspects into revising their perceptions of actual events, circumstances and motivations. Renegotiation of reality occurs when, by virtue of the institutionalized process of police interrogations, the suspect perceives that his initial reality holds no value to the interrogator or to the outcome of the interrogation, when he lacks

The Difference between the Miranda Rights and the Charter of Rights

1224 words - 5 pages time he voiced his right (Miranda Warning, 2014). Based on my research and what I have learned from Criminology 121, I believe the right to interrogate suspects while council is not present is an integral part of police work. The article points out that in most cases it is the interrogation that will be the most determinative factor in the outcome of any case (Friedman, 2014). It is clear that police have the upper hand during interrogations

Role of Psychologists in Developing Torture Techniques

2260 words - 9 pages (Leighton, 1949) with the breakthrough discovery that physical threats must be accompanied by the use of psychological strategies during interrogations. In 1945, the Department of Defense began funding psychologists as reimbursement for their efforts during World War II (Summers, 2008). The Office of Naval Research, followed by the National Science Foundation, and soon other major service branches including the Army Research Institute for the

Law Enforcement and Miranda Warnings Case Analysis

1284 words - 5 pages out in the suspect’s language so he can read them and sign them. The case Florida vs Powell (08-1175) Mr. Powell was place into custody for suspicion of illegally owning a firearm. The officers said Mr. Powell waived his rights to counsel. They proceeded to question him in an interrogation room. Since Mr. Powell did not speak or understand English very well, the Florida Supreme Court over turned his case. They felt that the police did not

Questionable Interrogations

1892 words - 8 pages as flawed is the area of interrogations though many other areas will be presented throughout this paper as well. By examining five cases involving questionable interrogation and showing other system flaws, I will enlighten others as to how our justice system handles its flaws, and hopefully I will provide motivation for further improvement. To show an unbiased and educated examination of the five cases involving questionable interrogations, I

Similar Essays

Interrogations, Confession And Admissions In The Criminal Justice System (Interrogation Policies Used By Police Today)

1843 words - 7 pages often a tool utilized by law enforcement to obtain a confession. There are many methods used by police investigators in attempts to obtain a confession during an interrogation. The foundation of interrogations, in my opinion, aimed at finding the truth. There are certain limitations in determining whether the confession obtained was voluntary.The limitations governing the police relate to the due process test and that of confessions obtained

Analyze Essay

1133 words - 5 pages truth and you have the wrong person. References Buckley P. J. (2000) the reid technique of interviewing and interrogation. Retrieved 12, Dec 2013 from http://law.uark.edu/documents/Judges-Reid-Technique.pdf Constitutional Law : Miranda (n.d) DPs- law enforcement academy. Retrieved 12, Dec 2013 from http://www.nmlea.dps.state.nm.us/legal/documents/Miranda.pdf Electronic recording of custodial interrogations (n.d) the justice’s project

Interrogations Versus I Nterview Essay

1502 words - 7 pages have their Fifth Amendment rights against self-incrimination nor do the Miranda Rights need to be read off because they are not in custody. The victim, witness or possible suspect has the right to remain silence, and end the interview at any stage. When an officer becomes suspicious about a particular suspect’s innocence, the interview will become an interrogation. Interrogations Interrogations are accusatory and designed to determine if a

Interrogations Versus I Nterview Essay

790 words - 4 pages The challenges and overcoming them There are a many challenges that an officer faces when it comes to interviews and interrogations. Some challenges include learning if someone is a possible suspect through the information received in an interview, preparation for the interrogation, issues with legality of the Miranda warnings, deception by the officer, emotional balance, and most importantly, preventing false confessions