This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Collective Security Essay

621 words - 3 pages

The system of Collective Security indisputably faces certain dilemmas and contradictions. It is clear that the premise of Collective Security still needs cautious legislation. It is only an evolving jurisprudence and its loose ends need to be tied up through concentrated deliberation. A system of Collective Security that would serve the purposes of keeping peace and would sustain continual international onslaught needs to be developed. A coping mechanism that would stand the test of time is of utmost necessity.

• QUESTIONS ABOUT ITS UTILITY: War theorists and strategists have questioned the workability of Collective Security. After World War II, there have been arisen 111 military conflicts so far, out of which only 9 have resulted in all-out wars between states. Civil wars, wars of secession, separatist movements, wars of liberation – these are the most usual types of violent conflicts, which are usually taken care of by indigenous forces. Collective Security ...view middle of the document...

This is particularly seen in cases assignments involve defending the supposed Third World countries. The alleged superpowers always reserve an exit route for themselves, and have never been forthcoming in establishing an international army of significant strength. Perhaps this has something to do with their inherent sovereign ego that needs to be satiated perpetually and their inherent hesitance to let an international force supersede their own. Or perhaps it has something to do with their reluctance to acknowledge a mightier force, as it may be perceived as a possible threat to their sovereignty. It is true that sovereign states cannot be fully bound by pledges to act in some hypothetical future case. Most international situations are only prophesized now, and there often is no conclusive proof that such a situation threatening international peace may manifest itself.

• TENDING TOWARDS UTOPIA: As suggested in the beginning of this paper, the concept of Collective Security tends to be over-ambitious. German Sociologist Karl Mannheim reserves a special term for Collective Security – “Relative Utopia” – one that tries to be realistic but retains the elements of fantasy. It looks to bridge what might sometimes be unbridgeable. It seeks to civilize a world that constantly heads towards anarchy.

Moreover, hypocrisy is often attributed to the ideology of Collective Security, as it uses war to rid the world of war. Although the international theory of Liberalism comes close to advocating Collective Security as a means to a desirable end, the fact remains that Collective Security offers nothing new to the world. The entire system and process works akin to the process of immunization, which gets rid of micro organisms through another breed of micro organisms. Similarly, Collective Security only uses war as a vaccination against war, and this logic is certainly vulnerable to criticism. Although its ends are commendable, its means are definitely disputable. The fact also remains that Collective Security is still a slightly Utopian concept; The order of the universe is chaos, inertia is rampant in the universe. To defy the inertia of a world that increasingly gravitates towards anarchy is a Herculean task. World order is after all, an alternate reality, albeit a desirable one.

Find Another Essay On collective security

NATO and Global Security Essay

1241 words - 5 pages All collective security arrangements have certain rules. States identify each other as fellow citizens within a larger society, they agree to follow a particular set of rules, and they enforce those rules through multilateral action, including the use of force if necessary. Beyond this basic structure, however, many forms of collective security are possible, varying by the substance of the rules, who determines the rules, and how to enforce the

History Essay Rough Draft

1023 words - 5 pages to light that the effective response to aggression is collective security, and not appeasement. World War II broke up the western European front due to the League of Nations. The League of Nations was simply not able to respond in a timely manner in response to the aggressors. Cited in the “World War Two – Causes” packet, the League of Nations was not able to act quickly because they only met a total of four times in one year. Also, the

The Security and Protection of the State

1072 words - 4 pages were definitely different in the way they were fought over new ideologies and over new borders, in response the global community through the actions and the protocols introduced by United Nations Security Council have been able to resolve various issues including the Bosnian Crisis, the invasion of Kuwait and Libya Civil War with quick judgement. Although the deployment of collective security has been correlated with global stability, there are

Peace and Security

1863 words - 7 pages Collective security is one type of coalition building strategy whether global or regional in which a group of nations agree not to attack each other and to defend each other against an attack from one of the others, if such an attack is made. The principal is that "an attack against one is an attack against all." It differs from "collective defense" which is a coalition of nations which agree to defend its own group against outside attacks

Individual and Collective Power Based on Mosca and Weber

1840 words - 7 pages Individual and Collective Power Based on Mosca and Weber In literary works by Gaetano Mosca and Max Weber, the idea of "power" can be extracted and further understood by examining related notions of power such as the "ruling class" and "legitimate domination" presented in them respectively. In particular, through the analysis of power, the distinction between individual and collective contexts of power becomes evident. That is, a

Causes of World War II

1061 words - 4 pages . Unfortunately he couldn’t be stopped, a policy of “Appeasement” from the League of Nations allowed Germany to build an army and begin the annexation of its European neighbors. This policy of appeasement was accompany by the belief that collective security would pull through. If all the nations banded together and declared collective security, no other country would dare attack. Unfortunately when Germany and her allies did attack, collective security

Why We Celebrate a Killing

643 words - 3 pages Haidt’s article, the American goal was achieved in removing the National Security threat, while collectively feeling secure once more. The display of the country’s flags on the homes of many citizens after 9.11, was the show of collective patriotism, while telling the leaders of the nation the need of collective security from any future attacks on this nation. The policymakers received the message, and thus in return, America once again feels

Security in the Business Environment

1919 words - 8 pages definitive meaning of some of these terms. The intention is not to provide an official definition but rather to define the use of these terms within this SMF. Security Program Security program is a collective term for the implementation of the integrated components that relate to the conception, design, deployment, and maintenance of organizational security. The program incorporates the elements described in this SMF, including: • Policies

Failure of the League of Nations in the Inter-War Period

1201 words - 5 pages After the Treaty of Versailles in 1919, which brought an end to the First World War, the League of Nations was established by the President of the United States of America, Woodrow Wilson. Wilson's intention on establishing the League of Nations was to stop all conflicts and wars around the world from ever happening again using the idea of Collective Security as the solution. Collective Security protected every country by mutual assistance and

Security Studies During and After The Cold War

2103 words - 8 pages and absence of open conflict built stability and when the rivalry ended this role was replaced with Unite Nations moving towards an international order as a security issue. The method of resolving security challenges have changed since the fall of the Berlin Wall with a variety of contemporary conflicts that lay examples to how the United Nations prevent conflict but this employment of collective security as a coalition was pre-existing in the

Reading Response to Life and Words

995 words - 4 pages eventful, Das is able to give significant insights into the interface between the individual and the collective, the self and the other, and the everyday and the event. In order to better understand these relations, Das undoes the stereotype of the detached, unbothered researcher and explores how the events and the people affected by them alters the ways of looking at things, as well as her own perceptions; making her ethnography akin to an

Similar Essays

The Struggle For Collective Security Essay

802 words - 4 pages It is only logical that countries try to avoid aggression and conflicts because of the costs of war, which include monetary lost, casualties both military and civilian, and property loss. Thus collective-security organizations were created to help to mediate between states in order to avoid interstate conflicts and aggression that could lead to wars. The United Nations is one of these organizations, its goals are to promote peace, security, and

Realism And The Concepts Of Collective Security And Defense

2323 words - 9 pages Realism is a theory that suggests the need for anarchy in the global arena, whilst at the same time realist doctrine suggests that stability can only be achieved through a “balance of power”. With this said, are the doctrines of Collective Security and Defense fundamentally different from realism or does the idea of a “balance of power” mean that even the anarchical law of Realism is destined to seek order or at the very least is at the mercy

Costs Of Labor Contracts Essay

1330 words - 5 pages the employees; however, to substantial success, unions have continually secured health insurance for their employees. Equally, collective bargaining has helped employees secure housing allowances as essential employee benefits, where unions have managed to convince some employers cater for the housing needs of their employees (Riccucci, 2006). Job Security and Seniority As observed by Cazes, Khatiwada, and Malo (2012), employment

Collective Bargaining Essay

1154 words - 5 pages Collective Bargaining PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 Running head: COLLECTIVE BARGAININGCollective BargainingUniversity of PhoenixCollective BargainingCollective bargaining is a process that involves "the negotiation, drafting, administration, and interpretation of a written agreement between an employer and a union for a specific period of time," (Byars & Rue, 2004, p. 374). The purpose of this paper is to describe the major provisions of the Taft