This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Classroom Mixtures For The Gifted Homogeneous Or Heterogeneous? Article Review

1130 words - 5 pages

Classroom Mixtures for the Gifted- Homogeneous or Heterogeneous?

John H. Holloway in his article, “Grouping Gifted Students”, looks at research to the question of whether or not gifted students can receive effective instruction in the regular classroom. He wants to know if researchers agree with Lisa Benson, a classroom teacher, who says no. Her reasoning is the gifted students become frustrated especially if they have a high degree of creativity and resources are not available in the regular classroom.
Holloway first looks at the question from the homogeneous versus heterogeneous grouping perspective. From this perspective two researchers, Renuzulli and Mesler, found that the regular (heterogeneous) classroom could serve the gifted students. Renuzulli suggested that teachers would need special training or access to specialists. The four other researches cited found homogenous grouping was better for gifted students. Burns and Mason found this was true because “the higher ability classes received better instruction or had higher ability teachers and benefited from high-ability classmates” (p.89). In another research, Rogers concluded that gifted students need some form of ability grouping to broaden and extend their curriculum. Shields found that homogeneous grouping had a positive effect on the attitudes of the gifted and how they felt about themselves as learners and the school experience. The study by Gentry, Rizza, and Owen expressed concern that there was little differentiation for the gifted students in the heterogeneous classroom.
The research of mixed-ability group options was next looked at by Holloway. Tomlinson’s research says the gifted can receive effective instruction in a differentiated classroom. However, she also sites modifications to be made for the gifted learner such as “more advanced reading or research material, calling on them think at a deeper level of complexity, and asking them to use more advanced skills.” (p. 90) Even after these modifications her research suggested that schools would still need to provide a variety of services and learning options. Lloyd suggested the grouping in a multi-age classroom had positive effects on the gifted students because teachers were more likely to look at the student as an individual
Holloway then cites at an interview of Sternberg in which Sternberg says there are other things to consider in the education of the gifted. First look at the various types of gifts students may have. Second, giftedness should be looked at as a process instead of a state. Third, look past the backgrounds of students.
Holloway ends with a summarization that both homogeneous and mixed ability classrooms can work. It is up to each school to decide what is best for the gifted students in their student body.
While reading this article I, too, was curious on whether researchers agreed with Lisa Benson. My first question was, however, what was the author’s definition of a regular classroom? In...

Find Another Essay On Classroom Mixtures for the Gifted- Homogeneous or Heterogeneous?- Article Review

Write an article arguing for or against the use of mobile phones and technology in schools

815 words - 3 pages can contact their children, if they are in danger. Parents give the their children a wide range telephone number because if they saw and hear any think strange they can telephone their relatives or people they know very well. It means that children have got emergency telephone Numbers, especially their parents Numbers also. So mobile phones is not just a phone but children can put their schedules, due dates for assignments in the mobile phones

Article Review on Inside the Wrong Body

1369 words - 6 pages Article Review on “Inside the Wrong Body” Ada Thao Holly Tracy-Chandler Psychology 101-009 April 24, 2014 Introduction In the article, “Inside the Wrong Body” by Carrie Arnold the main topic of study is about interoceptionability in humans. According to Carrie, interoceptionsimply is the knowledge of one’s internal bodily functions (Arnold, 2012). In other words, it is an explanation of an individual’s ability to be able to

Comparative Article Review: The Great Depression

1654 words - 7 pages column format with no breaks in between, and Open up his article by how the Communist Party of Canada (CPC) formed the National Unemployed Workers’ Association (NUWA), and how they fought for unemployment insurance or compensation, and how the police tried to repress the NUWA. The NUWA had economic demands for cash relief, free electricity, free gas, free water, and were against evictions. To spread their message the NUWA went door to door and

Literature Review on the Integration of Technology in the Classroom

2242 words - 9 pages Literature review will be conducted to examine and critiqued previous research regarding integrating technology in the classroom. The number students that use or have access to technology on a daily base increases daily. Technology has reshaped our educational system, from integration in the classroom, collaborating with peers, and how test are administered to students. Integrating technology in our educational system can assist the special

Building Employee Enthusiasm MGT 449: Quality Management and Productivity This is an article review for the Quality Management course

502 words - 2 pages Building Employee EnthusiasmIn the article, "Building Employee Enthusiasm", the author, Peter Staack, demonstrates the importance for organizations to increase their awareness of safety through the use of incentive promotional products. There is no substitute for a safety program that will save needed revenue normally utilized for workers compensation. Lowered worker's compensation claims are one of the most significant benefits that safety

My Educational Philosophy for the ESL Classroom

2120 words - 9 pages Teaching and learning a second or foreign language is much like teaching in the general education classroom. ESL classrooms need structure, nurturing, and sufficient instructional strategies. With such diversity among adolescent ELs, it is important for teachers to learn as much as possible about their students’ background, prior knowledge, and experiences, and to have knowledge of strategies that directly address the needs of their students

Effective Apps for Use in the Classroom

670 words - 3 pages Effective Apps for Use in the Classroom There are over 500,000 apps in Apple’s iTunes Store and the authors noted that there are many useful ones that can be appropriate to support learning and teaching (Norris & Soloway, 2012). Carr and Prater (2013) stated “classroom with the iPads involved students utilizing apps to reinforce skill acquisition of letters/sounds, sight/spelling words” (p. 3857). Because there are few studies that have looked

To Pay or Not to Pay, That is the question-explaining if we should or not pay for peoples organs- "lets pay for organs" time article

722 words - 3 pages In the Article "Yes, Let's Pay for Organs", Time (May 17, 1999) the author, Charles Krauthammer, questions if it is right for humans to pay for organs from either live or dead people. Pennsylvania wants to pay 300 dollars toward funeral expenses for the donor's family. They are hoping that paying people will bring in more organs. Krauthammer argues that while $300 is a generous offer, it can not be the same compensation for different social

Are Laptops in the Classroom Beneficial or Harmful?

1304 words - 6 pages are learning. These instructors believe that writing down the information that is provided in class is a much more efficient way to remember the material. Murray, Fried, Kolar, Sabatini, and Fink offer facts that support both sides and understand the use of laptops in the classroom. However, Murray’s article has a good support for using laptops during class: efficiency for the teacher. If every student has immediate access to necessary

Analysis of Unplugged: The Myth of Computers in the Classroom, Article by David Gelernter

849 words - 3 pages field of technology, suggests to limit the use of technology in the classroom in his article “Unplugged: The Myth of Computers in the Classroom” which was published in the New Republic magazine in 1994. In this article he offers well illustrated analysis which makes the readers to regulate the use of technology in the classroom. He thinks that the technology comes in a way of building strong foundation of basic skills. He insists that computers

Article Review Paper: "The Recognition of Brazilian Independence"

1329 words - 5 pages American history and was an authority on economic and political relations between Brazil and Great Britain. In February of 1951, Manchester’s article, “The Recognition of Brazilian Independence”, was published in The Hispanic American Historical Review. Nearly half a century later in April of 2000, Kenneth Maxwell presented a lecture at Harvard University entitled, “Why Was Brazil Different? The Contexts of Independence”. In both articles, the

Similar Essays

Article Review One Article Being Reviewed: “Co Teaching In The Esl Classroom”

557 words - 2 pages PAGE PAGE 1 Article Review One Article Review OneArticle being reviewed: "Co-teaching in the ESL Classroom"By: Lauryn BoorsteinECED232: Child Development and CognitionProfessor Dr. Nurun N. BegumSeptember 23, 2010Article Review OneIn the Article "Co-teaching in the ESL classroom", you will learn that classrooms are no longer a place for one instructor and thirty students; there are new models of teaching on the rise. Mainstream educators are

"Store And Forward: A Collaborative Approach For Developing Interactive Digital Media (Idm) For Classroom Instruction." An Article Review And Summary

820 words - 3 pages Both students and instructors may benefit from the use and availability of digital media technology. This technology that was once used by primarily business environments is now being offered to students. Henke wrote an article in 1997 for a doctoral dissertation that states, "Delivering instruction using a variety of modes (visual and verbal) allows more students to receive and access information through their preferred media and can increase

Heterogeneous Or Ability Grouping: What Is Best For All Students

1930 words - 8 pages gifted students in a heterogeneous classroom versus a gifted ability grouped classroom. The findings of this study showed no significant differences in boredom of students of different abilities. There were some interesting findings for the students’ reasons for boredom. (Frenzel, A., Gotz, T., Preckel, F., 2010). When the gifted students were placed in the ability-grouped classroom, the students’ reason for boredom was due to the fact that

Article Review: The Teen Brain

1178 words - 5 pages The article under review in this paper is 'Neurodevelopment: How does the teen brain work?' by Kendall Powell (2006). this article appears to be credible based on the following: although the author is a freelance science writer, his work lead one to believe he knows what he is talking about. In addition, he provides several supportive resources to back up his topics. He has several other articles and writings available on the internet. However