College Athletes For Hire Essay

1397 words - 6 pages

In the area of collegiate sports, there have been numerous heated debates about the integrity of many things concerning the NCAA and how it handles legal and ethical issues. Two well renowned scholars tackle this issue in their co-authored book entitled
“College Athletes for Hire, The Evolution and Legacy of the NCAA’s Amateur Myth” written by Allen L. Sack and Ellen J. Staurowsky. In their book, the authors enlighten the reader on such issues as athletic scholarships, professionalism in college sports, and favoritism for athletes as well as many more important legal, and ethical issues that we as a country need to address. In this paper I will not do a standard book report by simply regurgitating the information I read in their book. Instead I will try my best to give you my opinion of the issues previously mentioned, and finally what the authors feel should be done to remedy this dilemma as well as my own opinion on the matter, but first I will discuss the issues involved in athletic scholarships.
     “It is not whether an activity is perceived to be enjoyable that distinguishes employment from leisure. Rather it is the presence or absence of instrumental constraint,” ( p.4 ). This quote from the book best describes the problem of athletic scholarships as they exist today. Instrumental constraint is basically the control, or constraint of material rewards and resources, or in this case room and board or extra spending money for athletes receiving scholarships based on their athletic performance. The whole point of athletic scholarships are to free the already over taxed athlete from worrying about getting a full time job in order to pay for classes, spending money, and

room and board, on top of the full time job of school, and sports. But the dilemma is not in the money or in the scholarship itself; instead it lies in the eligibility and ethics of the issues. Take for instance Joe Schmoe, a well-rounded basketball player for the University of Anywhere. Last summer, after graduating from high school, Joe receives a letter from U of A offering him a full ride basketball scholarship starting this fall. Joe, excited as ever and not thinking of the fine print, agrees and leaves that September to attend the University. During that years’ regular season, Joe receives a resounding blow to his elbow and upper arm from a slip and fall accident on his way to class. The doctors tell Joe that he will not be able to play basketball ever again. Devastated, Joe returns to his dorm room and finds a letter from the university, informing him that he no longer has his full ride scholarship and must begin paying for his own room and board. Not able to pay for the $15,000 a year to attend the University, and his parents also unable to pay, Joe drops out of school and becomes a male dancer at the day and night dance club. Now the same thing would happen if Joe simply decided to no longer play for U. of A. in order to concentrate on his...

Find Another Essay On College Athletes For Hire

College Sports are Major Benfactor for Colleges and Athletes Should Be Paid

1021 words - 5 pages College sports are a major benefactor for colleges. When the topic of whether or not students should be paid for their athletic performance is introduced in a conversation, people against the subject tend to refer to the student athletes as if the college student’s life is a walk in the park. Because student athletes sacrifice a huge portion of their life for their university, they should be paid a small amount of from the millions that their

Should College Athletes receive pay for playing a sport for a university

544 words - 2 pages the teammates, inter-self and coaches4. The principal of basketball to an individual's lifeBasic Info: Basketball was created by Dr. James Naismith in 1891 in Springfield Massachusetts, its purpose was to unite and condition young athletes with the will and determination to appreciate a physical and mental sport. At the End of 1949 basketball became an integral part of American culture.Body 1: # 1 How it influenced teenage African American's

Should College Athletes Get Paid?

1536 words - 6 pages . Yes balancing an academic and athletic schedule would be hard but a scholarship is already given, the athletes shouldn’t be there for only money. Meshefejian states, “There are several persuasive arguments as to why college athletes should be paid, but those arguments ultimately fail because the first duty of a university is to educate, not to hire entertainers” (pg. 1 of 2). Therefore, athletes shouldn’t play for money; they should play

Why pay college athletes?

743 words - 3 pages Everyone has had some type of excitement after winning something. Nothing matters but the win without any thoughts of profit. Recently, there has been a debated question; should college students who play a sport get rewarded by being paid? I believe college athletes should not get paid for various reasons: they receive scholarships, perks and it would create problems with the university expenses. College athletes have been dedicating their time

college athletes

1184 words - 5 pages Pay To Play: Should College Athletes Be Paid? Does it make sense for an academic institution to run a multimillion dollar entertainment business, which is what college football and college basketball have become? Does it make sense for these institutions to pay the student-athletes who participate in these football and basketball programs? The reality is that college sports programs, namely the "big name" programs such as

Ncaa Madness

1166 words - 5 pages on their studies, effectively making them athletes first and students second”. Furthermore, the NLRB granted Northwester University football players the right to unionize in March of 2014. Although this is a breakthrough regarding the controversial topic, it could take numerous years and plenty of legal battles for any alterations to occur. This paper will address why I believe college athletes shouldn’t get paid and provide economic analysis to

Paying College Athletes

2002 words - 8 pages Paying College Athletes It is six o'clock in the afternoon at Florida State University. A young college football player has just finished a three-hour practice and is walking down the sidewalk with his teammates. They enter the local McDonald's for a burger. The young football star reaches into his pocket and pulls out a hand full of lint. He cannot work a part-time job like the vast majority of his peers, cause he already has a full time job in

Reform Models in Collegiate Sports

1343 words - 5 pages concerned. Academic capitalism notes that such scholarships help college athletes, especially women and those from minority groups to acquire an education. Sobocinski (2000) notes that close monitoring of athletes and offering them academic support can ensure college athletes to be at par academically with other students. Under this model, college athletes are viewed as amateurs who engage in sports as part of their vocation, being prepared for

Should College Athletes be paid? - Clay - Essay

889 words - 4 pages 4 Christian White Ms. Joseph American literature September 18, 2015 Should College Athletes be paid to play? College athletics have gained immense popularity across the United States.  Whether it was football, basketball, or hockey, ever since the turn of the century, intercollegiate sports have brought in a surplus of revenue to their respective Universities, as well as increasing the popularity of the College’s reputation. For example, in a

College Athletes Should Not Be Exempt from Regular Class Attendance Policies

825 words - 4 pages Many college athletes miss classes because of practice, competition and from exhaustion. For those reasons, supporters argue for exemption of athletes from class attendance policies. Others argue that college athletes are given scholarships to attend college to play sports. On the contrary, the focus of colleges is educating students. The question is, should colleges athletes be exempt from the class attendance requirements? The answer is

College Athletes should they get paid - Brockton High School English - Research paper

484 words - 2 pages Ogechi Okereke Professor Rocha College Introduction to Writing 10/4/2017 Should College athletes be paid? People often debate on issues in the world. People often debate on a significant topic. As a result, there are two sides to the argument, one side being the Yes side and the opposing side saying No. The argument that comes to mind is whether college athletes should be paid for playing amateur sports. Authors on both sides of the argument

Similar Essays

Compensation For College Athletes Essay

935 words - 4 pages needs. This is just one of the many reasons why college student athletes should be compensated for a percentage of what the university makes due to their success. First, student athletes should be paid because they make a large sum of money for their universities. Not only does the school make a large sum of money, but the cities where these schools are located make a large sum of money. Brazos Country where Texas A&M is located generated $86

College Athletes Deserve Pay For Play

955 words - 4 pages time. College athletes are considered full time workers. And do not have time to get a job and support them. This puts pressure on the students’ parents to provide them with the amount of money desired by their children. Many argue and say that it is not necessary for college athletes to be paid because the school is offering paid education which opens doors for the individual and places them with job opportunities which supports them for a

Unfair Advantages: The Loss Of Lowering College Acceptance For Athletes

991 words - 4 pages College bound students around the world are in search of an easier route to be accepted into college. What about college athletes? These students are those who stand out. Many college athletes feel as though they deserve a “reward” for enhancing the school’s program. Though they may deserve acknowledgement of their participation, lowering admission standards will lower their effort in school as well. Intercollegiate athletic programs corrupt

College Athletes Should Not Get Paid For Play

929 words - 4 pages The argument whether a student-athlete should be paid to play or not be paid is one that spans the ages. College sports are considered to be of amateur status by the NCAA. Therefore they believe student-athletes should not receive a pay check to participate in a sport. However on the other end of the spectrum, many critics believe that student-athletes should receive pay for play because not only are they participating in a sport, they are