This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Commodification And Exploitation Of Surrogacy Essay

1903 words - 8 pages

A discussion about surrogacy could result in many different arguments, but one of the most important would be that which deals with the ethical and moral relevance of surrogacy as it relates to both the surrogate and the contracting parents. In terms of ethical and moral relevance, we might consider whether the parties involved are being denied any negative rights and furthermore, how that could produce an unwanted outcome, for example commodification or exploitation. In what follows I will argue that full gestational surrogacy commodifies and exploits women and children; however, I question the negative connotation of the word “exploit” when the surrogate is fully educated about the process. Although surrogacy should be legally permissible, I argue that adoption should be the primary means of "having" a child.
Commodification:
Surrogacy commodifies women and children by selling that which is “market-inalienable,” meaning something that should not be sold, but even more broadly it takes humans and treats them as things rather than thinking and reasoning beings (p.174). Radin identifies non-fungible objects as alienable or central to who the person is, fungible items, however, are those that can be replaced by money (p. 176). I take the above argument to show that regardless of whether the surrogate or contracting parents think of this exchange as commodification or not, it is beyond doubt turning both the surrogate and future child into a commodity.
Thinking of women and children/fetuses in terms of market rhetoric feels intrinsically wrong and results in devaluation of life and morals. For example, prostitution commodifies women and even children by selling their bodies—something that is extremely personal to them. If we accept that prostitution is wrong and devalues women and children individually and as a whole, then it follows that full gestational surrogacy is also degrading because it treats women and children as mere things.
Some might object to this view, arguing that surrogates are providing a service and that it does not matter whether the surrogate needs the profit that will result or if the surrogate is doing it out of the kindness of her heart. Nevertheless, if you regard bodily integrity as a negative right, then it follows that the commodification of that negative right is wrong because it should not be subject to the action of someone else, here payment for full gestational surrogacy.
On the other hand, if the surrogate offers this “service” for free, meaning it is not commodified, then I argue along with Radin that the “noncommodified version is morally preferable” (p.182). However, I realize that since surrogacy has already become a commodity around the world it would be extremely difficult if not impossible to reverse. Because surrogacy is a growing field, attracting more and more families and surrogates it is becoming less likely that women will offer to carry a couple’s baby for altruistic reasons when they could be paid...

Find Another Essay On Commodification and Exploitation of Surrogacy

The Exploitation and Destruction of Mount Everest

1455 words - 6 pages have effects extending beyond just the visual landscape. The exploitation of Mount Everest has had damaging social and environmental effects. These effects are examples of the negative impact tourists can have on any destination, no matter how desolate. Firm rules and regulations must be imposed and enforced by multiple entities in order to lessen negative impacts that continue to occur on Mount Everest. According to The International

Shell Oil and the Exploitation of Nigeria

2206 words - 9 pages Shell Oil and the Exploitation of Nigeria      Nigeria has been a country in political turmoil for a long time. The country was created in 1914 under British colonial rule and at that time it was considered a protectorate. It was not until 1960 that Nigeria received independence from the United Kingdom. One of Nigeria's problems politically is that it has over three hundred different ethnic groups. The three largest

Analysis of Los Vendidos and Exploitation of Mexican-Americans

2526 words - 10 pages Analysis of Los Vendidos and Exploitation of Mexican-Americans The short play Los Vendidos portrayed by el Teatro Campesino shows the history of Mexican-Americans. It shows racist perceptions and actions towards Mexican-Americans. The title itself implies the exploitation of Chicanos. In translation from Spanish "Vendidos" can mean either those who sell-out others, or those who are sold. In the play either meaning can be applied. Those

The Isolation, Exploitation, and Discrimination of Border Crossing

1863 words - 7 pages When humans interact through the crossing borders and migration into new regions, the residents and immigrants are faced with the problems of racism, segregation, misinterpretation, and even exploitation of others. The Spaniards explored the New World in the 15th and 16th centuries and they saw a land full of economic opportunities. The native residents had no idea of what the European's intentions were with their exploration efforts. Central

Exploration, Exploitation and Colonization of America: Christopher Columbus

1133 words - 5 pages Christopher Columbus was a Spanish master navigator and admiral whose four transatlantic voyages opened the way for European exploration, exploitation, and colonization of the Americans. He has long been called the “discoverer” of the New World. Although, Vikings such as Leif Eriksson had visited North America five centuries earlier. Christopher Columbus made his voyage under the sponsorship of Ferdinand II and Isabella I. Who were the Catholic

A Contrast of Humanity in Suffering and Exploitation: The Grapes of Wrath

2604 words - 10 pages storm in Oklahoma, and their experiences during the trek to California and the hardships encountered on the way. Before leaving on their trip, the Joads must sell all of their farm implements and reduce their belongings because they need money for travel and survival. Steinbeck gives us many portrayals of exploitation of the downtrodden migrant. In this instance, the car dealers take advantage of the people who need to leave and have to buy a

The Congo Free State: A Legacy of Apathy, Exploitation and Brutality

2298 words - 9 pages international attention on the colony except for short times, the widespread economic exploitation of the rubber resources of the region, and the brutal mistreatment and near-genocide of the Congolese by those in charge of rubber collecting. While Leopold II, the King of Belgium, desperately wanted an overseas colony, the Belgian people did not share his enthusiasm, which created the feelings of neglect and apathy Belgium had towards Congo. The Congo

The Grapes of Wrath - Fear, Hostility, and Exploitation in Chapter 21

1059 words - 4 pages Fear, Hostility, and Exploitation in Chapter 21 of The Grapes of Wrath   Steinbeck's intercalary chapters in The Grapes of Wrath have nothing to do with the Joads or other characters of the novel, but help describe the story in different terms. They are similar to poems, offering different viewpoints of the migration, and clarifying parts of the story that the reader might not understand. An excellent example of this use can be seen

[LEGAL STUDIES]Discuss the issues surrounding IVF surrogacy and cloning, showing both sides of the argument and also at the same time, give your opinion

1818 words - 7 pages IVF, surrogacy, cloning and genetic experimentation are reasonably recent ideas and technologies that can certainly be improved on and explored further. But is it really the path the human race wants to take? Children being born to one mother and taken care of by another? Two people exact copies of each other? Living beings being altered from their natural form for the sake of our comfort and lifestyle? Raising our children in machines?We have

How does Walker use form, structure, and language to explore the exploitation of female characters in The Color Purple?

618 words - 3 pages Whilst exploring the exploitation of female characters in The Color Purple, Alice Walker portrays the female characters in the novel as weak-minded, easily enthralled and controlled by their male superiors. Walker represents the exploitation as a struggle for identity through her consistent use of the theme of power from male characters and the subjugation of females runs parallel along the segregation of the black community from the white

Christopher Columbus' enslavement and exploitation of the Caribbean's Amerindians. Also, his reasons for searching for new colonies

673 words - 3 pages used as slaves under a system known as the encomienda system. They were forced to pay tribute to the Spaniards by paying a certain amount of gold during a certain time. Though the Caribbean islands did not contain so much gold, the Indians were punished in vain for finding only very small amounts of riches. The encomienda system was just a fancy Spanish term for slavery and exploitation. The Spaniards did very horrible, degrading things such as

Similar Essays

The Morality Of Abortion And Surrogacy

1933 words - 8 pages The Morality of Abortion and Surrogacy It is said that, the basic principle of such tradition is that humans communicate through symbols, which are a common currency through which a sense of self is created through interaction with others. Mead's theory neatly avoids the trap of positing a sense of self that is constructed entirely through symbols and society by making a distinction between two different selves: "I" which is the

The Refrigerator And Marx's Theory Of Commodification And Alienation

2131 words - 9 pages Commodification and Alienation. I will examine the refrigerator as a commodity, its relationship to production and exchange of commodity, to consumption and the way we 'reproduce' our life. According to Marx, a production process of any kind and the distribution of a product are determined by social relations and forces of production (produktivekrafte). The dominant social relation in the capitalist world is based on class, but Marxists have

Biological And Ethical Benefits And Drawbacks Of Undergoing Surrogacy

2286 words - 10 pages -selling” process as it involves the surrogate mother be enter a contract with the intended parent(s) to give birth their child (Ciccarelli et al. 2005).The goal policy of surrogacy in Australia is to prevent exploitation of women who act as birth mothers and also the prevention of commercialisation of reproduction with children born through surrogacy (Millbank et al. 2011). Exploitation of commercial surrogacy is a problematic issue as this can

Maquiladoras And The Exploitation Of Women's Bodies

1446 words - 6 pages Maquiladoras and the Exploitation of Women's Bodies Works Cited Missing In a changing economic and political climate gender stereotypes in Juárez, Mexico refuse to change. With an increasing number of women forced into the workplace in maquiladoras(1), men's position and women's assumed position in society is being challenged. This changing economic environment in an unchanging cultural environment is part of the reason that young women