This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Choosing Deafness For Your Child Essay

2396 words - 10 pages

Choosing Deafness for your Child
For a lesbian couple that is unable to have a child, with just to two of them, in vitro fertilization with use of a sperm donor is an option. When implanting the embryos “a vast majority of people believe that one ought to want a healthy and happy child” (Weijer, Anthony and Brennan. 2013. p.37). However, people have deferring views on what counts as healthy. The couple that I will have discussed in this paper are both deaf and they want only the embryo’s where there is a high chance of the child being deaf to be implanted (Weijer et al. 2013. p.55). Using pre-implantation genetic diagnosis the couple is able to do this (Weijer et al. 2013. p.37). Both arguments, for and against, will be discussed. Choosing for your child to be deaf is wrong.
Deafness as a Disability
A disability is defined as a physical or mental condition that affects a person’s senses or activities (Ontario Human Rights Commission). According to this definition deafness is considered a disability. Deafness causes the person to have the absence of sound. Without being able to hear the person could miss out on many activities. If unable to hear you are missing one of the five senses. Looking at the couple mentioned in the introductory paragraph, who will be referred to as Barb and Ginny from here on, they argued that their child needed to be deaf in order to function in the deaf community in which they live in. Choosing this for their child is limiting them to that community and depriving the child of enjoyments created by the sense of sound. Although deafness is not a matter of life or death, it does restrict a persons opportunities in life (Gannon. 2005. p.106). Jonathan Glover argued in Choosing Children (2006. p.23) that a person who is born deaf would never hear the sound of laughter; they will never hear a waterfall or a river. Not only does deafness deprive the of a person enjoyable sounds, it also takes away important sounds that they may need to help them survive. Glover (2006. p.23) wrote that they might not hear an approaching car. Along with not being able to hear an approaching car a person could argue that a deaf person will not hear the sirens of an emergency vehicle approaching, the personal safety of the deaf person and those around the person at risk.
Deafness is not a disability immediately noticeable in a person. This leads to problems. In 2013, in California, a deaf man was approached by police officers. The officers suspected him of theft, there was a miscommunication between the deaf man trying to indicate to officers that he was unable to hear and the officers who were unaware of what the man was doing (Martin. 2014). Due to the barrier between the officers and the man, and from the miscommunication, the officers used force on the man. Living in a community that is known to have multiple deaf people is good for a situation like this; police may go into the situation knowing what they are going to have to deal with....

Find Another Essay On Choosing Deafness for your Child

Describe and discuss the social and emotional consequences for a child of being identified as gifted. Refer to evidence in your answer. (12 marks - 5/7 split)

1194 words - 5 pages gifted children may well come across social and development problems unless their giftedness is dealt with appropriately. Selig '59 found that the incidence of emotional/social maladjustment in highly gifted children was five times the estimated incidence generally found in school children.There is some ambiguity as to what the actual IQ of a highly gifted child is said to be. For example, in Terman's research he classified highly gifted as scoring

Impact of Deafness on Children Essay

743 words - 3 pages their disability. The impact of deafness on a child can be somewhat disheartening and sad. The impact on its social development is that the interaction it has with people who are not deaf. The majority of social development deals with gestures (Marschark 92). Gestures deal with how a child can be social with other people, for example using hand signal gestures with the thumb and index fingers or body gestures to interact with them. Another

Designer Babies

1715 words - 7 pages immoral and going against nature, and people’s good intentions can lead to bad circumstances. Designer babies are infants whose certain traits are chosen through a variety of scientific methods. In the United States, this science has been used for preventing and getting rid of serious medical conditions, such as different cancers and fatal diseases. However, it has been illegal to use it for traits you simply want your child to have, such

Cochlear Implants

2512 words - 11 pages individuals in the United States of America, cochlear implants do ultimately work. But cochlear implants do not eliminate deafness 100%, which in my opinion is why so many people are not warming up to the idea as fast as others would like. ( When a parent is looking into getting a cochlear implant for their deaf or hard of hearing child, there is many different aspects

Communication for the Deaf: Oralism and Manaulism

2009 words - 8 pages children, at least 1 is considered to be deaf or heard of hearing (Honig, 177.) Deafness is a disability that is easily overlooked and misunderstood because it is not a disability that is easily observed. Helen Keller once said that, “Blindness cuts people off from things. Deafness cuts people off from people.” When a person is blind or need glasses society easily recognizes that in some cases special accommodations may need to be made for this person

Genetic Engineering

903 words - 4 pages detail. This will include making the child smarter, stronger and faster. Creating more advantaged children could leave the current ones at a major disadvantage. While the altered children excel in sport, education and other major areas, the unaltered ones are left in their dust. Just like the lion and the gazelle, the fittest subject will always triumph over the lesser one. While choosing how your child will turn out may seem to have its advantages

Hearing Loss

1814 words - 7 pages distraction, but that’s not the case. It never slowed any of us down one bit, and after a while you don’t even notice it. Another way can include the child in a public school, but only be contacting with hearing students during activities such as gym, recess, or lunchtime. Mainstreaming can also put a hearing impaired child in a special program for deaf children that separates them from the other students in a different parts of the school (Schools

Vestibulocochlear or VIII cranial nerve

1457 words - 6 pages for scars behind the ears. o Do an otoscopic examination of both ears. Look for wax or other obstruction in the external auditory meatus and perforation of the tympanic membrane. - Whisper test The Whisper Test is a screening test for hearing loss in older children and correlates with a hearing loss of 30 decibels. o Stand about two feet behind the child on one side so that they cannot read your lips. o Place your finger on the external


789 words - 3 pages ensure parents have the resources for effective parenting; they must also provide accessible and appropriate services critical to meeting the needs of hearing children and their deaf parents. We don’t believe they should be specialist in deafness to care for deaf patients, but they do need to be aware of the communication problems, possibly hiring someone who is fluent in ASL who can interpret information for the child or their parent. As a group

Designer Disability

954 words - 4 pages certain situations, deafness. S.D. and C.M. are a lesbian couple in the U.S. that have been deaf since birth and they want to have a child. However, they don’t feel like they would be good parents to a hearing child, so they were deliberately looking for a sperm donor that suffered from congenital deafness. These woman support having a deaf child, because they look at congenital deafness as a culture and not a disability. Pre-natal genetic diagnosis

Deaf Like Me by Thomas S. Spradley and James P. Spradley

2236 words - 9 pages Have you ever felt like there was nothing that you can do for your child? In this book, Deaf Like Me, by Thomas S. Spradley and James P. Spradley, I can see the journey that Lynn’s parents took to get her help. (Spradley & Spradley, 1978). This book was an excellent read. I really liked the way that they described the ways they tried to help Lynn to understand the world around her. The book, is a great asset for any family that might be

Similar Essays

Choosing Deafness For Your Child Through Ivf Is Wrong

2475 words - 10 pages Choosing Deafness for your Child In vitro fertilization can be a way for two people, whom are unable to have children together, to have a child. With in vitro fertilization pre implantation genetic diagnostic testing is done to determine which embryos are to be implanted. Weijer, Anthony and Brennan (2013) say on page 37 that many people want to implant only the healthiest embryos. Unhealthy embryos could be labeled as those with a disability

Choosing The Right E Commerce Platform For Your Online Store

1003 words - 5 pages Chapter 4: Choosing the right ecommerce platform for your online store. Choosing the right eCommerce platform for your online store isn't only vital to the appearance and message that you want to visually achieve, but it is also imperative to your sales. Think about your personal shopping experience. The first thing that you do when you click onto a website or take a step into a new store is take notice of the appearance of the brand, clothing

Choosing The Best Dog Breed For Your Family

1573 words - 6 pages joy than a chore is necessary when asking: How much is that puppy in the window? “The American Kennel Club recognizes 150 different breeds of dogs and that number can soar to more than 400 if you count mixed breeds” (Sarah McCurdy). So how does a family decide on just one particular dog when there are so many different breeds? Understandably, picking the right pet dog for a family can require some research. When choosing a family dog one

Creating A Healthy Environment For Your Prenatal Child

1296 words - 6 pages Creating a healthy environment is critical for any baby’s well-being and healthy transition into this world. Teratogens are a main concern when creating a healthy atmosphere. For example, when my mother was pregnant with my brother, she did not understand the adverse effects on her baby’s development that smoking would create. Smoking was just routine for her, and the labels on the cigarettes as a fair warning didn’t change her opinion on