This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparative Anaylsis Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

1652 words - 7 pages

This paper compares Peter Tragos “Monster Masculinity: Honey I’ll be in the Garage Reasserting My Manhood” and Richard Majors’ “Cool Pose: Black Masculinity and Sports” in regards to males regaining their masculine identity during the transition of a gender blurred society. In Richard Majors’ article, he discusses how sport has become a major institutional context for the expression of masculinity and the development of the cool pose among black males (1). Peter Tragos article addresses how men are experiencing a backlash against the feminization of masculine culture (2). Both articles demonstrate an underlying need to re-establish dominance and power over women to further stimulate the need for the homogenization of a male dominating society. In contrast, Tragos analyses a man’s need to prove his masculinity and form a sense of dominance through media while Majors does the same, but from a black male’s perspective and through sports.
In order for men to possess power and dominance over women, they are expected to be educated. Tragos talks about how women now have a redefined notion of femininity that adopts both traditional and unconventional roles that they are now taking on. Women are becoming more independent and are expected to be strong while maintaining beauty. To fulfill the role of being strong and independent, they have to compete against men. Major’s emphasises the importance of black males to be educated in order to gain their masculinity. Majors expresses his concern about black males only being able to go to school through sports scholarships. The black males who do have the opportunity to attend college through athletic scholarships, often are forced back on the streets with degrees that will not let them succeed. Similarly, both articles indicate that men need to be educated in order to succeed and exert power and dominance over women. For men to be educated, they are able to attain good paying jobs to support their families. Although both articles discuss the importance of educating men, Tragos largely focuses on hegemonic masculinity in the context of exclusively white men. The article targets white men and women which insinuates that people of different race are to be minorized. In contrast, Majors does it in the context of black men. If black men cannot thrive as “men” in society due to disadvantages in school, black women in particular have a lesser chance of being educated since black men have a better chance through sports.
To be educated means to be able to have a job and have a source of equity. If men are educated more so then women, men will continue to dominant the workplace. The wealthier a man is, the more strength, power and dominance he conveys. Majors describes the dominant social definition of masculinity as being the breadwinner, having strength and dominating women (). American society inhibits black men from achieving many aspects of masculinity by restricting things like jobs, education and...

Find Another Essay On Comparative Anaylsis of Hegemonic Masculinity

Masculinity Essay

1298 words - 6 pages wrestling (Soulliere 1). Messages concerning masculinity and manhood were investigated and compared to the cultural version of masculinity (Soulliere 2006). Soulliere’s research proves that the World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) depicts messages, which supports the dominant hegemonic form of masculinity (Soulliere 2006). To further grasp and understand Soulliere’s hypothesis, we must first examine her research methods and outcomes. Soulliere

Compare and Contrast the Representation of Masculinity of John Wayne’s Rio Bravo (1959) and Die Hard (1988)

2209 words - 9 pages Narratives of the hero action has sustained the interests of audiences across the ‘changing space and time’ of popular culture and has become a ‘stalwart genre’ (Shimpach, 2010:30). This study will explore the construction of hegemonic masculinity by comparing the representation of heroic masculinity between John McClane (Die Hard, 1988) and John Wayne (Rio Bravo, 1959). It will examine: the framing of the physical body, the development of

Hegemonic Masculinity Practices

1493 words - 6 pages “category”. Connell and Messerschmidt (2005:846) observe that there are hierarchy within masculinity and describe this as a pattern of hegemony. Within this hierarchy, certain masculinities are socially more central and more associated with authority and power compared to others. They expand by stating that non-hegemonic masculinities, within the masculinities sphere – are subordinate to their hegemonic brothers. They describe this

Examining Sub-Cultures: The Goth Culture

1825 words - 7 pages focus on Goth culture and the extent to which it challenges the hegemonic norms of masculinity. “Hegemonic Masculinity refers to a culturally dominant set of ideas and practices about what it means to be a man and how men should behave” (Mansfield, 2007: 1). It is, in simpler terms the general perception of what it is to be masculine that dominants society and the way in which most people portray their masculinity. It is hoped that through the

Feminism and Masculinity

829 words - 3 pages In contemporary society, hegemonic masculinity is defined by physical strength and boldness, heterosexuality, economic independence, authority over women and other men, and an interest in sexual relationships. While most men do not embody all of these qualities, society supports hegemonic masculinity within all its institutions, including the educational institute, the religious institute and other institutes which form the ideological state

What´s Interpersonal Violence?

1719 words - 7 pages . While these problems may all be limitations of the model themselves, they help to explain why there current models are not gender dynamic. The next part will illustrate exactly what is meant by hegemonic masculinity and how it helps to understand family annihilation. HEGEMONIC MASCULINITY – FAMILY ANNIHILATION Despite the media attention and public interest familicide receives, it is still quite a rare event. Some studies have been known to

Agency Temp Workers and Gender Roles in Japan´s Workforce

2963 words - 12 pages examination of clerical work in Japan and the U.S.. In F. Rosenbluth (Ed.), The Political Economy of Low Fertility: Japan in Comparative Perspective (pp. 87-11). Stanford: Stanford University Press. Connell, R. (2002). Gender. Cambridge: Polity Press. Connell, R., & Messerschmidt, J. (2005). Hegemonic masculinity: Rethinking the concept. Gender & Society, 19(6), 832. Evans, J. (2002). Work/family reconciliation, gender wage equity and occupational

Gender Studies

1692 words - 7 pages between the ears. Femininity or masculinity, manhood or womanhood, when gender is given, the social construct order and holds that the individual must go the gendered norms and expectations. It is a binary, which we either male or female, but not both; Hegemonic masculinity is what the West based their masculine on. The ideal masculinity is that men need to strive to achieve. In North America, hegemonic masculinity is traits of aggressiveness

racial discourse in 8 mile

2483 words - 10 pages contributing to Eminem’s image. Several themes are defined through the movie’s underlying discourse of race and class: the commodification of black culture, racial opposition, “passing”, cross-cultural bonding, white heroism and white masculinity, the reversal of white privilege into a disadvantage, and essentially, the film in its entirety as a racially biased film. Set in 1995, 8 Mile is the semi-autobiographical movie about Eminem’s, né Marshall Mathers

Hegemonic Masculinity in American Society

1529 words - 6 pages Masculinity is described as possession of attributes considered typical of a man. Hegemonic masculinity is a form of masculine character with cultural idealism and emphasis that connects masculinity to competitiveness, toughness, and women subordination. Masculinity hegemonic is the enforcement of male dominion over a society. Masculine ideology dates back to the time of agrarian and the industrial revolution in Europe when survival

Culturally Dominant Models of How to be and Look a Man

2511 words - 10 pages female characters. The Doctor is subject to cultural developments in his masculinity depending on the hegemonic norm; he is white, middle class, independent heterosexual embodying the current extrovert nature of the young male sex symbol. Contemporary theory on masculinity in media to Baker (2006) constructs the basis of masculinity in a period as the reflection of changes in political ideology. Centralizing a thesis that ideology has a need to

Similar Essays

Messerschmidt’s Theory Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

2570 words - 10 pages Messerschmidt's Theory of Hegemonic MasculinityBy Rachel Bustamante, A #01507521December 11, 2012"Masculine domination…is neither fixed nor inevitable, but results from social struggles" (Messerschmidt, 1993). In order to better understand the male-dominated crime I have encountered personally, I thoroughly researched the theories in class and have chosen Messerschmidt's theory of hegemonic masculinity as the best possible explanation

Messerschmidt’s Theory Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

2570 words - 10 pages Messerschmidt's Theory of Hegemonic MasculinityBy Rachel Bustamante, A #01507521December 11, 2012"Masculine domination…is neither fixed nor inevitable, but results from social struggles" (Messerschmidt, 1993). In order to better understand the male-dominated crime I have encountered personally, I thoroughly researched the theories in class and have chosen Messerschmidt's theory of hegemonic masculinity as the best possible explanation

Critically Evaluate The Argument That The So Called "Crisis In Masculinity" Paradoxically Furthers Forms Of Hegemonic Masculinity

2586 words - 10 pages that masculinity qualities are being challenged by our society and feminism. Men are now being portrayed as trouble makers because statistics show that they have been doing worse than women in various areas. Nevertheless, people argue that this so-called "crisis in masculinity" is paradoxically further forms of hegemonic masculinity. This essay will establish the origin of the crisis in masculinity, which is believed to be the male liberation

Hegemonic Masculinity In Sports Media Essay

2064 words - 9 pages stratified, as some forms of masculinity and femininity are preferable to others (Moss 2). Sociologists often consider the most lauded masculinity in a particular culture to be hegemonic, or dominant, and this image of maleness becomes the ideal for men in that society (Moss 2). Although the concept of masculinity is constantly evolving, one activity that is often intertwined with the hegemonic form is the practice of sport (Brandt and Carsens