Combat Sports In The Ancient World: General Aspects Of Ancient Combat Sports

2688 words - 11 pages

Following Poliakoff’s introduction to the ancient combat sports, he proceeds to provide a basic outline to the world of ancient combat sports in a series of sections within the chapter, including: The definition of a ‘combat sport’ and its relation to recreation and training; similarities amongst combat sports, training methods and common practise; the premise of athletic festivals, and the organization of said competition.
The first area that Poliakoff studies is ‘General aspects of the ancient combat sports’ is the definition of a combat sport, which he splits into two explanations. Firstly, the idea of sport or athletics, Poliakoff believes, is an “activity in which a person physically competes against another in contest with established regulations and procedures, with the immediate object of succeeding in that contest under criteria for determining victory that are different from those that mark success in everyday life”. Furthermore, he explains that sport cannot exist without opponents and the measurement of success or failure, and that most forms of physical recreation could become athletic competition when performances begin to be compared. Following on from this line of thought, Poliakoff excludes a number of forms of combat under these conditions: fencing, armed duelling and gladiatorial events.
This stating of terms of the definition of sport is arguably the most prominent of arguments in this chapter. As Donald Kyle, author of Sport and Spectacle, rightly suggests, some may indeed question his approach to the exclusion of fencing, duelling and gladiatorial combat. Whilst other reviewers such as Stephen Instone comment on Poliakoff’s general lack of argument, and some just waive this chapter as satisfactory, Allen Guttmann focuses a little more of his review on Poliakoff’s definition.
Although Guttmann does note Poliakoff’s relegation of the discussion of gladiatorial combat to the appendix as a means to make things easier to manage, the reasoning behind the exclusion from the definition of a combat sport does throw up a number of flags; “gladiator fighting to kill or disable his opponent and save himself in any manner possible is not participating in a sport but in a form of warfare for spectators.” The ‘form of warfare for spectators’, I feel, does not sufficiently explain the exclusion. Combat sports and warfare for spectators are not necessarily mutually exclusive, and the opinions of the difference between them are variable on the opinion of the spectator or competitor.
Furthermore, Guttmann suggests that “Poliakoff’s stipulation that the criteria for determining victory in sports must be “different from those that mark success in everyday life”...one can nevertheless assert that the rules...were sufficiently different from the rules of war...to allow us to distinguish the two forms of combat.” Combat sports in the modern world benefit much greater from this definition, considering the rules of modern warfare don’t hold...

Find Another Essay On Combat Sports in the Ancient World: General Aspects of Ancient Combat Sports

The Breakdown of Women in Combat Situations

1269 words - 5 pages and combat missions might be put at risk by service members who cannot meet the demands of the battlefield, the military must be able to choose those most able to survive, fight, and win.All the debate in the world won't settle the issue of whether or not letting women or men fight together will strengthen or weaken our Armed Forces. Basically, it would have to be tried. As the saying goes, "run it up the flagpole and see who salutes it."

The Athenian Constitution Using the book by the same name by Aristotle, this is a general paper summarizing(for the most part) the development of the constitution adopted by the ancient Greeks

716 words - 3 pages Through a succession of so called "champions" the Athenian constitution developed into a system of government that represented the people and that the people could hold accountable. This was brought about by dispersing the tribes, the creation of a representative government, and limiting the abilities of the top governing officials. All of these factors resulted in a model of government similar to those used by many nations today.An important

Comparison of Civilizations in the Ancient World

1072 words - 4 pages achieving political order and refining human character. In conclusion, early civilizations were similar in geographic requirements but strayed away from each in other aspects of writing, religion, and social structure. Certain qualities of the layout and location of the civilization provided different advantages which created various adaptions of each civilizations way of life. The result of these adaptions formed the foundation of each society and persuaded a certain way of life most comfortable with the inhabitants of each civilization. Works Cited Duiker, W., & Spielvogel, J. (2010). World history: To 1500. (6th ed.). New York, New York: Wadsworth.

Deviance in the World of Sports

2414 words - 10 pages Introduction There have been many studies geared towards sports, and sports violence or deviance. Many theorists contemplate what causes athletes to be violent. Within sports there are various types of violence such as player on player, coach and fan violence. When professional athletes act violently on or off the field it leaves an impression on the viewers in our world of entertainment. There are many forms of deviance in sports

Dreams in the Ancient World

2960 words - 12 pages are interpreted according to the party dream of well known will be great, dream of poor will be insignificant. So we can it is hard to specify dream in general because the interpretation matters on the dreamer. After discussing the dream of ancient world we will see the dreams of new world of dream research. The new world of research discusses what dream is in new world, what happens when dreams are moved in to the laboratory m new facts about

The World Of Ancient Persia

1771 words - 7 pages In the sixth century B.C, the land that we now call Iran was the center of the largest empire in the world. The kings of Ancient Persia( such as Cyrus the Great) were the leaders of a great civilization that made amazing advances in laws, goverment and communication. Founded in 550 B.C by King Cyrus the Great, the Persian Empire spanned from Egypt in the west to Turkey in the north, and through Mesopotamia to the Indus River in the east. Unlike

Religions of the Ancient World

693 words - 3 pages Dipti Budhrani Mr. Yurchak American Literature 20 February 2014 Religions of the Ancient World Religion is an ever-growing idea that has no set date of origin. Throughout history religion has served as an answer to the questions that man could not resolve. The word religion is derived from the Latin word “religio” meaning restraint in collaboration with the Greek word “relegere” which means to repeat or to read again. Religion is currently

Summary of the Ancient World

3220 words - 13 pages . The Buddha, a man of deep understanding and deep sympathy and compassion, had said that all men are equal in their common destiny, so he opposed the idea of castes. His followers carried this principal of social equality throughout southern Asia, and caused both political troubles and enlightened political progress in many ancient states. An example of this was when Emperor Asoka was enlightened and gave up war and violence, sought peace with his people and with his neighbors, and set up for India what later came to be viewed as a Golden Age. You could say that Buddhism was the way to peace of mind, and to peace of the world, which ended up being some parts of Asia.

The Pro's and the Con's of Women Serving in Combat

1182 words - 5 pages Sue WaggonerProfessor KeeneEnglish 130216 September 2003The Pro's and the Con's of Women Serving in CombatWhether or not women should be allowed in combat is a question that rests in the minds of many Americans today. Although women are allowed to serve in the military they are still not allowed to serve in combat; why is that? Is it because today women are still not viewed as equal adversaries? These days and times, what exactly is combat? Is

The Birth of Religions and Philosophies in the Ancient World

1315 words - 5 pages The Birth of Religions and Philosophies in the Ancient World From the beginning of time, people all over the world have wondered where we come from, what our divine purpose in life is, and what we can expect after death. Questions about right and wrong, society and government, and nature and the cosmos, are some of the few wonders that ultimately created some of the earliest philosophies and religions, helping people find peace and explanation

Survival of an Ancient Sport, in the New World

917 words - 4 pages In one of the great European countries, Ireland, a sport so loved by its people has existed for many centuries. This sport is known as Gaelic football. It is one of Irelands most popular native sports. Gaelic football has had many changes made to it since it was first founded, which these changes are still practiced today. Gaelic football has a unique set of playing rules that sets it apart from any other sport played around the world. Gaelic

Similar Essays

History Of The Peloponnesian War, Written By Thucydides, Is A Work That Concerns Many Aspects Of This Long Combat

1448 words - 6 pages History of the Peloponnesian War, written by Thucydides, is a work that concerns many aspects of this long combat. One of its sections includes the speech made by Pericles in honor of the soldiers fallen in the battlefield. Greeks took the process of the burial very seriously - there were rigid rules as to how to conduct a proper funeral. The eulogy given by a figure of some prominence and authority was an essential part of it. In History of the

Yoga For Sports Performance Why This Ancient Discipline Has Become The Latest Cross Training Tool To Enhance Athletic Performance And Reduce The Risk Of Injury

599 words - 2 pages The practice of yoga was first developed in India and has evolved over thousands of years. Yoga disciples use poses, or asanas, to prepare their bodies for meditation practice-much as an athlete would prepare for a sports competition. The poses also serve as a means to alter one's consciousness and mental focus in the spiritual quest for "enlightenment." In essence, yoga is designed to bring body, mind, and spirit into balance (Hollingshead 30

Debate: Is There Violence In Sports? This Debate Covers The Aspects Of Violent Behaviors That Occur On The Playing Field And Off. This Debate Covers The Pro Side Of The Argument

596 words - 2 pages plays a big part in sports violence. Because of the mass exposure that sports are given in our society, athletes are given plenty of publicity to the public eye. According to the Daily Aztec Editorial:"The cycle works something like this: A talented athlete enters pro sports world filled with other talented athletes. The pressure cooker of pro sports causes rookies to publicly vent out frustrations during games or rookies look to make names for

Evolution Of The Engineer In Combat

1834 words - 7 pages (“March 11,” 2014). One such officer was Brigadier General Louis Lebègue Duportail. General Duportail was recruited by Benjamin Franklin in France, due to his engineering expertise with fortifications. General Duportail is credited with securing the site at Valley Forge during the winter months, which allowed for successful training of soldiers in combat skills while they waited out the harsh winter. Even though Brigadier General Duportail