Circumcision Is Not Necessary Essay

2331 words - 9 pages

Circumcision is NOT Necessary


The baby, Phil, is less than a day old. His tiny head still slightly misshaped, his eyelids puffy, his mouth half-open in his sleep. The nurse has taken him from his mother and is carrying him to another room in the pediatric ward. The nurse clicks on a white metal lamp with a twist of her fingers, removes the child from a cozy blue blanket, and lays him in a cold molded plastic form that is bolted tightly to the counter. This form fitting shell is called a Circumstraint. There are indentations for the baby’s arms and legs. The nurse methodically binds the secure restraining straps around his limbs, bends the flexible metal light over him and steps back. The baby is naked and spread-eagle, and he begins to cry. For many boys, life begins with circumcision, a painful cut to the sensitive skin on his penis. Is it necessary?
Every 30 seconds a baby boy is circumcised. It is the most common surgery performed in America. It is usually done without anesthesia, and often without the consent of the parents.
“I never questioned it,” says Mr. Theodore, the father of a circumcised boy. “The doctor took him away, performed the operation and brought him back. That’s just the way it was done. I was circumcised; he was circumcised. I don’t even remember signing a consent form.”
That’s typical, according to Craig Shoemaker, M.D., a North Dakota pediatrician and member of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) task force on circumcision. “Many doctors do not adequately counsel parents regarding circumcision—what the risks are, what the potential benefits are, how much it costs. Performing a circumcision without such counseling is inappropriate. Some people would call it criminal assault.” Most parents don’t know what circumcision really is, and yet 65 percent of them still allow doctors to do the surgery.
America is the only country in the Western world that routinely circumcises newborn boys. Eighty-five percent of the world’s men are uncircumcised. “The practice violates all seven principles of the American Medical Association’s code of ethics,” charges George Denniston, M.D., a Seattle physician and founder of Doctors Opposing Circumcision. “By definition it’s not even surgery. Surgery is removal of diseased tissue, or a repair of some kind.” “Nonsense,” says Edgar Schoen, M.D., director of perinatal screening at Kaiser Permanente Medical Center in California, and an outspoken proponent of circumcision. “There are numerous medical reasons for it.” This pro and con argument has been raging in the medical community for almost three decades. Meanwhile, the circumcisions continue.
The doctor enters the room, scrubs his hands in the sink, and snaps on plastic gloves. The nurse passes him a package, and he opens it on the counter beside the child. Inside are several large, light blue cloth napkins; some squares of gauze; a squeeze-tube of Betadine (an antiseptic ointment); and an assortment of stainless-steel...

Find Another Essay On Circumcision is NOT Necessary

Male Circumcision: A Social and Medical Misconception

1583 words - 6 pages is historically based on religious and cultural doctrine and not of medical necessity. Possible complications of circumcision include hemorrhage, infection, surgical trauma, and pain. (Gelbaum, 1992) Unless absolute medical indications exist, why should male infants be exposed to these risks? In essence, our society has perpetuated an unnecessary surgical procedure that permanently alters a normal, healthy body part.This paper examines the

The Views of Female Circumcision Essay

1417 words - 6 pages their feet broken they would not be able to get married. To my knowledge this practice no longer occurs in the twenty-first century, but another practice similar to it does. This practice is called female circumcision and is widely known in the United States as female genital mutilation (FGM). Female circumcision is a practice that is conducted in Ethiopia and Africa; it can have extremely harmful side effects which have led to it being banned in the

The Issue of Female Circumcision from a Medical Anthropology Perspective

1106 words - 5 pages Circumcisions commonly occur in many countries on the continent of Africa (Toubia 1994, 712). Different variations to the different type of female circumcisions occur based on geographical regions. Countries in Africa are not the only ones performing these types of procedures. In Indonesia and Malaysia, a symbolic circumcision is performed on females. This procedure includes making a small cut on the clitoris with an instrument sharp enough to cause only

No Skin of My Nose

1577 words - 6 pages Should circumcision be standard practice when boys are born here in Australia? Up until the late seventies, circumcision was routine for new born Australian boys. Now the debate rages on as to whether there are specific medical benefits to circumcision. Dr. Vijay Roach, a Sydney obstetrician, says that most fathers in the last decade want their sons circumcised; however the mother is often opposed for fear of hurting her son. It is not

Critique of Female Circumcision.

804 words - 3 pages political asylum (Rachels 31). Fauzia's story, and the many resembling it, have been the center of discourse between cultural relativists and those who feel that female circumcision is inherently immoral aside from the individual values of the culture.From the perspective of a cultural relativist, it is not one's place to apply the standards or values of one culture in the context of another culture in order to judge what is right and wrong

Analysis of "Dialogue with Trypho" by Justin Martyr.

1190 words - 5 pages given to "mark you (Jews) off for the suffering". The first point is that "God what not have created Adam uncircumcised" if circumcision would be necessary for salvation, however God created us imperfect in order to be able to choose between right and wrong so that we would experience genuine love to God and would be able to act according to our will. In such way, circumcision can be just another step, payment or a way to show genuine love to God

Female Genital Mutilation

1678 words - 7 pages , Sexuality and the Psychology of Love, that the "elimination of clitoral sexuality is a necessary precondition for the development of femininity. In 1979, the "Love Surgery" was performed on women in the United Sates. Dr. James Burt, the "Love Surgeon", introduced "clitoral relocation" (sunna circumcision) to the medical field. He believed and acted upon the idea that excision does not prevent sexual pleasure, but enhances it. Dr. Burt practiced

Female Genital Mutilation: Long Term Psychological Effects

2009 words - 8 pages does not have here clitoris removed is considered a great danger and ultimately fatal to a man if her clitoris touches his penis. Also, the circumcision issue is seen as a form of beauty. It is seen as aesthetically beautiful, as genitals are disfiguring and ugly in their natural state (Real Net, 2). In short, nowadays the practice isn't done to explicitly mean that girls are untrustable, but because, presently, the woman's clitoris is

The Covenant of Circumcision

3508 words - 14 pages ." --Genesis 17:9-14 Within the Jewish community, the topic of bris milah, ritual circumcision, has never been more controversial. Many liberal Jews are now rethinking its function in Jewish life, some even choosing not to perform it on their sons. They argue that circumcision is no longer of value now that the spread of infection can be halted by good hygiene and modern

Female Circumcision

3156 words - 13 pages It's the year 423 BCE, and the orders have just been sent out -- Every female is to be circumcised. Rumor has it that the newest Pharaoh is not very well-endowed and wants the females in his land to be circumcised to enhance his sexual pleasure (qtd. in Gruenbaum 43). Although such an account seems amusing, female circumcision and its effects are real. It is thought that female circumcision has been around for at least twenty centuries

Warrior Marks

2648 words - 11 pages important elements to understanding the continuance of female circumcision are social and religious traditions, power/alienation relationships, and aesthetic tastes. Is this longstanding tradition necessary and if so are there ways to incorporate more conducive (sterile instruments, medically certified/experienced doctors, age limit, etc.) methods of performing the operation? However unnecessary an outsider may think the practice is, the

Similar Essays

Do You Agree That "Being Religious In Itself Is Not A Necessary Qualification For A Student Of Religion?"

781 words - 3 pages I agree that 'being religious in itself is not a necessary qualification for a student of religion.' From the examples that follow, we will see why it is not a necessary qualification. However, we will also consider the argument of those who disagree with the above statement. Being religious in itself is not a necessary qualification for a student of religion just as how many students pick up a foreign language in school, for

'economic Growth Is A Necessary But Not Sufficient Condition Of Economic Development"

894 words - 4 pages ). Economic development as defined by Todaro is "not purely an economic phenomenon but rather a multidimensional process involving reorganization and reorientation of entire economic and social system".Economic growth measures growth in monetary terms and looks at no other aspects of development. Economic development looks at increase in productivity while taking into account factors like economic, social and political issues. Very often economic

Economic Growth Is A Necessary Condition For Economic Growth But Not A Sufficient Condition For Economic Growth

502 words - 2 pages DATE ACTIVITIES BIBLE REFERENCES LITURGIST / BIBLE READERS SERMONIST 8TH SEP GHAFES WEEK WITH FRESHERS 15TH SEP Agbeli Prosper 22ND SEP FRESHER'S DAY Amos 8:4-7 1 Tim. 2:1-7 Luke 16:1-13 Freshers Rev. Maxwell Anrwi 29TH SEP SCC SERVICE 6TH OCT Launching of Prayer Conference / Communion Service Hab. 2:1-14 2 Tim. 1:1-14 Luke 17:5-10 Rebecca Baidoo Rev. Faustina Abugri 13TH OCT God is Merciful to

Khetan Essay

1618 words - 7 pages male circumcision as HIV prevention strategy based on scientific proofs (WHO2012). Recent researches support the ancient explanation of ancient Egyptian that said the foreskin results in bad odor and some diseases. Therefore, the author think that male circumcision is more to be medical tradition than to be spiritual because it has existed prehistoric era when it was not supported by religion. Later religions encouraged circumcision and