This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Co Operatives Have A Dual Identity, Existing Simultaneously As A Social Movement And An Economic Enterprise. To What Extent Has The Recovered Fac...

1229 words - 5 pages

The rise of the recovered factory movement in Argentina seems to have been born not for economic enterprise, or of a great desire for social movement and gain, but out of desperation and starvation. Personal accounts in Sin Patron tell not of a revolution for its own sake but of a workforce doing "anything to survive" (Collective, 2007, p. 56). Far from reveling in the absence of leadership these working women often found themselves destitute and wishing for the return of the bosses to their occupied factories (Collective, 2007, p. 64). The interviews often show not of an expectation for the factories to become the collective property of the occupiers but of an expectation that the owners would return (Collective, 2007, p. 69).

To take over a failing business in a time of national bankruptcy, such as Argentina was facing in 2001, is a questionable economic decision at the very least. The factories which were occupied were on average 40 years old and in disrepair (sometimes intentionally on the part of the original owners) and combined with the strict rules on occupation, the transfer of debt, and the compensation of original owners in Argentina it would appear to be near enough economic suicide. Yet of the 200 factories that were initially occupied only 2 have failed and been forced to close. This success in the face of economic turmoil pays testament to the compatibility of economic enterprise within a social movement.

. Despite these unquestionable struggles many of the occupied factories succeeded in, not only drastically improving the welfare of its workers but also, either maintaining or increasing production within the factories. The economic successes of many of these businesses are undeniable in one factory alone there was "Increased production, profits and the workforce from 240 when they took over the factory to 400 in 2004" (Collective, 2007), showing that whatever their aims, the economic enterprise of the businesses seemed to be winning through. This improvement may have been a side effect and not an aim of the recovered factory movement Zanon for example increase the production from just 20000 to 300,000 from ownership by the capitalist to collective ownership by the cooperative. Increased incentive the workforce may have played a significant part in this, having a share in the business is success rather than just a wage packet will motivate workers to produce higher levels. The successes of the taken factories were not just seen through increased productivity and workforce sizes but also remarkable increases in factory safety, Zanon’s accident rate was decreased 89% from 300 after the takeover by the co-operative and not a single death occurred despite previous rates of one a month. This shows the cooperatives devotion to well-being of their members.

However the movement faced issues of involvement as Matilde Adorno said in Sin Patron the workers “Couldn't make ends meet on a dream" and that while ideologically...

Find Another Essay On Co-operatives have a dual identity, existing simultaneously as a social movement and an economic enterprise. To what extent has the recovered fac...

“The recession has had devasting effects on UK businesses. Even long established companies have been unable to withstand the impact of the worst recession for 90 years.” To what extent do you agree...

1043 words - 4 pages . But the consequences have also dwelled on bigger companies such as Cadbury with the closure of its chocolate factory at Keynsham near Bristol with the loss of 500 jobs or even the famous well-established brand Mark & Spencers. The latter has closed 27 stores during the recession and has brought the loss of 1,230 jobs. Directly link to the economic crisis, the difficulties which had suffered Mark & Spencer are a recession-proof. As

'In modern times, the rights of individuals have become increasingly threatened by governments.' To what extent has your awareness of danger been influenced by the works of one of more writers

1977 words - 8 pages knives into Jewish flesh and bone.' Holland does not portray the boy's as being cognicant of the words, rather, they sing the murderous anthem with disturbing ease, an ease usually afforded to those who do not think about what they are saying, but rather are simply repeating what they have been taught. The Nazi's also believed that a strong and healthy intellect could only be found in coincidence with a healthy body, and as a result sport became

To what extent was the Civil War an important watershed in US social and economic history?

1749 words - 7 pages 4 million slaves. By the 1800's, the African slave trade had been outlawed; existing slaves however were not freed. Men and women of the North pushed to completely abolish slavery. The southern farmers regarded the opinions of the northerners as detached from reality. They did not want to be pushed around by the northern people, and The South feared that losing the slaves would have a severe economic impact on cotton plantations.Abraham Lincoln

To what extent had the colonists developed a sense of their identity and unity as Americans by the eve of the Revolution?

748 words - 3 pages have put aside their individual issues to emerge as a united whole.In conclusion, the sense of unity and identity among the colonists from 1750 to 1776, eventually led to the Revolution. The colonists realized that even with separate goals, joining was essential for their survival. Through propaganda, the relationship between the colonies and Britain, and the French and Indian War, the colonists were able to realize the need for unity and identity.Bibliographyhttp://home.earthlink.net/~gfeldmeth/1998.dbq.html

To what extent had the colonists developed a sense of their identity and unity as Americans by the eve of the Revolution?

908 words - 4 pages away"(Document C) the 24th of February of the same year. What Lee meant was more than clear, America was now firmly united forever and as going to fight together against all of those who opposed.After gaining freedom, colonists thought that after someone comes to North America he or she no longer is a European. "...He becomes and American by being received in the broad lap of our great Alma Mater" In other words, now that they have become an

To what extent were political, economic, and social development between the Revolutionary War and the ratification of the Constitution, a reflection of the colonists' dreams for independence

646 words - 3 pages with creating their own political system/ government, establishing peace within the nation, and regaining their economic standing as a nation and not as individual states. These tasks, which seem simple to an outsider, caused the Americans much distress and dampened their hopes and dreams of a better and more stable life. The main contributor to their dilemma was the, newly developed, Articles of Confederation, which had numerous flaws that made the

To what extent did the economic, political and social institutions of colonial America provide a firm or faulty foundation for the United States of America?

591 words - 2 pages , and establishing the cash crop system and extensively trading with the rest of the world. To a great extent, the foundation for the United States, which ultimately made her so advanced, was provided by the social, political and economic institutions of colonial America.One of the important benefits that the United States provides today is the social mobility which lets people build up their careers and improve their life status. Moving up the

A look on the Canadian Identity as a Canadian citizen and what it means to me

1345 words - 5 pages in the number of firearms sold in the U.S. because of September 11, 2001. The same trend has not been evidenced in Canada. Americans have always been seen as more aggressive and "pro war". What other country would ever consider to have the mention of rockets and bombs within the first five lines of their national anthem? That doesn't speak very highly of a peaceful country. Every day the gap between Canadians and Americans grow, even though we are

To what extent can the 1936 popular front government be seen as a missed opportunity for social transformation

2255 words - 9 pages due to immigration and no country in the world had a higher proportion of people over sixty' (Jackson, p.18). Tardieu was obligated to carry out a series of long overdue reforms, incorporating advancements in technology and establishment of a welfare state. Jackson referred to it as a "period of transatlantic ideas of rationalisation an economic modernisation" (Jackson p.18). At the beginning of 1931 France, like the rest of the world, began to

Social Media Identity Has the Potential to Affect an Individual’s Current and Future Employment.

973 words - 4 pages With the current times of internet and social media usage, an individual’s identity has the potential to affect their current and future employment. Employers are increasingly using social media sites to screen potential and current employees to identify any activities or publications that may concern the organisations best interest. Many questions arise about the potential affects these actions can have on employment for individuals and are

The New Age Movement This paper outlines the New Age movement as a social movement including their basic beliefs and goals, who they are, and what they do, as well as their place in society

1846 words - 7 pages that is given prominence by the media such as phenomena, personalities like Shirley MacLaine, and events. The other, broader meaning is a more serious adherence to the occult-metaphysical tradition and an attempt to transform society. (Kyle 4) Many authorities state that the New Age is a passing fad that was best suited for the social and economic climate of the 1980's. The movement has received less media attention in the recent decade and some

Similar Essays

The Extent To Which A Central Bank Should Have Both Goal And Instrument Independence And Examine The Possible Implication Of This On Achievement Of The Macro Economic Objectives

2118 words - 8 pages In this essay I will investigate to what extent a Central Bank should have both goal and instrument independence followed by an examination of the possible implications this could have on the macro-economic objectives. A Central Bank has several functions; these include the issue of national currency, to act as banker to both government and private banks, and to oversee the financial system. Central Banks also administer national monetary policy

To What Extent Can Modern Scientific Theories Be Said To Have Disproved The Claims That The Universe Has Been Designed

1317 words - 5 pages For years evolutionists and creationists have been arguing about the way the world was created and whether it has been designed or has evolved over thousands of millions of years.William Paley was a creationist and believed that the universe must have a designer, as it is so complex with many complex organisms. To him it was observable that the universe is designed and if this is true then there must be a designer, which he believed to be God

“My Way Of Life Has Fallen Into The Sear…And That Which Should Accompany Old Age, As Honour, Love, Troop Of Friends, I Must Not Look To Have…”It Is Not Fate But Macbeth Who Is Responsible For His...

1030 words - 4 pages Ajay Mohanraj"My way of life has fallen into the sear…and that which should accompany old age, as honour, love, troop of friends, I must not look to have…"It is not fate but Macbeth who is responsible for his demise. To what extent do you agree?Set to the backdrop of medieval Scotland, William Shakespeare's "Macbeth" portrays how the protagonist Macbeth is responsible for his own destiny through the deeds he commits and that fate

“The Recession Has Had Devasting Effects On Uk Businesses. Even Long Established Companies Have Been Unable To Withstand The Impact Of The Worst Recession For 90 Years.” To What Extent Do You Agree...

1043 words - 4 pages . But the consequences have also dwelled on bigger companies such as Cadbury with the closure of its chocolate factory at Keynsham near Bristol with the loss of 500 jobs or even the famous well-established brand Mark & Spencers. The latter has closed 27 stores during the recession and has brought the loss of 1,230 jobs. Directly link to the economic crisis, the difficulties which had suffered Mark & Spencer are a recession-proof. As