College Football Labor Union Essay

1479 words - 6 pages

A very hot topic and issue in the world of college football is whether or not players should have a labor union, using the basis and guidelines of the united steelworkers union. There are two very different sides of this argument and whether or not it should be put into full force. Do college football players really need a player’s labor union? Kain Colter and several former Northwestern football players firmly believe that they should. This select group, of highly educated Northwestern graduates, is in hot pursuit of forming a player’s labor union. Their motive is to try and gain more rights and benefits for the college football player.
On Tuesday February 18th former Northwestern quarterback, Cain Kolter, testified at a National Labor Relations Board meeting (Tom Ferry). Colter testified that player’s, at the division one level of athletics, deserve and need a labor union ( Colter testified for this because he feels strongly that particularly college football players are being treated very poorly and are not given enough benefits and rights. Colter testified that players adhere to sometimes-grueling schedules, putting in 40-50 hour weeks on football, before the season ( “It’s a job there is no way around it” (Kain Colter). This Colter led bid, is supported by the United Steelworkers ( With the United Steelworkers by Colter’s side, he is hoping that they can give him the credibility and resources he would need to gain this players labor union. As well as, help set the guidelines of the union.
Kain Colter’s attorney John Adam stated, “Being a football player at northwestern is hard work. And make no mistake, it is work, the wildcats players earn their “compensation” with blood, sweat, and tears” ( Players at Northwestern are feeling like they are giving so much, but not receiving proper benefits and rights. Players would be defined as “temporary employees” because they are only at school and playing football for a finite period of time (Joseph Tilson). Colter then testified that football players are also very comparable to Navy seals because of the amount of preparation and time they are forced to put in before their game or “mission” ( With the rigorous amounts of hours players are forced to put in, this could be very compatrable. With Colter leading the bid he is trying to show that playing football at the collegiate level is a job, that requires mind and body. Colter relating college athletes to employees simply stated, “We must abide by certain rules, and are held to a different standard as oppose to other students that are on campus,” he later again stated, “Players can get their “compensation” taken away, for example their scholarship, playing time, and starting positions” (Kain Colter).
The ex-Northwestern quarterback also stated that he could not pursue his academic dream of becoming an orthopedic surgeon, because academic advisors steered him away from taking Chemistry, due to...

Find Another Essay On College Football Labor Union

Should College Athletes be Paid? Essay

849 words - 4 pages when students with academic scholarships do not even expect to get spending money. Athletes complain about not getting a salary for the sport they participate in, but they do not realize that education acts as another form of payment. It would be too expensive to pay all college athletes. Dennis Johnson, a free-lance writer, exposes most Division II sports drain athletic budgets and do not make a profit. He explains that football and men's

The Argument for Paying NCAA Football Players

2574 words - 11 pages has heated up with concerns over whether college football players are employees or not and thus entitled to pay. Like the O’Bannon case, a group of Northwestern University football players sued the NCAA and won a ruling to allow them to unionize. This means the players’ union would be entitle to collectively bargain with northwestern over players’ benefits. The University of Northwestern immediately filed an appeal against the ruling, while the

Essay on the payment of college players - UNG English 1101 - Argumentative essay

1041 words - 5 pages Duncan 4 Cale Duncan Professor Chris Davis English 1101 MW 4:05-5:20 5 September 2016 Essay #1 College football is one of the most popular sports in the country if not the most popular. As a result of this, football programs are usually the money making sport at almost all of the schools that field a football team. College football is also the main cog in the multi-billion-dollar machine that is the NCAA which has come under controversy for not

Labor Unions

3057 words - 12 pages that men should be paid according to labor performed and not by the color of their skin. This was a valuable lesson and is a good model of forming a union and how blacks could be included in the work force.      The work force around the world has changed, as have the means of production. America is a prime example of these changes internationally. America started with the initial settlers and then indentured servants were

Pay For Play In The NCAA

2856 words - 11 pages realizing the drastic growth of college sports around the nation and the massive turnout these sporting events are creating. This fact only adds to the extensive case that college football players are immensely underpaid. Additionally, while discussing the amount of money generated by these players, Reid Forgrave informs, "Syracuse's new conference, the ACC, recently signing a $3.6 billion television deal. It's unfair to athletes whose labor makes

NFL (National Federation of Lawbreakers?)

2914 words - 12 pages who are not part of the union which participated in negotiations with the NFL, the National Football League Player's Association. The non-statutory labor exemption cannot be used to protect anticompetitive agreements between employers and unions that affect only those not involved in the negotiations.Another subject that plays an important role in the legality of a labor rule is the rule's reasonability. Unreasonable rules are prohibited under

Time To Pay Them

2184 words - 9 pages things. The NCAA should pay college athletes because some believe that playing college sports is considered a job. Cooper also said “it is definitely a job for football and basketball players on athletic scholarships at Division I schools” (Cooper par. 1). College athletes put lots of work in to the sport that they play to where playing college sports is considered a job because this would be considered labor which they must be paid for their

Why pay for play will not work in college athletics

1000 words - 4 pages Paying college athletes has gained national attention over the past few months due to the Northwestern University football team’s challenge to unionize, but it is not a new debate. As early as 1936, “the Howard University football team struck for several games, demanding adequate medical supplies for players, nutritional food, and access to campus jobs”(Fram and Frampton 2). Colleges are responsible for the welfare of their athletes, and through

The current system of collegiate athletics and the NCAA

2615 words - 11 pages departments. By classifying athletes as “amateur student athletes” the college athlete labor market does not fall under federal or state antitrust laws or state workers compensation laws. The NCAA member schools are allowed to set the wage for the student athlete and not give benefits to players who suffer injury. Due to the rewards being bestowed onto the NCAA member schools and not the student athletes who produce the product, this system can be

Pay For Play

1737 words - 7 pages Twitter even when their sport is not in session in a few was this could be construed as un-constitutional. But when going to college as a d1 athlete are you just a way for the N.C.A.A. to make money? With these factors in mind, Division I football and men’s basketball players do not merely play a sport of leisure. Rather, they are core members of their university’s marketing team, as well as the labor force behind a lucrative industry in hosting

The Past, Present and Future of Labor Unions

2270 words - 9 pages general, knowing the roots of it is the best way to start. In this paper, the progress of the labor unions throughout history, the issues faced the developments it achieved, laws passed and the problem faced by today’s unions will be tackled. Table of Contents I. Introduction………………………………………………………….…1 II. Historical Development of Labor Union in the United States a. The first unions………………………………………...…….…2 b. After the Civil War

Similar Essays

National Collegiate Athletic Association Analysis

1119 words - 4 pages deserves more compensation than a single scholarship. The attempt to form a union is amiable and should be passed but, truthfully, it probably won’t, not quite yet. Somethings things that should happen don’t. The “tradition of amateurism” is too strong at the moment but along with many other “traditions” of college football, it is quickly eroding. 42 years ago, freshman weren’t eligible to play. If you would have asked anyone 15 years ago if a

The History Of The Labor Movement Up To The Present

2212 words - 9 pages . N.p., n.d. Web. 28 Apr. 2014. "Facts About Manufacturing in the United States." Facts About Manufacturing, Manufacturing Strategy. National Association of Manufacturers, 2014. Web. 01 May 2014. "Five Labor Leaders Who Improved Conditions for American Workers." N.p., n.d. Web. 28 Apr. 2014. Fowler, Jerem. "Players as Employees? High Costs of College Football Union Is in Millions." Eyeon, 21 Apr. 2014. Web. 27 Apr

The Ncaa And College Athletes: Should College Athletes Be Paid?

1464 words - 6 pages creating a union. Early in 2014 Northwestern University quarterback Kain Colter took the first steps in creating a NCAA recognized players union by appealing to the National Labor Relations Board. In an interview Colter stated "Right now the NCAA is like a dictatorship. No one represents us in negotiations. The only way things are going to change is if players have a union." In a landmark decision the NLRB ruled that the scholarship football players at

College Athletes: Amateurs Or Full Time Employees

2546 words - 11 pages college and because of the games they play and the championships they win. At first the idea of paying college athletes was out of the question, but now the argument has gone from a simple yes or no to a heated debate. Since college athletes are given a free education, they should not also be paid. This argument has reached its peak of debate when Northwestern University football players planned to form a union in order to receive some form of