This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Closely Watched Trains By Jiri Menzel And My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done?, Directed By Werner Herzog

1124 words - 4 pages

Closely Watched Trains is a Czech New wave film set in Czechoslovakia during the Nazi occupation in World War II. It revolves around the life and coming of age of Milos, a train officer.
The major theme of the movie is the way it satirizes Soviet Russia during this historical time period, which is unconventional for a movie set in World War II. Other themes emerge as well, such as sexuality (or the repression of sexuality), gender roles and masculinity.
There was also a scene that stuck out to me at the beginning of the movie, where Milos’ mother seems to crown him with his conductors’ hat, maybe signifying the important role that Milos being a train officer plays at the end of the film.
I also thought it was interesting that the movie did not demonize the Germans, as is usually the case with films set in World War II. The Germans are portrayed as benevolent in two scenes; the first is the portrayal of the German soldiers with the nurses, which demonstrates the loneliness of war. The second scene is when the Germans capture Milos, only to let him go after seeing his attempt at suicide.
As mentioned in class, the film is a masterpiece due to its subversive use of metaphor. The young Milos is a symbolic representation of the whole Czech state. He is, to put it lightly, “socially retarded.” He’s sexually repressed, juvenile, awkward, and shows a disinterest towards work. The metaphorical message is that Soviet Russia and the hand of communism never let anyone grow to full maturity, and that the Czech state was suffering from this adolescence. This movie is a demonstration of the ways in which sexuality can be transformed into a political message.

Entry 4: September 23d, 2011: My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done?

Directed by Werner Herzog and produced by David Lynch
This movie was based off a true story, but Herzog apparently wanted to stray from the actual facts of the case and focus more on the madness of the murderer. I really think he achieved what he set out to do. The film begins with a murder investigation. A woman is found dead in her neighbour’s house, presumably killed by her son, Brad McCullum. Once the police arrive on the scene, they find Brad locked up in his home and claiming that he has two hostages. The rest of the movie revolves around this scenario and the various flashbacks of Brad’s life told by his fiancé and his theatre director friend. The movie ends with him finally surrendering and letting go of the two hostages, his pet flamingos (or what he refers to as his “eagles in drag”).
Brad is depicted as a very deranged man. It is mentioned that he was depressed, which may have had something to do with his odd behaviour. When asked what made him this way or why he would kill his mother, the only thing his fiancé and friend could say is that he had gone on an excursion to Peru, and came back a changed man. He also lived alone with his mother for a relatively long time, and she seemed to coddle him, even as a grown...

Find Another Essay On Closely Watched Trains by Jiri Menzel and My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done?, directed by Werner Herzog

Not My Son Essay

961 words - 4 pages noise of a passing car. “Okay, press the button then,” I replied thoughtfully, not sure if he could reach yet. As the red man lit up, George grinned triumphantly. With the dog lead in one hand and his football in the other, we crossed the baked tarmac as the man glowed green. My mind started to wonder again as I watched my son closely. As ever, he was bouncing around, full of energy. His bright skin shone in the sunlight and his rosy cheeks

“My Son the Fanatic” Essay

1601 words - 7 pages Hanif Kureishi’s “My Son the Fanatic” is the story of two competing beliefs between a father and his son: Ali’s passion for anti western Islam, and his father Parvez’s dream of providing for his family. Both father and son have different views on how to live life, and the idea of religion. Kureishi explores the themes of, religion, fanaticism, and a father’s love for his son. The protagonist Parvez, an English Punjabi taxi driver, has adapted to

Advice to my Son

795 words - 3 pages father could be comparing these lines to one of his own experiences in a car crash, or an army battle. Mienke was showing how life could be gone in just an instant, and the destination could be already set for the person. The son has the decision whether he wants his life to be hell, because he works all the time, or to have a little slice of heaven by having some fun every now and then. “Beauty is nectar and nectar, in a desert, saves-- but

Go My Son

1307 words - 6 pages Hashem guides us through all situations, the good and the bad. We too go through times where we cannot understand how something that seems so bad can be good, or can’t seem to find a way to solve a nisayon we are put through. We are even sometimes blindsided when we do receive the yeshua, not realizing it was sent by Hakadosh Baruch Hu. By implementing the lessons of “Go My Son” and having the outlook of it is really Hashem arranging everything, we will be able to

To my son much advice

788 words - 3 pages mother. There is an old saying like mother like daughter, And that’s funny because my daughter is just like my wife they have the same attitude and loud mouth there one of the same. I guess that is true for the saying like father like son, it seems to me that my son was born knowing what football was, loves the game just like me. Advice to my son is things that you tell your boy, like how you have see things growing up or advice that your father

Find an explanation to how cancer started. i took the proof that exists today of how cancer may have started and explained how joseph, son of jacob, could be responsible for it

1359 words - 5 pages estimate acrylamide is responsible for several hundred causes of cancer each year (Mocivnik). A test was done by the FDA to see exactly how much acrylamide is formed in today's "freedom" fries. They bought some frozen fries that have yet to be cooked, and found that they contained no acrylamide. They then baked them for 10 to 15 minutes, as the package directed, and found a slight amount of acrylamide. However, none of the scientists considered the

Father and Son by Bernard McLaverty

2094 words - 8 pages listen to what is making you thin'. But the verbal exchanges between the pair are far from eloquent. The father is only able to verbalise his concern in a reproachful manner. His son sees this as interference in his privacy and, in the stereotypical manner, replies with sharp retorts. Every word spoken between them further distances them. "'Why don't you tell me where you go?' 'Look, Da, I have not touched the stuff

What the World Eats, by Peter Menzel

2267 words - 9 pages Four people sit kneeling around a small table in a small room laden with food. A room where a serious man in a black box holds out a can of something altered and edible, and a young girl perched near her mother clutches a bag of potato chips to her chest as if claiming it as solely her own. This is the scene depicted in a photograph of the Ukita family in Kodaira City, Japan as part of a series taken by Peter Menzel for the book “What the

Native Son, by Richard Wright

862 words - 3 pages character in the novel. He feels that Bigger is just a stupid fool, having done everything possible to actually get himself caught. Fadiman also writes that Bigger '...knew that the moment he allowed what his life meant to enter fully into his consciousness, he would either kill himself or somebody else.' Fadiman then goes on by criticizing Wright stating that he is too explicit, repetitive, and overdoes his melodrama from time to time. Fadiman

Native Son by Richard Wright

1660 words - 7 pages beginning, could change the world. In fact the leader of the free world, President Barrack Obama, is a black man and he is working to fix the corruption. Obama’s new initiative called “My Brother’s Keeper” is the next big step to helping black men have a fair chance at a better life. Although many of America’s systems are still run by white people and will continue to hurt black men, it is never too late to fight for what is right. Speaking as a

Native Son by Richard Wright

2400 words - 10 pages Native Son by Richard Wright Who is the victim in a prejudiced civilization? The dominant group or the minority? "Native Son," a

Similar Essays

Untitled And Advice To My Son, By Peter Meinke

1457 words - 6 pages to able to find true beauty within another person or yourself. The theme in Untitled, on the other hand, is different and is seen more as remorse or in an unspoken way, asking for forgiveness. From the beginning the speaker, Peter’s father, feels bad for everything he has done to his son. He starts off by saying, “to my son Peter, / whom I have hurt a thousand times” (Meinke, Lines 1-2). From these lines to the end he describes the pain that he

Letter To My Son By Lord Chesterfield

1863 words - 7 pages trying to prove to his son that he is not dictating because he is the father, but just giving advice on what is to be done. He tells his son, “let my experience supply your want”( (Chesterfield 262). He wants him to believe that he wants the best for him, and that is why he is writing the letter to him. In the last paragraphs of his letter, he tells his son that he must use the education he has received to become a better, and independent person

My Son, My Executioner Essay

692 words - 3 pages From a global viewpoint, the passing of generations of the human race is a smooth and natural cycle, one generation bringing another generation into this world, as they themselves begin to leave it. From the perspective of the individual, however, this cycle can bring about a mixture of feelings, from pride to depression, as they watch their own lives fall second to that of their children. Donald Hall’s “My son, my executioner” and Rita Dove’s

My Son The Fanatic Essay

1018 words - 4 pages My Son the Fanatic Hanif Kureishi’s short story “My Son the Fanatic” is the story of two competing beliefs: Ali’s passion for anti western Islam, and his father Parvez’s dream of providing for his family. Both father and son have different views on how to live life, and the idea of religion. Kureishi explores issues of identity, religion, and a father’s love for his son. Parvez, an English Punjabi taxi driver, has adapted to a new way of life