This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Civilization Or Barbarism: Which Is More Acceptable?

937 words - 4 pages

In Walter Benjamin’s “Thesis on the Philosophy of history”, he argued that civilization could not exist without barbarism. Civilization is the stage of human social development and organization that is considered most advanced. Barbarism is the absence of culture and civilization. Walter Benjamin feels that barbarism was not on document at the first stages of civilization. In many societies, there were always examples of barbarism and civilization. There is no actual evidence of civilization because many civilization documents contain barbaric rules, laws, and regulations. Therefore, in many civilizations they believed that they were civil but in actual reality, they depicted some actions of barbarism. Some examples of “civilizations” and documents that contained barbarism consisted of the Qin Dynasty, the pyramids of Egypt, the Hittite law code, the Huns, Rome, and the Greeks.
In the Qin dynasty, they were very structured and had many rules. In some ways, their civilization was barbaric. In the Qin Dynasty, they had something called legalism. In legalism, it required restraint and discipline. The people involved were evil. They were forced to obey Qin Shi Huang.They had an army called the terracotta army. When Qin Shi Huang died, he killed some soldiers to go with him in the afterlife and he forced artisans to make life size models of the soldiers. This showed that in this society, they called themselves a civilization but their actions were barbaric because they had a strong hold on their people and their society was not equal. They had slaves working hard and some died while performing labor on the Great Wall of China. In history books, they only give credit to those who were noble at the time but not the actual builders of the wall.
Secondly, millions of slaves built the pyramids of Egypt. Many consider the Egyptian “civilization” barbaric. In Egypt, many workers died during the building of the pyramids. They were forced to work endlessly to build these pyramids. Many of the pyramids were named after the famous people and the kings. In the Egyptian civilization to present day, they have over 138 pyramids. They had to carry tons and tons of brick to build these pyramids. The slaves who built these pyramids did not get credit. The pharaoh had a lot of power so he was able to set rules and force people to work until they finished the pyramids.
The document that many think to be barbaric is the Hittite law code. The Hittite law code was a document full of laws and punishments. For example, one of the laws says, “If anyone oppose the judgment of the king, his household shall become a ruin. If anyone oppose the judgment of a lord, his head shall be cut off”. Their society was very harsh. In a way, you could call it...

Find Another Essay On Civilization or Barbarism: Which is more acceptable?

A trust is a relationship formed at the direction of someone, in which one or more persons hold - University - Essay

1716 words - 7 pages Equity and Trusts A trust is a relationship formed at the direction of someone, in which one or more persons hold the individuals’ property subject to certain obligations to use and guard it for the advantage of others. There are two common types of trusts; express and implied. Express trusts are usually created by a person orally or in the form of a written statement and involve all the parties concerned; whereas implied trusts are created by

Determinism or Freewill? Which is in Control?

656 words - 3 pages In the question of which is in contol, freewill or determinism, determinism is the controlling factor. Determinism is that which determines the cycle of life as a whole. It is the web that is spun at the beginning of human existance; it never changes because it is the devine design. If determinism is life's ultimate design or plan did freewill ever exist? If so, when and where did it exist? The answer is that freewill does exist but it

Soccer is More Than Life or Death

870 words - 4 pages and Torneo Postobon also with eighteen teams. Within these two categories, there are rivalries between teams that have reached such extraordinary heights that it affects the way the thirty-three Colombian departments see each other, in particular, Antioquia and Cundinamarca, more specifically, Medellin and Bogota. The rivalry between these two cities is so potent that when their soccer teams play against each other, fans are killed after the game

IS EDUCATION MORE EXPENSIVE OR IGNORANCE?

1520 words - 7 pages this system, the government can earn higher interest, and gather more money from each debtor. It also lesser the burden for students, and simultaneously benevolent to the student and beneficial. Another example would be, in the UK, there is a limit set on the tuition fees in all the universities, that they cannot exceed by any means. By this system, universities are not to allowed to gain any unwanted or unnecessary fees from students. Concluding

Cultural Relativism vs. Ethnocentism - which is more objective?

1023 words - 4 pages different cultures. A cultural relativist maintains the post-modernist view that there is no moral or cultural high-ground with which to judge one culture in relation to another, thus each culture must be understood from its own perspective, and within its own context. Some practices may appear bizarre when observed cross-culturally, however, in their own cultural context, they seem quite natural. A relativist approach has its limits, and these

Wood Vs. Steel Which Is More Environmentally Friendly?

616 words - 3 pages For over many years mankind has tried to make are world more eco-friendly efficient. People have discussed many different examples like gas vs. electricity, paper vs. plastic, or even wood vs. steel. All these objects have something in common and that is that they all benefit society in some kind of way. People have done research about one of the examples more specifically, wood vs. steel and found pros and cons for both. Steel is more

Craft Unions Compared to Industrial Unions: Which is more effective?

1888 words - 8 pages With the advent of an industrialized working class in the mid nineteenth century, and more complicated and permanent forms of labour relations, workers formed networks to turn their shared experiences, problems, and interests into a collective political and economic force for change. These organizations came to be known as labour unions (Godard 86). Although "unions" are often spoken of as single entities, in reality, no one union is responsible

Business Ethics: Do you think it is morally acceptable an employer to read his or her employee's e-mail?

790 words - 3 pages the only potentially criminal substance that can loiter on commercial servers. Offensive matter, such as porn and sexist or racist messages, can exist on a staffs' computer long after the porn has been viewed or the messages sent. If this content is accidentally, or not, dispersed among many employees, there is a risk that one or more of the addressee's will be personally insulted. As employers are under a responsibility to present a safe and sound

Which should educational systems emphasize more,capacity or emotions?

634 words - 3 pages he or she thinks matters a great deal more than it probably does in reality. Too much emotional self-exploration could create individuals who see their emotions as more important than what they contribute to society, which would damage that society as a whole.A certain amount of self-introspection into one's emotions is probably helpful to the development of a student as an overall person. Usually this kind of activity is explored fully in basic

Civil War In England. Which Were More Important, Short-term Or Long-term Causes?

1033 words - 4 pages What led to Civil war in England. Which were more important, short-term or long-term causes? From the beginning of Charles's rule in 1625, long-term factors such as his Arminian beliefs, disputed ways of raising of finances and methods of enforcing laws created huge resentment which led to the civil war in England. Short-term factors like the Bishops wars, the Long Parliament, rebellion in Ireland, the Grand Remonstrance and the attempts by

Qualitative Research or Quantitative Research - Which is better and why?

1838 words - 7 pages deviation is so small, thus the observations are spread out over a very small sample which would not accurately represent the entire ethnic group. There is such a small valid percent that subjects would need to be targeted as they are unlikely to be caught during random sampling.2.Providing either hypothetical and/or published examples, how accurate is it to label content analysis as a quantitative method?It is quite accurate to label content

Similar Essays

Facundo Or Civilization And Barbarism By Domingo R. Sarmiento

954 words - 4 pages Facundo or Civilization and Barbarism by Domingo R. Sarmiento "Facundo or, Civilization and Barbarism," by Domingo F. Sarmiento is a book which talks about the many topics of government and political situations in which Argentina was involved. Mary Mann is the translator of the book and the introduction is by Ilan Stavans. The time period the story takes place in is the nineteenth century, but the book was written in 1845. The

The Journey Or The Transformation: Which Is More Important?

1979 words - 8 pages transformation is more about the transformation, or the journey itself. Although the transformation is the end result on who we are to be, the path that leads us there, the journey we humans take on is the most influential aspect of the journey of transformation, as seen through the ideas of action, devotion, and knowledge taken out from excerpts of the Bhagavad Gita. The Bhagavad Gita is the song of the god Krishna, created in order to spread

Which Is More Effective At Bringing About Political Change, Political Parties Or Social Movements?

1621 words - 7 pages The purpose of this essay will be to determine whether New social movements or New politics parties are more effective with bringing about change with a focus on green politics. I will look at the structures of a political system that enables Green political parties to gain representation. Often Green political parties start from grassroots social movements, which can make it difficult to separate the influence that they have on policy change

Is Prayer In School Legal Or Morally Acceptable? Students, Parents

889 words - 4 pages Is prayer in school legal or morally acceptable? Students, parents and school officials have debated the issue of school prayer for several years. Since the case of Engel v. Vitale, in which Steven Engel of New York led a class action suit that went all the way to the supreme court and eventually ended in the banning of prayer in schools (pray 1). Everyone has the right to freedom of speech and self-expression, therefore everyone has the right