Christopher Clombus Is Not A Hero

1972 words - 8 pages

Introduction

"In 1492 Columbus sailed the ocean blue." That's the one date everyone remembers, the date in virtually every school child's history textbook. But, they leave out pretty much everything about Columbus and his exploration of the New World. It's the part many people have yet to learn about. For years, Columbus has been presented to us as a hero. In 1934, President Roosevelt even gave Columbus his own holiday. To this day, we celebrate his "discovery" of America. What is found in history textbooks now, have seemed to show another side of Christopher Columbus, a side that they wouldn't dare teach in elementary school. It's the rest of Columbus' tale of "discovery". This paper will show you that Christopher Columbus didn't technically "discover" America and that his actions were much louder than the words we read about in school.
Third grade seems like such a long time ago, yet I remember the Christopher Columbus story like it was nothing. It started out with a boy named Christopher Columbus; he was born and raised in Genoa, Italy. He grew up wanting to be an explorer. He also grew up believing the earth was round, yet no one believed him, so the great explorer intended to prove it. He was going to find a westward route to India. To go on this exploration, he needed ships and men and the only one who was willing to provide him with this was Queen Isabella of Spain. She provided Columbus with three ships, the Nina, the Pinta, and the Santa Maria. He set sail in 1492 and after about two months they had reached land. Columbus believed he had reached India. He had no idea he had encountered another part of the world. He actually ended up in the West Indies, the island we today call Haiti. Because he thought he was in India, when he met the people that already lived there he named them Indians. They all got along very well. The Indians taught them how to grow food and use the land to survive. Columbus and his men would trade a lot with the Indians and they all lived happily ever after. That's pretty much where our textbook stopped. I have never learned anything else about Columbus until now. There is so much that my third grade teacher left out and didn't explain.
REASONS FOR HIM NOT BEEN A HERO
Columbus gets a lot of credit for "discovering" land that already had people living on it, a land that has already been encountered by other people way before Columbus was even born. In 70,000 to 12,000 B.C. Siberia explorers sailed to Alaska. In 10,000-600 B.C., Siberians also went to Canada and the state we now call New Mexico. A little more recently the Vikings in 1000-1350 came from Greenland and Iceland. They traveled to Labrado, Baffin Land, Newfoundland, Nova Scotia, Cape Cod and further south. Around 1311 and 1460 explorers from West Africa came across to Haiti, Panama, and Brazil (Loewen 48). These were only a few of the many encounters of the Americas. A result of these explorations was the...

Find Another Essay On Christopher Clombus Is Not A Hero

Chris McCandless is NOT a Hero

712 words - 3 pages Many people have read the story “Into the Wild” By Jon Krakauer, when mentioning the name Chris McCandless he is either viewed as hero or as a dumb man. The people who view him as a hero tend to believe that he was determined enough to want to do something. Others view him as an idiot who just wanted attention. Him being unprepared and not knowing much about how to survive in the wild made McCandless an idiot, the dumb jerk. Also causing him to

Was christopher Coloumbus a hero or villian?

555 words - 2 pages ended up causing harm to the Indians. "He selected an unhealthy and inconvenient site for the settlement of Hispaniola" ("Columbus-Hero or Villain" Felipe Fernandez-Armesto, 13). Not only did his unwillingness to others and his arrogance cause harm to the natives but also to the missionaries that worked with him. After he was removed from the colony in 1500 it was a missionaries opinion that "the colony would never be at peace if he were allowed

Is Brutus a hero or not - english 2 - persuasive essay

827 words - 4 pages purpose behind it, not a mindless slaughter. Brutus is not scheming to gain power by the death of Caesar as the other conspirators are, but instead he is aiming to help Rome. A hero, defined by his flaws and misjudgments, fits the noble Brutus. His mistakes lead to his downfall and death, as it goes with being the heroes. He succumbs to flattery, a deeply rooted flaw. However, throughout it all, Brutus remains good and noble. He wants only what is best for Rome, not what is best for himself and that’s why he is a hero.

Macbeth: Not A Hero

1185 words - 5 pages What makes a hero a hero? By definition, a hero display courage in adverse situations and who are willing to self-sacrifice in positions of weakness. Based on this definition, the character of Macbeth is not a hero but a man whose lust for power led to his own destruction and take opposition against Ian Johnston’s Introduction to Macbeth. I believe that the character of Macbeth in Shakespeare’s tragedy Macbeth is not a hero because he was

A Literary Analysis of How Dr. Frankenstein is a not a Hero

801 words - 4 pages , Frankenstein, Or the Modern Prometheus, Frankenstein would not be considered a hero. Initially, Victor Frankenstein wouldn’t be considered a hero because he went against the laws of life. As it is seen by most people, death and life should be the decision of God, and God only. People should not be given the choice of life and death. Therefore, Victor Frankenstein, in Mary Shelley’s story breaks the laws of life by creating a monster out of

Explain why Willy Loman is or is not a tragic hero

925 words - 4 pages Loman is not a tragic hero by Aristotelian standards because he "does not fall from a great height, nor does he come to any realization of his complicity in the event." Traditionally tragic heroes are men of high standing, princes, kings and generals, who fail and eventually die due to a fatal flaw, or hamartia. Aristotle would not have considered 'Death of a Salesman' a tragedy, because a tragedy must show a person who is worth serious

Antigone Tragic Hero Essay about "Antigone," by Sophocles. Discusses why Antigone is NOT a tragic hero and compares her to Oedipus, who IS a tragic hero

899 words - 4 pages Antigone Tragic Hero EssayAntigone is not a tragic hero for three main reasons: her fall was not from a position of greatness or nobility; she chose her actions with full awareness of the consequences; and her actions did not cause her to make a huge discovery about herself. Because of these factors, what happens to Antigone is not a tragic downfall, but more so the result of a deliberate course of action.Before Antigone was condemned to death

Is Christopher McCandless a True Transcentalist?

1919 words - 8 pages Poacher into Saint by Craig Medred, and Nature by Ralph Waldo Emerson. The primary focus of this essay is to provide an opinion on a strikingly debatable topic; Whether or not Christopher McCandless, hero of Krakauer’s Into the Wild, was a true transcendentalist. Despite the bold actions of Chris McCandless on his daring Alaskan odyssey, he turned out to be far from a true transcendentalist, failing to meet the definition of transcendentalism

What Is A Hero?

667 words - 3 pages out what a hero is not. Almost everyday someone on television talks about athletes and celebrities as being heroic. But are they. In my opinion they are not heroes at all. They are more like role models, having no heroic qualities whatever. They are not even good role so when Michael Jordan and Harrison Ford risk lives saving a mother and her children from a tornado then they will posses the qualities of being a hero. Also policemen and firemen

What Is A Hero

779 words - 3 pages act purely for the benefit of another without regard to our own safety. An act which could lead to disastrous or life changing consequences. A hero cantake on many forms. Many times a hero can be defined as a person who displays a large amount of qualities that I do not have, yet I do admire. One example could be my immediate family members. They save me each day from many things. However, the best definition of a hero I can muster is one who

Is Grant a Hero?

945 words - 4 pages If you watch modern movies you will find that these times it is quite easier to be a hero than it was fifty years ago. The world gives us multiple opportunities to proves ourselves and give us the self-satisfaction of being able to say you are a hero. But what is a hero? Grant says, “A hero is someone who does something for other people. He does something that other men don’t and can’t do. He is different from other men. He is above other men

Similar Essays

Odysseus Is Not A Hero Essay

768 words - 3 pages feel a hero is, he doesn¹t even come close. In the book, Odysseus does nothing out of the goodness of his heart. Even if Odysseus fought in the Trojan War, he is not a hero because he is self-centered and ignorant to other people¹s values and needs.There are multiple examples of Odysseus being self-centered, such as not taking people¹s advice. Odysseus was given advice from Circe that said not to try to fight Scylla even when she

Beowulf Is Not A Modern Day Hero

1023 words - 4 pages Beowulf is a character that possesses all the qualities of an Anglo-Saxon hero. He is strong, fearless, brave, courageous, and arrogant. But are these qualities enough to consider him a hero by the standards of today? A hero not only needs to be physically outstanding, but he also needs to have integrity, moral values and needs to act without thinking in his own benefit. Beowulf has many characteristics of a hero but he also has some defects

Chris Mc Candless Is Not A Hero

1472 words - 6 pages man, but his selfish and ultimately complacent attitude towards life and his successes led to his demise. To some, Chris is seen as a hero, a young man who succeeded in every challenge he took on. In Chris’ mind, he was his own greatest hero, “he was Alexander Supertramp, master of his own destiny” (23). In reality, McCandless was inexperienced and is not a hero nor does he deserve the wild praises he receives. Many people “live within unhappy

Odysseus Is Not A Hero English Essay

1139 words - 5 pages Odysseus: Hero or Not? Odysseus is well known for being a hero in Homer’s The Odyssey. Homer’s The Odyssey takes place in Greece, after the Trojan War has ended. It follows the adventure of Odysseus as he travels back to his home. Many people consider Odysseus a hero; he is not. Odysseus is not a hero because he made very foolish decisions, was self-centered, and did not have a good heart. Odysseus was not smart at making decisions. When