Citizenship By Birthright Essay

1018 words - 4 pages

Citizenship by Birthright
According to the Council on Foreign Relations, birthright citizenship “grants citizenship to everyone born in the United States regardless of their parents' status” (Rawlins, 2011). While this seems to be in-line with the fourteenth amendment which states “all persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside” (Congress, 1866), the true intention of this part of the constitution is hotly debated, particularly in light of the current economic downfall in the United States. With that said it may behoove constituents to look into the real costs versus benefits of birthright citizenship and what effect this is having on the country as a whole.
There are many political figures who believe the intention of the fourteenth amendment did not include granting automatic American citizenship to those born of illegal immigrants. One such advocate is Senator Lindsey Graham, a representative from the state of South Carolina. In summation, Mr. Graham believes the United States made “a mistake” in granting said citizenship and that the birthright practice only serves to encourage illegal immigration (Preston, 2010). This senator is one of many who believe illegal immigrants are not under jurisdiction of the United States, as outlined in the fourteenth amendment. Furthermore, he shares a belief immigrants cross United States borders with the intention of having children on American soil, in order to solidify their ability to reside illegally without going through the legal process of citizenship. For example, once an illegal immigrant has a child in the United States, the child becomes a citizen and, after that, it is very difficult for authorities to deport the parent(s) as their child has a right to be in the country and they are responsible for that child. To spearhead the resulting economic impact of supporting the non-taxpaying immigrants, Mr. Graham supports a new initiative to first grant legal citizenship to millions of people already residing in the United States illegally and then modify the amendment to reduce illegal immigration overall.
The Birthright Citizenship Act of 2011 (H.R.140), was introduced to congress on January 4th, 2011 by United States Representative Steve King of Iowa. In short, this bill strives to put an end to birthright citizenship for those born to undocumented immigrants, alleviating the related economic burden. However, the bill would still allow children born to at least one United States Citizen, legal resident, or member of the military to be declared citizenship, protecting children of those parents who have followed the law appropriately. American residents seem to be showing support for this bill, as documented in a telephone poll conducted by Rasmussen Reports (Waddington, 2011). The results of the survey showed that only 28% of Americans believe birthright citizenship...

Find Another Essay On Citizenship by Birthright

Chinese Immigrants in the United States

1839 words - 7 pages lawfully occupant outsiders and comparable bills have been introduced by several lawmakers in every Congress. The current Congress saw the presentation by Rep. Nathan Deal of the "Inheritance Citizenship Act of 2009," which so far has assembled about one hundred sponsors (Jeffrey, 2010). The United States Preeminent Court has held that the United States conceived youngsters of changeless occupant outsiders are secured by the Citizenship Clause. The

What Explains the Difference Between Germany’s and France’s Immigration Policies?

1778 words - 7 pages nation above all others and placing primary emphasis on promotion of its culture and interests as opposed to those of other nations or supranational groups.” Likewise, a nationality is an attribute that one has when they belong to a group of people who have a common (or believed) ancestry, tradition, and language. Citizenship, according to the Eurostat News Relsease is, “the legal bond between an individual and a state, acquired by birth

Illegal Immigration

1097 words - 4 pages The devastating amount of illegal immigrants is increasing daily. The numbers almost tripled by 2008 at an atrocious 11.9 million compared to the 3.5 million that were in the United States in 1990 (Izumi). Referring to these numbers by including the government incentives such as; birthright citizenship, Medicare, and the IRS whom is paying billions of dollars of tax refunds to the illegal non-citizens of America. They are getting costs of about

The Eloquent Rhetoric of Feminism

1253 words - 6 pages history reveals, citizenship did not ensure a definitive right to vote. In the late 18th and early 19th centuries voting was limited to property owning males who were presumably wealthy upper class citizens. American men and women alike have the birthright of independence and individuality. Additionally, women are tasked with the responsibility of managing the household. Stanton relates to the working woman by defining women’s duties and the effort

The Reforms of Cleisthenes

693 words - 3 pages In ancient Athenian society, citizenship and the exclusivity thereof was key to the function and operation of the radical democracy. Very few residents of Athens were actually full citizens; social status was divided into several groups in order to maintain the government. Both Athenian citizens and foreigners alike admired the Athenian democracy. As Thucydides recorded of Pericles' Funeral Oration, "Our government does not copy our neighbour

Political Liberalism

1110 words - 4 pages of man, the freedom to own property, and that status is not a birthright but an extension of talent. Property also represented a very strong idea in the minds of many liberals. Davies concludes, "nineteenth-century liberals also gave great weight to property, which they saw as the principal source of responsible judgement and solid citizenship." (A History of Europe, p.802) However, property soon became defined as a natural right. Davies

Illegals and the Bottom Line

4329 words - 17 pages . Why is it that those that break-and-enter into our country illegally, demand the privileges that many of us have worked extremely hard for all of our lives? What gives them the right to be a citizen over the person that has applied for citizenship and gone through the appropriate channels to gain citizenship? New York Times ran an editorial by Ross Douthat, which emphasizes this point when he writes “And many have spent years navigating our

Negotiations to End Apartheid

2363 words - 9 pages (Mountain, 2005). Although its title changed, the practices of slavery continued in South Africa until 1994. Documented negotiations to end slavery can be seen as early as the 1893 when Mohandas (Mohatma) Ghandi began his crusade against racism known as “Satyagraha.” Although considered “war without violence”, Ghandi’s 1908 campaign stirred the Indian nation to protest en-mass by burning their passes. These actions would have been considered as

America Must Stop Illegal Immigration

1250 words - 5 pages the country, the first hundred years of the nation were established with an open border (Hing). This would welcome foreign nationals displaced by the ravages of war or persecuted by totalitarian governments in hope of a better life. The fourteenth amendment, ratified in 1868, would establish the rights of citizens, or legally recognized subjects or nationals of a state or commonwealth, either native or naturalized (McClenaghan). Many illegal

Federal Immigration Control

2407 words - 10 pages illegals do not have to pay. Considering the current debt that the United States government is in, they should make it mandatory forJaime 2every illegal to pay federal taxes. By doing so, it would help the government financially, which might lower taxes for Americans, and it would be one less incentive for illegal immigrants. The government should stop giving birthright citizenship and welfare to the children of illegal aliens. With most people

Do we Aspire to Democracy, or is Democracy Something Achieved?

1825 words - 7 pages , property, and the pursuit of happiness” (Dahl, 59). It is human natural nature to desire equality and liberty. We are born free but, we have engendered a notion where we must have a leader for the stability of society. Leaders are placed into power by various ways, birthright as with monarchy, wealth as with aristocracy, and by citizens’ choice as in democracy. In aristocracy and monarchy equality and liberty is not expressed. Citizens are unable to

Similar Essays

Birthright Citizenship Essay

1004 words - 4 pages ancestors realize that one day illegal immigrants would use and abuse this amendment to the point that birthright citizenship in the United States must be stopped immediately. Illegal immigrants, or people that are thinking of becoming such, see this amendment as the only way out of their hard lives into the United States to live out their American Dream. Pregnant mothers cross through the scorching heat of the deserts in Texas, New Mexico

I Am An American Essay

1768 words - 7 pages main ideas and events to answer the same question—Should birthright citizenship be carried on into the future of the United States? In 1868, congress passed the Fourteenth Amendment that granted citizenship to all those who are born on U.S. soil. The Fourteenth Amendment was constructed to rectify the dispute that was caused by the Dred Scott case. Dred Scott vs. Sanford was a case where the U.S. Supreme Court said that African Americans that

American Citizenship And Immigration Essay

1592 words - 6 pages Today the Society is split into three separately minded groups. In no specific ordering, the first is determined to believe that any one person born in the United States is a citizen and which means their parents should become citizens along with them. These are the ones whom obtain “birthright citizenship” (Raul). The second are firm believers in the only ones that should be citizens are the ones who go through the proper process of becoming a

Immigrants Essay

1534 words - 6 pages applies to all children, even of illegal immigrants. The children are either taken with the parents or left alone. "Throughout this country's history, birth within the territorial limits of the U.S. confers United States citizenship" (Dellinger). Both ways they are affected and have to live by themselves. The children, according to the constitution, are citizens of the United States. The deportation of immigrants started after the 14th amendment