Chief Seattle's 1854 Oration Was It True?

578 words - 2 pages

Chief Seattle, leader of the Duwamish tribe, was author of the famous speech to Washington Governor Stevens upon his arrival to Seattle in 1854. However, many doubt Chief Seattle's speech to have taken place. There is little credible evidence available to back up the existence of the speech with the exception of a newspaper article written by a Doctor Henry A. Smith. The article, titled "Chief Seattle's Speech," was published in the "Seattle Sunday Star" on October 27th, 1887. If Doctor Smith was witness to Chief Seattle's epic speech, he was the sole translator. How are we to know that translation faults and liberations were not made by Doctor Smith? The Duwamish language was not a written language, having no alphabet, thus no official record or writing could have been made. For these reasons, it is highly probable Chief Seattle's Oration of 1854 never existed. The first and only published account of Chief Seattle's Oration was written in the "Seattle Sunday Star" on October 27th, 1887. The author of the article, Doctor Henry Smith, was said to have been a witness at the speech and served as a translator for Chief Seattle; however, no official document of this account exists in any historical archive. Chief Seattle's speech has been widely cited in numerous books and documents, but every citation leads back to Doctor Smith's article. Therefore, the only proof available that this speech ever occurred is the newspaper article dating back to 1887 from this one source. If we are to give the benefit of the doubt to Doctor Henry Smith as having been...

Find Another Essay On Chief Seattle's 1854 Oration - Was it true?

'It was not the weakness of the nationalists but the strengths of the colonial rulers that led to the failure of the nationalist movements in SEA before WWII.' How far is this true?

3039 words - 12 pages being described as "offered no more than example; they offered no power-sharing, and they had no concept of a commonwealth... The nationalist movement was formed very much in antagonism to them." The colonial powers were willing to crush any opposition as long as they deemed it to be a threat to their authority. The oppression limited the space for the nationalist to grow legally in terms of nationwide associations and movements. In Vietnam

The Conceding Threat Essay

2006 words - 9 pages Is it Red Face vs. White Face, or Red faces and White faces? Chief Seattle, in this oration to Governor Stevens, discusses the comparatives and differences between these two conglomerations of people using rhetoric devices such as similes, concession, repetition, and tone. Through the use of these devices, Chief Seattle sets in his purposes of both warning the White Faces that although they hold the current power, and although the Native

Indians and there Sacred Lands

1029 words - 4 pages . There is also agreement of the three in the spiritual sense of the land.In Chief Seattle's speech, he talks in more of the spiritual sense of the land. But it is in direct relationship to the abuse that the White Man exerts on the land. He makes many references towards the Indian Spiritual being, that he is very different from that of the White Man. He makes many analogies towards that of the spiritual importance of the burial grounds and the

Oration Defined by Cicero

1645 words - 7 pages easily moved by "good" speech. The power of oration gives men "The one special advantage we enjoy over animals is our power to speak with one another, to express our thoughts in words. For this reason it is a particularly satisfactory experience for a man to take pleasure in conversation and seek to excel at it." (Crassus qtd. in Cicero 247) Cicero was correct in gauging oration as a fine art. For oration bundles a mass of different skills that

Neo-Aristotelian Analysis of Chief Sagoyewatha’s Speech to Missionaries; 1805

3232 words - 13 pages elders of the Iroquois Confederacy and discuss the request. Red Jacket's speech was highly logical and Bertsch 3 utilized terminology intended to foster consubstantiality between him and the missionaries. During the oration, he argues that it would be preferable to preserve the status quo and respect each groups right to practice their faith the way it had been passed down to them from their ancestors. Although very skillfully and

The Funeral Oration

1273 words - 5 pages war, and the deaths that were a result of it, were the driving factors behind Pericles writing and speaking his "Funeral Oration." Pericles took to his natural inclination to speak and inspire, and used the excuse of a eulogy as an opportunity to get his message across to the good people of Athens. "The Funeral Oration of Pericles" offers many insights into the life if Athenians at the time it was written, allowing the reader to learn about the

Examining how Brutus and Mark Anthony Utilise Language to Manipulate the Audience in Act 3 Scene 2 of Julius Caesar

2072 words - 8 pages conspirators. This is in order to strengthen his defence of his actions and to prove that his actions and ideals are justified. Brutus's funeral oration is mainly based upon his constant use of personal pronouns to influence the crowd. For example, 'As Caesar loved me, I weep for him; as he was fortunate, I rejoice at it; as he was valiant, I honour him: but, as he was ambitious, I slew him'. By his constant

Pericles

955 words - 4 pages Thucydides’ interpretation of Pericles’ Funeral Oration is a significant text of the Classical World, delivered by Pericles during 5th Century Greece and the Age of Pericles. It is intended as an account of the soldiers lost during the Peloponnesian War, however it is a statement that expresses the myth and ideals of Athens, all of which are relevant to 5th century Athens. It functions as a model for future societies and portrays the unique

An Analysis of Marc Antony's Funeral Oration during Julius Caesar

619 words - 2 pages Analysis of Marc Antony's Funeral Oration"...Bear with me; / my heart is in the coffin there with Caesar, / And I must pause till it come back to me." (JC III ii 47) Marc Antony's speech at Caesar's funeral was so cunning and powerful that it caused the crowd's loyalties to sway. Prior to Marc Antony's oration the crowd favored Brutus and the conspirators. However, Marc Antony's compelling discourse caused the plebeians to support him, and not

The Book of Courtier Baldesar Castiglione

1010 words - 4 pages The Book of Courtier Baldesar Castiglione The Renaissance was a period prompted by the rebirth in classical culture. As classical culture resurfaced, it gradually awakened and inspired the human soul, leading to tremendous development in individuality. Humans took a gigantic stride away from barbarianism and distinguished themselves by focusing on intellectual progress. The capabilities of human nature unfolded as man studied all

Thycydides and The Peloponnesian War

2526 words - 10 pages “Pericles’ Funeral Oration” and why the war degraded it to a rasher reality in “Civil War in Corcyra”. Thucydides’ loved his city-state of Athens and wrote his work to analyze war to understand the circumstances that lead up to the demise of greatness of Athens around him. Thucydides wrote this book and died before the war was over; even though he was amidst the chaos of the fighting he was able to discern and question the fall of Athens culture of

Similar Essays

How Far Is It True To Say That The Weimar Republic Was Doomed From Its Foundation?

1361 words - 5 pages How far is it true to say that the Weimar Republic was doomed from its foundation ?In November 1918, the first republic is declared in Germany. It is however unable to survive, and only 25 years later replaced by the dictatorship of Hitler. Indeed, the democrats lacked legitimacy right from the start. Directly after the war, army generals blamed the SPD as "November Criminals", accusing them of having betrayed the German people by signing the

How Far It Is True To Say That World War Ii Was The Result Of Hitler's Aggressive Policies?

1360 words - 5 pages When examining The Second World War and its causes, there are generally two major commonly accepted historiographical views. It is firstly the conventional view, which blamed Hitler’s aggression, and , as stated by Churchill, it was largely Chamberlain’s appeasement policy that made room for this aggression to come through, or the second, common revisionist view that put the blame on France and Britain- their self interest and simply

"How Far Is It True To Say That The Weimar Republic Was Doomed From It's Foundation?"

2034 words - 8 pages catalysts. Even if they were hindrances statesmen that were willing to take risks in order to bring their country back into economic and international stability (even if it meant getting help from an Allied nation) while partially sacrificing their personal (or party's) agendas, were one of the reasons that proved the Weimar Republic's potential and showed that it was not doomed from it's foundation, as Alan James Edwards wrote "No one factor was

'how True Would It Be To Say That Socrates Was A Sophist?'

1649 words - 7 pages publicly disdained material possessions and was renowned for walking around Athens without any shoes. Socrates believed that the pursuit of the truth was far more important than material wealth and opted instead for a free exchange of idea's and felt it an obligation to share important things with other citizens so that all could benefit. However, it seemed that no matter how hard he tried to distinguish himself from the sophists, Socrates was