Civil Procedure Law Reform Essay

3488 words - 14 pages

Electronic copy available at: American Bar Association winter/spring 201111
Mediation and Civil Justice Reform in Hong Kong By Kun Fan
Kun Fan is an assistant professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong and a member of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators. She can be reached at kunfan@ and thanks Cynthia Lee for her help in conducting research.
In response to social change and technological advances in Hong Kong that resulted in a sharp increase in civil litigation, the Civil Justice Reform (CJR) was implemented in April 2009. It was closely modeled on the Woolf Reforms in England, and according to Seagroatt J., a court of appeal judge, "the problems which gave the impetus to the Woolf proposals also exist [in Hong Kong]: delay, unwieldy procedure, excessive use of resources to advance or rebut a claim, and an unacceptable level of cost." Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Gov- ernment, Civil Justice Reform: Interim Report and Consultative Paper, Nov. 21, 2001, at 15. In addition, Hong Kong's legal system had suffered pres- sures caused by complexity and unrep- resented litigants (Interim Report, at 15-16).
The final report of the Chief Justice's Working Party on CJR was published on March 3, 2004, after a seven-month consultation period; it contains 150 recommendations. In particular, the Working Party identifies the underlying objectives of the civil justice system, one of which is facilitating settlement. Mediation is recognized in particular as giving effect to this underlying objec- tive. In response to the final report, the judiciary promulgated a Practice Direc- tion on Mediation (PD 31), which became effective on January 1, 2010. It seeks to provide a framework within which the court can discharge its duty to facilitate the use of mediation when exercising its case-management pow- ers and for the parties to make use of mediation in appropriate cases for the
settlement of their disputes. To what extent may the CJR and PD
31 change the practice of the courts in the administration of civil justice, and eventually affect the overall litigation culture in Hong Kong?
Can the Court Order Unwilling Parties to Mediate? It's generally accepted that the court, in the absence of a specific statutory provi- sion, does not have jurisdiction to order a reluctant party to submit its dispute to mediation. In other words, there is no power to order mediation under common law or as part of the court's inherent jurisdiction. Gary Meggitt and Farzana Aslam, "Civil Justice Reform in Hong Kong: A Critical Appraisal," 28 C.J.Q 1 (2009), at 112.
In the United Kingdom, while the courts have a duty under the overrid- ing objective to encourage alternative dispute resolution (ADR) where ap- propriate, it is not, as yet, compulsory. The court of appeal has held that the court has no power to order the parties to mediate, but simply to encourage it. In Halsey v. Milton Keynes General NHS Trust, Dyson J. stated...

Find Another Essay On Civil procedure law reform

Security Sector Reforms Essay

1255 words - 5 pages security.”(Ward) The procedure of this is quite simple, yet effective. In order to do this, a developed country would send people to start police, or some kind of law-enforcers, a democratic system, and democratic leaders. They would also need to send some of their own law-enforcers to keep an other dictators from rising during this process. While the troops were protecting the citizens, the, ‘instructors’ could teach the police and democratic

Security Sector Reforms Essay

1105 words - 5 pages In the world, there are many third world countries that have or have had a dictator that needs to be or has been overthrown. Libya was one of those third world countries. Their dictator, Muammar Gaddafi, was killed. When a dictator is overthrown, the security sector usually falls with them. There are many ways to reform the security sector in a country, the best of which, would be through instruction. The procedure of this is quite simple, yet

Criminal Justice Comparative Different Countries

2523 words - 10 pages , T.B., Law Reform in a Mixed ‘Civil Law’ and ‘Common Law’ Jurisdiction, 35 TUL. LA. REV. 927 (1975).The District Courts Association Website, Scottish Courts Website,

Contempt of Court in Canada

2368 words - 9 pages offence of contempt of court and narrow the scope of this paper. The second part will set out and explain the arguments in favour of, and against, codifying the law. Finally, the last part of the paper will set forth some proposals for reform. The Openness Principle Even before freedom of expression was enshrined in our constitution, the judiciary noted that the basic principle governing judicial proceedings in Canada was their openness

Discuss the extent to which International assistance can and should be effectively used to achieve security sector reform as part of post-conflict peace-building.

3491 words - 14 pages IntroductionDuring conflicts, military forces are habituated in committing egregious human rights violations, likewise are the ruthless paramilitary bodies that fall outside the chain of command. Also, the judicial system and the principle of rule of law are either routinely sidestepped, or abused along ethno-political contours. In short, the entire system of government is skewed towards the rationale of war. Hence, the need to reform these

Tort Reform

1377 words - 6 pages is illegal, but is not criminal." (Lane, 2003) An example of a tort is an auto accident. Tort reform isn't one single idea or law. Instead, it's a group of ideas and laws designed to change the way our civil justice systems works. While each tort reform law is different, they all are designed to either limit the circumstance under which injured people may sue, limit how much money juries may award to injured people, or both. (Lane, What is Tort

Legal Review

1396 words - 6 pages Greek law is the distinction between private and public law (Tassopoulos, n.d.). All the applicable Greek laws are codified in different codes. The only exemption is the administrative law (WUni, n.d.). According to Tassopoulos (n.d.) the most essential codifications of the Greek law is the civil code, code of civil procedure, code of the law trimune, code of criminal procedure and penal code. Since the Greek (Hellenic) legal system belongs to

legal syllabus

7408 words - 30 pages government or court can claim cyberspace as its exclusive jurisdiction. Its global nature poses particular challenges for the law.Assess the role of law reform in addressing emerging technological issues and enforcing rightsCriminal and civil wrongs in cyberspace can sometimes be classified familiar categories, but may also take on new characteristics.Hacking- unauthorised access to data held in a computer or computer system, changing data

Criminal Conspiracy in Historical Common Law

1371 words - 5 pages Criminal Conspiracy in Historical Common Law The law of conspiracy is considerably more complex and uncertain than it need be because the statutory reform of the area largely contained in Part I of the criminal law Act 1977 was only partial. As a result, there are now two types of conspiracy – statutory conspiracies governed by the 1977 Act, and an important but limited range of common law conspiracies, which were expressly retained by the act

Central Athenian Historical Overview

1004 words - 4 pages years ostracism fulfilled its function of aborting serious civil unrest or even civil war. At the end of the fifth century it was replaced by a legal procedure administered by the jurors of the people's courts. Power to the people, all the people, especially the poor majority, remained the guiding principle of Athenian democracy.

The Legal History of China

2368 words - 9 pages absolute criminal law, civil law, procedure law and substantial law. Detached the criminal law and civil law, detached the procedure law and substantial law, \and began to adopt some system such as trial at Bar, defend, etc,. 2\Nanjin kuomindang government replanted the legal system in Japan, including constitution, the statutes of different legal departments, courts, procuratorate, IV socialism society from 1949 till

Similar Essays

Tort Reform Essay

1095 words - 4 pages advantage of the businesses. The American Tort Reform Association, also known as the ATRA, founded in 1986, is a “bipartisan coalition of more than 300 businesses, corporations, municipalities, associations, and professional firms (American Tort Reform Association )” such as Exxon and General Electric that work together to "bring greater fairness, predictability and efficiency to the civil justice system through public education and legislative reform

The Role And Effectiveness Of The Law Commission

1032 words - 4 pages of reforms caused a great deal of concern. This led to the introduction of the Jellicoe Procedure which was meant to speed up the number of reforms that made it into the law. It has been successful in introducing some reform however it is still limited. Criminal law has also created a big unresolved problem because it cant use fast track procedures as it is too controversial. The current role of the law commission as

Comparing Civil Disobedience By Henry David Thoreau And Martin Luther King's Letter From Birmingham Jail

727 words - 3 pages reform the government and the means of accomplishing it. In King's Letter from Birmingham Jail and Thoreau's Civil Disobedience, both agreed on injustice of majority to rule over minority, both resisted the government passively, and both wanted a better government immediately.The majority is not necessarily right, but they have always been the ones in power because they are the strongest and the most influential. Therefore, all the laws are

Health Care Reform Essay

1207 words - 5 pages The Health Care Reform Bill was surrounded by an extensive array of factors and had many relevant elements which either supported or opposed the bill. This paper focuses on examining what the decision making procedure and particular issues linked with this specific process might have been in the developmental procedure and passing of the Health Care Reform Bill. The decision making aspects involved with the developmental and passing procedure of