Comment Of “Active And Passive Euthanasia”

613 words - 3 pages

“Active and Passive Euthanasia,” by James Rachels, makes a strong case over the doctrine permitting certain Euthanasia’s. This doctrine, adopted by the “House of Delegates of the American Medical Association” in 1973 (p. 302), states that, it is permissible for doctors to withhold medical treatment allowing a patient to die, but it is never permissible to take direct actions designed to kill the patient. Rachels disputes against this doctrine. Rachels’ core arguments is against the dispute that killing, in itself, is worse than letting die (p.302). Many prohibitionists believe there are important moral differences between active and passive euthanasia. But is there? While one is considered murder, the other is letting nature pan out. Rachels argument suggests this claim invalid. Recall Rachels example of two cousins in sticky situations. The author explains a circumstance in which a man, Smith, is in line for a hefty inheritance behind his 6 year old cousin. Overpowered by greed, Smith enters a restroom where the child is bathing, and drowns the child making it look like an accident (p.304). In a different version, Jones is also in line for a substantial inheritance but the 6 year old is still in his way. When headed to murder the child, luck strikes Jones, and he witnesses his cousin slip and fall hitting his head. Jones excitedly watches the six year old struggle face down until he drowns from personal injuries (p.304). Rachels argues that in neither situation would the men be able to stand up to a court of law stating that, “if the difference between killing and letting die were in itself a morally important matter, one should be able to say that Jones's behavior was less reprehensible than Smith's” (p.305) However, in this case watching the child drown is as ruthless as physically drowning the child. His argument proves that there is...

Find Another Essay On Comment of “Active and Passive Euthanasia”

Conversion Efficiency of Active Energy and Solar Energy

826 words - 3 pages electrical energy in two ways - using photovoltaic materials which generate an electrical potential when exposed to light or using a thermal process that uses the energy from the sun to heat a working fluid in an electricity generating cycle. Another way of looking at it is as passive and active solar energy. Now you might be wondering what is meant by active and passive, isn’t all transformation of energy active? Passive solar energy relates to

Po's and Con's of Euthanasia Essay

712 words - 3 pages “The term Euthanasia derived from the Greek word meaning “good death” It is the act or practice of ending the life of a person either by lethal injection or the suspension of medical treatment. Because of this, many view euthanasia as simply bringing relief by alleviating pain and suffering. The word has also been applied to situations when a decision is made to refrain from exercising "heroic" measures in an end-of-life situation.” (Alliance

Ethics and Morality of Euthanasia

2233 words - 9 pages Outline I. Introduction II. Euthanasia III. Patients Right to Die IV. Legal Issues With Euthanasia V. Nursing Attitudes Toward Euthanasia VI. Contributing Factors for Nurses VII. Conclusion Ethics and Morality of Euthanasia Luke Westphal NSG 316 H003 February 24, 2007 The role of a healthcare professional is a very trying role. Nurses and doctors alike are faced with difficult decisions everyday that interfere with their own personal beliefs and

The Pros and Cons of Euthanasia

1640 words - 7 pages . a painful, disease or condition."# Euthanasia can be traced back as far back as the ancient Greek and Roman civilizations. It was sometimes allowed in these civilizations to help others die. There are many forms that Euthanasia can take. Euthanasia can active voluntary, passive voluntary, active involuntary or passive involuntary. Voluntary euthanasia was approved in some ancient societies. Today, the practice of euthanasia causes great

Euthanasia a Controversial and of Risky Practice

1728 words - 7 pages comes to the cons. Christians believe that taking a life would be interfering with God’s plan for all living beings. This makes the Christians against passive euthanasia ("debate.org"). Along with the many cons of euthanasia there are many pros that need to be taken into account. These pros can also be categorized into legal and personal beliefs. One source claims that the right to die is protected by the same constitutional safe guards that protect

Why volcanoes become active and passive from the different perspectives of authors. How people have made up stories in order to understand the reasons on how volcanoes became active

928 words - 4 pages Volcanoes and its Associated FolkloreVolcanoes tremble, rumble, explode, and rip themselves apart destroying acres of land, millions of homes and killing thousands of people. For centuries people around the world were powerless to understand the earth's convulsions and ability to cause such horrific destruction. Looking for explanations, stories were conjured up of superhuman forces, folklore and myths as a conclusion to why this natural

Looking at the Rights and Wrongs of Euthanasia

1039 words - 4 pages Looking at the Rights and Wrongs of Euthanasia In my essay I will look at the rights and wrongs of euthanasia and look at it from the points of two different major religious groups. The first religion I will look at is Christianity. Christians believe that euthanasia is wrong because each persons suffering is caused because God believes that person has done something wrong and deserves to be punished. The second

Pro Euthanasia in Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men

1001 words - 4 pages The Ultimate Gift-Euthanasia Prompt: Defend or challenge the notion that George's act of killing Lennie was one of kindness In John Steinbeck's classic novella, Of Mice and Men, George makes the decision of killing Lennie because he knows it is in Lennie's best interest. His act of killing Lennie is not considered criminal. George has good intentions in killing his companion. George is trying to prevent Lennie from being tortured and

Comment closely on act III scene III of Shakespeare's "THE TEMPEST" and show its relevance to the whole play

961 words - 4 pages find, and the sea mocks our frustrate search on land. Well, let him go". The description of their futile search as "frustrate" could mean that the fruitlessness of their search makes him frustrated. His comment on the mocking of the sea, shows that he is in despair for the sea looked on as they searched on land, knowing(the sea) very well that it(the sea) had taken Ferdinand. With this tone and these comments, Antonio creates a mood of sorrow and

Learning Style inventory and MBTI and the usefulness of them in a business. It is also based on my concrete experiences, active experience, reflective observations, abstract experiences.

1949 words - 8 pages continue to learn until I am and old person.I feel that learning is an important part of ones life.4. Active ExperimentationBy continually facilitating motivation and encouragement to a child, the childwill continue to learn and advance. In another situation teachers can rewardtheir students for making good grades, therefore encouraging them to learn.The resources and the knowledge that I have gained from the reading in thetextbook, group

Euthanasia argumentive essay. Discusses both the positives and negative aspects of it.

2104 words - 8 pages these pleading sufferers are asking for an end to something that most people need not experience. Two types of euthanasia are passive, to die by way of discontinuation of life supportive devices, and active, to die by taking physician prescribed medication that will cause death.The issue of Euthanasia has both haunted and satisfied many people when dealing with a loved one concurring with a terminal illness. So should there be a continuous stoppage

Similar Essays

Active Euthanasia Pros And Cons Essay

4296 words - 17 pages Abstract Euthanasia is a long debated topic, going back for decades in our country alone. Both sides of the topic have valid points morally and ethically. The Netherlands have had euthanasia laws in effect since 1973. America has very few states with legislation on the books: Oregon enacted in 1997, Washington 2008. Germany experimented with Active Euthanasia in the 1930’s, resulting in one of the most horrendous genocides in the past

Active Euthanasia, Free Will And Autonomy

2102 words - 8 pages Active Euthanasia, Free Will and Autonomy "Medicine in the hands of a fool has always been poison and death." -C. J. Jung Euthanasia, from the Greek, quite literally means "the good death." Advocates of euthanasia, offer it as a solution for the emotional, psychological and physiologic suffering of terminally ill patients. The type of euthanasia, which is presently under debate, is called "active euthanasia" and is defined as an act

Analysis Of An Author's Argument For Active Euthanasia

1011 words - 4 pages An Author's Argument for Active Euthanasia"Active and Passive Euthanasia," by James Rachels, takes on the argument of using euthanasia to kill the suffering patient, or, instead, letting the patient willingly die on his own. The type of argument presented is a position because James Rachels takes on the position as an advocate of active euthanasia. His claim is explicitly stated because he argues that "killing is not in itself any worse than

Physician Assisted Suicide And Voluntary Active Euthanasia: A Closer Look

2456 words - 10 pages give the reader a very clear understanding of the terms. In doing so, I shall employ two arguments (involving linguistic impression) to explain there is no difference between active and passive euthanasia and almost no difference between VAE and PAS (although there is one). In my final third argument, I shall address why PAS is easier to defend morally than VAE, and why VAE should only be performed where PAS is not applicable. Then I will discuss