This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Commentary On Peter Singer´S Practical Ethics And His View On Abortion

1133 words - 5 pages

The goal of this essay is to summarize Peter Singer’s opinion on the moral approach of abortion, which is describes in his book Practical Ethics. His goal is to clarify and provide a clear-cut answer to what is generally thought as a moral debate with no solution. To him, the subject of abortion is far from being so, as the ethical problem has wrongly been approached.
Singer first points out that the different opinions on abortion come from the debate on when a human life actually begins. He formulates the common argument against abortion as follows: it is wrong to kill an innocent human being; a human fetus is an innocent human being; therefore, it is wrong to kill a human fetus. It is because killing a human being is undoubtedly wrong and immoral that the opposition instead attempts to deny the second part of the argument “a human fetus is an innocent human being”. By doing so, critics argue that the fetus does not have the status of a human being. This debate results in focusing on whether, or when, the fetus can be considered a human being, and therefore given the same rights against being killed as another human being. Singer however claims that it is difficult to find a moral dividing line between a fetus and a human being because the development of the human egg to a child is gradual. To prove his point, he describes four commonly proposed moral lines (birth, viability, quickening, and consciousness), which he then denies with strong arguments.
On the first stage, birth would not be a plausible line because it is so arbitrary. In fact, we are sympathetically inclined towards a newborn baby because we can touch and see it; it however creates favoritism over a fetus. Also, he argues that there should not be a difference between a baby that is almost in term and a newborn baby, because they are very similar to one another; the only difference is their location in and out of the mother’s body. The second stage is viability, which is the time where the fetus would be capable of living outside of the womb if it were obligated to. Singer argues that viability is not a defined moment in pregnancy; it in fact varies according to medical access and advances in different countries. He gives the example of a 6-month-old prematurely born fetus, which would have much more chances of survival in an advance medical city, rather than in a small village in New Guinea. So would it be morally accepted for a woman from New York to fly to New Guinea and get an abortion, but immoral for her to get it in her own city? Opposition responds that the dependency of the fetus to its mother for survival removes its rights of life independently of the mother’s wishes. However, this claim implies that any human being dependent on another would give away their right to live, which is absurd. Singer concludes that the fetus’ dependence on its mother does not give her the right to kill it. The third stage Singer discusses is...

Find Another Essay On Commentary on Peter Singer´s Practical Ethics and his View on Abortion

Marquis´View on Abortion and Euthanasia Essay

977 words - 4 pages is not more important than another, no matter how old they are or whether or not they have been born yet. Therefore the loss of any life is tragic and even though we usually abort a fetus in the early months of pregnancy, we should treat it as strongly as we treat the killing of an adult. Although his stance on euthanasia is related to this topic, his views and ideas differ slightly from his views on abortion in several ways. First off, he is

Karl Marx and His View on Religion

1390 words - 6 pages Karl Marx and His View on Religion Karl Marx, the founder and main advocator of his Marxist philosophy, wrote the Communist Manifesto in 1848. This document was the basis for all of his thoughts and ideas of the world at the time being. One of the major topics that he spoken on was how religion affected the society and how it was an institution that was not actually necessary to exist. Marxist

Peter Singer and Moral Decisions

936 words - 4 pages responsibilities should remain same regardless of other people's opinions. And these obligations must be based on my personal financial health and should not have to increase or decrease in order to compensate for other's lack of response. Peter Singer advocates a demanding and severe philosophy where morality is based on personal responsibility. Though his arguments sound convincing when taken in context to the thought experiments, but are they practical

Commentary on Nietzche´s Philosophy about God and Humanity

1036 words - 5 pages base their objections on a misperceived threat to their unwavering doctrine of religious faith. To make this evident, we begin with one of philosophy’s most argumentative, yet widely misunderstood quotes. It was in 1882 when Nietzsche first suggested that God is dead in his book The Gay Science. “God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him. How shall we comfort ourselves, the murderers of all murderers? What was holiest and mightiest of

Brief Commentary on Jane Austen´s Pride and Prejudice

917 words - 4 pages and walks about Netherfield, and dodges opportunities to encounter him. All of Elizabeth’s preconceived notions are incorrect, for Mr. Darcy realizes that he slowly falling in love. Still, his pride keeps him from truly pursuing her hand. Unfortunately, Elizabeth encounters the suave Mr. Wickham, who fuels her prejudice with several surprising lies about how Mr. Darcy ruined his life. Later on, Jane and Elizabeth hear that the inhabitants of

Society’s View on Abortion, Euthanasia and the Death Penalty

1692 words - 7 pages they wanted to have an abortion. I am not against the right to die with dignity. My nephew died this past Thanksgiving Day, after 37 years of pain and suffering from Sickle Cell Disease. The last three months had been really tough on him and his immediate family; his heart had begun to fail, his kidneys started shutting down and he was in constant pain. I really felt helpless when we could not help him except to visit him in the hospital

Commentary on Steven Spielberg´s Lincoln

1482 words - 6 pages Steven Spielberg proves to his audience yet again his mastery and skill in the cinematic arts in his 2012 historical drama, Lincoln. Spielberg's directing experience, accompanied by a convincing portrayal of Abraham Lincoln, the sixteenth president of the United States, by Daniel Day-Lewis provides the people with a film stocked with emotion, suspense, and triumph. However, as with most films based on historical events and figures, Spielberg

Sex selection - a commentary on ethics

918 words - 4 pages against the law to pick and choose the sex of the baby to be. Under the current law people can be charged $200,000 or be jailed for up to five years if they decide to do this.Sex selection is wrong, it is discrimination based on gender. Why should individuals have the right to choose who gets born and which types of lives are acceptable? In traditional patriarchal societies, such as India and China, the preference for boys has led to huge imbalances

Thoreau´s View on Nature and Human Necessities

1495 words - 6 pages compares a farmer on the farm to a prisoner in chains. He calls it working harder than necessary for subsistence that shackles people. Thoreau believes in lessening one’s needs. Thoreau suggests that living in the woods is less work, and it is less expensive. Thoreau identifies this type of living as freedom and uncommitted. He felt so free that he decided not to pay his taxes and went to jail for a day. Thoreau states how he never found any

Commentary on Margaret Atwood´s A Handmaid´s Tale

1607 words - 7 pages pollution and chemical spills led to declining fertility rates, the architects of Gilead assassinated the president and members of Congress and launched a coup, cracked down on women’s rights, and forbidding women to hold property or jobs. The main character, which is named Offred later, attempted to flee across the border into Canada, but they were caught and separated from one another and has never seen each other again. After her capture

Analysis and Commentary on Bill Gate´s Article: How to Fix Capitalism

1364 words - 6 pages After having read through Bill Gates’ article “How To Fix Capitalism”, I agreed completely with the various ideas Bill Gates states and I believe that creative capitalism can and should be an effective way to make the world as a whole a better place overall. In the following essay I am going to attempt my hand at explaining the current situation, explaining some of the background that brought us to this situation, expound on what a government

Similar Essays

Commentary On Lorber´S Night To His Day”: The Social Construction Of Gender

950 words - 4 pages As Lorber explores in her essay “Night to His Day”: The Social Construction of Gender, “most people find it hard to believe that gender is constantly created and re-created out of human interaction, out of social life, and is the texture and order of that social life” (Lorber 1). This article was very intriguing because I thought of my gender as my sex but they are not the same. Lorber has tried to prove that gender has a different meaning

An Essay On Peter Singer, The Author Of Famine, Affluence, And Morality

639 words - 3 pages Peter Singer, the author of Famine, Affluence, and Morality, attempts to distinguish between obligation and charitable motivations. He tries to show that wealthy people should do more to help the people of the world who are needy and suffering from famine. Many people think that giving to famine relief is a good deed, but is optional. Singer believes it is mandatory and morally justified for the fortunate to help the deprived as much as possible

Judaism's View On Abortion Essay

1112 words - 4 pages Judaism's View on Abortion There are many different views on abortion and rabbis have given their opinions over the centuries. The Bible asserts that G-d created all things, but the issue of abortion depends on when life begins in the womb. Read Exodus 21 verses 22 - 23. What does this passage tell us about the mother's life and the unborn child's rights

Buddhist View On Abortion Essay

678 words - 3 pages number of devoted Catholics and defended by at least a few. As a Buddhist, I would most likely still be for abortion. Buddhism itself speaks with more than one moral voice on this issue against abortion. The core belief in Buddhism is against abortion, but there are commonly people of this religion that don’t agree with that. For the time in which I will be writing this essay, I am one of those people. Most of my fellow Buddhists believe in the