Fighting For The Common Good Essay

1436 words - 6 pages

Mahatma Gandhi and Thomas Aquinas were two of the most influential philosophers of their respective times. Aquinas’s theological ideas on politics, ethics, and natural law have influenced have been a great influence western civilization and he is also held in high regard within the Catholic faith tradition, being honored as a saint. Gandhi was an influential leader in the movement for India’s freedom from British rule. He preached a philosophy of nonviolent civil disobedience and is held as the inspiration for civil rights leaders and non-violent activists around the world. Both philosophers sought to instruct others on how to live a virtuous life and help contribute towards the common good of all people. However, Aquinas and Gandhi hold different views on how their shared goal is to be met. When comparing the two philosophies, one finds that Thomas Aquinas’s philosophy of natural law is superior to Gandhi’s philosophy of Satyagraha since it allows individuals and countries a way to justifiably defend themselves against those who wish to do them harm.
Thomas Aquinas held the view that violence was necessary when it was justified and meant to ensure the common good. Thomas Aquinas’s philosophy can be broken down into one easy to remember phrase, ““Good is to be done and pursued and evil is to be avoided.” All other precepts of the natural law are based on this” (Aquinas I-II.94.2). Aquinas’s bases his entire philosophy around the simple idea that evil should be shunned from individual’s lives and they should instead focus on the good. Yet, Aquinas did foresee that in certain cases, violence and war were necessary to ensure the common good, “Therefore, if a man be dangerous and infectious to the community, on account of some sin, it is praiseworthy and advantageous that he be killed in order to safeguard the common good” (Aquinas II-II.64.2-3). Aquinas even gave detailed instructions on when war was to be pursued. In order for this to occur, three conditions had to be met. The war must be declared by a sovereign authority, it must have a just cause, and the war must advance the common good. Helen Hayden further develops Aquinas’s just war theory as she writes, “Subsuming war under the obligations of neighborly love…requires wars to be undertaken in order to defend one’s own common good as well as the common good of those too powerless to act” (2). Aquinas thought that above all, good must be pursued and evil must be avoided, however, he concluded that violence was sometimes necessary in extreme cases in order to prevent evil.
Gandhi held the view that violence was never justifiable and that in order for one to be victorious over evil, one must be willing to die in order that the enemy can learn the truth. Gandhi took a clear stance on the use of violence, “Whereas the former (Satyagraha) has been conceived as a weapon of the strongest, and excludes the use of violence in any shape or form” (Gandhi 112). Gandhi also stated that one cannot...

Find Another Essay On Fighting for the Common Good

Segregation: Fighting for the Same Rights

1334 words - 6 pages Segregation was very hard to endure to those who were colored in the 1960’s. Segregation was basically a white person making cruel remarks to a colored person or about the colored people in general. Segregation wasn’t just making racist remarks but it made people fight about little events that weren’t worth fighting about. White people would even take the colored to court just for having a nice car or even not addressing a white person as “sir

Private Military Fighting For the US

2173 words - 9 pages ). The US military, besides for a few inside sources does not have the advantage of being able to hire local citizens. The way of war is changing, new technology, new leaders, and new reasons to fight. While we try to keep the fighting down to a minimum, maintaining status quo for private military contracts can help the US remain the strong and powerful nation it is today if need be. They offer vital support, logistics and consulting. Not to

Socialism for the Common Man

2429 words - 10 pages late 1904, Sinclair left for Chicago to tell the story of the poor common workingmen and women unfairly enslaved by the vast monopolistic enterprises. He found that he could go anywhere in the stockyards provided that he “[wore] old clothes… and [carried] a workman’s dinner pail” (Sougstad 553). While Sinclair spent seven weeks in Chicago living amongst and interviewing the Chicago workers, he came upon another discovery—the filth of improper

Analysis of Against the Odds and Against the Common Good

2119 words - 8 pages , instructing the readers to what is right and wrong, but not giving us a reason why. This shows especially at the end of the essay when she says that state legislators who have the best interest of the people would recognize that getting rid of lotteries is for “the common good”. In short, Jimenez makes some good points in her argument, but she only makes 'the point' and doesn’t elaborate on it or back it up with substantial evidence. Readers

Jay Gatsby; The White Knight Fighting for the Fair Maiden

1023 words - 5 pages Jay Gatsby; The White Knight Fighting for the Fair Maiden Courtly love is a fundamental metaphor of Fitzgerald’s, The Great Gatsby, and, therefore, the elusive Jay Gatsby plays out his role as a courtly lover throughout the novel. Gatsby’s abnormal situation with Daisy reflects the metaphor of courtly love. Many of the characteristics used to define courtly love are reflected in Gatsby’s actions. Every choice that he makes is an attempt to win

The ACLU of Pennsylvania: Fighting for the Equality of All

1501 words - 6 pages deal with politics, health, etc. (“PhillyPride…”). One of the most involved and passionate organizations in Philadelphia fighting for LGBT rights, including the right to marry, is the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is a nonprofit, nonpartisan, membership organization founded in 1920 with organization centers and headquarters throughout the nation. The ALCU is dedicated to defending and

Were North American Revolutionaries Fighting For The Rights Of Englishmen ?

2115 words - 8 pages WERE AMERICAN REVOLUTIONARIES FIGHTING FOR THE RIGHTS OF ENGLISHMEN In September 1774 the first Continental Congress met in Philadelphia PA, and after some protracted discussion, issued the Declaration and Resolves of the First Continental Congress. Twelve of the thirteen colonies were present, the exception being Georgia. Discussion centred on the on the perceived infringements of their "rights as Englishmen" as inflicted upon them by the

The Differences Between Fighting Communism for American Presidents

1147 words - 5 pages The Differences Between Fighting Communism for American Presidents Many years passed between the presidential terms of Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan yet the fight against Communism endured. Each president had his unique way of defining the importance of fighting Communism, Nixon attempted to contain the spread of Communism while Reagan tried to transcend it. Nixon succeeded when using intelligent and friendly diplomacy in China and

For the Greater Good

1084 words - 4 pages A wise and frugal government, which shall leave men free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned - this is the sum of good government. Thomas Jefferson In the past, the intent of most House and Senate bills fell pretty much into one of four categories. They addressed routine funding for critical services, they echoed the will of the people, they fixed

For The Greater Good

700 words - 3 pages begets violence. This point can be understood through Gandhi quote: “an eye for an eye will only make the whole world blind”. In other terms if we as a country solve problems through capital punishment it will create a cycle of violence that will cause much greater good than harm. If violence is allowed to be a legal form of punishment within the government then rates of violence will spread throughout the country and violence will become more

Why The Common Core: Benefits for Students

1801 words - 8 pages Zabrial Crocker English Composition II Instructor Giffin Why The Common Core: Benefits for Students February 9, 2014 The Common Core Standards of Mississippi is an excellent way to educate Students in today’s society. This new way of education is believed to be the best method of teaching our young people the skills they will need to know to be successful as they enter into college or the workforce. The Common Core

Similar Essays

Common Core Not For The Common Good

1371 words - 5 pages the Common Core, due to “President Barack Obama’s Race to the Top initiative, which awarded more than $4 billion in federal grants to states that demonstrated a commitment to education reform and innovation. “ ( Golod). Now many states are fighting to get out of Common Core. The majority of the funding for Common Core has come from The Gates Foundation and companies such as Microsoft. Even with funding from the government and Obama’s Race To The

Standing Out For The Common Good

1224 words - 5 pages further. We must also abolish all compulsory subjects; and we must make the curriculum so wide that ‘every boy will get a chance at something’. Even the boy......can be praised and petted for something. Then no boy and no boy’s parents, need feel inferior.” This is a way of making the student feel better about himself. He is, in a sense, pretending to be completely dedicated to persuading the audience how and why democratic education is good

Mill's Utilitarianism, Sacrifice The Innocent For The Common Good?

1209 words - 5 pages . Unfortunately for the decision maker, the information necessaryto make either of these calculations is unavailable.There is no way to determine which people will be killed and weighwhether their deaths would be good for society. Utilitarianism requiresthat one compare the good that the people would do for society with theharm they would do society if they were not killed. For example, if ayoung Adolf Hitler were in the building, it might do more

Fighting For The Philippines Essay

728 words - 3 pages The Philippines was colonized by the Spanish in 1564. After much fighting with the Spanish the Philippines established the first Philippine Republic but this victory was short lived. The Spanish lost control of the Philippines after the Spanish-American war in the Treaty of Paris (1898). The Philippines were given to the Americans for $20 million by the Spanish. The United States were then considering to annex the Philippines because they felt