Common Sense, Ethics, And Dogma In The Wife Of Bath

3262 words - 13 pages

Common Sense, Ethics, and Dogma in The Wife of Bath


In his Canterbury Tales, Geoffrey Chaucer assembles a band of pilgrims who, at the behest of their host, engage in a story-telling contest along their route. The stories told along the way serve a number of purposes, among them to entertain, to instruct, and to enlighten. In addition to the intrinsic value of the tales taken individually, the tales in their telling reveal much about the tellers. The pitting of tales one against another provides a third level of complexity, revealing the interpersonal dynamics of the societal microcosm comprising the diverse group of pilgrims.

Within the larger context, the tales can be divided into groups. These ‘fragments’ are each cohesive, not in the least because of their treatment of a single overarching question or issue, as is examined in detail by structuralist critic Jerome Mandel, in Building the Fragments of the Canterbury Tales. Using Mandel’s premise as a beginning, one can further conjecture a structural similarity between the fragments; for the immediate purposes, a similarity between Fragments I (beginning with the Knight’s Tale) and III (beginning with the Wife’s Tale) is worth noting, in which an opening tale poses a serious question and partially addresses it, and a pair of lighter tales follows, each playing off the other to further examine the question. As the fragments progress, moreover, the questions as they arise encompass the previous question. Thus, the Wife of Bath’s Tale serves an important didactic purpose in encompassing the Knight’s, and heightening the level of the dialogue as Alice, the Wife of Bath, exams the validity of the question the knight poses in its entirety.

In the Knight’s Tale, the question is posed, “Which is worse, to be in full view of one’s desire, yet it be unattainable, or never to be able to view the object of one’s desire?” The pain of either choice has as its basic assumption the existence of covetousness. Both the young knights in the tale possess that most basic characteristic of courtly romance, that of hopeless covetousness – desiring that which is seemingly unattainable. Alice of Bath gives us an exercise in critical thinking by taking issue with this basic premise of courtly love, to be felt towards lovers, but not towards wives.

In introducing his modern English translation of the Canterbury Tales, Nevill Coghill gives us a primer in courtly love, thus:

It was not in fashion to write poems to one’s wife. It could even be debated whether love could ever have a place in marriage; the typical situation in which a ‘courtly lover’ found himself was to be plunged in a secret, an illicit, and even an adulterous passion for some seemingly unattainable and pedestalized lady… the most beautiful of absolute disasters, an agony as much desired as bemoaned … This was not in theory the attitude of a husband to his wife. It was for a husband to command, for a wife to obey (12).

With both the...

Find Another Essay On Common Sense, Ethics, and Dogma in The Wife of Bath

The Wife of Bath Essay

1455 words - 6 pages relationship exercises control over her husband. Therefore, the Wife of Bath is a strong advocator of female maistrie within a marriage, by not only believing in maistrie, but also practices it in her own life. The Wife of Bath is a strong woman and knows what she wants from men. Alisoun is a promiscuous woman filled with sexual desires. She has been married five times and in each marriage she not only knows what she wants, but she also knows

The Wife of Bath Essay

1017 words - 4 pages Pardoner, hearing this, interrupts her in disgust and tells her how he has been thinking about marriage but now is glad that he is a single guy. The Wife of Bath then tells the other pilgrims what has happened to her five husbands. She says, “Tho housbonds that I hadde, As three of hem were goode, and two were badde. The three men were goode, and riche, and olde”[Norton,121]. In other words, the first three husbands were good to her; they were

The Wife of Bath

2334 words - 9 pages In The Canterbury Tales, the Wife of Bath gives an in-depth look on her life and understanding on the world as she perceives it. During her Prologue, we learn that what she calls experience stems from her first three marriages, but during her last two there is a shift in power. The Wife of Bath demonstrates her understanding and power throughout her first three marriages both physically and emotionally and the contrast of her lack of control in

The Wife of Bath

1057 words - 5 pages . These were unfortunate circumstances for Chaucer as his ideas were not particularly welcome with the people of power in his country. To express his opinions and stay away from the gallows Chaucer wrote stories in which he used the characters to express his philosophy. One such character in the Wife of Bath who Chaucer uses to express his egalitarian views and critique patriarchy. The Wife is an older woman who has had five husbands over the

The Wife of Bath

1349 words - 5 pages The Wife of Bath The Wife of Bath, one of the many characters in Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales, is a feminist of the fourteenth century. Chaucer, in the "General Prologue," describes her as promiscuous. The Wyf confirms this claim in the prologue to her tale, the longest in the book. An analysis of the "General Prologue" and the "Wyf's Prologue" reveals a direct relationship between the Wyf of Bathe and the characters in her tale, such

The One and Only Wife of Bath

3619 words - 15 pages be seen maternal figure that possess as a threat of breaking in the societal system by empowering the status of women. In the Wife of Baths Prologue, her true colors unfurl which gives the reader the sense of who the Wife of Bath is and where her mind is in terms of the gender inequality. Her prologue also lays down the path to the direction her tale is going to go. The wife of Bath makes it clear that more than anyone it is her that has

The Wife of Bath, The Wife of Bath Prologue, and The General Prologue

1415 words - 6 pages The Wife of Bath, The Wife of Bath Prologue, and The General Prologue These selections from The Canterbury Tales best exemplify the ideals and traits of women (as portrayed by Chaucer). In, The Wife of Bath Prologue, the narrator brags of her sexual exploits as well as her prowess of controlling men. The narrator is quite forthright in her enjoyment of this manipulation; she comments on her technique of lying and

The Impressive Wife of Bath

1002 words - 4 pages , her sinuous marital experience and her overseas adventures. The tale gave an exhaustive portrayal on the dressing of the wife of Bath: Her kerchiefs were elaborately woven; her hose was in vibrant red; her shoes was polished new. All of these traits in her dressing led us readers to the image that how fashionable this women should be! I can hardly imagine how such a Medieval women could be so stylish! As far as I know, women at that time

The View of Marriage in The Wife of Bath

2346 words - 9 pages Dictionary. In both the Prologue and Tale of the Wife of Bath we see the institution of marriage used as control over money and sexual powers. Chaucer's Wife of Bath displays a complete sense of mockery toward marriage as a holy institution. The Prologue and Tale of the Wife of Bath clearly show that the Wife of Bath sees marriage as a woman's dominance over a man. In the Prologue, the Wife of Bath starts to defend her actions of

Desire in Chaucers "The Wife of Bath" and Sir Philip Sidney's "Astrophil and Stella"

1040 words - 4 pages When a person is infatuated with something, they can become single-minded and ignorant to reality. If they cannot have the object of their desire, they may be plunged into a state of despair and frustration. Sir Philip Sidney explores the affects of desire in his sonnets, Astrophil and Stella. Geoffrey Chaucer also delves into the topic in “The Wife of Bath’s Prologue and Tale”. These two works present the idea that desire is

Comparision of the Wife of Bath and the Fairy Queen

1731 words - 7 pages Comparing two women indeed gives you, as an individual, a peek into each woman’s life. At times you may discover that they are very similar, while other times you may discover shocking differences. When comparing the Wife of Bath, an older pilgrim traveling to Canterbury, and the Fairy Queen, a beautiful and supernatural woman, we uncover distinct similarities and differences in their lives. We notice similarities in the way they view a

Similar Essays

Sovereignty, Supremacy, And Dominance In The Wife Of Bath

1296 words - 5 pages Sovereignty, Supremacy, and Dominance in The Wife of Bath When reading the wife of Baths prologue and then her tale one can not help but to see the parallels present. The major parallel that exists is the subject of sovereignty. Who has it, which wants it, which deserves it and what will you do to get it? First we see that the Wife claims to have sovereignty over each of her husbands even though some were harder to gain dominance over than

The Wife Of Bath Essay 879 Words

879 words - 4 pages The Wife of Bath The Wife of Bath is the tale of an independent and headstrong woman. She strongly believes in the worth of every woman and that women should be dominant in their marriages. The Wife of Bath also directly speaks against strict religious claims for chastity and monogamy, using Biblical examples. These examples include Solomon to show that the Bible does not openly condemn all expressions of sexuality, even outside of

The Wife Of Bath Essay 764 Words

764 words - 3 pages image of medieval women. (women) The Wife of Bath was one such woman.In "The Wife of Bath and the Painting of the Lions", The Wife of Bath, (Alyson) talks about a picture of a man killing a lion, and in the fable the lion states that if the lion had painted the picture it would have been much different. Alyson, I believe, painted her own picture. Alyson was herself a feminist in every sense of the word, she was very sexual, forwardly honest with

The Wife Of Bath Essay

1421 words - 6 pages Chaucer in "The General Prologue" as a "somewhat deaf," red-faced and "gap-toothed" woman who has her own business as a weaver of cloth. To show everyone in the town that she is well off, when she goes to church on Sundays, the Wife of Bath -- Dame Alisoun - overdresses: she wears a skirt and red stockings, wuth ten pounds of "coverchiefs" and tight-laced supple shoes: "Her wearing of such garments stamps her as the most prosperous woman of business