Commentary On Stanley Fish's "How To Recognize A Poem When You See One"

914 words - 4 pages

Hersh PatelAP English14 September 2003Commentary on Stanley Fish Article"How to Recognize a Poem When You See One"Stanley Fish, in his inductive essay "How to Recognize a Poem When You See One", argues that the process of "distinguishing" certain "features" of an object follows "the act of recognition". Fish offers such conclusions from a short anecdote, which illustrates an analytical response of a group of students to five names he writes on a board. The students, who focus on Christian symbols and Biblical allusions, spontaneously analyze and extract meaning from the list. The story exemplifies Fish's theory that "all objects are made not found". Fish also concludes that interpreters "find" poems, not by the poem's "distinguishing features", but by the knowledge of poems the interpreters possess; he believes that "interpreters do not decode poems; they make them". The differences an interpreter sees in certain objects result from the "different interpretive operations" he or she performs and not from "something inherent in one or another". As Fish states, the interpreter derives this knowledge of operations from "a publicly available system of intelligibility," or, in other words, from sources of education, such as books, teachers, and "producers" of literature. The interpreter's thoughts, in essence, are the products of the quality, quantity, and focus of the source of intelligibility. In absence of this "public source", an individual's interpretation becomes prone to objectivity and subjectivity since his or her "meanings" of a text become independent of those of the "social construct".Fish's theory that "all objects are made", "not found", through "interpretive strategies" arouses skepticism as to its validity during certain circumstances. The theory itself explains that interpreters of poetry "make" the poem, that students "make" the assignment, and that they create such objects through the "source of intelligibility", or the interpretive strategies of a public source. In other words, an individual's knowledge, which he or she gains through public resources, allows him or her to identify an object by merely believing that the object exists as a certain identity, not by the qualities the object possesses. The contradiction arises as Fish generalizes his belief that "no one of us wakes up in the morning and reinvents poetry". If the term poetry replaces the "object" in his theory, then interpreters "make" poetry through interpretive strategies. Hence, the interpretative strategy defines "poetry" and, according to the theory, humans redefine, or reinvent, the term "poetry" following each "recognition." The theory allows humans to classify anything as being "poetry". By utilizing "distinguishing features" to identify some objects, in his case "poetry", interpreters may prevent this constant redefining of terms, which tends to...

Find Another Essay On Commentary on Stanley Fish's "How to Recognize a Poem When You See One"

A commentary on Bushed, a Poem by Earle Birney

547 words - 2 pages see his dreams shatter so he can start over again. We can only conclude that it is a cycle that those who are not osprey, hunters and users will have to endure. 	On the technical side Birney writes his poem in prose therefore the only thing that can give us the feeling for the poem is the use of tone. This however, does not remain constant it changes halfway from a more happy poem to a dark, evil poem. One strange thing about Birney’s

You are on a long road trip when a woman spies you reading Streetwise by Elijah Anderson. How do you respond (using crime and cultural theory to back your opinions) when she makes this statement:

1065 words - 4 pages all inner-city residents placed themselves in that position, but I don't think poverty or the criminal behavior of others determines one's outcome. Why do you think these external cultural conditions are so important, how do you see their impact?Me: A look into violent crime's importance in poor urban neighborhoods highlights the host of ways that inner-city residents are harmed by the rippling cultural effects beyond their control. Due to

Gifted Girls - In Education, how to recognize

620 words - 2 pages planning.Males as well as females should be counseled about the redistribution of family responsibilities when this is a desirable solution.Experiences should be provided which help girls develop their autonomy, tolerance for ambiguity and assertiveness.Information and role models should be provided which illustrate a variety of possible satisfying lifestyles.Gifted girls should be encouraged to engage in appropriate career planning and be taught how to

How To Write a Poem

1015 words - 5 pages Robert Frost once said “A poem begins as a lump in the throat, a sense of wrong, a homesickness, a lovesickness.” “It’s when an emotion has found its thought and the thought finds words. Poetry is a vital language of the heart. Poems rely on the writer’s deep and intensive feelings toward a subject. Poems can help a person find their inner feelings that one could not express directly to someone, but only could explain with pen and paper

Discuss how you feel about the form of discrimination they explore in their poem, what effect do you think they are trying to have on you as a reader?

1239 words - 5 pages discriminated against others, or about ways that we have been discriminated against. It gives readers the idea that discrimination is truly something to be ashamed of, and that one day Americans would understand this. This shows how Langston Hughes hoped that as a country, America would one day look back and see how wrongly they treated African-Americans. The future, after all, depends on how well we can learn from our past, and move forward. The

Compare 'Vultures' by Chinua Achebe with one other poem to show how poets use poetry to make a protest.

865 words - 3 pages , vocabulary and poetic voice.The protest made in these poems makes me wonder why humans behave the way they do. How can the commandant in Achebe's poem go shopping for chocolate with the smell of 'human roast' still 'clinging rebelliously to his hairy nostrils'? This horrifying image makes me feel the protest strongly. In a similar way, Osundare, when he writes about 'they'- the violent people who casually pick up Akanni one morning - makes me react

Commentary on the Poem Child and Insect

1142 words - 5 pages line “He races back, how quick he is, look”. This line further emphasizes the rhythm of the poem and the energetic mood it creates. The run on line could also be interpreted as a representation of the child’s speech which is cut and uneven because of his cheerfulness and need for a breath. Moreover, the word choices of the author particularly words such as “snatched”, “quick”, “look”, “sudden” help to reinforce the pace of the poem and thus

Commentary On Self-written Mock-epic poem

842 words - 3 pages 'unsettling'. To evict tedium in our topic, we personified the music controversial as a conflicted couple. Our mock-epic poem draws heavily on the technique of satire (irony, exaggeration and sarcasm) and rhetorical devices to mock the degradation of value and meaning in modern popular music, in the context of a relationship.In stanza three, as Mayuri had summarized, portrays the relationship as a representation of music as an ever-changing culture

How Do you See Marilyn Monroe?

1083 words - 4 pages helped you make up your mind on Monroe or maybe even changed your opinion, I know when I did research my opinion changed. The one thing that inspires me the most about Marilyn Monroe is she’s known to be one of the most beautiful woman ever and she doesn't have a Victoria secret model’s body figure, shes a little chunky and I think it shows that you don't have to be skinny or perfect to be beautiful. Works Cited

Commentary on Hamlet, act 3, scene 2 from line 216 "HAMLET Madam, how like you..." to line 249 "OPHELIA The King rises"

1928 words - 8 pages ) contains two enigmatic metaphors whose contrast is emphasized by the juxtaposition of the clauses.On the one hand, the "galled jade" may refer to Hamlet himself, the latter considering himself hurt and tired of waiting to avenge himself. In this case, the idea that the protagonist is eager to strike is conveyed by the verb "wince".On the other, the second clause may allude to Claudius's present attitude, that of a confident man who is not expecting

How well does Wordsworth succeed in listing our human sympathies in The Lyrical Ballads? To what extent can you see a developing philosophy in his poetry?

751 words - 3 pages Thorn", is described as a "wretched woman", who sits alone beside an "aged thorn" atop a "heap that's like an infant's grave in size" - this portrayal of Martha at the start of the poem sets up her character as being grim and dark, someone to be feared ("I have never heard of such as dare approach the spot when she is there"). The language Wordsworth uses seems to have the intent of causing readers to dislike and ostracise Martha based on scarce

Similar Essays

Analysis On A.E. Housman´S Poem When I Was One And Twenty

779 words - 4 pages The concept of living and learning, is that an individual needs to live and make mistakes in order to learn and become wiser. Many people would acknowledge that they have learned more from the mistakes they have made then the advice they have received. This concept is demonstrated in A.E. Housman’s poem “When I Was One-and-Twenty.” In this poem the speaker receives advice from a wise man on the topic of love. The speaker does not know the

A Comparison Paper Done On Monet's Painting Of The Japanese Bridge. One Completed When He Was In His Prime Youth And The Other Finished When He Was Old And Could Barely See.

680 words - 3 pages . The sprinkling of browns gave this picture a more natural look. The shower of burgundy was added to give the viewer of the painting the suggestion that fall is currently arriving. These works of genius is absolutely stunning and breathe taking when seen up close.The last reproduction of Monet's Japanese Bridge was constructed the year of 1923 during autumn. At this time Monet was an elderly man and he could barely see because of such awful

We Are All One People. This Is An Essay About How It Doesn't Matter Who You Are Or What You Think You Are, That When Tragedy Happens We Are All The Same.

601 words - 2 pages hotel. I noticed the long lines of people waiting for a phone.A reporter then said that a plane had gone into the Pentagon and that one was on its way to the White House. This is when I noticed the difference in the room starting to shift. I noticed all these "professionals" that are usually so distant began to change. Oddly enough they began to merge closer and started to put one arm through another and slip arms around the next person to them

How You See World Opposed To How A Child Sees The World.

659 words - 3 pages All I Really Need to Know I Learned in Kindergarten is a beautiful poem, written by Robert Fulghum, about how everything you learn in kindergarten can be applied throughout your entire life. You learn everything from the golden rule to basic sanitation in kindergarten and it never becomes useless information.In the poem Fulghum says: Share everything.Play fair.Don't hit people.Put things back where you found them.Clean up your own mess.Don't