Cloning More Ethically Acceptable Than Global Warming

856 words - 3 pages

Cloning More Ethically Acceptable than Global Warming


One day soon, human clones will walk among us. Does the thought send a shiver up your spine? How about the notion of eating french fries from a potato engineered with jellyfish genes to make its leaves bioluminescent? We should consider our responses to both issues now, before reality comes knocking at the door. Several groups have announced intentions to clone humans, and the bioluminescence gene has already been successfully incorporated into potato plants.


If those prospects make you squirm, you're not alone. The public's emotional response to the issues of human cloning and biotechnology far outstrips its response to global warming and widespread species extinction. When Dolly the sheep was first cloned by Scottish scientists, political leaders around the world sensed the negative reactions among their constituents and moved to pass legislation banning the new technology in humans. Any new developments in the area stir up fresh controversy, such that the cloning issue is frequently featured on the front page of major newspapers. These articles seem to suggest that apart from a few mad scientists, most everyone agrees that cloning humans is wrong.


But why is it so wrong? Consider the Monitor's quotes from the experts. Professor Chen, vice-president of Beijing University, says about human cloning, "There isn't a controversy. There's no real discussion. We know it's wrong and not natural." John White, who is secretary for science policy at the Australian Academy of Science, is equally willing to speak authoritatively on the issue: "We clearly oppose cloning whole human beings. There are too many troubling ethical and moral issues."


Of course, there are troubling issues that need to be considered. The new technology suffers from several technical challenges, such as a low rate of successful implantation and a low rate of subsequent survival. We certainly wouldn't want cloned children to suffer illnesses caused by imperfect technology. Others voice their concern that parents who employ the techniques to recreate a lost child will place burdensome expectations on the cloned child, who - despite sharing the genes of the lost child - will be a unique person. Indeed, the word "clone" is misleading, since such children will be less similar to the original child than would be an identical twin (the clone will not have shared the same womb at the same time). But do such issues justify an outright ban on human cloning? The technical challenges will soon be overcome with the help of new research, and...

Find Another Essay On Cloning More Ethically Acceptable than Global Warming

A close look at Cloning Essay

1181 words - 5 pages , "as they do in the cattle business, is to split the cells of an early multi-celled embryo which will form two new embryos" (Lawren).For it to get started into practice it took more than fifty years of questioning andtesting. "The first successful cloning experiment involved a leopard frog. It took place in,1952 with group of scientist from the Institute for Cancer Research in Philadelphia(Lawren)". You may not be able to see it at this early

Humans Should Not be Blamed for Global Warming

886 words - 4 pages place between the 16th to the mid 19th century. During this period the polar ice caps extended considerably further from the poles than they do currently. Accordingly it is acceptable to state that climate change and hence global warming is part of the Earth’s natural cycle. It is alleged that global warming is ‘man-made’ due to it being caused by greenhouse gases (most notably Carbon Dioxide) that contribute to the ‘greenhouse effect

The Ethics of Cloning

848 words - 4 pages age where we have more power than ever to change the natural state of things, it becomes increasingly important that we consider the ethical implications involved in cloning to control how we as a people progress our civilization. The lack of knowledge regarding cloning aids in people’s skepticism and concern as many people do not understand how cloning works. Dolly the sheep became the first animal to be successfully cloned in 1996 and instantly

The Ethics of Cloning

1717 words - 7 pages According to Richard Dawkins “Cloning may be good and it may be bad. Probably it's a bit of both. The question must not be greeted with reflex hysteria but decided quietly, soberly and on its own merits. We need less emotion and more thought” (Dawkins, 2011). Cloning is a general term used to describe the replication of biological material (Cloning Fact Sheet, 2009). Throughout this paper the reasoning behind why cloning is an acceptable and

Human Reproductive Cloning Should be Banned

1053 words - 4 pages tissues and organs for transplant. The goal of this process is strictly to harvest stem cells, resulting in the creation of “cloned organs”, which can be used to treat heart disease, Alzheimer’s, and cancer. However, because reproductive cloning involves the creation of a specific being with specific characteristics it is much more controversial, and has much more at stake than therapeutic cloning. There are definitely advantages of

Cloning: What is the right thing to do?

1363 words - 5 pages of purpose. There are downsides to cloning, reproductive cloning is expensive and highly ineffective. Many cloning attempts are required before a single living offspring is produced. This increases costs. In addition to costs and low success rates cloned animal tend to have more physical problems, and are prone to shorter life spans (Reaves, Bring Back the Dodo).      Whether human cloning is ethically justifiable or not

Human Cloning

693 words - 3 pages , pressure started to build on the scientists because people started to doubt if cloning was ethically and morally correct. Governments began to introduce bans and constraints on cloning, as they felt cloning was not correct. Human cloning could be very beneficial to humanity, could be used to improve people's appearances and is no more incorrect than the role doctor's play everyday. A great benefit cloning can give is that it gives couple who

Cloning, Pros and Cons

3749 words - 15 pages number of people. (Bandman & Bandman, 2002). A utilitarian person with the passion of therapeutic cloning would see destroying embryos for research as ethically sound because in the end more people might be helped with cures, rather than looking at all of the embryos destroyed. This person would also believe that the end justifies the means (Bandman & Bandman, 2002). Since a person's own passions and reasoning justifies an issue right or wrong

Cloning: Right Or Wrong? Should cloning be legal? What are the pros and cons of cloning? What can cloning lead to? What should be done?

563 words - 2 pages products such as proteins for humans.Some people would suggest that cloning is unnatural and not ethically correct but so would be talking medicine when you fall sick. The whole of the modern medicine world in based on unnaturalness, so it seems cloning would be part of that modern medicine world. Some people also suggest that clones of human beings would behave in different ways than a normal human being would however this is also wrong as the

Cloning Regulations Needed

1177 words - 5 pages rather than to involve another man or to adopt a child (Herbert). Father Richard McCormick, a Jesuit priest at the University of Notre Dame insists that, "Infertility is not an absolute evil that justifies doing any and everything to overcome it" (Woodward). Ethicists agree that adult cloning is "bizarre. . . narcissistic and ethically impoverished." Adults who raise themselves would be raising children who are also their twins. The words "mother

Argument Against Cloning

960 words - 4 pages Human cloning has always been an issue of controversy, both religiously and ethically. Should a person be cloned for the sake of experimentation? Should a species be cloned in order to reproduce organs? Intense questions have been asked since the discovery of cloning, however the most controversial question is: is cloning right? The cloning of any species, whether human or not, is ethically and morally wrong.The process of cloning inevitably

Similar Essays

Global Warming, Its Effects On The Us Economy, The Enviroment And More.

5148 words - 21 pages U.S. coast. (10,12,14,15,19)Calculations of climate change for specific areas are much less reliable than global ones, and it is unclear whether regional climate will become more variable.(15)Greenhouse GasesMany chemical compounds found in the Earth's atmosphere act as "greenhouse gases." These gases allow sunlight, which is radiated in the visible and ultraviolet spectra, to enter the atmosphere unimpeded. When it strikes the Earth's surface

"Even If Conventional War Is Acceptable For Christians, Nuclear War Could Never Be." Do You Agree? Give Reasons For Your Answer, Showing You Have Considered More Than One Point Of View.

597 words - 2 pages "Even if conventional war is acceptable for Christians, nuclear war could neverbe." Do you agree? Give reasons for your answer, showing you have considered more than one point of view.In the modern world, there has been much debate, particularly within Christian denomination groups, over the subject of nuclear war. As opposed to conventional warfare, nuclear war employs the use of weapons of mass destruction such as chemical, biological and

The Present And Future From Human Cloning

1567 words - 6 pages because the more people there are the more gases are released in their life time. This means that the effects of global warming such as drought, flooding, hurricanes, and starvation would all begin to increase. So the cost of a life in order to create human clones cannot be worth just a loved one because it could possible kill millions. For human cloning to occur correctly then it would change the limitation of man. Research for new types of

Cloning: The Face Of A Better Tomorrow

3082 words - 12 pages As the world has grown and developed, there has been more of a demand for newer and more efficient ways to solve world problems. Cloning has opened up doors and shined some light onto some optional ways of resolving various global issues. Cloned animals could be used to increase productivity in the manufacturing and sale of meat. Cloning could also improve our agriculture and help to preserve our animal population. Lastly, cloning could