Children's Literature Discussion Essay

2661 words - 11 pages

Children's Literature Discussion

"The history that makes us wish fairy tales did happen, that life were
like a children's book and we all lived happily ever after, is not an
easy history to read or write. If we persist in thinking that children
need hope and happy endings then the stories we give them about the
Holocaust will be shaped by those expectations… For there are those
who would tell us yet another fairy tale, one in which the mass murder
of millions of people did not happen I know that it did, and I know
that we need to find ways to tell children."

(Kertzer, 1999, p.253)

Children's literature continues to inspire both children and adults,
and more recently while doing so, has prompted questions to emerge
concerning the appropriateness of particular content. When adults
begin to delve beyond the pastel coloured, cheery fairy-tales and
nursery rhymes into something deeper the realism they discover becomes
disquieting. Should children be permitted to read and immerse
themselves in illustrations of soldiers, concentration camps and
bombs? Should young people be dwelling upon and receptive to concepts
of war and violence through literature? The manner, which authors
explore and attempt to depict these sensitive and graphic issues such
as acts of violence and war, comes into question when a microscope is
placed over such contemporary and historical children's literature.
However, the answers seem to be unattainable or non-existent until the
stories are examined closely.

Analysis into junior fiction classified as 'Realism literature'
reveals an array of contradicting opinions and perspectives given by
academics, critics and the like. A critical perspective will be
gathered within this paper by examining and evaluating closely a
selection of writings, these include Roberto Innocenti and Christophe
Gallaz's "Rose Blanche", Gary Crew and Shaun Tan's "Memorial" and "My
Dog" by John Heffernan and Andrew Mclean. When analysing the
respective narratives a range of critical and enlightening issues will
be broached including the outcomes, values and perspectives which are
raised within the stories through concepts of hope, second chances,
misery or new beginnings. In addition to these queries the value of
these books for children, which integrate depictions of war and
violence within both illustrations and text, will be investigated.

Innocenti's "Rose Blanche" is written in a manner whereby the
protagonist's character develops into something which is admirable,
lovable and self-sacrificing, all of which seem to be often foreign
elements within the nature of many children in today's well fed
society. The violence that she experiences in her hometown blossoms a
wary curiosity and traces of foreboding trepidation, the impact upon
her life is displayed in a form one may find difficult to define as
positive or negative. Rose's approach to the war and acts of violence
which surrounds her environment...

Find Another Essay On Children's Literature Discussion

Lord of The Flies Essay

2191 words - 9 pages good and evil and how evil comes so close to overcoming good but cannot quite prevail. Works Cited Friedman, Lawrence S. "Grief, Grief, Grief: Lord of the Flies." William Golding. New York: Continuum, 1993. 19-32. Rpt. in Children's Literature Review. Ed. Allison Marion. Vol. 94. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Literature Resources from Gale. Web. 11 Jan. 2012. Golding, William. Lord of the Flies. New York: The Berkley Publishing Group, 1954. Gussin

It's Time to STOP Banning Books

1418 words - 6 pages these topics when discussed in class because we are taught that these topics are not appropriate to talk about publicly. There are many factors that play a major role in how an individual perceives certain topics in books. If taught at an earlier age that these topics are suitable for mature discussion, a child is less likely to find it funny or become offended. How a parent reacts to certain material is how a child is raised to react the same

Fantasy Is Reality

1468 words - 6 pages we are living in. Therefore, when we imagine we are going out of reality. Therefore, fantasy which encourages imagination is said to be a kind of escapism. Peter Hunt quoted Le Guin's in Children's Literature: Ten years ago, I went to the children's room of such-and-such city, and asked for The Hobbit; and the librarian told me, "Oh, we keep that only in the adult collection; we don't feel that escapism is good for children" Just

Love Relationships of Children of Divorce

2513 words - 10 pages divorce have focused on dealing with the reality of the situation, as well as the feelings produced by it. Goals have been identified for these groups (DeLucia-Waack, 2007). They are to: help children gain a clear picture of the divorce process through discussion, normalize common experiences and feelings, provide a safe place to talk about concerns, help label, understand, and express feelings about the divorce, develop new coping skills, assist

Nursing research

10154 words - 41 pages findings were consistent with other research suggesting the lack of involvement by parents in children's pain care. However with all that has been stated within the discussion section it all tended to lean toward the researchers original research question and supported there finding, but no-where in this section did they present an argument against there findings. They have however noted that there must be a lack of communication between parents

Nursing research

5107 words - 20 pages findings were consistent with other research suggesting the lack of involvement by parents in children's pain care. However with all that has been stated within the discussion section it all tended to lean toward the researchers original research question and supported there finding, but no-where in this section did they present an argument against there findings. They have however noted that there must be a lack of communication between parents

Medical Research and Dependent People

3305 words - 13 pages Medical Research and Dependent People How may children and other dependent individuals are subjects in research projects to which they cannot consent and from which they cannot benefit? This topic was much discussed in the United States about twenty-five years ago, but has recently reemerged in the discussion of the European Convention on bioethics and through current discussion in the medical literature of the kinds of consent and

Difference between Qualitative and Quantitative Research

610 words - 2 pages The first question asked by any researcher with a new topic to study is: 'What sort of research should I use?' Reference to the literature can be confusing: so much research has been done, so many questions asked and sometimes answered, and so many conclusions have been drawn that it can be difficult to sort out one research technique from another. The decision most beginners to research find taxing is: 'Should I use quantitative or qualitative

Censorship of Huckleberry Finn

1240 words - 5 pages opportunity for open discussion with parents about what age is appropriate to understand the sensitive subjects addressed in the novel. Twain himself never intended for Huckleberry Finn to be a children's story. The issues are too complex for young children and the history too extensive for an elementary, middle-school or possibly even a high-school age child to understand. If discussed openly and intelligently, perhaps we might be able to better

Censorship of Huckleberry Finn

1240 words - 5 pages opportunity for open discussion with parents about what age is appropriate to understand the sensitive subjects addressed in the novel. Twain himself never intended for Huckleberry Finn to be a children's story. The issues are too complex for young children and the history too extensive for an elementary, middle-school or possibly even a high-school age child to understand. If discussed openly and intelligently, perhaps we might be able to better

The Factors That Affect Mathematics In A Group Of Grade Five Students In A Rural School: Review of Literature

3899 words - 16 pages Socio-Economic Status of parents will affect their children's cognitive development in a number of ways. According to Maslow (1970) needs or motives exist in a hierarchy. Only when physiological needs, for example food and sleep, are satisfied, can growth needs, which are esteem and achievement, be met. This means that if children are functioning without adequate nutrition and rest, it is likely that they will be unable to perform at a required

Similar Essays

Children's Comprehension Of Television Messages Essay

9911 words - 40 pages Children's Comprehension of Television Messages The literature surveyed so far regarding children's attention to television has relied on observation of visual attention by the child viewers. Measures of visual attention alone do not provide an indication of what aspects of the message children are extracting from the television screen. In order to acquire indications of this, researchers have relied on post-viewing measures of

Childhood In Literature Discuss With Reference To Either One Object Type, Or A Group Of Objects That Constitute The Material Culture Of Children

2183 words - 9 pages their task of reducing the grown-ups' world to material that lends itself to the patient labour of reinterpretation.In the beginning there really was not a children's literature. Children's literature is a new phenomenon. The vast majority of literature throughout history has been oral. All the earliest myths, legends, fables and tales are now dumped into the category of children's literature. The earliest stories were attempts for people to come

Literature And Astronomy Essay

557 words - 2 pages young child when my mom, a children's librarian, filled our home with wonderful books, and my dad read them aloud to us at night. Listening to these classics was the cherished part of my day and it is to this early presence of family reading that I attribute my current love of literature. I am now taking "A.P. Great Books," an English course centered around the discussion and analysis of the greatest literature of all time. Exploring the writing

Digital Story Reading Essay

3102 words - 13 pages stories, phrases and individual words. There are some that provide word pronunciation and verbal definitions on some selected words. Here are some of the examples of electronic books:Table 1 Analysis of Results Literature Arguments Discussion Implications to the Research Argument 1 Vocabulary acquisition is a prerequisite to reading skills. Argument 2 Story reading is an effective way to enhance preschool children's vocabulary. Argument 3