This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Colonialism And Morality In The Moonstone And The Man Who Would Be King

1403 words - 6 pages

Colonialism and Morality in The Moonstone and The Man Who Would Be King

Let us presuppose to begin with that the cursed jewel is an impossibility and the powers of the Moonstone or any other gem for that matter only exist on an atomic level ( i.e. the energies which bind such objects together and make them what they are). Additionally it should be considered that no such object is the means by which a being exerts powers and no such object consciously exerts powers itself. Notions of the cursed or powerful jewel can be seen as a bi-product of what Said terms “Orientalism.” Said describes “The Orient” as “almost a European invention,” a place of “exotic beings and remarkable experiences.” (Ashcroft et al ed. p.87) This hypothesis adequately compliments Wilkie Collins’ characterisation of the eponymous jewel in The Moonstone and the moral pattern the author forms around its adventures.

In the Nineteenth Century the jewel was the ultimate exotic object, Collins describes the Moonstone as “a yellow diamond- a famous gem in the native annals of India,” (Collins p.33) and clearly credits influence to the Koh-i-Noor in his preface to the novel. Collins builds upon the alien nature of such an object utilising the perceived mysticism of the Orient linking the jewel to a “four handed Indian God” (Collins p.33) [Said’s “exotic being” ?] and superstition, the notion of the jewel “feeling the influence of the deity who adorned it” (Collins p.33) [“remarkable experiences” to Said?]. Collins rapidly develops the exotic object into the cursed object primarily to create a long involving tale with a successfully satisfying denouement. the novel is, of course foremost a detective story; how memorable or lengthy a tale would it have been if the misappropriated object were as English and as homely as say half a crown or a tin of boot polish? The jewel is portrayed as a fascinating invader in the Empire’s heartland, an English country estate, in theory its safest haven. The Moonstone is a narrative device which illuminates the text in multiple ways.

Such a device remains popular in western adventure literature and film, whether in the form of an Egyptian scarab or a monkey’s claw. The mystical object with powerful properties is involved in adventure tales from Conan-Doyle through Indiana Jones, even one of the most famous of modern legends the fates of Carter and Caernarfon excavators of Tutankahmun’s tomb involves a curse and shameful Orientalism. Perhaps the best indicator of such notions becoming part of western folklore is when they become utilised as simple metaphor. This is apparent in John Huston’s 1975 film version of Rudyard Kipling’s The Man Who Would Be King. The desire of the central protagonists; Peachy Carnahan and Daniel Dravitt to become “Kings” of an isolated region of the Indian sub-continent is built upon by the abundance of treasures that becomes available to them, an aspect absent from Kipling’s original tale. Huston’s version increases...

Find Another Essay On Colonialism and Morality in The Moonstone and The Man Who Would Be King

Imperialism and Colonialism in The Tempest

1118 words - 4 pages colonial power between the characters. The island in the Tempest has often been interpreted as the “brave new world” by many critics. There are several occurrences throughout the play that display the desires of all the characters who want to be in charge and have power over others on the island. Prospero, the main character, manipulates everyone around him to achieve his desires of gaining back his dukedom. Caliban, Prospero’s slave and the first

Colonialism and Oppression in the African Diaspora

2248 words - 9 pages black women among the most oppressed groups worldwide. Arguably, the effects which Europe’s global colonialism have had on women of the African diaspora can be most easily seen on the African continent. Kenyan feminist and environmental activist, Wangari Maathai, explores the legacy of colonialism and oppression in her native country through her moving 2006 memoir, Unbowed. Maathai explains that over the course of the nineteenth and early

Colonialism and Oppression in the African Diaspora

1048 words - 5 pages to create infrastructure in African countries. In Togo, for example, a number of hotels, oil refineries, textile factories, and cement plants have emerged in recent years. At first glance, this would seem to be a positive impact of post-colonial interactions between France and Africa; but, the situation beneath the surface is actually quite problematic. Most of the countries responsible for these new industries are of Western origin, meaning

Imperial Resistance in Wilkie Collins's The Moonstone

785 words - 3 pages and colonialism ‘suggests an analogy between imperial and sexual domination’ (Dead Secrets: Wilkie Collins And the Female Gothic. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1972, p.145). The male theft of the moonstone and the threat implied by Rachel’s approaching loss of virginity are equated with the colonial rape of a feminized India --the jewel in the imperial crown. None of the English characters manage to explain the theft of the

The Absence of Morality in King Leopold's Ghost and in the Congo Today

1301 words - 5 pages royalties. Stanley also wrote other books about his adventures in the Congo after the one in which he found Livingstone. This is how the exploitation began. It would continue when King Leopold of Belgium would hire Stanley to travel along the Congo and discover the territory in the name of Belgium and develop the territory into a colony which was his dream ever since he had heard of Stanley's expedition.King Leopold was a leader who was very intelligent

Wilkie Collins "The Moonstone"

7136 words - 29 pages , which adorns the top of the Russian Imperial Sceptre, was once the eye of an Indian idol. The famous Koh-i-Noor is also supposed to have been one of the sacred gems of India; and to add to this, to have been the subject of a prediction of misfortune to the person who would divert it from its ancient uses.The novel begins with the stealing of the Moonstone from the temple. The scene is set in the Indian shrine where the gem adorned the forehead of

Beowulf, the one who will be king

844 words - 3 pages year old man battle a powerful beast rather than risk dying themselves. These men could not even protect their own king, for their cowardice and selfishness took precedence over Beowulf's life.The dragon's existence is a result of its need to be placed there in order to kill the hero. Jung states correctly that as the hero 'enters the mature phase of life, the hero myth loses its relevance. The hero's symbolic death becomes... the achievement of

The colonialism and imperialism in China in the 19th century

895 words - 4 pages government still functioned in much of the same ways as it did under British colonialism. Furthermore, the language of English and British culture highly impacted the society of Hong Kong and Southern China for over a century.By the late 1800s, China is said to be "carved up like a melon" by foreign powers competing for "spheres of influence" on Chinese soil.Basically it was the European nations dividing China into spheres of influence during the

Lord Of The Flies?Who Would Be The Better Leader

889 words - 4 pages , forceful, quick, and violent causing him to be very animal-like. In the harsh, savage environment like nature both would be a good leader; but who would be the best survivor in the long run? A calm, peaceful thinker or a violent hunter who wishes only to survive.Consider if there was no chance for a rescue and the boys had to survive on the island for many decades. Who would be the better leader then? I believe that if there could be no rescue

Prospero's Relationship with Caliban and Colonialism in "The Tempest"

1442 words - 6 pages quite the opposite, an attitude that would've been not only in keeping with Caliban's personality, but the typical native's, too. It is doubtful, however, that any actor would have had the braverism to be so bold about snubbing colonialism in front of no less than the King; the man responsible for the increase in British colonial activity, although it is quite probable that this insincerity was Shakespeare's intention. In conclusion, the Tempest

The Impact of European Colonialism in Turks and Caicos

1561 words - 6 pages opened a resort in Grace Bay. Later on in the 1980’s Club Med funded an upgrade to build a larger airstrip so that larger aircrafts can arrive without trouble. This would also help stimulate the economy because more tourists would be able at one time. Overall, this project helped stimulated the economy growth slowly. Since the new airstrip was built foreign couples that do not live in Turks and Caicos Islands have been selecting the Islands as a

Similar Essays

The Man Who Would Be King

1351 words - 6 pages While The Man Who Would Be King director John Huston may have made an effort to mitigate some of the overwhelmingly imperialist perspectives in his adaptation of Rudyard Kipling's novel, many depictions of the Easterners in his film still have the air of Western superiority. In fact, if Huston had completely removed this aspect of Kipling's tale from the story, the film would no longer be a faithful representation of the original work. The

Racism In The Men Who Would Be King

785 words - 4 pages In the Men Who Would Be King both Peachy and Danny show that they are racist. This is seen in both Hudson’s version of the story and in Kipling’s version of the story. In Kipling’s version of the story there are variations of how racism is displayed, even though Danny and Peachy go into depth on reasons why they are not racist. In Hudson’s version of the story, the men are much more open about their racist comments than in the book. This may

Pride And Prejudice By Jane Austen: Any Man Who Tries To Argue Jane Austen's Ability To Draw Characters Would Be Undoubtedly A Fool, For The Author's Talent In That Area Of Prose Is Hard To Match

1775 words - 7 pages Pride and PrejudiceAny man who tries to argue Jane Austen's ability to draw characters would be undoubtedly a fool, for the author's talent in that area of prose is hard to match. However even the most ardent fans of Austen will have to agree with the fact that the personages she creates are not appealing to every man. An exception to that trend in this reader's opinion would be the character of Mr. Bennet, who by his sharp wit and stark realism

The Moonstone Essay

2062 words - 8 pages vanished as a direct result of the altruism and idealism of Mahatma Ghandi, who saw, as no other leader of his age had done, the necessity for interracial conciliation and transcendent faith if India were to arise from bloody, mutually destructive, strife and take her rightful place in the society of nations. Today, Collins's The Moonstone may be viewed not as a response to a national insurgency and/or European determination to keep the native in