This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Civil Military Relations Essay

1773 words - 8 pages

Civil –Military Relations
Civil military relations can be understood as ‘two hands on the sword.’ The civilian hand determines the timing to draw out the sword from its sheath and the military hand carries out the civilian government’s order to put the sword in combat. Civil military partnership is shared between the civilian government and the military establishment in order to run the state affairs.
The paper examines the complexities of civil-military relationships from the past till to date. Further, it interprets the viewpoints of authors: Peter D. Feaver in his article, ‘Armed Forces & Society’ and Marybeth P. Ulrich’s article ‘The Runaway General’. Authors’ interpretations signify how far the US is fair in treatment of civil-military relations. In the end, the paper suggests ways to coordinate relations between armed forces and civilian government.
I agree to the interpretations of Marybeth Ulrich. She is vocal in civil-military relations. She supports a balance in civil military decisions, placing the civilian government on the driving seat. But I disagree with Feaver over the point of the agency theory. My perception is that there should be coordination between the civil and military relations. Both civilian executives and military personnel are needed for state’s safety and wellbeing of the people. Any deviation in decision making during the peace time and the war time is jeopardous to the state. I advocate that no one is superior or inferior. They are like strings on the lyre to work equally.
Peter D. Feaver proposes ambitiously a new theory that treats civil-military relations as a principal-agent relationship. Here, a principal is the government and agent is a military man, capable of carrying out the duty. According to him, the civilian executive monitors the actions of military forces of a nation state but military obedience is not automatic. It depends on strategic calculations of whether civilians will catch and punish the miscreant. Huntington speaks about balance between political influence and the military professionalism that can ensure national security. He says that such balance can only be achieved by objective civilian control of the military. It means civilian control over defense personnel in country’s defense affairs, deployment of forces, and use of armed forces, setting of military priorities and ordering them to go to war. Civilian control is a substantial element of an effective system of democratic control. Huntington provides an innovative way of making sense of the U.S. Cold War and post-Cold War experience, especially the distinctively stormy civil-military relations of the Clinton era. In the decade after the cold war ended, civilians and the military had a variety of disputes over whether and how to use military force. These episodes, as interpreted in agency theory by Feaver, contradict the conventional wisdom that civil-military relations matter only if there is risk of a coup. On the...

Find Another Essay On civil military relations

paper

1555 words - 7 pages changed throughout the war as military friends of soldiers who died tried to recreate the “good death” in war-torn field far away from home. One of the scariest things about the United States Civil War was that many male family members died while on duty far away. Being away from home was very uncommon, for even in 1910, less than 15 percent of Americans died while away from home. (Faust, 9). Because of this and the types of death, meanings and forms

"The Strategy of a warrior state: Rome and the wars against Carthage, 264-201 B.C."

2162 words - 9 pages ) coalitions, (4) strategic endurance, (5) civil-military relations (6) reassessment, and (7) naval strategy. The assessment will then focus as to how these elements of strategy were applied resulting in either success or failure. Although the elements of strategy are discussed separately they are interrelated and should be considered in a holistic sense. Our critical review will be initiated with an examination of "strategic assumptions

The Democratic System of Government is appropriate for Pakistan

904 words - 4 pages relations with America and much less importance was given to other countries. But America did not support Pakistan when India was blaming us for the Mumbai attacks. Everyone in Pakistan is blaming the current government for all these problems but no one is blaming the original culprit, the military dictator.Not only Pakistan, there are examples of many countries like Thailand, Indonesia and North Korea in which military dictatorship is said to be

Military Sexual Assault

1316 words - 5 pages about the controversy now that they know what the focus of the controversy focuses on. Apart of this issue is to look at how the military received the power to take cases in their own courts and not public courts. In the 1776 Articles of War it stated that rape or any capital crime was not taken to the commander but to civil courts. Congress passed the” Act for Enrolling and Calling Out the National Forces and Other Purposes” in 1863 that

Social, Economic and Political Factors Involved in the Spanish Civil War

981 words - 4 pages the opposition) drifting too far into communism. The National Front could not stand it any longer, so a military coup was hatched, lead by Franco to overthrough the government. This plan was set up so that two main forces, one coming from the north, and the other from the south would eventually converge and snuff out the Republic. The National Front eventually won the civil war, not only because it had financial and military

The small countries in the International Relations

680 words - 3 pages Untitled The small countries in the International Relations Northwith standing the quantity of small countries all over the world they are still less studied. In the theory of the International Relations the interest over the problems of small countries increases but slowly. There is no final answer to criteria of determination of the type of the small countries. A small country , first of all is weak in view of military and

The United States Army as a Profession of Arms

625 words - 3 pages ] to create expert knowledge and to police the application of that knowledge by individual professionals.”1 Not only do the American people trust the Army to come up with its own doctrine, they expect them to teach it to the future of the Army. Other occupations do not have this autonomy because they have not developed this trust. The trust has developed because the Army also adheres to cultural norms for civil-military relations. For example

Domestic Operations and Aid to Civil Power

2902 words - 12 pages Themselves. Accessed 28 Jan 2009. http://www.parl.gc.ca/information/library/idb/forsey/can_am_gov_01-e.asp7.Hackett, Sir John Winthrop. The Military in the Service of the State. War, Morality, and the Military Profession. United States of America by Westview Press, Inc. 1986.8.Lerhe, E. Civil Military Relations and Aid to the Civil Power in Canada: Implications for the War on Terror, 2004. Accessed 4 Feb 2009. http://www.cda.cdai.ca/symposia/2004/Lerhe

Don't Ask, Don't Tell

1451 words - 6 pages American Revolution and the Civil War, while no military code actually addressed homosexuals, anyone found committing homosexual acts was dishonorably discharged (Walke). With the turn of the century, the U.S. military actively began prohibiting and prosecuting homosexual acts (Walke). Throughout the 20th century, individuals seeking to serve in the military were prohibited from serving if they had a history of homosexual activity. With his election in

Sara Military Intervention March 2014

1780 words - 8 pages transition of power from Mubarak and Ben Ali progressed rapidly because of the positive role the military in each country played and their refusal to silence protesters on behalf of the regime. Unlike Egypt, where the military leadership was gifted with profitable business ventures and promising opportunities, the military in Tunisia didn’t have a solid foundation for relations with Ben Ali’s regime. The armed forces in Tunisia were popular among

Feasibility of Intervention in Syria

965 words - 4 pages the Assad regime, military involvement by the US can sever relationships between them. The United States also already has history and poor relations with Iran, and with Iran’s effective air defense team and weapons of mass destruction, intervening in Syria could make the US, or any country that gets involved, a target (Miller). Causing conflicts with Syria would also sever ties between the US and China, and this will have a significant impact on

Similar Essays

The Transformation Of Civil Military Relations In Turkey

1657 words - 7 pages Thorny Road of Change The Transformation of Civil–Military Relations in Turkey Ronald Iane 1030700057 Subject: Political Cultures and Economies in Transition Instructor: Dr Edoardo Monaco Submitted on: 20 May 2014 Introduction Before Abdul Fattah al-Sisi’s sudden rise to fame, the renowned example of civilian-military relations anomaly in the Middle East is Turkey: elected officials run routine government business under the watch of a

The Posse Comitatus Act Of 1878

899 words - 4 pages order and discipline in their jurisdiction. The act is very small and allows the military to assist civilian authorities if the need is needed and wanted. I believe that the Posse Comitatus Act serves a valuable purpose in American Law, but changes could be made in the future to provide a more up to date standard, especially in the realm of terrorism. Works Cited 1. "Posse Comitatus Act." Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia, 6Th Edition (2013): 1. Military & Government Collection. Web. 7 Dec. 2013. 2. "Aid Of Civil Authorities and Public Relations." 32 CFR 501.1. 2002.

Germany’s Involvement In The Spanish Civil War

1215 words - 5 pages and Franco were fascist leaders. Their shared ideologies led to Hitler’s support of Franco. Like George Orwell said, “For some reason, all the best matadors were Fascists” (Homage to Catalonia). The Spanish Civil War was a trial of sorts for many German weapons, as well as its military strategies. By aiding Spanish Nationalists, the Germans not only developed advantageous international relations with Spain, but came out more prepared to fight in

Occupation And Civil War In The Contemporary World International Realtions Adn Global History Essay

1361 words - 6 pages and Civil War ! 2 and ideas are the basis of the administration since the ideologies govern the country. While some argue that civil wars are permanent and the same other scholars suggest that they are different. For any civil war to take place, there is a need for objective and the trinity. There must be a political objective, capable military and a supportive population for the civil wars to occur. Since civil wars have been there for a long