Comercial And Business Law Questions Essay

3604 words - 15 pages

Question (1a)
Directors’ duties are to act within powers, promote success of company and avoid conflict of interest.
Tracey had breached her contract as a director of the business. Under Companies Act (CA) 2006, this act places directors’ duties on a statutory basis although there are common law rules we can also refer to and further guidance can be gained via the case law. Directors’ duties are enforceable in the same way as any other fiduciary duty owed to a company by its directors and remedies available may include: damages or compensation where the company has suffered loss; restoration of the company’s property; an account of profits made by the director; and rescission of a contract where the director failed to disclose an interest. It should be noted that the previous does not apply to the duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence under s.174, which is not considered to be a relating to the relationship between a trustee and the person or body for whom the trustee acts duty. Section 175 of the Act specifically deals with the duty to avoid conflicts of interest. The section makes clear that a conflict of interest may, in particular, arise when a director makes personal use of information, property or opportunities belonging to the company.
Directors do have the option to approve a conflict of interest under s.175, and this preserves the ability of the members of a company to authorise conflicts that would otherwise be a breach of this duty. Applying the rules to the facts of the problem scenario it can be seen that Des has beached his statutory duty under CA 2006 s.175 by allowing a conflict of interest to arise without declaring it to the board and getting the approval of the other directors or indeed the members Regal Hastings Ltd v Gulliver (1942).

The case of Regal Hastings demonstrates the application of the duty of conflict of interest where directors failure to declare profits that were made due by using company information and opportunities was seen as a breach of S175. However in Regal the directors were still part of the Company and in this case scenario Tracey has left the organisation. This raises the important question of the extension of the conflict of interest duty to Directors once they leave the organisation, is there still an obligation to abide by this rule? Following the ruling in IDC it can be seen Mr Cooley was seen as liable under S175 even though he had left, as he took advantage of a corporate opportunity that only came to him due to his work at IDC. Hence once Mr Cooley left the courts felt that this duty did still apply as it was an advantage he gained whilst he was at IDC.

In contrast the case of Island Export may be a ruling that will work in Tracey’s favour. In Island Export the Company had rejected the opportunity to take the contract and therefore when the director who had left the organisation had taken up the opportunity there was no liability. Hence applying this ruling to Tracey...

Find Another Essay On Comercial and Business Law Questions

Contract Law - Questions regarding the UCC and UCITA

612 words - 2 pages The Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act and the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act that govern electronic business arose out of concern the skyrocketing popularity of e-commerce and its processes put e-commerce outside the boundaries of traditional contract law (Cheeseman, 2006). UCITA is "intended to bring the same uniformity and certainty to the rules that apply to information technology transactions that the Uniform Commercial Code

Business Law and Repetitive Strain Injury

2444 words - 10 pages Statistics, Annual Report 2005 (CM6799) (London, the Stationery Office, 2006) Claims An employee who is injured at work can make a claim under civil law, alleging the employer has breached its duty of care to provide a safe work place. The employer is legally responsible for the injury, in terms of both tort of negligence and/or breach of statutory duty. RSI claims are seemingly rising and reported to have cost business employers £300

Business Law - Contract Dispute and Negotiation

889 words - 4 pages dispute seems to be moving from amicable agreement into the realm of adversarial dispute.ReferencesCheeseman, H. R. (2004). Business law: Legal, e-commerce, ethical and international environments (5th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.Eavis, P. (2007, October 1). Sallie Mae's high-stakes standoff. Fortune Magazine, 2007, October. Retrieved October 1, 2007, from

Australian Law and Business - case study

2464 words - 10 pages the Legal position under the Contract Law regarding the above situation and followed by relevant recommendations.Legal position under the Law of ContractFirst, we will look into whether there is a valid contract between Jack and Albert.Jack is a taxi driver and he is stationed at the Toowoomba Railway Station for picking up passenger at the material time. As Jack and Albert do not know each other, and Albert did not make any appointment with

Questions and Answers to Lincoln Electric case study by Harvard Business School

858 words - 3 pages system to other countries and the utilization of management controls to monitor it.*External: It was unreasonable to expect, considering the extensive experience with the US labor markets and the period of time required to customize the incentive system to fit a very specific culture, that it could be instantaneously transferred to a different business environment. It is clear that the rewards offered through the incentive plan did not have the same

Business Management questions and answers

635 words - 3 pages 1. What is the fundamental goal of business? Do all organizations share this goal?The fundamental goal of business is to earn a profit. Not all organizations share this goal because they are nonprofit organizations.2. Name the forms a product may take and give some examples of each.The forms a product may take are tangible and intangible. Tangible goods are computers, clothing, automobiles, and food. Intangible goods are services or ideas made

Business Management Questions And Answers

839 words - 4 pages things less expensive.4. How do political issues affect international business?Political issues affect international business by it helps to sell products overseas.5. What is an import tariff? A quota? Dumping? How might a country use import tariffs and quotas to control its balance of trade and payments? Why can dumping result in the imposition of tariffs and quotas?An import tariff is a tax made by the nation on goods imported into the country. A

Business Management questions and answers

664 words - 3 pages 1. What is information technology? How has technology influenced the economy?Information technology is the process and applications that create new methods to solve problems, perform tasks, and manage communication. Technology has influenced the economy by it has been a driving force in advancing the economic systems and the quality of our lives.2. Define data, knowledge, and information. Why is information important in business?Data is

Business Law and Ethics Can the Issue of Profitability and Ethics Be Balanced Against Each Other

918 words - 4 pages BUSINESS LAW AND ETHICS.Can the issue of profitability and ethics be balanced against each other:Businesses in today's world is a major part of everyday life some corporate are even larger than many economies of the world thus the businesses have a responsibility towards the very society in which they carry out their operations. This is known as corporate social responsibility according to (Kotler year missing)"corporate social responsibility is

P7 and M3 of BTEC Business Lvl3 Yr2 (Law module ) - Btec Buisness - Essay

2910 words - 12 pages damages that they may face throughout the contract. Furthermore, another advantage of liquidated damages would be both Jack and the supplier could settle any dispute regarding losses or damages without having to bring it to a court of law. For example, if Jack were to cancel the contract he may offer to pay for the kitchen even though he doesn’t want it, so that the business can regain as much of their losses as possible. Disadvantages of Liquidated

Example Law Exam - Monash University - Questions and Answers

978 words - 4 pages the contract upon a breach of a condition by David? Defining condition Test of condition: Tramway and Associated Newspapers Law on time stipulation in the contract Conclusion: Termination of K and refusal to accept delivery justified Question 1: Part B The issue: what are the options available to John upon David’s repudiation of the contract? Anticipatory breach: Foran v Wright Repudiation: Laurinda, Bowes v Chalayer

Similar Essays

Business Law Questions Essay

1143 words - 5 pages official reports continues will this alter the appellate process? Should it?A. In my opinion it will alter the appellate process, but not by much, because appellate courts look at questions of law and procedure; in other words, it concerns the application or interpretation of the law and whether it was carried out properly by the trial judge or by a jury. On questions of fact, it can affect the process in the way that the appellate court is now looking

Business And Law Essay

1611 words - 6 pages Author' Last Name PAGE 1 [The Author's Name][The Professor's name][The Course Title][Date]Business Law and Product LiabilityProduct liability law has evolved from two bodies of law: contracts and torts. Contract law provides the rules for ascertaining the legal responsibilities of parties to formal agreements, including contracts for the sale of goods. Tort law provides the rules for determining whether a person has acted negligently towards

Business And Company Law Essay

2875 words - 12 pages reasonable, for instance the dissatisfaction must be provided bona fide and therefore the employee can have no authority to dispute the dismissal. According to Industrial Law, an employee has the entitlement to challenge the termination in industrial adjudication when he/she is terminated for the breach of conduct on complaints made against her standard of performance during the probationary period. (D’Cruz, 1998) In Muru case, the administration

Agency Law And Business Entities Essay

2434 words - 10 pages laws are referred to as agency laws.Barnes, Dwarkin, and Richards (2003) stated Agency law addresses three basic but fundamental questions:1.What duties do a principal and an agent owe each other?2.What is the liability of the principal and the agent on contracts made by the agent?3.When is the principle liable for the torts of the agent?Answering these questions is critical for clarity in business transactions that occur between two entities. These