This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Cipa Mandated Filters On School Computers Essay

1537 words - 6 pages

It seems unlikely that there is a school librarian out there who has not encountered a problem with--or railed against--the presence of CIPA-mandated filters on school computers. My own career so far has allowed me to experience a full range of experiences with school computers, from a filterless library to an overfiltering situation so egregious that my journey to have it resolved culminated in suing the school district that employs me—Knox County, Tennessee. I just discovered, in fact, that a Google search for “internet filtering in schools” lists the ACLU litigation for which I was a plaintiff, Franks v. Metropolitan Board of Public Education, as its second hit.

This journey toward resolution was a long one that began many months before I thought it would ever be necessary to engage the services of civil rights attorneys. I first became aware of websites that seemed inappropriately blocked by our filtering system, Education Networks of America (ENA), in the course of helping students in the library of Fulton High School with persuasive essays on contemporary topics. This discovery was underscored by my additional role as the faculty sponsor of Fulton High’s Gay Straight Alliance (GSA), since the blocked sites that initially concerned me were those of the Human Rights Campaign ( and the Gay Lesbian Straight Education Network ( Of note is the fact that GLSEN is an organization that is fully endorsed by the National Education Association; their site has been listed in NEA Today magazine as a resource for promoting safe schools (citation needed?).

Since I couldn’t imagine that these sites, upon review, would continue to be blocked (yes, I know; the more stories of censorship I hear the more I realize how naïve I was back in August of 2007!), I submitted my unblock request to ENA via the form that is linked on the “Blocked Website” page result. I received a prompt email response back from ENA stating, “We cannot unblock the websites referenced…as the site categorization indicates it references/provides access to Sexuality/Alternative Lifestyles”.

In fact, I later discovered that the HRC and GLSEN websites did not at all meet the criteria for ENAs description of the “Sexuality/Alternative Lifestyles” category; what I found in reviewing that list of blocked categories was one called LGBT, defined as “Sites that provide information regarding, support, promote, or cater to one’s sexual orientation or gender identity including but not limited to lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender sites. This category does not include sites that are sexually gratuitous in nature which would typically fall under the Pornography category”.

The biggest challenge in trying to acquire a “fix” for this issue, even when it became clear that, as noted above, the censorship was deliberately focused on the LGBT category of information (not a “glitch” as it was called by the Superintendant and stated in the media once the ACLU...

Find Another Essay On CIPA-Mandated Filters on School Computers

Internet Censorship: How it effects education

1262 words - 5 pages age of seventeen. are legally exempt from the CIPA, meaning that Internet blocking does not have to effect them, although many institutions still use it because it keeps teaches on track with their job, as well as students. The EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) performed a study on the accessibility of information on school computers operating with two very popular brands of internet blocking software, N2H2's Bess, and Surfcontrol's

Children and the Media/Advertising Essay

817 words - 3 pages . These include measures to block or filter pictures that: (a) are obscene, (b) contain child pornography, or (c) when computers with Internet access are used by minors, are harmful to minors; 2) Schools subject to CIPA are required to adopt a policy to monitor online activities of minors; and 3) Schools and libraries subject to CIPA are required to adopt a policy addressing: (a) access by minors to inappropriate matter on the Internet and World Wide

Filtering Software is Unnecessary

1804 words - 7 pages enforce consequences for violations. Third is effective monitoring. Ensure that computer monitors are in a public view. In school libraries, do not let students work on computers unsupervised. Create websites with age appropriate links. With education, Acceptable Use Policies, and monitoring, filters are unnecessary. Works Cited American Library Association. (n.d.).Free access to libraries for minors: An interpretation of the library bill of

Filters Are Needed to Protect Children From the Internet

2056 words - 8 pages COPA has been declared unconstitutional by federal courts and has been appealed to the Supreme Court. Hence, the battle continues.  In December 2002, Congress passed the Children's Internet Protection Act (CIPA) which mandated that libraries or schools receive government subsidies to install filters. The American Civil Liberties Union and The American Library Association sued the government for this, because they thought

Recommendations for Internet Monitoring

753 words - 3 pages , Kindergarten-12th grade schools are required by law to add filters to blocks sites obscene and harmful to minors. This requirement comes from a federal law enacted by congress called the Children's Internet Protection Act (CIPA). This law is indeed important for the safety of children at school. However, it only requires that there is sufficient monitoring it does not specify what specific sites should be monitored. Therefore it is up to the

We Need Internet Censorship Now!

1178 words - 5 pages killed a 7-year-old neighbor), and hopes it won't take a tragedy like that for lawmakers to take action.   On the federal level, the Children's Internet Protection Act (CIPA) was signed into law on Dec. 21, 2000. It requires schools and libraries that accept federal funds to use filtering technology on computers with Internet connections. Institutions have until July 2002 to decide whether to install such measures. Those who don't will

Freedom of Expression on the Internet

3977 words - 16 pages to restrict access to material on the internet. The Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA) states, among other things, that schools and libraries that receive government funding for technology must have “Internet safety measures in place. These include measures to block or filter pictures that: (a) are obscene, (b) contain child pornography, or (c) when computers with Internet access are used by minors, are harmful to minors;”[vii] While

The Negative Effects of Censorship

3851 words - 15 pages Amendment shows relevance in the United States because of the Court’s siding with Tinker. In conclusion, the United States should not censor free speech and expression because doing such violates the First Amendment, and its violation has been upheld in various legal incidents, such as the Supreme Court’s ban on appealing CIPA, and their upholding of Tinker v. Des Moines School District as a legal precedent for many cases relative to freedom of speech

Censorship in Libraries and Schools

1071 words - 4 pages booth like places around the computers so that the screen can only be viewed form right in front. Some libraries just ask the people to stop looking at those certain sites, but we all know how well that works. Other libraries just install filters on the computers that are in the children's section and only in that section. Some of the other libraries get the parents written permission or require parental supervision to use the computers." These

The Internet and Education

2318 words - 9 pages percentage of teenagers on the Internet increased significantly in the US . Teen Internet Usage Use the internet or email All teens 94% Girls 95 Boys 93 Age 12–14 92 15–17 96 Primary school presence? Since the inception of online courses the sector has reported growth. Secondary and college level education have also experience increase enrollment. • High school age students have taken online courses

Why We Shouldn't Censor the Internet

1444 words - 6 pages themselves. Even if a school decides to take this verdict to heart, it is most likely to over adjust and unblock several unnecessary sites out of their fear of legal risk. No internet filter is perfect, and cannot possibly be perfectly calibrated to permit access to any such resources while filtering out others except on a tedious manual basis. The inefficiency of internet filters is surprising, because both parents, schools, and businesses shell out

Similar Essays

Web Filtering Essay

7172 words - 29 pages -filtering in schools Like libraries, schools are federally mandated to install web-filtering software on their Internet terminals by the Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA) to receive discounted funds for Internet access and internal connections. But unlike libraries, which have fought the CIPA in court, the CIPA still exists for publicly funded schools. Web-filtering in schools has found some controversy surrounding web-filtering in school

Internet Filtyers At Libaries Essay

889 words - 4 pages Filtering Of Public ComputersThe battle continues about whether public libraries should install filters on their computers in order to prevent children from accessing obscene or sexually explicit internet sites. According to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), libraries prevent people from reaching many other internet sites when they install filters. Therefore, they are violating the first amendment rights of persons who use the computers

Public Libraries Should Not Block Internet Pornography

2079 words - 8 pages precedent for the unconstitutionality of internet filters. Todd Anten’s article, “Please Disable the Entire Filter: Why Non-Removable Filters on Public Library Computers Violate the First Amendment gives an account of the ruling. The Loudoun County Library had instituted restrictions to internet access on all library computers with software that would block sites that “displayed obscene material, child pornography, and material deemed harmful to

Information Technology Act Paper

862 words - 3 pages filters in their computers. Before schools and libraries can receive government funding there is some requirement and policies that have to be addressed by the institutions.The policies and requirements are:Measures to restrict a minor's access to inappropriate or harmful materials on the InternetSecurity and safety of minors using chat rooms, email, instant messaging, or any other types of online communicationsUnauthorized disclosure of a