Comparative Article Review: The Great Depression

1654 words - 7 pages

Two articles written about the Great Depression, one by James Struthers and the other by John Manley, each article takes a different view on the depression. One is looking exclusively at the politics and the other looking a public organizations and party formations, each showing a fear of foreign ideals. All of this would shape the way in which the working and middle class would look at and provide input into future governments.
Let’s look at the differences first, James Struthers you can see by title alone that this article is on the unemployment policy and will look at the government and the Prime ministers of the 1930’s. John Manley article you can see by the title that you will be looking at reforms and different organizations that were formed in 1929-1939 and the fears of communism that came with all th3ese organizations. Just by looking here you can see that each article yes looks that the same time period but John Manley looks at the great depression a bit earlier than James Struthers.
Going into the article as you read the opening paragraphs you get a feel for the overall argument which is too restated within the closing paragraphs as well. So with in James Struthers article the reoccurring theme that seems to be the central argument is the fact that both the R.B. Bennett and Mackenzie King governments refusal to provide and help with unemployment insurance was due to both thinking it would make the people reliant on the government, and that people needed to tighten their belts. With John Manley the reoccurring theme is the Communist Party of Canada and the movements and followers that come with it and the focus on obtaining some sort of employment insurance and support for those who were or have become unemployed during the Great Depression and the boldness to express their concern.
Looking at James Struthers you can see the one of the techniques used is the separation of sections. James Struthers opens and asks general questions such as why did the depression take us by surprise? Or why did we not follow in the Britain’s footsteps and create things like a national system of unemployment insurance if a state employment service to cope the joblessness? Along with the idea that the depression would pass in time like it has done in the past, and that the overall argument was that the joblessness was due to the seasonal work and the government thought that these seasonal workers were paid enough to keep them going through the winter. Another factor was that unions were not powerful until World War Two.
Now if you look at John Manley’s article you see that his technique is different in the sense that it is written in a two column format with no breaks in between, and Open up his article by how the Communist Party of Canada (CPC) formed the National Unemployed Workers’ Association (NUWA), and how they fought for unemployment insurance or compensation, and how the police tried to repress the NUWA. The NUWA had economic...

Find Another Essay On Comparative Article Review: The Great Depression

The Great Depression Essay

1004 words - 5 pages The decade known as the Great Depression was an era filled with both hardship and tribulation. Historians continue to debate the root causes of the collapse of the stock market which led the country into depression. Other deride the ineptitude of the Canadian government’s response to the crisis. At any rate, the “Dirty Thirties” was a period of time unlike any other. While those who suffered through it are largely gone, the memory of those dark

The Great Depression( Canada) Essay

1013 words - 4 pages The great depression, a time that was hard for almost all Canadian citizens. A time where Canadians looked towards there government for some form of decisive action that would end the great depression but unfortunately, Canadians only received relief efforts and attempts at protecting our economy both of which where horrible inadequate. As a result, Canadians during this time faced a series of hardships which worsened the human condition

The Great Depression( Canada)

1013 words - 4 pages The great depression, a time that was hard for almost all Canadian citizens. A time where Canadians looked towards there government for some form of decisive action that would end the great depression but unfortunately, Canadians only received relief efforts and attempts at protecting our economy both of which where horrible inadequate. As a result, Canadians during this time faced a series of hardships which worsened the human condition

The Great Depression

910 words - 4 pages The Great Depression Many times throughout history, the United States has undergone economic depression. The most recognized period of economic depression is called the Great Depression. The Great Depression is well known because of the seriousness of the stock market crash. The results of the crash were more serious than any other crash throughout American History. The Great Depression caused a change in the nature of the

The Great Depression

1759 words - 8 pages There have been many downturns in America’s economy, but one stands far above the rest. The term for depression refers to long-term severe downturn in economic activity. The Great Depression is, without a doubt, the longest and most severe in American history. When sustained for a long period of time, it’s not surprising that the people affected by an economic depression could begin to feel emotionally depressed. The Great Depression lasted over

The Great Depression

2358 words - 10 pages The Great Depression At the end of the 1920s the world experienced a devastating economic depression that struck countries with market economies. Despite the great depression being mildly experienced in some countries, the United States of America was hit so mind-bogglingly that at its nadir in 1933 an approximate value of 25% of all workers and an overwhelming 37 % of all non-farm workers were completely out of work and thrown to the curbs. The

The Great Depression - 553 words

553 words - 2 pages The Great Depression "Exploration is the engine that drives innovation. Innovation drives economic growth. So let's all go exploring" ­Edith Widder. The status on America's economy is what the country depends on. In the past, there have been various events that have affected our economy in different ways. The Great Depression of the 1930s was one of the most severe economic failures of all time. However, it was the American people

the great depression

714 words - 3 pages 1 The Great Depression Causes of the Great Depression Many factors played a role in bringing about the depression; however, the main cause for the Great Depression was the combination of the greatly unequal distribution of wealth throughout the 1920's and 30's, and the extensive stock market speculation that took place during the 1930's. These were not only the factors of the great depression, structural weaknesses and the fact that most of the

The Great Depression

1296 words - 5 pages The Causes of the Great Depression The cause of the Great Depression has been debated for many years. The actual cause of the Great Depression is a multitude of factors, there was no single cause. Several reasons for the Great Depression were supply and demand, the banking system, wages of workers, success and failure of business, government policy, excessive speculation in the stock market and the unequal distribution of wealth

The Great Depression

1203 words - 5 pages      The Great Depression was a period, which seemed to go out of control. The crashing of the stock markets left most Canadians unemployed and in debt, prairie farmers suffered immensely with the inability to produce valuable crops, and the Canadian Government and World War II became influential factors in the ending of the Great Depression. The 1920’s meant prosperity for Canada. Canadians living in the 1920’s were

The Great Depression - 664 words

664 words - 3 pages The Great Depression is one of the longest and most severe economic hysterias experienced by the industrialized Western world. During the depression the political, economic, and social institutions in the U.S were in bad conditions. The government, various groups, and individuals sought ways to address the problems that Americans faced. Starting in the United States and later on engulfing nations worldwide, the Great depression that up rose

Similar Essays

Hard Times Book Review: Hard Times By Studs Terkel An Oral History Of The Great Depression New York: Pantheon Books, 1970

1643 words - 7 pages Studs Terkel, the noted journalist, radio commentator, and author has provided us with different views on different topics with the many books he's published throughout the years. Particularly in his 1970 publication of Hard Times, which is an oral history of the Great Depression of the nineteen thirties. Terkel interviewed dozens of people across the United States for this book, then bringing together a collection from these interviews with

The Great Depression Essay

1279 words - 5 pages Many adolescents, In the Great Depression, received the full affects and suffered. Some were left hungry, impoverished, and hopeless, how are adolescents today compared? The 30’s were a time of great distress for many Americans. Events such as the stock market crash, an economy suffering from being inflated, overuse of credit, a farming crisis, and other events led America to the economic downfall known as the Great Depression. During the great

The Great Depression Essay 2235 Words

2235 words - 9 pages , expectations changed. The misery of the Great Depression was finally brought to an end.      There was a book review that I read about this book. The reviewer had little criticisms to say about The Great Depression. He explained simply that the book was just based on fact mostly, so there was no reason to disagree with Berton. I completely agree with the reviewer in that I didn’t disagree with anything the author was

The Great Depression Essay 902 Words

902 words - 4 pages Two books by different historians paint a largely similar picture of the Great Depression of the 1930s, but have quite different attitudes about this period. The Age of Extremes, The Short Twentieth Century 1914 - 1991, written by Eric Hobsbawm, who experienced the depression first hand, exaggerates somewhat the social suffering of this period. Whereas Britain in the Depression: Society and Politics 1929 - 1939 was written by two much younger