Common Law Development Of Defence Of Provocation. Refers To The Case Of Mancini

2231 words - 9 pages

Question:Critically evaluate the development of common law principles applicable to the defence of provocation in criminal law from the decision in Mancini v DPP [1942] AC 1 to Mascantonio v R (1995) 183 CLR 58. Assess the degree to which the common law has proved inflexible in responding changing societal needs and expectations. Are there other legal means of achieving substantive justice?At the time of the case of Mancini the concept of provocation as a defence to murder was already a well established one dating back centuries. It originated from the days when men bore arms and engaged in quarrels of violence that often resulted in a homicide being committed. For provocation to be an ample defence to murder it needed to be something which incited immediate anger, or 'passion' and which overcame a person's self control to such an extent so as to overpower or swamp his reason. What this something can be has been the subject of many views through the centuries, and these views have strongly depended upon the type of person whom the law has regarded as deserving extenuated consideration when provoked to kill. In the words of Viscount Simon 'the law has to reconcile respect for the sanctity of human life with recognition of the effect of provocation on human frailty. ' In this regard the difficult concept of the 'reasonable man' or the 'ordinary man' has developed and with it the legal doctrine that provocation must be such as would not only cause the person accused to behave as he did but as would cause an ordinary man to so lose control of himself as to act in the same sort of way. It is therefore interesting to examine how the doctrine of common law in relation to provocation has responded to changing societal needs and values. It also provides a useful case study in which the development of common law doctrine can be observed. It is useful to conduct a case-by-case analysis of the rule of provocation as a defence to murder in order to more effectively observe the legal evolution that has taken place.In the case of Mancini v DPP [1942] AC 1 the appellant had been convicted for murder after stabbing a man to death in a club. The appellant's counsel contended that the trial judge should have directed that the jury was open to find provocation to reduce the appellant's conviction to manslaughter. Lord Simonds provided direction upon what kind of provocation would reduce murder to manslaughter. He said that the provocation must temporarily deprive the provoked individual of self-control and in deciding this regard must be had to the following circumstances: the nature of the act which causes death, the time which elapsed between the provocation and the act which caused death, the offender's conduct during that interval and all other circumstances which indicate his state of mind. It is here that the well known characteristics of 'an unusually excitable or pugnacious' person are excluded from amounting to provocation. Lord Simonds also said that 'the...

Find Another Essay On Common Law - Development of Defence of Provocation. Refers to the case of Mancini

Sources of Common Law Essay

4071 words - 16 pages courts. In the case of Pugh v Heath, Lord Cairns stated that, "the court is now not a Court of Law or a Court of Equity, it is a Court of complete jurisdiction."[12: Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1873 (36 & 37 Vict c. 66) and the Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1875 (38 & 39 Vict c. 77).][13: Pugh v Heath (1882) 7 App.Cas. 235.]However, it is important to note that the principles of common law and equity remain as two separate bodies of

The Right of Private Defence Essay

2811 words - 11 pages The right of defence of one's own body or property is an unavoidable right. prior to the times when men began to live as members of organized communities, individuals were completely left to themselves to take whatever action for their protection .Even in ancient times the right of private defence had significance. Ancient law givers like Manu gave the authority of using arms in self defence in times of fear of danger. There were no limitations

The Satire of Johnathan Swift Revealed. Refers to "Gulliver's travels

788 words - 3 pages During the eighteenth century there was an incredible upheaval of commercialization in London, England. As a result, English society underwent significant, "changes in attitude and thought", in an attempt to obtain the dignity and splendor of royalty and the upper class (McKendrick,2). As a result, English society held themselves in very high regards, feeling that they were the elite society of mankind. In his novel, Gulliver's Travels, Jonathan

Comparison of common law and equity law

2888 words - 12 pages context refers to "statutory law" (the laws enacted by Parliament), and "case law" (the principles established by judges when they decide cases).Distinction between law and equityThis article or section does not cite its references or sources.You can help Wikipedia by introducing appropriate citations.In modern practice, perhaps the most important distinction between law and equity is the set of remedies each offers. The most common remedy a

Defence Of AU

1634 words - 7 pages Opponents of Act Utilitarianism attempt to argue that Act Utilitarianism (henceforth AU) does not account for justice when applied to ethical dilemmas. It is the authors opinion that these claims are factually incorrect and this essay shall attempt to prove this through analysis of common arguments against AU, and modifying AU to allow for justice to be more readily accounted for. AU is an ethical theory credited largely to Jeremy Bentham. AU

The Insanity Defence, in Need of Reform?

1869 words - 7 pages Harper case, even though the cases were similar. 7. Overall, the law lacks clarity with regards to availability the insanity defence. Judgments have been inconsistent with providing a clear basis for the law surrounding the insanity defence. This could be remedied with the creation of a statutory insanity defence, which would eliminate the issues of interpreting judgments. Law and Medical Understanding 8. In addition the law's lack of

In The Defence Of The Prince

1513 words - 7 pages regime and political thought are not accessible to the everyday person. Some parts neglect, and create a topic, the mundane man; different contradict what folks are told for hundreds of years. One major deficiency is that the indisputable fact that his methodology does not coincide with common morality. From birth, we tend to square measure instilled with bound conceptions of right and inaccurate. These principles square measure, conventionally

The Evolution of Criminal Law: From the Common Law to Modern Statutes and the Model Penal Code

4557 words - 18 pages liability offenses: bigamy and statutory rape cases. Mistake of fact with regard to the age of the individual consenting to intercourse, and mistake as to one's marital status were neither defenses under the common law nor under modern statutes.Under the Model Penal Code, if strict liability (or "absolute" as the MPC refers to it) is imposed as to any specific element of an offense, that offense is deemed a "violation" which does not constitute a

Common Law in Australia: The Tort Of Negligence

9095 words - 36 pages TORT - A Tort is a civil wrong that is outside of Contract Law and arises out of a recognition that a person is responsible for their acts and omissions when dealing with others. The term "Tort" refers to a number of different laws such as nuisance, trespass and assault. Torts action generally compensates the individual for personal loss where the loss was caused by another person. It is based on Common Law.NEGLIGENCE - Negligence is one of many

The History of English Common Law in Hong Kong

833 words - 3 pages local courts. Through the central authority, a unified system of Law was slowly used and it is known as the Common Law. We called it Common Law because the Common Law was common to all men within the King judicial system. As the local custom preceded both judicial precedent and legislation, we can say it is the original source of Law.The Writ SystemWithin the three hundred years after Norman Conquest, local custom was slowly replaced by the Common

Analysis of the Case Law

3355 words - 13 pages Analysis of the Case Law "There is no prescribed constitutional relationship between the courts and the executive, but the judges assert their inherent power, derived from the rule of law, to review executive actions" The question starts off by giving us an element of the separation of powers when it says that there is no prescribed

Similar Essays

The Development Of Common Law And Equity

3149 words - 13 pages The Development of Common Law and Equity 1.0 Introduction I have been asked to write a report on the development of common law and equity. Common law refers to the law created by judges that was historically significant but has been since superseded by parliament. It is in parallel with equity which refers to the source of law created by the Lord Chancellor which was designed to supplement the common law

The Abolition Of The Provocation Defence

3317 words - 13 pages couples on a frequent basis. It is undecided at common law as to whether mere words can ever amount to provocation although there is some obiter comment which previously suggested that they can (Moffa).This case caused a strong reaction in the media and the community and lead to calls for the abolition of the provocation defence. It is argued here that mere words should never amount to sufficient provocation to deprive the ordinary person of the

The Common Law Of Employment Essay

607 words - 3 pages , therefore, Queen sues him for negligent misrepresentation. The Supreme Court of Canada rules in Queen’s favor and awards him $50,000 in damages along with damages in other areas. In this case, the common law is used by Queen to protect himself from the negligent actions of his employer, which might not have been possible, if judges did not create the common law of employment. In this situation, it is clearly evident that the common law protected

The Art Of Defence Essay

904 words - 4 pages As Emily quickly rushed out of the door, she quickly grabbed her black down coat. She suddenly got into her friend Tailor's old Toyota Prius. Taylor imminently drove off to class. Once they got to the Iris & B. Gerald Cantor Center for Visual Arts, at Stanford University where they attended, they walked into Mrs.. Basile’s contemporary art class. They quickly snatched a seat next to their friend Yael in the back of the room. The eccentric