College Athletes Should Not Get Paid For Play

929 words - 4 pages

The argument whether a student-athlete should be paid to play or not be paid is one that spans the ages. College sports are considered to be of amateur status by the NCAA. Therefore they believe student-athletes should not receive a pay check to participate in a sport. However on the other end of the spectrum, many critics believe that student-athletes should receive pay for play because not only are they participating in a sport, they are entertaining the spectators. They believe that if performers in the entertainment industry are paid, why not pay the college-athletes.
Are student-athletes considered student-athletes or employees? The NCAA stands firm by the rules that student-athletes are not employees, therefore should not be treated as employees. Critics disagree with this NCAA ruling, and believe that due to the large amount of revenue the student-athletes generate, they should be paid for their efforts as employees are paid. The NCAA statistics show that, “only 30 percent of Division I football and 26 percent of Division I men’s basketball programs post revenue over expenses.” The fact is that most all NCAA championships “lose money.” The overall revenue primarily earned from the “Division 1 Men’s Basketball Championship, helps 400,000 student-athletes at more than 1,000 member institutions learn and compete in 23 sports and 88 national championships.”
If student-athletes receive monetary rewards for playing they could be considered professional. Therefore, if a student-athlete is paid to play and treated as an employee or professional would they then have the same rights under the Federal Labor Laws? Such rights as to form unions, negotiate wages, hours and working conditions? The federal labor laws differ in many states, especially in the more southern states, and only apply to private employers’, this might affect the larger public schools, such as perhaps the University of Georgia or the University of North Carolina.
Robert and Amy McCormick, law professors at Michigan State University, believe that some student-athletes attend college to play sports and that due to scheduling conflicts between class and practices they do not have full choice as to what major they would like to take (Cooper, 12 – 13). “The way football and basketball players in Division I programs manage juggling sport and school, the McCormicks maintain, undermines the NCAA’s contention they are student-athletes.” (Cooper, 12-13).
The NCAA believes “that a student-athlete is a student first and athlete second.” Student-athletes benefit more than from playing a sport that they love. The graduation rate is higher among the student athletes than the general student body. “NCAA studies show that student-athletes enjoy high levels of engagement in academics, athletics and community: have positive feeling about their...

Find Another Essay On College Athletes Should Not Get Paid for Play

Should College Athletes Get Paid? Essay

993 words - 4 pages The scholarships given to college athletes are not sufficient enough to sustain them throughout the year, which is why I believe they should get paid and receive benefits. Student athletes, especially football and basketball players, play a major role in generating revenue for schools, businesses, coaches and the players do not see a penny. College athletes often do not have money in their pockets for extra food, clothes, housing and

College Athletes : Should They Get Paid

1019 words - 5 pages money for not having enough players. Speaking of money, do all athletes get paid? The biggest sports in college have to be football and basketball. Does that mean the players of that sport get paid more, while the others get less to no money? Because all of the players are in college, they should not get paid to play. (BDL Sports) Some athletes could be sneaky though. Would some take “under the table” money? Some athletes are disgusted at the fact

Why NCAA College Athletes Should get Paid

1428 words - 6 pages problem is not with money distribution as the University of Alabama brings in an average of 28 million dollars a year in just ticket sales. The question now is how it should be incorporated, how each sport’s income be divided, why they should receive income and how much each sport makes. College athletes deserve to get paid because they are making their respected schools too much money for them not to be receiving at least some part of the profit

Should College Athletes Be Paid to Play?

675 words - 3 pages participation in sports. A number of factors lead many people to believe that collegiate level athletes should be seen as wage earners. Athletes should not be paid to play at the collegiate level because they are provided scholarships which pay for their schooling, it would eliminate the recruiting process, and if they were paid it would be unfair for high school athletes not to be paid to play as well. A majority of college athletes are given

Why College Athletes Should NOT be Paid

1997 words - 8 pages Are Not Professional Athletes." U.S. News 6 Jan. 2014, sec. Opinion: n. pag. Print. 5. "Mixed reviews in Louisiana for play-for-pay plan in college sports." the town talk.com 6 Apr. 2014: n. pag. Web. 6. Morganteen, Jeff. "Should Student Athletes Be Paid? No, Says NCAA President." NBC News. NBC News.com, 26 Mar. 2014. Web. 25 Apr. 2014. http://www.nbcnews.com/business/careers/should-student-athletes-be-paid-no-says-ncaa-president-n62671 7

Should College Athletes be Paid?

997 words - 4 pages watch. The only way to get players to try is to base their pay on their performance in play. The only problem with that is many of the players will get mad about their pay (Aaron). ! One of the main arguments for the athletes to get paid is because they bring in revenue for their college. Another reason college athletes should not get paid is because there would be many arguments about which sports would get paid. Many people believe that only

Should College Athletes be Paid?

849 words - 4 pages Are college sports an extracurricular activity or a job? The argument to pay college athletes has increased in the last few years. Some say athletes have a full time job and deserve to be paid since they are over-scheduled with many school-related activities. College athletes should not be paid because it is a privilege to play a sport for a college. Athletes receive a full scholarship for their participation in a college sport. In his article

Should College Athletes Be Paid?

1754 words - 8 pages College athletes should be paid because of the hard work, dedication and effort they put into their respective sports. These athletes are a major source of income for their schools and they are not receiving a penny for it. These college athletes deserved to be paid, colleges are using these athletes to get money and they are never given anything but a pat on the back and a good job. College athletes work and train

Should College Athletes be Paid?

1181 words - 5 pages I was not really aware of the amount of people who actually concerned themselves with whether or not college athletes should be paid until I started doing research. There is no coincidence between the absurd amount of money that college sports have begun making and the more recent argument that college students should be getting paid. Going into this, I anticipated that there would be an endless amount of articles against athletes being paid for

Should College Athletes be Paid?

1540 words - 6 pages college sports. Most others, such as field hockey, wrestling and swimming, do not attract big crowds or make big bucks.” (Should college athletes get paid?). Also the sports team that give out the most money for athletes to come and play for them, are football and men’s basketball. “Critics of paying college athletes note that only a small number of them compete in sports or on teams that actually generate revenue. They argue that if players were

Should College athletes be paid?

1678 words - 7 pages There is a debate on whether college athletes should be paid. It has been known that the fewer scholarships given to student-athletes increase their competiveness on the field, which shows us that keeping money away from student-athletes makes them more competitive (Baird 2). There is also a case that student-athletes are being robbed because they are not receiving compensation for their own likeness (Holthaugh JR. 1). Television networks are

Similar Essays

Should College Athletes Get Paid To Play

786 words - 3 pages Should College Athletes Get Paid to Play Forget about the game-winning touchdown, forget about the cheerleader girlfriend, and forget the pageantry. What about the hard earned money college athletes will never see and earned? In the world of college sports its win or go home, and to the winners go the spoils. Most successful college sports teams rake in millions of dollars in revenue. Steve Spurrier, the coach for the Florida

Should College Athletes Get Paid? Essay

561 words - 2 pages . When going into a college for a sport, students receive scholarships which pay for most, if not all of their necessities anyway. Scholarships enforce the student athlete to keep their grades up so they can keep this money given to them. These students are already getting free meals, merchandise, and exposure so why add more money? College athletes should not be paid because it is not their job to play in a sport. They are in college which means

Should College Athletes Get Paid? Essay

1551 words - 7 pages Right now in sports, there is a huge debate on whether or not college athletes should be paid. For years now college athletes have gone out and performed on national television, working hard to make it to the next level. They have given it there all, and not only that, the athletes bring in about $11 billion in annual revenue from college sports. Now days, sports is a business, and college sports are the same. Division 1 college sports provide

Should College Athletes Get Paid? Essay

1536 words - 6 pages . . . paying athletes would ruin the joyfulness of college athletics (par. 8 of 8). Athletes were not paid in middle school or high school, yet still continued to play for the love of the game, why should college be any different… it shouldn’t. Wouldn’t it be such an honor to say I was an athlete at that college; I wore their jersey for years as I stepped out every day, giving it my all, knowing not all people get that same opportunity