Choices And Responsibility In London's To Build A Fire And Crane's The Open Boat

1642 words - 7 pages

Choices and Responsibility in London's To Build a Fire and Crane's The Open Boat

Naturalism portrays humans' control over their actions and fate as limited and determined by the natural world, including their very humanity. The freedom described by Jean-Paul Sartre results in all individuals having the ability to make present choices independently. Despite the fatalism illustrated in naturalism, the characters in London's 'To Build a Fire' and Crane's 'The Open Boat' are ultimately responsible for their choices and consequences of their choices.

In 'To Build a Fire,' the man's antagonist is nature: London displays the man's journey as restricted by external forces. First, the temperature of the tundra is seventy-five-below zero (978), which naturally exposes the man?s ?frailty as a creature of temperature? (977). Obviously the man is subject to the forces of winter, and can not change his homeostasis as a warm-blooded animal. Similarly, London employs the ?traps? (979) of snow-covered pools of water to show that while humans may presume we are invincible, nature will stealthily remind us of our vulnerability (through invisible germs, for example). Just as the man does not see the ?trap? (981) that soaks his legs, he fails to notice the dog?s apprehension regarding their journey (981). Here London shows man's self-proclaimed superiority is falsely assumed, as he lacks the ?instinct? (978) that the dog possess; later, the man can not kill the dog (985), which signifies the dog is not subordinate regarding survival. After the man steps in the water, London notes, ?He was angry, and cursed his luck aloud? (981). By attributing his misfortune to ?luck,? the man relieves himself of responsibility, recognizing himself as a victim of nature. Later, though, he thinks, ?Any man who [is] a man could travel alone? (982) in spite of the weather: this arrogance signifies that the man operates independent of nature.

Though London illustrates how nature is a difficult external force, the man is responsible for his misfortune, as his circumstances are the consequences of his choices. The narrator explains that the man was traveling ?to take a look at the possibilities of getting out logs in the spring? (978); more than likely, he did not have to perform this task, which required taking ?the roundabout way? (978). Also, despite being a ?newcomer to the land? (977), the man fails to bring a human companion to the ?unprotected tip of the planet? (982): just as the Earth is exposed to space here, as the narrator describes, the man has little defense against the cold. The man is not ignorant of the extreme cold, but rather, arrogant; though warned about the conditions (982), the man does not bring anything except a small lunch (978). Another sign of his lack of preparation is his failure to sufficiently protect himself from frostbite: he ?experienced a pang of regret that he had not devised a nose-strap...[that] passed across the cheeks, as well, and...

Find Another Essay On Choices and Responsibility in London's To Build a Fire and Crane's The Open Boat

No Accidents in Jack London's To Build a Fire

2768 words - 11 pages As the title implies, Jack London's 1908 short story contains within its narrative a literal set of sequential directions on how "To Build a Fire." London extends this sequential conceit to his fatidic vision of the universe. Unlike the dog in the story, who can rely on its pure-bred arctic instinct as it navigates through the dangerous tundra, the anonymous man possesses a duller, myopic instinct which is unable foresee the

The Theme of Jack London's "To build a fire"

572 words - 2 pages The significance of the words 'dying and death' in Jack London's 1910 novel, 'To Build a Fire' continuously expresses the man's dwindling warmth and bad luck in his journey along the Yukon trail to meet 'the boys' at camp. London associates dying with the man's diminishing ability to stay warm in the frigid Alaskan climate. The main characters predicament slowly worsens one level at a time finally resulting in death.The narrator informs the

Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat"

1096 words - 4 pages Stephen Crane: The Open BoatThere are many good short stories in this world, but how many of them can captivate the reader in such a short amount of time like that of Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat." As a reader of this story one may feel as if they too were on the boat with these men. Not just any writer could activate the reader in such a manner as this. Yet we will never know the true extent to how much more of an impact he would have made on

Stephen Crane's " The Open Boat"

1764 words - 7 pages Naturalism and Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" Naturalism is frequently cited as one of the dominant literary movements of 19th century America. Naturalism aimed at a detached, scientific objective portrayal of a natural self controlled by instincts and ruled by passion. Since a self was not perceived to have free will, naturalism debunked moral judgment. Historically, naturalism is perceived to have been more inclusive but also less selective

Stephen Crane's The Open Boat

776 words - 3 pages Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat"        “None of them knew the color of the sky.” This first sentence in Stephen Crane’s “The Open Boat” implies the overall relationship between the individual and nature. This sentence also implies the limitations of anyone’s perspective. The men in the boat concentrate so much on the danger they are in, that they are oblivious and unaware to everything else; in other words, maybe lacking experience. “The

Man and Nature in Stephen Crane's The Blue Hotel and The Open Boat

2883 words - 12 pages Man and Nature in The Blue Hotel and The Open Boat      Stephen Crane uses a massive, ominous stove, sprawled out in a tiny room and burning with "god-like violence," as a principal metaphor to communicate his interpretation of the world. Full of nearly restrained energy, the torrid stove is a symbol of the burning, potentially eruptive earth to which humans "cling" and of which they are a part. As a literary naturalist, Crane

Interpreting the Uninterpretable: Unreasoning Nature and Heroic Endurance in Crane's The Open Boat

1847 words - 7 pages , the theme and purpose of ''The Open Boat'' can be discerned. Despite the unsentimental realism of the story, Crane sought to portray his idea of the true meaning of heroism. His remark that such a story would be ''instructive for the young'' is particularly revealing because it links the purpose of ''The Open Boat'' with that of Crane's most famous novel, The Red Badge of Courage, in which a young man's romantic dreams about courage and heroism

The Importance of Setting in Jack London's To Build A Fire

1561 words - 6 pages The Importance of Setting in Jack London's To Build A Fire       In "To Build a Fire" by Jack London, the setting plays a significant role throughout the entire short story.  Jack London uses certain techniques to establish the atmosphere of the story.  By introducing his readers to the setting, prepares them for a tone that is depressed and  frightening.    Isolated by an environment of frigid weather and doom, the

Analysis of Jack London's "To Build a Fire"

823 words - 3 pages In Jack London's "To Build a Fire" we see a classic story of man against nature. In this story, however, nature wins. One reason that this is such a compelling and engrossing story is the vivid descriptions of the environment the nameless main character endures. Plot and characterization are brief, and the theme is simple. Yet this story is still a very popular story, and it has a mysterious quality that makes it great. Jack London starts

Critical Analysis Of Jack London's To Build A Fire

765 words - 3 pages . In the story "To Build a Fire" by Jack London, this is what happened. Because of the man's inability to see danger and his futile effort to cling on to life, London shows what happens when human nature deteriorates.The man's inability to see danger exemplified how unimaginative and shallow the man's thoughts actually are. Knowing that it is fifty degrees below zero or lower, the man still doesn't realize the danger and trouble he is in. He lacks

What are the themes found in Crane's Open Boat?

2413 words - 10 pages In "The Open Boat" Stephen Crane uses repeating themes of character experience, action and imagery to convey feelings of the overbearing vulnerability, and seeming futility, of the successful human race when placed in context and comparison to nature itself. Crane's depiction of four men in a dinghy that "many a man ought to have a bath-tub larger than" guides a reader through alternating themes of hopelessness and hope during a dilemma that

Similar Essays

Symbolism And Devices In Stephen Crane's The Open Boat

1990 words - 8 pages the story is presented at this point when a man is spotted on the shore signaling the boat and there is extensive dialog in the boat as to what the meaning of the signals are.  Crane relates this episode from the point of view of the boat’s occupants without description or exposition to point out the irony.  What was earlier optimism and hope in the first part of the story is now transitioned into the long night “on the sea in an  open boat

Comparing Destruction In Steinbeck's Flight And London's To Build A Fire

738 words - 3 pages Journey to Destruction in Steinbeck's Flight and London's To Build a Fire Not many people have to face death in the cold wasteland of the Arctic or rugged mountains of California, but Pepe and "the man" do. Although the ironic destruction of Pepe and the man were caused by relentless forces of nature, their attitudes and reasons for going on their journeys differed. The setting in both stories consisted of extreme climate and

Jack London's To Build A Fire

992 words - 4 pages Jack London's To Build a Fire Nature is always pushing man to his limits. When man heeds the warning signs that nature has to offer and those warnings of other men, he is most likely to conquer nature. When he ignores these warnings, nature is sure to defeat man. To build a fire is a prime example of this scenario. In the short story, “To Build a Fire” by Jack London, an inexperienced traveler in the Yukon travels alone with his dog, even

Indifference To Anxiety In Crane's The Open Boat

2619 words - 10 pages Indifference to Anxiety in Crane's The Open Boat    In recent years, critical response to Stephen Crane's The Open Boat has shifted dramatically, focusing less on the tale's philosophical agendas than on its epistemological implications. The story no longer stands as merely a naturalistic depiction of nature's monumental indifference or as simply an existential affirmation of fife's absurdity. Instead, we have slowly come to realize a new