Child Pornography And The Supreme Court

611 words - 2 pages

In this paper we shall present an important case involving the governments attempt to defend a child-protection law designed to guard minors against internet pornography. In Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition, 00-795, the court heard arguments over the Child Pornography Protection Act of 1996 (CPPA).(Ashcroft)


The production or possession of actual child pornography was illegal prior to 1996; the CPPA broadened the definition of child pornography to include images that merely appear to be children engaged in sexually explicit conduct -- for example, images of adults digitally altered to look like children -- or that convey the impression that the individuals involved are minors. The rationale behind the law was that it is not only the children involved in the creation of child pornography that are harmed, but that the images themselves are harmful because they incite pedophiles to abuse children.


In a 1982 case, the Supreme Court said that child pornography, like obscenity, should not receive First Amendment protection because children were abused in its production. This case raises a bigger issue: whether the mere existence of pornographic images involving children is harmful even if no real children were involved in their creation.


The Free Speech Coalition, a group of adult-oriented businesses and artists, filed suit in federal district court in California, alleging that the law was vague and overbroad in violation of the First Amendment. They lost at trial court, but the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed.


Deputy Solicitor General Paul D. Clement argued in favor of the law before the court, saying that images of children engaged in sexual activity, whether or not they involved real children, pose a real danger to actual children because they could be used by pedophiles to entice children into illicit sexual activity or to pose for pornographic pictures. He said that the provisions at issue...

Find Another Essay On Child Pornography and the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court Essay

1067 words - 4 pages In 1787 Article three of the constitution created the Supreme Court, but not until 1789 was it configured. The way it was originally set up was with one Chief Justice and five associate judges, with all six members being appointed for life. This court serves as the “supreme law of the land”, it has the power to determine if state or federal laws are in conflict with how the Court interprets the constitution.      Presently the supreme

The Political Supreme Court Essay

587 words - 2 pages ), religious affiliation (their stance on abortion et. al), possibility of judicial activism or restraint, and partisan affiliation (get the backing of your own interest groups or to gain support from the opposing).      Now these interest groups also try to win over the president in the nomination of Supreme Court justices. They would often be found lobbying lobbying the judicial committee and the President. These interest groups

The Voting Rights Act of 1965 and the Supreme Court

765 words - 4 pages President Obama, the 1st black president, election’s shows evidence that the Voting Rights Act is no longer needed. This led to the Supreme Court to rule that section 4 is unconstitutional ever since it’s recent update in 1975. Making minor changes such as moving polling places and redrawing electoral districts. (“Supreme Court Invalidates..”) In conclusion, in order to ensure that young people keep the spirit of the Voters Right Act- one

The United States Supreme Court

670 words - 3 pages The laws of the United States of America are governed by the Constitution which is broken down into three main branches. These branches are the Legislative Branch, Executive Branch and the Judicial Branch. The Judicial Branch of the government is made up of the Supreme Court, Circuit court of Appeals, Specialized Courts and District Court. Congress passes laws, the President either passes or vetoes these laws, but the Supreme Court decides if

The Judicial Branch and its Supreme Court History.

1301 words - 5 pages The Judicial BranchAnd ItsSupreme Court's HistoryThe laws of the United States of America are governed by the Constitution which is broken down into three main branches. These branches are the Legislative Branch, Executive Branch and the Judicial Branch. Although all three branches provided a key structure in the building of our country, I have chosen to concentrate on the Judicial Branch and its Supreme Court because of its struggle into

The United States Supreme Court

1975 words - 8 pages THE UNITED STATESSUPREMECOURTI've chosen to research on the Supreme Court and it's Justices. This seemed like an interesting topic to me, because someday I want to be a part of the legal system.The Supreme Court of the United States, composed of a chief justice and eight associate justices, is at the apex of the U.S. judicial system. Provisions for the making of the Supreme Court were made in Article III of the U.S. Constitution. In addition to

U.S. Supreme Court and the Impact of Sentencing

1753 words - 7 pages generally done by proof of work dependability, scholastic progress, paying child support, complying by court ordered sanctions, no further convictions, the absence of drugs in their physical system, remaining in a specific location, and maintaining a good relationship with the probation agency. The agency is determined by the location and decision of the judge mandating the sentence of probation.Many conditions of parole are systematically similar but

Euthanasia Essay - Assisted Suicide and the Supreme Court

1568 words - 6 pages Assisted Suicide and the Supreme Court      After the nation's highest court declared that U.S. citizens are not constitutionally guaranteed the right to a physician-assisted suicide, the movement has sort of lost its steam. Why do the Supreme Court Justices consider legalization dangerous? How did it win legislative approval in Oregon in the first place? What is the current trend in public opinion about this question? This essay will

The Nomination Of William Rehnquist To The Supreme Court And The Power Of A Supreme Court Chief Justice

1102 words - 4 pages Established in Article III of the United States constitution, The U.S. Supreme Court is the only federal branch that is comprised of non-elected members. Justices are appointed by the President with the advice and consent of Congress. The court adjudicates cases that arise through U.S. Constitutional issues (as opposed to state issues), U.S. laws and treaties, interstate cases and cases where a state itself or the U.S. is a party in the case

The Morphing of Child Pornography

766 words - 3 pages First Circuit found itself "firmly satisfied that it is well within Congress's power to regulate virtual pornography of minors of all ages."(United)   The Ninth Circuit recognized there is a compelling interest in banning child pornography but stated that the U.S. Supreme Court in Ferber "implicitly rejected the regulation of pornography that does not involve minors." Where the Ninth Circuit had hinged its ruling on the existence of an

The Fight Against Child Pornography

2341 words - 9 pages Communications Decency Act in 1996 introduced by Senator James Exon. Exon introduced this bill by showing images of hard-core pornography and child pornography, both of which are illegal. Civil Rights groups immediately created an uproar to stop this bill from being implemented. In ACLU v. Janet Reno, the ACLU made claims that the public would be harmed because their 1st Amendment rights were being broken. A Federal Court in Philadelphia ruled that

Similar Essays

John Marshall And The Supreme Court

843 words - 3 pages Chief Justice John Marshall made the Supreme Court what it is today with the help of the case of Marbury vs. Madison. He wrote the decision for "the most monumental case ever decided by any court in any country" (Glennon). Judicial review, and Chief Justice John Marshall, earned the Supreme Court the respect and prestige it carries today. Marshall had several qualities that gave him the power and respect to succeed in making a

The Supreme Court And Personal Civil Rights

1224 words - 5 pages I. "Our constitution is colorblind, and neither knows nor tolerates classes among citizens. In respect of civil rights, all citizens are equal before the law.” – Justice John Harlan, in his dissenting opinion in the case Plessy v. Ferguson. (History of Brown v. Board of Education) The US Supreme Court has evolved to promote new personal civil rights for African-Americans, ultimately creating a more racially equal society. II. The first way that

The Supreme Court And Civil Rights

1147 words - 5 pages . “Rights were eventually applied against actions of the state governments in a series of cases decide by the Supreme Court,” Dawood stated. In previous years (1790-1803), the Supreme Court had little say in decisions being made by government. As time went on the Supreme Court took on more responsibility and started making additional decisions, which in time helped minorities gain their civil rights. It took a couple of years, as a matter of fact

The Supreme Court Essay

1106 words - 4 pages various places. The place to find the Supreme Court now is in Washington DC, on First Street located in Northeast. The Supreme court was created during the Constitutional Convention of 1787 during which the delegates discussed the necessity of a Supreme Court. The two major reasons for the need of this type of court was going to be to settle the conflicts that may arise between states, and the fact that there would be a court that would have to