Cole Inquiry (Australian Wheat Board Scandal)

1366 words - 5 pages

(Note: Any random numbers were originally in superscript and are references to sources mentioned in the bibliography)BackgroundThe UN Oil-For-Food program began operation in early 1998. The purpose of the program was to allow the Iraqi government to purchase food and other necessary resources essential for the population, without allowing the Iraqi government to rebuild its military. Iraq would sell its oil on the global market, but the money received would be put into a specially monitored bank account, used to purchase food. The program ended in 2003 when Coalition forces invaded Iraq.1However, it was discovered in 2005 that the Australian Wheat Board had paid almost $300 million to Alia, a Jordanian trucking company, which passed on most of the money to the Saddam Hussein regime. In return, Iraq purchased their wheat from Australia at a higher price to compensate for the fees. This effectively allowed Iraq to turn the ‘food money’ in the monitored bank account into ‘spending money’ for regime-related purchases that the UN economic sanctions were there to prevent. The benefit for AWB was that Iraq bought wheat from them and at a higher price.1,2The Cole Inquiry was established in December 2005 to ascertain whether Australian companies (including AWB) were responsible for paying kickbacks to Saddam Hussein. It is generally undisputed that the illegal transaction did occur and AWB were aware of it, however the confusion now is about whether the government knew what was happening and allowed it to happen.3The key innovative aspect of this issue is the conduct of the AWB. Corruption has occurred throughout history, but this particular event shows how sometimes economics and politics have different interests, and it is when these interests are mutually exclusive that we compromise our own values for other benefits. A relatively new concept that the AWB scandal represents is that of economic globalisation – a free-trade economy across the world. There are a range of opinions on the morals and ethics of global free trade (it can ‘cut out’ local, smaller businesses), however when the ideals of economic freedom become opposed to political ideals, the question must be asked whether this capitalist environment is encouraging the right sort of business. While the actions of AWB are generally considered to be immoral, it is unlikely Australia would have won business contracts with Iraq if it refused to pay bribes.4 The morality behind AWB’s decisions purely lies upon whether the needs of doing business are greater than political needs and honesty.The question posed in the Cole Inquiry is essentially “Did the AWB’s actions constitute a breach of law?” Evidence including reports of meetings between AWB officials and Iraqi regime officials, documents concerning payments to the trucking company Alia and government records seems to show that AWB did in fact breach law by transferring funds to a country with...

Find Another Essay On Cole Inquiry (Australian Wheat Board scandal)

The Los Angeles Police Department Essay

1795 words - 7 pages accompanying the long-awaited Board of Inquiry report into the corruption centered in the department's Rampart Division, Police Chief Bernard C. Parks called the scandal a "life-altering experience for the Los Angeles Police Department" in which corrupt officers took advantage of lax supervision to carry out criminal acts. "We as an organization provided the opportunity," Parks wrote. The 362-page report was given to Mayor Richard

murdoch case Essay

3561 words - 14 pages the culture of phone hacking and also revealed to the competitors of NoW, New York Times, was found dead. The other competitors, Guardians reported the crimes of NoW publicly. The scandal indicates the highly competitiveness of the media culture where increasing the popularity of "tabloid" news is the key to success. In addition, the British Prime Minister required the examination called Leveson inquiry in November 2011, which found that the

Australian dairy industry analysis. Includes the effect of deregulation of the industry

2327 words - 9 pages industry is the third largest rural industry in Australia, behind beef and wheat. It is a major rural employer and one of the leading rural industries in terms of value adding. Australia's production has increased both in volume and value terms over the past ten years. 'Gross farmgate value, the value of the industry immediately following the production process, has increased to approximately 3.3 billion Australian dollars. The Gross farmgate value

SBS Leaving the ABC Unaccountable

2056 words - 8 pages educational nature 4. promote the musical, dramatic and other performing arts in Australia 5. transmit to other countries programs of news, current affairs, entertainment and cultural enrichment that encourage awareness of Australia and an international understanding of Australian attitudes on world affairs” (Austrain Broadcasting Corporation, 1983). These provisions are addressed by the ABC board the duty of the board is to ensure corporate

The Efficacy of Deposit Insurance in the Australian Context

5068 words - 20 pages repay creditors. This provision is strengthened by the fact that the sufficient assets must be held in Australia to a cover to their Australian deposit liabilities.The 1997 Financial System Inquiry concluded that the existing depositor preference laws were more effective, reflecting concerns which mirrored the general literature that the introduction of deposit insurance would reduce incentives to manage and monitor risk. This view was relaxed

Administrative Law in Australia -- Notes on Natural Justice

7990 words - 32 pages being consulted Maritime Union Austrlia v Minister for Transport (b) Undertakings by Administrators 12 Australian courts do not accept that undertakings give rights to procedural fairness - but growing acceptance. Cole v Cunningham: Public servant who resigned after scandal suggested that if he went quietly he could maintain a clean record. `The respondent was entitled to hold the reasonable expectation that he would be afforded a

Beecher Tilton Scandal

610 words - 2 pages Elizabeth Cady Stanton, a women’s movement activist, who in turn repeated it to Mrs. Woodhull. While initially the affair was only known to a small group of prominent members of Mr. Beecher’s congregation, Mrs. Woodhull’s article has made it a national sensation and a well sought after press item. The internal inquiry of the Plymouth Church board exonerated Mr. Beecher, but excommunicated Mr. Tilton. The inquiry was a subject of daily articles

Global Education - Senior Study of Society Rationale

1072 words - 4 pages itself, and will apply the initiative to the Study of Society senior syllabus (Queensland Board of Senior Secondary School Studies [QBSSSS], 2000) and Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young Australians (Ministerial Council on Education, Employment, Training and Youth Affairs [MCEETYA], 2008). Global education is an initiative that encourages the development and promotion of attitudes and skills required to value and protect the

A comparision between the Swiss and Australian economy

1184 words - 5 pages handling the trade balance. This is mainly due to the different industries in the two countries.Australia is very much different from Switzerland because Australia relies on exporting it resources such as metals, meat and wheat exports. Australian government and reserve bank have to implement policies at the right time to regulate the price of the dollar because if the dollar gets to high then exports would fall. Unlike Switzerland which has not

Was Australia a working man's paradise

671 words - 3 pages suggests that this was a myth. Australian economic prosperity was based on our exports of wool and wheat. Wool prices rose 30% between 1902 and 1914. The mining industry also provided exports. Manufacturing was limited though the number employed rose from 132,000 to 239,000 between 1901 and 1913. Australian manufacturing relied on tariff (import taxes) protection to compete against cheaper foreign goods. ARGUMENTS FOR ARGUMENTS AGAINST Pay and

What caused the great depression?

688 words - 3 pages problem was that, it was a country built around export earnings, no longer had the opportunities to import-manufactured goods. As the economical situation worsened it created massive unemployment in the cities. It became extremely difficult to sell Australian wheat, wool, flour, dairy produce and minerals, to the depressed international market, which was 88% of the countries export income. Australia was extremely close to bankruptcy in early 1930

Similar Essays

Pricing Issues In The Australian Wheat Industry

1641 words - 7 pages domestic use & exportGraph 4: Wheat consumptionTradeAustralia is currently one of the top five wheat exporting countries with the export volume of 18million tonnes in 2000. Compared to USA 35 million tonnes, Canada 26 million tonnes, European Union 14 million tonnes and Argentina with 10 million tonnes. We represent just 3% of the global wheat production but account for 15-18% of total world exports.The Australian Wheat Board (AWB) stated

The Challenges Of Contemporary Policing Essay

2721 words - 11 pages & Blunden, A 2010, Australian Law Dictionary, Oxford University Press, South Melbourne. • Newburn, T & Newyroud, P 2008, Dictionary of policing, Willan Publishing, UK & USA. • Newton, J, Lait, M & Glover S, ‘LAPD Condemned by Its Own Inquiry Into Rampart Scandal’, Los Angeles Times, 1 March 2000, viewed 28 March 2014, • Ogloff J, Warren L, Tye C, Blaher F & Thomas S 2010, A Study of Psychiatric

Why Did The Alp Lose The Election Of December 13th 1975 So Badly?

2165 words - 9 pages When the Australian Labor Party came to power in November 1972, it was following almost a quarter of a century of Liberal government, whose policies were becoming increasingly outdated in comparison to the forward thinking promises of ALP leader, Gough Whitlam. The following three years were a program of social reform, though the leadership period suffered under the effects of a world economy turned sour and through a perceived mismanagement of

Australian Economics Essay

2105 words - 8 pages driving forces affecting change in the Australian financial system, especially in view of technological development. Based on the results of the exercise, the Inquiry was further mandated to provide regulatory recommendations that would be enforced in the country in order to ensure that the financial system was responsive, efficient and flexible to the contemporary needs of Australia. It was hoped that proper regulations would lay the basis for